Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

veritasluxmea
Posted

-edited for space-

Does it work? Yes, sometimes. But, as with anything, there's no sure bet. But while there's still breath there's hope :dancer1: But every Catholic is doing this stuff, right? :think:
 

But what if you were in a discussion with someone who was behaving more hostilely towards the Catholic Church, saying things like, "I don't want to have anything to do with that Church. They disagree with gays," or if it wasn't a friend of yours, just a casual neighbor or stranger? We can't have good relationships/friendships with everyone in our lives, so we can't expect to evangelize solely through relationships. Sometimes a situation does call for simple apologetics. 

 

I hope every Catholic is doing this stuff, but I doubt it. If they are, it's not working well enough. 

Posted

But what if you were in a discussion with someone who was behaving more hostilely towards the Catholic Church, saying things like, "I don't want to have anything to do with that Church. They disagree with gays," or if it wasn't a friend of yours, just a casual neighbor or stranger? We can't have good relationships/friendships with everyone in our lives, so we can't expect to evangelize solely through relationships. Sometimes a situation does call for simple apologetics. 

 

That sounds like my mother :hehe2:  Seriously though, it depends what was said to them to get that reaction. I'd say to simply see what need they are expressing and what caused it. Basically just let them vent their views without offering a defense. It maybe they believe the church is unjust, unfair or whatever. I'd acknowledge why I think they come to that conclusion. That will make them appreciate you, that you're strong enough to take on their view.  Be ready to explore the Catholic view (they may have misconceptions) but also tell them what your view is and what the view is in different Christian traditions, and why. Give it time and then ask them if they want to have a chat over coffee,  no pressure. If the topic comes up again you are prepared for a fair exchange, no debates though  :)

I doubt neighbours would say that to me, partly as I wouldn't jump on them with a Catholic invite/question and also because they'd not want to be rude. But, i know what you mean, and I know people who are on the mellow end of that view. They've progressed from outright hostility to admitting, as they've come to know me, that there is some good in Catholicism and that not all Catholics are bad. We can be open to friendships and relationships, of various sorts, with all people. I'd say Christians are called to this way of thinking. Whether the other person is willing is another matter. But there are ways to navigate around people who are hostile to faith issues at first, such as getting to know them or chat to them on something else you have in common/mutual need.

True, there's only so much a person can do from there own side and progress takes time. I think people sometimes expect instant change, it doesn't really happen. We may not even see the result of the seeds we plant. But little and often is a good rule. Different things work for different people. Our job is to be a light or way pointer for people -  to keep that door of welcome open so people can find their way into God. I know this works because friends I've known have become Christians, not always Catholics, but they have a relationship with Jesus now. It's easier now for some to see a more rounded idea of what Catholicism is about than before. They may even become Catholics at some point, God knows, but I just pray for their wellbeing and growth.
 

 

I hope every Catholic is doing this stuff, but I doubt it. If they are, it's not working well enough. 

Well some are, but many Catholics aren't moving out of their comfort zones. It's harder to build up then it is to pull apart. I think Christians have been meeting up with non Christians for coffee, cake, parties and dinner for centuries. Jesus did so in the Gospels as well. He sat with tax collectors and Prostitutes. They weren't reformed or exprostitiutes. They would leave him and go and see clients. He also included other excluded people, eunochs etc. I doubt he was scorning people at each meeting, why would they go if he did? He wanted to listen, edge them forward, teach, understand, be a companion.

Posted

All matters of evangelisation are contextual. It all depends on you. It depends on how much tme we have and lots of stuff.  It's important to know how I'd come to know you in the first place, whether I'm the person best (or only person) to introduce a conversation on matters of faith, and how I come to know these matters about your background and sex life (am I assuming, is it first hand information, second hand, gossip?).

There might be other matters, issues, experiences, and needs that are more pressing than those you've provided. But the core questions will always be the same, regardless. That is how can I tell, show or be with you in a way that leads you to greater holiness? How can you lead me towards the same path? So how do we do it together?

The process of conversion is, in large part, done by example. It's not a single isolated event or action. It's relational at the core. So what you do and say at each stage depends how well the person would know you. The priority is to build a mutually good relationship up, be it already a friendship, acquaintance, or whatever.

There has to be a space where each person can trust the other to accept them as a person of worth and dignity, able to make their own choices with freedom. The relationship shouldn't be based on one person conforming to the other persons beliefs and expectations (a power imbalance). So it's no good pretending to be a friend if remaining a friend is not the long term intention, regardless of the outcome on matters of faith. I shouldn't see you as 'my project', but as a person. :photo:

My approach is usually to be a friend and companion who 1) Listens and is present, 2) Observes, 3)Supports, 4) Builds up and encourages, 5)Shares, 6)Informs, 7)Leads by example, 8) Isn't quick to judge, offer opinions or advice unless asked (or permission is sought).

So, back to the example, you would come to see what I value, believe and do in the midst of all that. I may invite you to get involved in a parish social justice outreach group, like SVP. I may invite you to a meetup with other Catholic friends :beer: , or an event or regional Catholic festival.

I would ask you if you wanted to come to mass with me, or meet me afterwards in the church so we can go with some others for dinner or drinks :cheers: .
I would probably give you leaflets, books, or advice on retreats. I may talk to you, and offer to show you, the various ways I pray or read the bible. I may buy you Catholic gifts or cards. I may ask you more about your relationship with God, what you are struggling with and why. I would talk about church doctrine, ideas and theology. I would invite you to bible study. I would ask you about your personal relationship, how it is and what you both struggle with. I'd want you to have a well rounded and educated udnerstanding of the teachings, debates and issues at stake. I'd tell you about RCIA, the sacraments, Jesus (and his love overcoming sin), the purpose and meaning of mass etc. I'd advise you on a priest to talk with if you're having pastoral problems. I'd try and open the process up and not do it alone.

Above all, I'd be praying for you to grow closer to God, see his grace, and his love in your life and the church. :cool:  I'd be doing this because I thought it was good, not because you're Gay and in a relationship. I'd do the same thing for anyone I knew. It could be a single straight guy who 'dates' lots of girls and has zero interest in anything Catholic.  I know a few peeps like that as well :detective:

Does it work? Yes, sometimes. But, as with anything, there's no sure bet. But while there's still breath there's hope :dancer1: But every Catholic is doing this stuff, right? :think:



 

 

Okay, great so far.

 

But you never once mentioned the fact that I, in this scenario, am engaged in an intrinsically disordered relationship and engaging in sinful activities with a member of the same sex.

 

So let's say it all goes as you planned.  Now I ask you.  "What about the fact that I love being gay and I'm in a committed relationship to my boyfriend, we're getting married next month, and we're adopting a lovely little baby?"

 

Posted (edited)

Okay, great so far.

 

But you never once mentioned the fact that I, in this scenario, am engaged in an intrinsically disordered relationship and engaging in sinful activities with a member of the same sex.

 

 

You missed the bit where I said:  ..'I would ask you about your personal relationship, how it is and what you both struggle with. I'd want you to have a well rounded and educated understanding of the teachings, debates and issues at stake' and 'I'd advise you on a priest to talk with if you're having pastoral problems' and also 'I would talk about church doctrine, ideas and theology'.

My priority in this situation, as in any situation, is that a person first develop a sense of God, faith, prayer, service to others and the mass. There's little point placing other aspects as the major priority when the person doesn't even seem to be a practising Catholic. It just makes no sense and is counterproductive.

Does this mean contentious issues are ignored?  No, obviously not, but the person has to be in a position where they can actually process, respond and make an informed decision for themselves.  In my view it's better to be more nuanced and incremental at the early stages, especially when trust and knowledge is being built up. As the Bible says, God desires mercy and not sacrifice.
 

 

So let's say it all goes as you planned. 

 

All as planned? I'm not sure what this means. I'd call it being alongside someone on their journey. You could call it a strategy, as everyone has aims. But I can't control the outcome, so it's not really a plan in that sense.  Have you become a practicing Catholic or an active member of another church (or none)? Have you developed a faith and knowledge you are happy with? Have I got an idea about any of your developments or situation regarding faith, morals and practice?

 

 

  Now I ask you.  "What about the fact that I love being gay and I'm in a committed relationship to my boyfriend, we're getting married next month, and we're adopting a lovely little baby?"

 

 

 

Well then that's a choice you've made. I'd listen. I'd make more tea. I'd carry on the same process as I outlined in the first place, based on the context of the situation. The specifics will vary. Two different people can make the same choices, but they may come to make them with totally different levels of knowledge, thought and experience.

It could be the case, at this point (you've not put a time span?), that you've ditched the Catholic church and become a Buddhist. Maybe you've developed a deep faith and become an Anglican, enjoying the Catholic reformed doctrine and theology. Maybe you've already got a pride parade outfit! Maybe you've decided to become a more engaged Catholic, but you dissent on those teachings on homosexuality. Maybe, regardless of your current view, you'll be thinking and doing differently in 20 years time? Maybe you won't. God knows :flex2:

 

 

Edited by Benedictus
Posted

Did hitting someone over the head with a Bible ever convert someone's soul? I sincerely doubt it. 

 

Speaking purely for myself, "HOMOSEXUAL ACTS ARE A SIN BY THE WAY" never helped me address my sexuality within the context of my faith. My faith in and love for the Lord did. Maybe if we started with that more often we'd reach more people.

 

The distinct lack of compassion that is so often seen, illustrated by some responses in this thread, disappoints me. I understand why some people don't feel they have a place in the Church. 

Not The Philosopher
Posted

There is, I think, something to be said for obedience and humility here. It is, of course, important to articulate Church teaching and to understand the rationale behind it, but when it comes to conversion it seems to me like the more primary thing is cultivating an attitude of obedience.In other words, the question should be less like: does the potential gay convert understand why homosexual acts are sinful? and be more like: does the convert love and trust the Church enough to accept her authority in this matter? If you have the latter, the understanding often will eventually follow.

Posted

In other words, the question should be less like: does the potential gay convert understand why homosexual acts are sinful? and be more like: does the convert love and trust the Church enough to accept her authority in this matter? If you have the latter, the understanding often will eventually follow.


That's a really great point. I'd like to ponder that a bit more.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...