KnightofChrist Posted October 28, 2014 Posted October 28, 2014 The Church in her infancy did not come to peace with (aka accommodate) popular sins of the time, she gave the peace of Christ to persons who would except it. Pagan Rome at the time was much more sinful than today. There were many odd unions which were sexual in nature between persons then, as well as many other strange sins. She didn't come to peace with those sins, in fact she was so 'confrontational' against the world to the point that many of the faithful at the time were martyred. Perhaps our generation is just more enlightened and the blood of those martyrs was somewhat meaningless.
CrossCuT Posted October 28, 2014 Posted October 28, 2014 (edited) I think we live in a time where we dont have to resort to war and violence in order to get our point across. :unsure: ...least I hope we dont have to.... Edited October 28, 2014 by CrossCuT
blazeingstar Posted October 28, 2014 Posted October 28, 2014 The Church in her infancy did not come to peace with (aka accommodate) popular sins of the time, she gave the peace of Christ to persons who would except it. Pagan Rome at the time was much more sinful than today. There were many odd unions which were sexual in nature between persons then, as well as many other strange sins. She didn't come to peace with those sins, in fact she was so 'confrontational' against the world to the point that many of the faithful at the time were martyred. Perhaps our generation is just more enlightened and the blood of those martyrs was somewhat meaningless. Another good grief. Yes, certain cultures at times faced different problems. We are not dealing with those issues. No one is saying "I will kill you if you don't play nice with homosexuals" Actually, they were called to be set apart and be kind...which isn't all that much different than what the Pope is saying. Be set apart but really learn what we believe. Right now we are not truly in control of our own behaviors. The people who are under the banner of Christian have many different views....not all in line with the church. Quite frankly, times are different in most of the world today.
CrossCuT Posted October 28, 2014 Posted October 28, 2014 "Should the Catholic Church make its peace with same-sex unions – not in terms of giving moral approval or abandoning its teaching on marriage, but finding a less confrontational way to talk about these relationships and a more welcoming posture for people living in them?" This has been something I've tried to discuss for a long time. I don't think it's going to happen here at phatmass, but I'd be really happy to see it happening in the "real" world. It is happening in the real world! Thats whats so exciting!
KnightofChrist Posted October 28, 2014 Posted October 28, 2014 Another good grief. Yes, certain cultures at times faced different problems. We are not dealing with those issues. No one is saying "I will kill you if you don't play nice with homosexuals" Actually, they were called to be set apart and be kind...which isn't all that much different than what the Pope is saying. Be set apart but really learn what we believe. Right now we are not truly in control of our own behaviors. The people who are under the banner of Christian have many different views....not all in line with the church. Quite frankly, times are different in most of the world today. Yeah another good grief, just marginalize me please makes it easier to dismiss me as a nutter. Same goes for FP he's just a kid who makes callous quips that give people Ebola.
CrossCuT Posted October 28, 2014 Posted October 28, 2014 Yeah another good grief, just marginalize me please makes it easier to dismiss me as a nutter. Same goes for FP he's just a kid who makes callous quips that give people Ebola. Oh come on!!! I was trying to ease the tension! I hope this doesnt mean youre going to stop sending me extra candy crush moves? :(
blazeingstar Posted October 28, 2014 Posted October 28, 2014 Yeah another good grief, just marginalize me please makes it easier to dismiss me as a nutter. Same goes for FP he's just a kid who makes callous quips that give people Ebola. I'm not saying nutter, I'm saying part of the problem. People glamorize the time of Martyrs as if its an Itchy and Scratchy set where the Romans were going around with steaked clubs bopping Christians on the head for calling their sex acts naughty. In reality, they were still humans who had normal human interactions. It's one of the reasons St. Paul speaks about being unequally yoked. Because being yoked (eg married) with an unbeliever creates a huge problem. However, it would also imply that people reacted on a daily basis with those who did not believe. One of Jesus' biggest changes He brought to religion was the idea of "loving your neighbor as yourself" and the idea that the sinful like Barnabus or the Good Samaratin, were humans, too. In our culture today, we've also become obsessed with blaze' labeling of people. Those homosexuals and every so often one blatently celebate donates to build a church or helps a kid so we say oh, that's a "Good homosexual". Err no. We're doing the EXACT same thing. By Jesus we're called to be Priest, profit and king. Which means that we are called to minister, look ahead and to leadership roles. There's nothing in there about bludgining sinners. There are limits. Jesus set limits on things. If you're not welcome, shake the dust. Harm the children, earn a millstone...so on and so forth. But there's a huge balance. Its just like pre-marital behavior. Some couples find that not kissing before marriage works for them but then there are perfectly happy Catholic nudists who go to the beach together before marriage and kiss. The church lets us decide what is best for us. Perhaps you fall more towards the persons who don't kiss before marriage. That's ok, there's room for you....so long as you don't say that nudists are going to hell or any other variety of chaste courtship in between.
franciscanheart Posted October 28, 2014 Posted October 28, 2014 Really? Please tell me you're not also in favor of tossing out Dignitatis Humanae and Nostra Aetate. *angrycommentaboutFP'sapparentlackofempathy*Remember: he has a lot of maturing to do, too. He's in that "MUST PROVE MANLINESS. MUST BE BUTTHEAD TO BE DEVOUT," stage that so many of us had to go through to get where we are now. I think you're confusing making peace with forever passively accepting wrong behavior. I see "making peace" as meeting people where they are and giving them what they need in that moment.YES. This. (A person with a brain! And a heart! That communicate! AMEN!) I am in full favor of empathy and compassion. I do not think, however, that empathy and compassion are code words for throwing out the truth in the name of making people feel more welcome... I am not empathetic to making us feel better about our sin by watering down its ugly truth with nicer language.No one is suggesting we should change the teaching of the Church. You say you're all for empathy and compassion, and then demand that we present a reality in words which convey, immediately and without mercy, the bottom line. Should we present the bottom line? Sure. Should we acknowledge sin for what it is? Of course. So where does God's Infinite Mercy come in? The way you have presented things, mercy is removed from the discussion. The most charitable thing you can do for a person is tell them the truth. Not telling them the truth is uncharitable...Most of what you're saying (over and over again) is that homosexual acts are sinful and disgraceful in the eyes of God and therefore the Church. We know that. There's no need to keep repeating it to sound faithful or dominate the conversation with Truth. We're all on the same page, and so far, all in agreement about the gravity of those sins. But that's not the focus on the conversation here, or there. The issue is how we address these things, and how we evangelize. In your perspective, as presented by you, we tell people straight up that God wants you in Heaven so you better quit that gay shit; it's an abomination.Do you see where this might not be an effective means of conversion on the global scale? Now I know you have tons of experience dealing with people, FP, being a man of many talents and travels. However, how would you go about handling this basic situation. You have a friend with a small daughter (just them in the apartment) and you are cooking with her. You open the fridge to find 4 lbs of butter. Curious at the large amount of butter you ask, "Oh, friend, what are you cooking with all that butter?" Friend replies, "Oh that's for 2 weeks, its how I get child to eat veggies" Meaning 1/2 stick or 1/4 cup butter to get child to eat her veggies." Do you a) Tell the truth to the mother bold and outright that she's killing her kid?b) Make a suggestion that thats alot and ignore the problemc) Also decide that 1/4 cup of butter on boiled veggies is a great idead) Cook with the mother every night for a few weeks showing her how to cook veggies so they are both palatable and use 1/10 of the butter she was originally This in a tiny microcosm of what needs to be done to improve behavior. She probably would not be my friend if I told her she was killing her kid even if it was "true"Storing this one away for future reference. :like: It may interest you to know I actually do know people in these situations, I do talk to them about this stuff, and it does work. I never said we should go to people and tell them they're going to hell, as that doesn't work. That is doing what I repeatedly denounced in this thread, which is focusing on one side of the truth and ignoring the other.It doesn't interest me, but then, I don't much care for people who are like, "I have a black friend. He's okay with me making racist comments. So, what's your problem?" Kinda the same thing.On the whole, we've seen as a Church, I think, that our approach isn't working. Not because our teachings are wrong or mean or anything like that, but because the tone is all wrong, and people can't hear the mercy. I've struggled with it here at phatmass for years, and I'm a faithful Catholic. :like: Since when is it weird for me to repeat the Church on matters of the faith? I don't have a Church Militant tag just because I'm so loveable and popular, you know.No one is suggesting it's strange for you to be loyal to the Church. In fact, if anything, your passion for being right blinds you. Where is the compassion of Christ? You lack it sometimes, though I'm sure it doesn't feel that way.
franciscanheart Posted October 28, 2014 Posted October 28, 2014 Then maybe you shouldn't start off your contribution to a thread with a rather callous quip, if you intend to be understood with more nuance?But then where would be the shock value and chance for online martyrdom?! :idontknow: The Church in her infancy did not come to peace with (aka accommodate) popular sins of the time, she gave the peace of Christ to persons who would except accept it. Pagan Rome at the time was much more sinful than today. There were many odd unions which were sexual in nature between persons then, as well as many other strange sins. She didn't come to peace with those sins, in fact she was so 'confrontational' against the world to the point that many of the faithful at the time were martyred. Perhaps our generation is just more enlightened and the blood of those martyrs was somewhat meaningless.Fixed. I'm not saying nutter, I'm saying part of the problem. People glamorize the time of Martyrs as if its an Itchy and Scratchy set where the Romans were going around with steaked clubs bopping Christians on the head for calling their sex acts naughty. In reality, they were still humans who had normal human interactions. It's one of the reasons St. Paul speaks about being unequally yoked. Because being yoked (eg married) with an unbeliever creates a huge problem. However, it would also imply that people reacted on a daily basis with those who did not believe. One of Jesus' biggest changes He brought to religion was the idea of "loving your neighbor as yourself" and the idea that the sinful like Barnabus or the Good Samaratin, were humans, too. In our culture today, we've also become obsessed with blaze' labeling of people. Those homosexuals and every so often one blatently celebate donates to build a church or helps a kid so we say oh, that's a "Good homosexual". Err no. We're doing the EXACT same thing. By Jesus we're called to be Priest, profit and king. Which means that we are called to minister, look ahead and to leadership roles. There's nothing in there about bludgining sinners. There are limits. Jesus set limits on things. If you're not welcome, shake the dust. Harm the children, earn a millstone...so on and so forth. But there's a huge balance. Its just like pre-marital behavior. Some couples find that not kissing before marriage works for them but then there are perfectly happy Catholic nudists who go to the beach together before marriage and kiss. The church lets us decide what is best for us. Perhaps you fall more towards the persons who don't kiss before marriage. That's ok, there's room for you....so long as you don't say that nudists are going to hell or any other variety of chaste courtship in between.Emphasis mine.I recently took time away from a friendship for exactly this reason. Despite her view of me as whole and respectable and good, she viewed other homosexuals with contempt and disgust. I was labeled good because I had earned such a label through my devotion to my faith. What she is missing -- what she cannot or will not see -- is that I am intrinsically valuable because I am.It is frustrating beyond belief -- though markedly less hurtful now than it used to be -- to know just how many people in this world still operate in the modes of "good gays" and "bad gays", whether they'd label them with such direct language or not.
Lilllabettt Posted October 28, 2014 Posted October 28, 2014 Remember: he has a lot of maturing to do, too. He's in that "MUST PROVE MANLINESS. MUST BE BUTTHEAD TO BE DEVOUT," stage that so many of us had to go through to get where we are now. lol. yes, you have come so far, FH. Once you were like FP but now you are far far beyond FP. between you two he is the one who is immature. lolz
franciscanheart Posted October 28, 2014 Posted October 28, 2014 lol. yes, you have come so far, FH. Once you were like FP but now you are far far beyond FP.between you two he is the one who is immature.lolzI'm glad that's the one thing you took from everything I posted. :like:
Lilllabettt Posted October 28, 2014 Posted October 28, 2014 well unfortunately no matter how great your message is it gets lost if your delivery stinks. ... the irony should be approaching lethal levels at this point.
franciscanheart Posted October 28, 2014 Posted October 28, 2014 Mea culpa? Still, I don't see how your commentary helps progress the conversation at all. :huh: For what it's worth, I have shown extreme restraint. :like:
Basilisa Marie Posted October 28, 2014 Posted October 28, 2014 (edited) The Church in her infancy did not come to peace with (aka accommodate) popular sins of the time, she gave the peace of Christ to persons who would except it. Pagan Rome at the time was much more sinful than today. There were many odd unions which were sexual in nature between persons then, as well as many other strange sins. She didn't come to peace with those sins, in fact she was so 'confrontational' against the world to the point that many of the faithful at the time were martyred. Perhaps our generation is just more enlightened and the blood of those martyrs was somewhat meaningless. Yeah, lots of people were martyred, and that was heroic witness to the truth. But that same Church also decided that the ones who chose not to be martyred because they denied the faith were to be allowed back into the fold, many without any sort of major act of reparation (i.e. years of literal sackcloth and ashes). And how did some people respond to that show of mercy? By leaving the Church and doing their own thing. No one's calling to change any of our doctrines, people are trying to figure out the best way to help people grow in their relationship with Christ. Maybe for some people they really need that kick in the pantaloons. But that's not going to work when they already have a hostile view of the Church, or if they already know that their situation is bad. Edited October 28, 2014 by Basilisa Marie
PhuturePriest Posted October 28, 2014 Posted October 28, 2014 Remember: he has a lot of maturing to do, too. He's in that "MUST PROVE MANLINESS. MUST BE BUTTHEAD TO BE DEVOUT," stage that so many of us had to go through to get where we are now. YES. This. (A person with a brain! And a heart! That communicate! AMEN!) No one is suggesting we should change the teaching of the Church. You say you're all for empathy and compassion, and then demand that we present a reality in words which convey, immediately and without mercy, the bottom line. Should we present the bottom line? Sure. Should we acknowledge sin for what it is? Of course. So where does God's Infinite Mercy come in? The way you have presented things, mercy is removed from the discussion. Most of what you're saying (over and over again) is that homosexual acts are sinful and disgraceful in the eyes of God and therefore the Church. We know that. There's no need to keep repeating it to sound faithful or dominate the conversation with Truth. We're all on the same page, and so far, all in agreement about the gravity of those sins. But that's not the focus on the conversation here, or there. The issue is how we address these things, and how we evangelize. In your perspective, as presented by you, we tell people straight up that God wants you in Heaven so you better quit that gay poo; it's an abomination. Do you see where this might not be an effective means of conversion on the global scale? Storing this one away for future reference. :like: It doesn't interest me, but then, I don't much care for people who are like, "I have a black friend. He's okay with me making racist comments. So, what's your problem?" Kinda the same thing. On the whole, we've seen as a Church, I think, that our approach isn't working. Not because our teachings are wrong or mean or anything like that, but because the tone is all wrong, and people can't hear the mercy. I've struggled with it here at phatmass for years, and I'm a faithful Catholic. :like: No one is suggesting it's strange for you to be loyal to the Church. In fact, if anything, your passion for being right blinds you. Where is the compassion of Christ? You lack it sometimes, though I'm sure it doesn't feel that way. I've never said or implied (at least intentionally) that anyone here wishes the Church would relax its teaching. However, I don't see how watering down language will help. Watering down language to make people take the bite will only make them bitter when they learn the Church still sees these sins as something which cries retribution from heaven. One of my best friends is a gay Wiccan Hindu. We talk about this quite a bit, and you would be amazed that even though I am not shy around charitably telling him the truth about his acts (Not in a "You're going to hell and crying out to heaven for retribution!" type of way, but in an actually tactful manner that does mention the gravity of what he does), he still likes me a lot and we speak on a daily basis. He is, I would venture to say, the closest and best friend I have at this moment. He is both fully aware of God's love for him, and fully aware of the gravity of his acts (He was raised Catholic, for the record). That is what I am getting at: We either go too far one way or too far the other. Liberals sometimes speak solely of how God loves us, and traditionalists sometimes speak solely about how God hates your sin and what you're doing. Both are just as damaging, and both are only one side of the whole truth. I am for telling all of the truth, not just half. All I've taken from your last paragraph is a reaffirmation that I am right. :|
blazeingstar Posted October 28, 2014 Posted October 28, 2014 I've never said or implied (at least intentionally) that anyone here wishes the Church would relax its teaching. However, I don't see how watering down language will help. Watering down language to make people take the bite will only make them bitter when they learn the Church still sees these sins as something which cries retribution from heaven. One of my best friends is a gay Wiccan Hindu. We talk about this quite a bit, and you would be amazed that even though I am not shy around charitably telling him the truth about his acts (Not in a "You're going to hell and crying out to heaven for retribution!" type of way, but in an actually tactful manner that does mention the gravity of what he does), he still likes me a lot and we speak on a daily basis. He is, I would venture to say, the closest and best friend I have at this moment. He is both fully aware of God's love for him, and fully aware of the gravity of his acts (He was raised Catholic, for the record). That is what I am getting at: We either go too far one way or too far the other. Liberals sometimes speak solely of how God loves us, and traditionalists sometimes speak solely about how God hates your sin and what you're doing. Both are just as damaging, and both are only one side of the whole truth. I am for telling all of the truth, not just half. All I've taken from your last paragraph is a reaffirmation that I am right. :| Yeah, I don't think you're seeing the point or comprehending the issues as they often play out in the world today. We're not talking about one lapsed Catholic gay wiccan hindu vegetarian martial artist, we're talking about a vast population who's often very hateful and very militant against Catholics. And the Pope is saying that both sides have to come to a middle ground. Part of that middle ground, however, does involve changing some language that is not divine (eg from the Bible) so that people can understand it better. Language is a powerful tool but gets dated. I mean just look at when people begin the Our Father or Hail Mary. I know traditionalists who just about loose their top if you say "the" and "your" rather than "thee" and "tho". And "thee" is not really Biblical, the Latin/Aramaic dosn't add up...its just how it was translated into English back in the 1500's. Those languages don't even have classifiers. So to change our language, weither it be thee's or anything else is part of a natural evolution of culture and language and, yes, even feeling.
CrossCuT Posted October 28, 2014 Posted October 28, 2014 (edited) FP so then are you like a big fan of the Westboro Baptist church? Cuz they sure dont water things down. Edited October 28, 2014 by CrossCuT
Kateri89 Posted October 28, 2014 Posted October 28, 2014 I wonder if I'm missing the point of this thread. Lots of debate going back and forth about not "watering down" teachings of the Church vs. being charitable and relying on gradualism but has anybody given any concrete examples of what we should be doing? For instance, would it be good for parishes to have support groups for their parishioners with homosexual inclinations or would that be counterproductive since it would single them out? Should priests be giving more homilies on the Church's teachings about homosexual acts while also emphasizing God's mercy? Forgive me but it seems that this thread would be much more productive if instead of arguing over someone's intent (words can be interpreted very differently when read instead of heard) we actually floated some solid ideas around.
blazeingstar Posted October 28, 2014 Posted October 28, 2014 I wonder if I'm missing the point of this thread. Lots of debate going back and forth about not "watering down" teachings of the Church vs. being charitable and relying on gradualism but has anybody given any concrete examples of what we should be doing? For instance, would it be good for parishes to have support groups for their parishioners with homosexual inclinations or would that be counterproductive since it would single them out? Should priests be giving more homilies on the Church's teachings about homosexual acts while also emphasizing God's mercy? Forgive me but it seems that this thread would be much more productive if instead of arguing over someone's intent (words can be interpreted very differently when read instead of heard) we actually floated some solid ideas around. That's what the whole sinoid was all about. To come up with those ideas. The issue is that many people are against changing the language and the outreach at all because they feel it would water things down.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now