blazeingstar Posted October 29, 2014 Posted October 29, 2014 :rolleyes: As I've already told you, the whole issue with allowing certain divorced and remarried people to communion is for those who are trying to make a good effort to repent, but our annulment process is long, laborious, and imperfect, and sometimes there are other goods to be achieved by, say, allowing the couple to still live together (though not engaging in the marital act). It may be an occasion of sin for the couple, but maybe there are other goods to be achieved - this is what I understand to be one of the questions at the synod. So how much repentance is enough repentance? How much suffering is enough suffering? And as far as others, the Church HAS decided to recognize the good in other religions insofar as they participate in the truth of Catholicism. See the Vatican documents. So it's not that far of a logical jump to recognize the good in irregular relationships as part of a greater effort to reach out to them to bring them closer to Christ through conversion. Do we really, truly believe that there is absolutely nothing good in a long-term, stable, loving same-sex relationship? Yes, we can't tell people that it's a-okay to engage in homosexual (or premarital) sexual activities. But do we also want to say that those activities have destroyed any good that the couple may experience from their relationship? People who are in habits of mortal sin of an addictive nature (say, a sexual sin) should go to confession after they commit the sin before they receive communion. But the Church also mercifully recognizes that sometimes, the addiction can sometimes render those acts venial instead of mortal, because the person wasn't truly free to choose that act. It's not realistic to expect a person with a sinful addiction to quit cold turkey after they go to confession once, we do expect them to make their best effort to fight it, and we encourage frequent confession and reception of communion to help strengthen that person against sin so they can overcome it with grace. This isn't a totally new idea. People lead messy lives, and conversion and holiness is a process. This whole thing is about trying to figure out the best way to help people in that process. Maybe no changes will be made. That'd be fine, I trust that the bishops are going to try to figure out what's best. We've now entered the twilight zone. I agree with you. I think much of the harshness comes from this crazy idea we must be militantly against all sins. This idea that we are called to be soldiers, (a very European idea) when we're actually called to be priest, prophet and king.
veritasluxmea Posted October 29, 2014 Posted October 29, 2014 I think much of the harshness comes from this crazy idea we must be militantly against all sins. This idea that we are called to be soldiers, (a very European idea) when we're actually called to be priest, prophet and king. In all fairness, we are called the Church Militant... No, that doesn't mean we should burn down mosques, yes, it means we're still fighting against the devil and world for our salvation. We should be fighting against all sin in our lives and helping others as much as prudently possible. So in a sense, we are soldiers.
Maggyie Posted October 29, 2014 Posted October 29, 2014 If you look at the 3 Popes, and subtract out the environmental factor of their upbringing and their personalities, much of their doctrine is affected by the language they spoke. It's no surprise to me that a German pope used harsher language than a Polish one, and that a Spanish speaking Pope has different ideals than his predecessor. Until you suddenly realize that Cardinal K is a German and German theology in general is the most liberal "national brand" of theology there is. Suddenly the elaborate vaguely prejudiced faux intellectual/pseudoscientific language based argument falls apart. Behold the power of education. :rolleyes: As I've already told you, the whole issue with allowing certain divorced and remarried people to communion is for those who are trying to make a good effort to repent, but our annulment process is long, laborious, and imperfect, and sometimes there are other goods to be achieved by, say, allowing the couple to still live together (though not engaging in the marital act). It may be an occasion of sin for the couple, but maybe there are other goods to be achieved - this is what I understand to be one of the questions at the synod. So how much repentance is enough repentance? How much suffering is enough suffering? "Though not engaging in the marital act" That's exactly the status quo. Although some pastors may ask partners to live apart the rule is simply they must live as brother and sister. Do you think divorced and remarried people need to live as brother and sister? Is that what is being discussed at the synod? This would result in no change to current practice.
Basilisa Marie Posted October 29, 2014 Posted October 29, 2014 "Though not engaging in the marital act" That's exactly the status quo. Although some pastors may ask partners to live apart the rule is simply they must live as brother and sister. Do you think divorced and remarried people need to live as brother and sister? Is that what is being discussed at the synod? This would result in no change to current practice. Is it? I dunno, others, like Credo, have made it clear that many pastors ask the couple to live apart. I don't know what the status quo is for most places. I live in the Archdiocese of Seattle, a relatively liberal diocese, but in a rather conservative deanery. There's a lot of variety in how these situations are addressed, and that's just in my own tiny corner of the world. The fact is that people who aren't validly married shouldn't be engaging in sexual activities. This is pretty clear and irrefutable, and I haven't seen anything from the synod that addresses this specific point. What I have seen is the question of whether divorced and remarried couples can be allowed to communion. Part of the issue I imagine is the fact that it can be a sin to get married (civilly, whatever) to someone else when you're sacramentally married to another person, and it would seem that persisting in that relationship even without sexual relations can be sinful. Someone correct me if I'm wrong on that point.
Ash Wednesday Posted October 29, 2014 Posted October 29, 2014 Peeps in this thread should have a glass of wine and maybe take a bubble bath and then resume the discussion. (FP can have grape juice or some such thing) Who needs a thread for that? We should be doing that anyway. ;)
Gabriela Posted October 30, 2014 Posted October 30, 2014 I agree with everything in this article except that the HF's unveiling of a bust of PE Benedict is a significant gesture. I think it's just another event. But otherwise, yeah, I think the dude is right. Especially about our penchant for taking quotes of context and then demonizing the person behind the sound byte.
Socrates Posted October 30, 2014 Posted October 30, 2014 Should the Church make peace with people putting their immortal souls in danger by living sinful lives? No, and it's a silly question to ask. Next, please. I'll have to agree with the fetus here. The Church can never "make peace" with sin, of any kind, regardless of how un-pc such a stance may be. The Church already clearly teaches that persons suffering from homosexual inclinations are to be treated with respect and compassion. Compassion involves dealing with persons in real life in a charitable manner, not in changing or watering down moral teaching to make it more palatable to modern sensibilities. Nor does it mean the Church should praise "positive" aspects of "relationships" that are intrinsically immoral. There will always be people who are upset by being told that what they are doing is sinful, but calling evil good is not in anyone's true best interest, and is not true compassion or charity. Jesus Christ displayed superb compassion and mercy in His dealings with the woman caught in adultery. However, He told her to "sin no more," and felt no need to find nice things to say about her adulterous relationship.
Socrates Posted October 30, 2014 Posted October 30, 2014 Conservatives- Stop being verbally abusive bung-holes who thing that the world must work your way or else. You are not in charge, never have been, never will be. God is. Stop trying to control things you cannot, like civil law that's been passed when its not life or death. Exactly what are you referring to here? Is the business of civil law to be left solely to liberals and leftists? (And in reality it's the political left that is hell-bent on changing civil law and its meaning in this country, and in disregarding the Constitution. This includes changing the legal definition of marriage, and in activist federal judges ruling against--on no sound constitutional authority--state laws already decided by the people of those states.) Former Pope Benedict very firmly opposed homosexual "civil unions." Was he just another abusive conservative bung-hole?
Aragon Posted October 30, 2014 Posted October 30, 2014 From my understanding the problem stems from Latin and finds itself in other Indo-European languages, so Italian and Spanish would be affected. Languages like Polish, Taglong and Russian not so much. A Polish priest I knew loved Jackie Chan...the idea that someone foreign became America's hero... He had this saying "English cuts like a bullet when you only need a nice light karate chop" Now that doesn't make the world's most sense, but I've heard it from other priests raised in other languages that English (and Spanish, but that less so) have a horrible way of being demoralizing and degrading. If you look at the 3 Popes, and subtract out the environmental factor of their upbringing and their personalities, much of their doctrine is affected by the language they spoke. It's no surprise to me that a German pope used harsher language than a Polish one, and that a Spanish speaking Pope has different ideals than his predecessor. Hmmmm, I'm pretty sure Italian isn't affected. The word inordinata is most accurately translated as 'disordered' and is done so in Italian, French, Spanish, etc, but in Italian I'm pretty sure (from only a few years of high school LOTE and a 2 month vacation, mind you...) that the word "disorder" (disordine) in Italian isn't ever used in a psychiatric sense like it is in English. They speak of "disturbo mentale" rather than "mental disorders" so there's no risk of it being understood as a clinical diagnosis saying homosexuals are mentally ill like there is in the Anglo-sphere. Can anyone who is fluent in any of these Romance languages confirm this?
An Historian Posted October 31, 2014 Posted October 31, 2014 The difference is, Future Packer, that you're a devout Catholic actively pursuing holiness. Telling you that x or y behaviour is sinful is effective for you because you believe in sin and don't want to offend God. Telling you it leads to Hell is effective because you believe in Hell. However none of that harsh language will work for someone in an irregular situation who isn't a strong Catholic. If I go around telling the gay people or cohabitating people I know that their sexual behaviour is "disordered" and that for that reason they need to repent or go to Hell they're not going to listen. What they will do is write me off as judgmental and want nothing more to do with me. That's why it's important that Catholics, including our leaders, use a language that is both intelligible and attractive to the mass of people who aren't devout Catholics, because the "harsh language" you're advocating simply won't be effective for them. How do you propose we convert sinners without addressing the realities of sin?
Benedictus Posted October 31, 2014 Posted October 31, 2014 How do you propose we convert sinners without addressing the realities of sin? God does the changing, not rules and not people by their own hand. People can't convert unless they first have a relationship with God first. The church puts the cart before the horse sometimes (or certain people do) expecting people to accept their sin and then find God/ build a relationship with him. This doesn't work in unchurched and dechurched cultural populations, or people with postChristian mindsets. It just sounds like guilt, rigidity and fundamentalism to such ears. New patterns and ways are necessary.
An Historian Posted October 31, 2014 Posted October 31, 2014 God does the changing, not rules and not people by their own hand. People can't convert unless they first have a relationship with God first. The church puts the cart before the horse sometimes (or certain people do) expecting people to accept their sin and then find God/ build a relationship with him. This doesn't work in unchurched and dechurched cultural populations, or people with postChristian mindsets. It just sounds like guilt, rigidity and fundamentalism to such ears. New patterns and ways are necessary. I am well aware that conversion can only be accomplished by God's grace. I think it's blatantly obvious as to what I meant when I asked how we are to convert people. The example of the early Christians has already been pointed out but I will reiterate those same examples. The early Christians did not convert society and persons by ignoring sin and its realities. Rather than lowering themselves they lifted society up. When Saint Peter gave the first sermon in the history of the Church, he proclaimed the divinity of Christ, he announced the good news of salvation, [b]and told people that had to do penance for their sins.[b] Why all of this talk of news ways and patterns? The Christian Gospel has been the same for two thousand years. Christ has died for you, He has risen in glory and conquered death, and invites you to participate in His life of grace, [b]to do so you must repent of your sins and do penance.[/b] With all due respect I don't think for a moment that we should entertain this foolish reeamination of our evangelisation in light of modern society's state. Modern society is in its current state because it has lost all concept of sin and its realities and our need of repentance and penance. Ignoring and glossing over these realities to somehow ingratiate ourselves to society will accomplish nothing but the continual decline of the Catholic faith in western society. Look to Saint Francis of Assisi as a model for evangelisation. Contrary to those pretty little 1950s holy cards, thise scarred, sickly, emacniated figure that roamed Europe in sacklothe, preaching eternal fire, repentance and penance, that we may live, wouldn't be getting all warm and cosy with sinners. He would move amongst them, live amongst them, offer them love, care and support. All the while leading them to a full and total repentance of their sins.
An Historian Posted October 31, 2014 Posted October 31, 2014 "But if the punishment due for our sins is put off till the next world, then it will be God's avenging justice, which puts everything to fire and sword, which will inflict the punishment, a dreadful, indescribable punishment: "Who understands the power of your anger?" Judgement without mercy, without relief, without merit, without limit and without end. Yes, without end. That serious sin you committed in a few brief moments, that deliberate evil thought which now escapes your memory, that word carried away by the wind, that brief action against the law of God - they shall all be punished for eternity, in the company of the devils in hell, so long as God is God. And this avenging God will have no pity on your torments, on your cries and tears, violent enough to cleave the rocks. To suffer forever, without merit, without mercy, and without end." "They will be like thunder-clouds flying through the air at the slightest breath of the Holy Spirit. Attached to nothing, surprised at nothing, troubled at nothing, they will shower down the rain of God's word and of eternal life. They will thunder against sin, they will storm against the world, they will strike down the devil and his followers and for life and for death, they will pierce through and through with the two-edged sword of God's word all those against whom they are sent by Almighty God."
Ash Wednesday Posted October 31, 2014 Posted October 31, 2014 I'm just in awe filled amusement of the usage of the term "bung-hole".
Benedictus Posted November 1, 2014 Posted November 1, 2014 (edited) I am well aware that conversion can only be accomplished by God's grace. I think it's blatantly obvious as to what I meant when I asked how we are to convert people. The example of the early Christians has already been pointed out but I will reiterate those same examples. The early Christians did not convert society and persons by ignoring sin and its realities. Rather than lowering themselves they lifted society up. When Saint Peter gave the first sermon in the history of the Church, he proclaimed the divinity of Christ, he announced the good news of salvation, and told people that had to do penance for their sins.[b] Why all of this talk of news ways and patterns? The Christian Gospel has been the same for two thousand years. Christ has died for you, He has risen in glory and conquered death, and invites you to participate in His life of grace, [b]to do so you must repent of your sins and do penance. With all due respect I don't think for a moment that we should entertain this foolish reeamination of our evangelisation in light of modern society's state. Modern society is in its current state because it has lost all concept of sin and its realities and our need of repentance and penance. Ignoring and glossing over these realities to somehow ingratiate ourselves to society will accomplish nothing but the continual decline of the Catholic faith in western society. Look to Saint Francis of Assisi as a model for evangelisation. Contrary to those pretty little 1950s holy cards, thise scarred, sickly, emacniated figure that roamed Europe in sacklothe, preaching eternal fire, repentance and penance, that we may live, wouldn't be getting all warm and cosy with sinners. He would move amongst them, live amongst them, offer them love, care and support. All the while leading them to a full and total repentance of their sins. I said the church puts the cart before the horse a lot of the time. I didn't say the church should leave the cart behind! I think you're reading more into what I actually said. These are different times culturally than the times of Jesus and Francis. They were times when people were pagans, or had other faiths, and would have already had some sort of understanding of religious devotion, community and faith. There was something to work with. That isn't necessarily the case anymore. Speaking of sin to people who don't even see themselves in this way is a futile way of doing things. It only picks up a minority of the broken and eager to listen (or those with a faith background, or a minority of seekers). If an impact wants to be made, and the solutions to flow out again, then core Gospel needs to come first. Why does God care and love them? What did he do? How does he show himself in their lives? How can he improve their lives and be with them? This comes and then a concept of sin and regret for sins against him. Part of the problem is that the churches, by and large. haven't accepted the tide has overtook them in many places and they need to rethink how they engage people (and why they lost them). Some churches do get it and they are growing because of it, not due to simple migration or birth rates. But the Catholic church is behind the time (and is losing out), and needs to adjust in terms of outreach targets and church models. Less grand standing to the fringes and more action on the parish level. Edited November 1, 2014 by Benedictus
Lilllabettt Posted November 1, 2014 Posted November 1, 2014 I said the church puts the cart before the horse a lot of the time. I didn't say the church should leave the cart behind! I think you're reading more into what I actually said. These are different times culturally than the times of Jesus and Francis. They were times when people were pagans, or had other faiths, and would have already had some sort of understanding of religious devotion, community and faith. There was something to work with. That isn't necessarily the case anymore. Speaking of sin to people who don't even see themselves in this way is a futile way of doing things. It only picks up a minority of the broken and eager to listen (or those with a faith background, or a minority of seekers). If an impact wants to be made, and the solutions to flow out again, then core Gospel needs to come first. Why does God care and love them? What did he do? How does he show himself in their lives? How can he improve their lives and be with them? This comes and then a concept of sin and regret for sins against him. Part of the problem is that the churches, by and large. haven't accepted the tide has overtook them in many places and they need to rethink how they engage people (and why they lost them). Some churches do get it and they are growing because of it, not due to simple migration or birth rates. But the Catholic church is behind the time (and is losing out), and needs to adjust in terms of outreach targets and church models. Less grand standing to the fringes and more action on the parish level. The Charismatic, evangelical and LDS churches that are growing are not doing so by "finding new ways" to present difficult teachings. They are fundamentalist. They preach fire and brimstone, my friend. They are the ones who actually go on and on about the gays. What makes the different is they offer the kind of cohesive community that comes with hard identity religion. Maybe we should follow their example?
penguin31 Posted November 1, 2014 Posted November 1, 2014 The Charismatic, evangelical and LDS churches that are growing are not doing so by "finding new ways" to present difficult teachings. They are fundamentalist. They preach fire and brimstone, my friend. They are the ones who actually go on and on about the gays. What makes the different is they offer the kind of cohesive community that comes with hard identity religion. Maybe we should follow their example? Strong community among parishoners plus doctrine and dogma that is generally consistent and coherent is almost always going to be a winning recipe for a strong faith and historically is what separates the faiths and denominations that endure against the ones who either gradually fade or disappear quickly.
An Historian Posted November 1, 2014 Posted November 1, 2014 I said the church puts the cart before the horse a lot of the time. I didn't say the church should leave the cart behind! I think you're reading more into what I actually said. These are different times culturally than the times of Jesus and Francis. They were times when people were pagans, or had other faiths, and would have already had some sort of understanding of religious devotion, community and faith. There was something to work with. That isn't necessarily the case anymore. Speaking of sin to people who don't even see themselves in this way is a futile way of doing things. It only picks up a minority of the broken and eager to listen (or those with a faith background, or a minority of seekers). If an impact wants to be made, and the solutions to flow out again, then core Gospel needs to come first. Why does God care and love them? What did he do? How does he show himself in their lives? How can he improve their lives and be with them? This comes and then a concept of sin and regret for sins against him. Part of the problem is that the churches, by and large. haven't accepted the tide has overtook them in many places and they need to rethink how they engage people (and why they lost them). Some churches do get it and they are growing because of it, not due to simple migration or birth rates. But the Catholic church is behind the time (and is losing out), and needs to adjust in terms of outreach targets and church models. Less grand standing to the fringes and more action on the parish level. Okay, if I'm not correctly understanding you, then let's try a little role play. Let's pretend I'm a homosexual man, who's been in a sexual relationship with another man for the past 3 years, I don't go to Mass or frequent the Sacraments, though I was baptized by a priest because my mother was Catholic until she died when I was 12, and my father was never around. Convert me.
Benedictus Posted November 1, 2014 Posted November 1, 2014 The Charismatic, evangelical and LDS churches that are growing are not doing so by "finding new ways" to present difficult teachings. They are fundamentalist. They preach fire and brimstone, my friend. They are the ones who actually go on and on about the gays. What makes the different is they offer the kind of cohesive community that comes with hard identity religion. Maybe we should follow their example? I'm talking about ground strategy, not changes to doctrine. Many of the churches you refer to are solid in their doctrine, but are very nuanced about how they present it and bring people in. Most Catholic churches, by contrast, in my experience have lots of anonymous people meeting in a building for mass. Only a small proportion meet in smaller groups or socialise deeply. There isn't the faith formation on any serious level for adults, no faith sharing, no testimony, no... well, a lack of lots of things. There isn't the interest or will by dioceses to move on these things. In many parishes there isn't even tea and coffee after mass to talk together! The faith can become abstract and distant. If you leave people to their own devices long enough then they start creating something that makes sense to them. The current problems many perceive with the laity are, to a large part, caused by the church in my opinion. Churches that are growing have, and are, innovating on the ground level to build up disciples through new models of ministry: cell groups, faith sharing, testimony sharing, and adequate support for members of the congregations. Above all those that are growing want to 'know' people, be with them and encorage them. They pray with them, visit them, invite them for coffee or dinner etc. They don't simply just point out peoples failures and seek to enforce rules on them. Actually not all evangelical and charismatic churches are growing. It's not the doctrine that cuts it necessarily, it's all the other things. Lets not forget that many evangelical churches are taking Catholics in Brazil and elsewhere. It's not necessarily doctrine that's the issue, it's how it's lived and presented as relevant. The Southern Baptist Convention, solid on doctrine, is in decline. This is also the case with Conservative Lutheran churches and many conservative Congregational and Baptist churches. They have the same problems as many liberal churches, they don't connect their message in a good way and or don't innovate. They carry on patterns and models of church that stop working. It's a mistake to think that doctrine is what holds the people by itself. The LDS church, if you believe they are growing by conversions and have a good retention rate (I don't), are impacted by a higher than average birth rate. The status of their growth has been disputed for many years. I wouldn't say they were fundamentalist in the typical sense either. There's many things I like about the LDS, but obviously they hold to many things mainstream Christianity doesn't. I would say there general view on Hell isn't as harsh or fixed, esp compared to fundamentalist Bible Christians. They appeal because they have a solid community spirit and see everyone as family. But they have problems, similar to the Catholic church, and that's worth noting. So far I don't see much shift towards patterns and ways of being that encourage growth in most Catholic circles.
Benedictus Posted November 1, 2014 Posted November 1, 2014 Okay, if I'm not correctly understanding you, then let's try a little role play. Let's pretend I'm a homosexual man, who's been in a sexual relationship with another man for the past 3 years, I don't go to Mass or frequent the Sacraments, though I was baptized by a priest because my mother was Catholic until she died when I was 12, and my father was never around. Convert me. All matters of evangelisation are contextual. It all depends on you. It depends on how much tme we have and lots of stuff. It's important to know how I'd come to know you in the first place, whether I'm the person best (or only person) to introduce a conversation on matters of faith, and how I come to know these matters about your background and sex life (am I assuming, is it first hand information, second hand, gossip?). There might be other matters, issues, experiences, and needs that are more pressing than those you've provided. But the core questions will always be the same, regardless. That is how can I tell, show or be with you in a way that leads you to greater holiness? How can you lead me towards the same path? So how do we do it together? The process of conversion is, in large part, done by example. It's not a single isolated event or action. It's relational at the core. So what you do and say at each stage depends how well the person would know you. The priority is to build a mutually good relationship up, be it already a friendship, acquaintance, or whatever. There has to be a space where each person can trust the other to accept them as a person of worth and dignity, able to make their own choices with freedom. The relationship shouldn't be based on one person conforming to the other persons beliefs and expectations (a power imbalance). So it's no good pretending to be a friend if remaining a friend is not the long term intention, regardless of the outcome on matters of faith. I shouldn't see you as 'my project', but as a person. :photo: My approach is usually to be a friend and companion who 1) Listens and is present, 2) Observes, 3)Supports, 4) Builds up and encourages, 5)Shares, 6)Informs, 7)Leads by example, 8) Isn't quick to judge, offer opinions or advice unless asked (or permission is sought). So, back to the example, you would come to see what I value, believe and do in the midst of all that. I may invite you to get involved in a parish social justice outreach group, like SVP. I may invite you to a meetup with other Catholic friends :beer: , or an event or regional Catholic festival. I would ask you if you wanted to come to mass with me, or meet me afterwards in the church so we can go with some others for dinner or drinks :cheers: . I would probably give you leaflets, books, or advice on retreats. I may talk to you, and offer to show you, the various ways I pray or read the bible. I may buy you Catholic gifts or cards. I may ask you more about your relationship with God, what you are struggling with and why. I would talk about church doctrine, ideas and theology. I would invite you to bible study. I would ask you about your personal relationship, how it is and what you both struggle with. I'd want you to have a well rounded and educated udnerstanding of the teachings, debates and issues at stake. I'd tell you about RCIA, the sacraments, Jesus (and his love overcoming sin), the purpose and meaning of mass etc. I'd advise you on a priest to talk with if you're having pastoral problems. I'd try and open the process up and not do it alone. Above all, I'd be praying for you to grow closer to God, see his grace, and his love in your life and the church. :cool: I'd be doing this because I thought it was good, not because you're Gay and in a relationship. I'd do the same thing for anyone I knew. It could be a single straight guy who 'dates' lots of girls and has zero interest in anything Catholic. I know a few peeps like that as well :detective: Does it work? Yes, sometimes. But, as with anything, there's no sure bet. But while there's still breath there's hope :dancer1: But every Catholic is doing this stuff, right? :think:
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now