Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Posted

George Zimmerman is a fat beach who was on a power trip with his gun. You listen to him on the 911 calls he already knows Martin is a black thug. All fatty had to do was indentify himself when he first started following him. He has a gun he has nothing to be worried about. Crack a joke from a distance. See what Martin is doing in his community. He didn't do none of that. And that's why I have no respect for him and don't think he's this big victim...I wish him and his family safety and hope nothing bad happens to him.

Posted

And it was 7pm....That's huge...Martin was walking back home to watch the second half of the nba all star game...

Posted (edited)

And I think Martins parents should be patted on the back...They have handled this really well...I don't know what is going on behind the scenes but if that was my son or brother Zimmerman would have to hide from me for the rest of my life...

Edited by Guest
Posted

Honestly, anyone who watch the entire trial live or participate in gathering evidence etc doesn't have any right to an opinion on this case. Media writes what it wants to make stories. It takes sound bites of witness testimony with interesting juicy pieces to keep us interested. If you really thing fox news, msnbc, cnn, or any other media outlet, or heck even all of them combined (except for watching the entire video feed) provide you enough evidence to find Mr. Zimmerman guilty or not guilty then you are seriously mistaken.

 

Sincerely,

Someone who just deliberated as a juror on a 5 week murder/manslaughter trial (not the Zimmerman case obviously since it was an all female jury...).

Posted (edited)

I accept the verdict it is what it is...OJ walked and so did Casey Anothny...Still doesn't change my thoughts on fatty...

Edited by Guest
Posted (edited)

Are you convinced beyond a reasonable doubt that he didn't shoot in self defense? If there is room for one iota of doubt in your mind "well it's possible he was being beat up and pulled the trigger in fear for his life, we'll never know for sure" then you have to acquit the person of murder.

 

If you can honestly say, "there's only 3 people who really know how this went down, Zimmerman, Martin and God" then you have to say not guilty.

Not true. One iota of a speculative nature because you cannot know something empirically is not considered reasonable doubt in a court of law. Empirical data is not required for a conviction. There are probably hundreds of possibilities of how something happened in several cases where a defendant is found guilty, but the alternative possibility has to be a reasonable possibility from evidence or testimony that you find credible. An expert witness that does not seem to be credible positing some crazy out there idea that would be technically possible is not necessarily reasonable doubt.

 

 

The jury didn't find Zimmerman not guilty because he was innocent, they found him not guilty because of lack of evidence. Just like in the OJ case it's very likely Zimmerman is a murderer, but that 1% of doubt allows them the be acquitted. I'm not saying this is bad just saying that  Zimmerman is far far from innocent.

 

The fact that you're already throwing out buzzwards like "open minded, p.c. liberalism" makes me think you listen to Rush a lot.

It takes more than just an ounce of doubt. Jury's look at the overall picture and take all evidence into account, not just some oddball idea of what happened that may or may not be reasonable.

 

Agreed on those points.  While I respect that the due process model of justice was used, with a jury deciding Zimmerman's legal guilt/non-guilt, I was shocked he didn't at least get manslaughter.  A seventeen year old kid died and by not paying attention to what 911 told him to do, he at least set up the situation that led to it, by getting out of the car.  Conflicting claims of having the gun pulled or not, from the moment he left the car, he set up a situation that was going to end poorly.

A jury can't convict manslaughter based on Zimmerman's decision to follow the child after being given instructions not to follow him from a dispatcher. Manslaughter is based on the conduct the defendant committed that caused injury to the victim. Stepping out of the car is not the conduct Zimmerman is on trial for, nor is imprudence for putting himself into a poor situation.

 

My understanding of what the jury has to look at is at the time of the shooting was Zimmerman acting in self defense to preserve himself from the threat of what he reasonably believed to be serious bodily harm, or did he act recklessly/extremely recklessly by choosing to draw his firearm and pull the trigger? The surrounding facts regarding his conversation with the dispatcher, his choice to leave the car, etc. can only be viewed in light of Zimmerman's mindset at the time of the conduct (I.E the jury being convinced that he was intentionally pursuing a fight).

 

 

edited to add: As for the jury's verdict I trust they acted in good faith, reasonably, considered all the evidence presented to them, and followed instructions given by the court. Is it possible they were wrong? Sure, but I'm certainly in no position to question their verdict.

Edited by Slappo
Posted

Since this whole case seems to be racially focused, it should be noted that when O.J. was acquitted the reactions of many African Americans on the news were joyful and excited.  So lets review: when a "white" man (Zimmerman) is acquitted in the murder trial of a black boy (Martin) even though people believe the evidence is overwhelming that Zimmerman was guilty of at least manslaughter, many people scream "racism".  When a black man (Simpson) is acquitted in the murder trial of a white person (Nicole Brown) even though people believe the evidence is overwhelming that Simpson was guilty, it's a wonderful day in America because the justice system didn't convict a black man.

 

All I'm saying is that racism is not solely an attribute of white people.  Whether or not Zimmerman acted because of racial profiling, he certainly isn't alone.  I neither agree nor disagree with this verdict because I don't know enough about the case.  I'm just noting the hypocrisy.

Posted

George Zimmerman is a fat beach who was on a power trip with his gun. You listen to him on the 911 calls he already knows Martin is a black thug. All fatty had to do was indentify himself when he first started following him. He has a gun he has nothing to be worried about. Crack a joke from a distance. See what Martin is doing in his community. He didn't do none of that. And that's why I have no respect for him and don't think he's this big victim...I wish him and his family safety and hope nothing bad happens to him.

By your tone, one would get the impression that you approve of mob Justice.
Posted (edited)

Since this whole case seems to be racially focused, it should be noted that when O.J. was acquitted the reactions of many African Americans on the news were joyful and excited.  So lets review: when a "white" man (Zimmerman) is acquitted in the murder trial of a black boy (Martin) even though people believe the evidence is overwhelming that Zimmerman was guilty of at least manslaughter, many people scream "racism".  When a black man (Simpson) is acquitted in the murder trial of a white person (Nicole Brown) even though people believe the evidence is overwhelming that Simpson was guilty, it's a wonderful day in America because the justice system didn't convict a black man.

 

All I'm saying is that racism is not solely an attribute of white people.  Whether or not Zimmerman acted because of racial profiling, he certainly isn't alone.  I neither agree nor disagree with this verdict because I don't know enough about the case.  I'm just noting the hypocrisy.

 

This. 

 

And people seem to be forgetting that Zimmerman is mixed race, white/Hispanic (and looks a lot more Hispanic than white). So using him as a "typical white guy" example is a little erroneous. 

Edited by EmilyAnn
Posted (edited)

I don't wish mob justice. I said in the paragraph you quoted that I hope him and his family remain safe. I don't like the guy though. I believe Martin was kicking the ish out of him and mabey he did feel he had to shoot. Although I believe he put himself in that situation by how he handled everything before he was getting his butt kicked. I don't believe for 1 second he was this innocent watchman and said nothing to provoke a fight with Martin. Like I said over and over all Zimmerman had to do was identify himself to Martin at 7 pm and see what Martin was up to. Inject some humor in the situation. He didn't do any of that. Instead he played overweight retarded batman. From his tone on the 911 calls to what he said and what ended up happening (the shooting) its pretty clear to me he approached the situation as if Martin was a black no good thug. When in all reality he was a kid coming home with a snack to watch the 2nd half of the nba all star game.

Edited by Guest
Posted

From PresidentEnder on reddit 

 


Carrying a gun does not make you a righteous bastion of moral purity. It does not make you badder, harder, bigger and stronger than the others around you. It does not grant you authority. It provides its user with a means to equalize a potential disparity in lethal force, and morally, that's all it does.

The gun is not a license to go to dangerous places, do dangerous things, or create dangerous situations, just because you might have a better chance to survive them. You should still use caution and maintain situational awareness to avoid violence. You should back down from the swaggering bravado of other men and act more timidly and kindly than your caveman instincts would normally encourage you to. Rather than carrying a gun through the bad part of town at 3am, it's better to structure your day so that a trip through the bad part of town at 3am is not on the agenda.

Zimmerman was legally justified to shoot Martin at the moment he took the shot, as was just proven in a court of law. But Zimmerman, Martin, and society as a whole would've been better served if Zimmerman had not followed Martin, or at least had not followed Martin as long as he did.

Now, we'd have been equally well-served if Martin had reached his father's residence and simply stayed inside rather than swaggering out to confront the much smaller man who'd trailed him home. Martin acted just as Zimmerman did and just as we should not: he assumed that because he possessed superior access to lethal force, he could ignore social decorum and safety and march into what would otherwise be a dangerous situation. And regardless of what happened between the end of the phone call and the end of the altercation, he paid for his masculine pride with his life.

If you're going to carry a gun, be educated, trained, and practiced. Carry safely in a holster. Carry jacketed hollow point ammunition. And do not treat the gun as a license to be stupid. Carrying a gun means the opposite: it means you have a duty to be cautious and to be smart.

Posted

From PresidentEnder on reddit 

 

 

Martin swaggered out?  Typical.  So he reached his father's house and then swaggered back out to confront Zimmerman?

 

And Martin wasn't larger.  Zimmerman weighed significantly more than him.  Martin was 4 inches taller.  Height is often a disadvantage unless it is accompanied him greater weight and strength.  Ask anybody who has boxed.  

Posted

I'm taller than most people.  I possess superior access to lethal force.  Look out world!

HisChildForever
Posted

Are people under the impression that the jury was racist? If so, I'd like to know how they've come to this conclusion. Since all we actually know about the jury is that they're women, five are white and one black or Hispanic, and five of the six are mothers. And unless I'm mistaken, it's racist to assume white = automatic racist. 

HisChildForever
Posted

I don't wish mob justice. I said in the paragraph you quoted that I hope him and his family remain safe. I don't like the guy though. I believe Martin was kicking the ish out of him and mabey he did feel he had to shoot. Although I believe he put himself in that situation by how he handled everything before he was getting his butt kicked. I don't believe for 1 second he was this innocent watchman and said nothing to provoke a fight with Martin. Like I said over and over all Zimmerman had to do was identify himself to Martin at 7 pm and see what Martin was up to. Inject some humor in the situation. He didn't do any of that. Instead he played overweight retarded batman. From his tone on the 911 calls to what he said and what ended up happening (the shooting) its pretty clear to me he approached the situation as if Martin was a black no good thug. When in all reality he was a kid coming home with a snack to watch the 2nd half of the nba all star game.

 

Can we stop with the name-calling? 

Posted

How so...exactly? 

Well apparently I'm seeing something that isn't there from this post:

 

 

 I was genuinely interested in knowing what your experience was. Makes sense.  :like:

 

 

So I'm sorry for misreading things!

Posted

Are people under the impression that the jury was racist? If so, I'd like to know how they've come to this conclusion. Since all we actually know about the jury is that they're women, five are white and one black or Hispanic, and five of the six are mothers. And unless I'm mistaken, it's racist to assume white = automatic racist. 

 

 

I don't think the jury was racist.  I think that Zimmerman was probably innocent under Florida's Stand Your Ground Law.  

HisChildForever
Posted

I don't think the jury was racist.  I think that Zimmerman was probably innocent under Florida's Stand Your Ground Law.  

 

My comments are really me wondering at all these people involved in protests and marches. If they think Zimmerman a racist and this a racial killing - yes, by all means speak about how horrible that is. But if that's the case, and the jury ruled not guilty, then they're basically calling the jury racist for siding with Zimmerman (or at the very least calling the jurors a bunch of morons for not realizing this was a racially-fueled, malicious murder). I would just like to see these people put forth the evidence that the jurors are in fact racist - which, unless the jurors go public and allow investigations into their personal lives - is simply impossible to procure.

Posted

My comments are really me wondering at all these people involved in protests and marches. If they think Zimmerman a racist and this a racial killing - yes, by all means speak about how horrible that is. But if that's the case, and the jury ruled not guilty, then they're basically calling the jury racist for siding with Zimmerman (or at the very least calling the jurors a bunch of morons for not realizing this was a racially-fueled, malicious murder). I would just like to see these people put forth the evidence that the jurors are in fact racist - which, unless the jurors go public and allow investigations into their personal lives - is simply impossible to procure.

 

I think most people protesting are outraged at the law.  Not the jurors confined to the parameters of that law.  

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...