Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

MissScripture
Posted

Unfortunately, not everyone is close friends with everyone and knows each other really well. And regardless of intention, it DOES matter how people come across. Especially since this is not the only incident where TJMH has seemed to be targeted. I realize that's probably no one's intention, but it is how it comes across. And FWIW, my opinion in this are unbiased. It just seemed crude and rude how people were speaking to each other.

But then it also matters that she tried to pass off that answer as her own and got snarky when it was pointed out. She was equally as snarky, so why were/are Icey and FH being flogged for snark? And she wouldn't have been "targeted" in this case if she had cited her source. It does matter when people copy and paste without crediting the author. That is still plagiarism even if its not an academic setting.
FutureCarmeliteClaire
Posted (edited)

But then it also matters that she tried to pass off that answer as her own and got snarky when it was pointed out. She was equally as snarky, so why were/are Icey and FH being flogged for snark? And she wouldn't have been "targeted" in this case if she had cited her source. It does matter when people copy and paste without crediting the author. That is still plagiarism even if its not an academic setting.

Because I didn't read this comment well enough:

 

Oh poo, I forgot I have to cite my sources every time I answer a question on phatmass.

 

Silly me. 

 

And I didn't realize this was snarky, so thus I was shocked by the responses that followed. My apologies.

 

But please everyone, continue to make snarky and rude comments. I'll back off now.

Edited by FutureCarmeliteClaire
KnightofChrist
Posted

But then it also matters that she tried to pass off that answer as her own and got snarky when it was pointed out. She was equally as snarky, so why were/are Icey and FH being flogged for snark? And she wouldn't have been "targeted" in this case if she had cited her source. It does matter when people copy and paste without crediting the author. That is still plagiarism even if its not an academic setting.

 

She admitted it was a mistake and had forgotten to post the link. So the charge that she tried to pass off the answer as her own isn't one we should make unless we are also going to make the charge that she is being dishonest about making a mistake. 

 

The trouble could have been avoided if it was only pointed out that the source was missing, as the "fixed" post did at first, but then that was not enough, there had to be a charge of plagiarism (a joke so it seems) and other snarky stuff (jokes as well) even after she admitted it was mistake, in an apparent joking manner. Which probably made her defensive and answer with snark herself.

 

After she admitted the mistake and that she forgot, it should have been dropped. 

PhuturePriest
Posted

Question: Why would you want your baby to be born in the caul? All I can think of is the scene in The Fellowship of the Ring when they are making Uruk-Hai and they rip them out of the caul. :P

franciscanheart
Posted

Found the photo!

305771_10150354482346952_869715437_n.jpg

Posted

Question: Why would you want your baby to be born in the caul? All I can think of is the scene in The Fellowship of the Ring when they are making Uruk-Hai and they rip them out of the caul. :P

 

 i really didn't need that image in my head. :|

Posted

Found the photo!

305771_10150354482346952_869715437_n.jpg

 

babies (and their mommies) are pretty awesome. :) 

PhuturePriest
Posted

 i really didn't need that image in my head. :|

 

Sorry. :P

 

But really, why would you actually want a baby born in the caul? It seems a little less... I don't know. I just don't find cauls cute or adorable. They're rather messy, actually. I know childbirth when the caul is broken is messy already, but that's expected, and I find babies cute in spite of all the goop and muck on them. :P

FutureCarmeliteClaire
Posted

Found the photo!

305771_10150354482346952_869715437_n.jpg

 

That's amazing!! :love:
 

FutureCarmeliteClaire
Posted

Sorry. :P

 

But really, why would you actually want a baby born in the caul? It seems a little less... I don't know. I just don't find cauls cute or adorable. They're rather messy, actually. I know childbirth when the caul is broken is messy already, but that's expected, and I find babies cute in spite of all the goop and muck on them. :P

 

My cousin was closing his eyes and humming the entire time his wife was giving birth. I wanted to slap him, lol.

PhuturePriest
Posted

My cousin was closing his eyes and humming the entire time his wife was giving birth. I wanted to slap him, lol.

 

Hahaha. I'm not going to judge him because I've never seen childbirth in person, but I don't think I would avoid the situation entirely. Messes never really bothered me, especially if it was something important. But I know not everyone has a stomach like I do, so I'll give your cousin the benefit of the doubt. :P

CatholicsAreKewl
Posted (edited)

Found the photo!

305771_10150354482346952_869715437_n.jpg

 

This looks like a Guantanamo Bay interrogation procedure.

 

Edited by CatholicsAreKewl
PhuturePriest
Posted

 

 

This looks like a Guantanamo Bay interrogation procedure.

 

 

It looks like a lot of extra work to me. I would charge extra for having to do this if I were a doctor.

Archaeology cat
Posted

anyway, moving on.....
 
i'm actually hearing that people are getting more and more pics of babies being born "in caul" nowadays? anyone have more information on that?

 yep, more birth photographers and more people choosing providers who don't routinely break the waters. 

Sorry. :P
 
But really, why would you actually want a baby born in the caul? It seems a little less... I don't know. I just don't find cauls cute or adorable. They're rather messy, actually. I know childbirth when the caul is broken is messy already, but that's expected, and I find babies cute in spite of all the goop and muck on them. :P

for one, it greatly reduces the chance of infection if the membranes are intact.
PhuturePriest
Posted

 yep, more birth photographers and more people choosing providers who don't routinely break the waters.  for one, it greatly reduces the chance of infection if the membranes are intact.

 

Well, that's a bonus. But I don't see why everyone is so amazed over it. It's not like the birth is cuter because the baby is in the caul or anything. :P

IcePrincessKRS
Posted

Well, that's a bonus. But I don't see why everyone is so amazed over it. It's not like the birth is cuter because the baby is in the caul or anything. :P

 

It's just neat to see because it doesn't happen all that regularly.
 

Posted

It's appropriate to cite your source when you quote something no matter where you use it. Anyone who has made it past grade school knows that.
 

 

False. I teach college kids and encounter plagiarism (both intentional and unintentional)

 

ALL

 

THE

 

TIME.

Posted

 

 

This looks like a Guantanamo Bay interrogation procedure.

 

 

rotfl  rotfl  rotfl  rotfl  rotfl  rotfl  rotfl  rotfl  rotfl  rotfl  rotfl  rotfl  rotfl  rotfl  rotfl 

PhuturePriest
Posted

It's just neat to see because it doesn't happen all that regularly.
 

 

Neither does spontaneous combustion, but you won't see me talking about how cool and awesome it is if someone with me in the room suddenly goes aflame for no reason. :P

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...