Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Gay: Born That Way?


  

69 members have voted

You do not have permission to vote in this poll, or see the poll results. Please sign in or register to vote in this poll.

Recommended Posts

Tab'le De'Bah-Rye
Posted (edited)

Like i really do feel for people that struggle with habitual sin whatever form it is in, and how you can start to believe your cursed or something. Keep going to confession, that's all i have got to say, Even if your confessing the same ol same ol for years, and i know it's mega hard and embarrassing and shameful at times to do this, know your not alone, Jesus is with you and he loves you, that is why he gave us the sacrement of confession.

Edited by Tab'le Du'Bah-Rye
LouisvilleFan
Posted

I'm the original poster and I am positive I made no suggestion that we use biological hypotheses to excuse anything.

I think it's pretty telling that so many have experienced such immature, knee-jerk reactions to a very simple question. That's all it was: a question.

Instead of just answering the question, we ended up with everyone's opinion on everything related to homosexuality and sideways accusations of somehow supporting the "homosexual agenda".

I've never once said that gay sex was moral. I've never once suggested "gay marriage" should be legal. All I did was ask a question about people's understanding of homosexuality.

Do I think many here are ignorant? Yes. Do I strongly disagree with most of the theories presented? Yes. But that doesn't mean I'm preaching something immoral or that I'm somehow supporting the "gay agenda".

 

I'm curious what kind of conversation you would prefer to have in this thread? Obviously you're going to get knee-jerk reactions... that's par for the course.

 

I chose Sometimes, with the exception that any choice is involved. I don't think anyone chooses their sexual identity, although one's actions (especially during adolescense) could greatly influence it.

Posted

. I understand that you are a realist unreflective ideologue
 

fxd

CatholicsAreKewl
Posted (edited)

fxd

 

Hindu apostate!

Edited by CatholicsAreKewl
Posted

I used to think people weren't born gay...But if people honestly are born gay then I don't know if I can be against gay marriage anymore...I mean if God honestly created a person to be in love with the same sex then why would He hate it ? Because the Old Testement says He does ? There is a lot with the Old Testement that I'm not convinced God gives His 100 percent stamp of approval of...Are any of the stories even non fiction actual real life history ? Not being a smart a** just asking an honest question...Again I have always been against gay marriage cause I believed it was wrong and people weren't created that way they chose to be...But if they are born that way then that changes everything for me on how I look at this subject and how I feel about it...

PhuturePriest
Posted (edited)

I used to think people weren't born gay...But if people honestly are born gay then I don't know if I can be against gay marriage anymore...I mean if God honestly created a person to be in love with the same sex then why would He hate it ? Because the Old Testement says He does ? There is a lot with the Old Testement that I'm not convinced God gives His 100 percent stamp of approval of...Are any of the stories even non fiction actual real life history ? Not being a smart a** just asking an honest question...Again I have always been against gay marriage cause I believed it was wrong and people weren't created that way they chose to be...But if they are born that way then that changes everything for me on how I look at this subject and how I feel about it...

 

God doesn't make people gay. If people are born gay, that means there is something that went wrong. If we are to say God makes people gay, then we should say God makes some people retarded, too. But he doesn't, just as he doesn't make people gay.

 

And I'm not comparing mental retardation with being gay, to be clear. But if we are to say you can be born gay, that means there is something wrong mentally, just as something went wrong if you are born with mental retardation.

Edited by FuturePriest387
Posted (edited)

And for the record I'm not for gay marriage...I don't see how a man could be attracted to another man...I think its crazy that they actually are and I don't believe God would make a man this way...I don't get it at all...Not to be offensive but I think its actually sick...With that said I know a gay guy and I'm cool with him...I would never not like him because he wants to have sex with guys...It just baffles my mind because as a guy I think women are so beautiful and I don't see how a guy could think otherwise...But again if he is born this way and created this way it changes everything in my opinion...

Edited by Guest
Posted

Future Priest good post...I like the example you used...I didn't think of it that way...It still a tough spot though if even that's the case...To tell a gay person there born this way but God didn't intend it and if they want to marry the person they love they are going to hell...Real tough spot...

Posted

Delivery Boy, as far as I know, most men have a desire to have sex with women that they are not married to. I am married, and I often find my self desiring other women.

 

Just because "God made me this way" doesn't mean that I believe adultery should be acted upon or accepted.

Basilisa Marie
Posted

It seems pretty obvious to me that the point of this thread is to explore how the various denizens of Phatmass feel about what makes people gay.  It's an important question, because learning what someone believes about how people 'become' gay has a huge influence on how they approach other "gay" questions.  It also has a tendency to dictate how people treat non-heterosexual people, though not always.  The kinds of language people use to talk about it is also indicative of their position.  Two people could essentially have the same "position" on what "makes" people gay, but the way they talk about it could be wildly different.  

 

I think it's interesting to see the range of opinions presented here, and to hear the reasoning behind them.  They've been a bit surprising too.  

Posted

Personally, I think "being gay" meaning, choosing a gay lifestyle, simply means that a person is choosing to live a sinful lifestyle. Same as people who are sexually active outside of marriage. Same as people who live a dishonest life of theft and crime. Same as people who choose to live a life of selfishness and gluttony. Same as married people who are not open to life. Gay acts are sinful, just like a long list of other sinful acts, and we all, gay and straight, should be trying to destroy that sin in our lives and be holy.

Posted

Dust I like your example about the adultry but here's where it fails in my mind....If someone is born gay and that's the way they really are then it doesn't seem right to say you can't be with a person you love or you're going to hell...If "sam" is born gay and has no attraction to females then honestly it doesn't seem right to say he's going to hell if he were to marry another man he loves and be faithfull to him...Again I always thought "Sam" made a choice to be gay therefore I could see how it was wrong....But if Sam has no choice in the matter then it changes everything for me...I'll still side with the Church although its something I nolonger understand....Because ya you commiting adultry is wrong but it seems a bit unfair to say "sam" is wromg in the same way because he wants to marry and love someone he was born to be attracted to and love...

Posted

I wish it was a simple people weren't born gay...I really thought that's the way it was...

Posted

Dust I like your example about the adultry but here's where it fails in my mind....If someone is born gay and that's the way they really are then it doesn't seem right to say you can't be with a person you love or you're going to hell...If "sam" is born gay and has no attraction to females then honestly it doesn't seem right to say he's going to hell if he were to marry another man he loves and be faithfull to him...Again I always thought "Sam" made a choice to be gay therefore I could see how it was wrong....But if Sam has no choice in the matter then it changes everything for me...I'll still side with the Church although its something I nolonger understand....Because ya you commiting adultry is wrong but it seems a bit unfair to say "sam" is wromg in the same way because he wants to marry and love someone he was born to be attracted to and love...

 

What about a married man who falls in love with his co-worker? What if he realizes that the woman he married is not his "true love"? It is not his fault he is born with the desire to love women. That's the way he is. That's the way God made him.

 

See, he always has a choice. Most times, our choices must deny our "natural urges", and instead conform to the will of God. If we only do what we think we were born to do, then we become our own Gods.

Posted

I'm the original poster and I am positive I made no suggestion that we use biological hypotheses to excuse anything.

 

I never said you did.

 

However, plenty of people do - I was criticizing the common mentality of "gays are born that way; therefore, there's nothing wrong with homosexual activity, gay marriage, etc."

I didn't say this was your position, I was simply giving my $.02 on the topic, explaining how the underlying problem behind this is the whole mentality that people should always follow their sexual urges, whatever they may be, and that sexual self-control is wrong or unrealistic.

Unfortunately, this attitude is very widespread in our culture today, so I thought it was worth addressing.

 

Personally, I sincerely did not know what your purpose was in making this poll, which was why I asked.

 

 

I think it's pretty telling that so many have experienced such immature, knee-jerk reactions to a very simple question. That's all it was: a question.

I think it's pretty telling that so many assume whatever I say is a personal attack or accusation about them.

 

I don't think anything I posted there was immature (other than maybe the Reverend Horton Heat video).



Really, it's not always about you.  I apologize if my post gave this impression.

Posted (edited)

I love conversing with you, even if we tend to disagree a bunch (I still owe you a reply, I'll get to that soon). I think we should be careful about how we address this issue. No one really knows what to classify gayness as exactly, but the way it is phrased in the above statements makes it appear as if attraction is something we can manipulate willfully. I understand that you are a realist, but it might be unnecesary to emphasize the connection between original sin and gayness. Acting on suicidal ideations is also sinful but I wouldn't tell someone that their depression was caused by the fall of man.
 

 

 

Personally, I think homosexual tendencies can be overcome, either through a life of disciplined and prayerful celibacy, or, in some cases, being able to successfully transition from homosexuality to a "straight" life.  

While I realize that this is controversial (due largely to the way this issue has become politicized), I do not think we can simply discount as lies or propaganda the testimony of all those who have made such a transition.  To do so, I think, shows a rigid ideological bias.

People overcome or change their tendencies in many other areas of their behavior, so I don't think it impossible when it comes to sexuality.

 

 

And, yes, as a believing Christian, I believe that depression is the indirect result of original sin just as much as homosexuality.

In an unfallen world, there would not be any homosexuality, depression, or other sexual, mental, psychic, or physical disorders.

 

Obviously, if you're not Christian and don't believe in original sin and the fall of man, you will not agree, but I will speak my beliefs whether others agree or not.  I think for a Christian audience, it's an important point to make.  Homosexuality is really not that different than any number of other disordered tendencies we fallen human beings all experience.

Edited by Socrates
Posted

fxd   I have nothing meaningful to contribute, so I'll call names, as usual.

 

Fxd

Winchester
Posted

I never said you did.

 

However, plenty of people do - I was criticizing the common mentality of "gays are born that way; therefore, there's nothing wrong with homosexual activity, gay marriage, etc."

 

Right. Which wasn't really the topic. You lack focus!

I expect better of you, Socrates. The others who failed to stay on target irritate me, but none disappointed me so much as you.

Posted (edited)

Right. Which wasn't really the topic. You lack focus!

I expect better of you, Socrates. The others who failed to stay on target irritate me, but none disappointed me so much as you.

 

What I talk about is the topic.

 

I don't think we talk enough about anarcho-capitalist principles and the evils of the State.

 

 

Sorry, I was forgetting that Phatmass threads are not for discussion of larger issues, but must stay limited to back-and-forth personal attacks and snark. I'll try to be more focused next time.

Edited by Socrates
Winchester
Posted

What I talk about is the topic.

 

I don't think we talk enough about anarcho-capitalist principles and the evils of the State.

 

 

Sorry, I was forgetting that Phatmass threads are not for discussion of larger issues, but must stay limited to back-and-forth personal attacks and snark. I'll try to be more focused next time.

 

You haven't the wisdom to go off topic in the proper way. Perhaps one day.
 

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...