Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Posted

Well, this is awkward. 

took the words right out of my beak

PhuturePriest
Posted

Actually you're wrong because Science.

 

Studies show men's testosterone actually peaks around 30.

 

And Crosscut, I hope this dosn't make you gag, but that was funny.

 

Studies I've seen say 18 for men and 30 for women.

veritasluxmea
Posted

Literally this thread

 

topiclist.gif

 

Posted

my seester is a torpedo to your battleship.

 

 

 

Posted

I'm really offended right now at all of the things

Credo in Deum
Posted

Literally this thread

topiclist.gif


I laughed out loud.
Posted

I am in full favor of empathy and compassion. I do not think, however, that empathy and compassion are code words for throwing out the truth in the name of making people feel more welcome. The Church says homosexual acts are a sin that cry out to heaven for retribution, and I am inclined to agree with the Church. Is that harsh wording? Yes. Is it also the truth? Yes. It is also the truth that if I were to commit sins of a sexual nature, I would be in the same boat and in just as much danger of hell. You don't see me asking the Church to water down its language about my ultimate resting place if I live a life of sin. It is also the truth that God loves us all equally, regardless of inclination, and he wants us all in heaven with him and to in turn reject our base passions if they're leading us towards sin.

 

I am fully empathetic to the inclination towards sin, as I also sin. I am not empathetic to making us feel better about our sin by watering down its ugly truth with nicer language.

 

The difference is, Future Packer, that you're a devout Catholic actively pursuing holiness. Telling you that x or y behaviour is sinful is effective for you because you believe in sin and don't want to offend God. Telling you it leads to Hell is effective because you believe in Hell.

However none of that harsh language will work for someone in an irregular situation who isn't a strong Catholic. If I go around telling the gay people or cohabitating people I know that their sexual behaviour is "disordered" and that for that reason they need to repent or go to Hell they're not going to listen. What they will do is write me off as judgmental and want nothing more to do with me. That's why it's important that Catholics, including our leaders, use a language that is both intelligible and attractive to the mass of people who aren't devout Catholics, because the "harsh language" you're advocating simply won't be effective for them. 

veritasluxmea
Posted

The difference is, Future Packer, that you're a devout Catholic actively pursuing holiness. Telling you that x or y behaviour is sinful is effective for you because you believe in sin and don't want to offend God. Telling you it leads to Hell is effective because you believe in Hell.

However none of that harsh language will work for someone in an irregular situation who isn't a strong Catholic. If I go around telling the gay people or cohabitating people I know that their sexual behaviour is "disordered" and that for that reason they need to repent or go to Hell they're not going to listen. What they will do is write me off as judgmental and want nothing more to do with me. That's why it's important that Catholics, including our leaders, use a language that is both intelligible and attractive to the mass of people who aren't devout Catholics, because the "harsh language" you're advocating simply won't be effective for them. 

Pretty sure FP knows that already, pretty sure this thread needs to die. 

Posted

The problem as our teachings are currently written, for a 16th century audience (or maybe 1960 if we're lucky) are based on the understanding and typically abhorrent translations of the Bible available then.  We actually do know a lot more about Latin, Aramaic and other languages and it allows us to be more precise and to allow language into current teachings.

 

 

Cardinal Carlo Martini said that the church was at least 200 years out of date on most things. I think there was a tug in the 1960's, but yeah. Apparently it's now the 21st century!
 

PhuturePriest
Posted

The difference is, Future Packer, that you're a devout Catholic actively pursuing holiness. Telling you that x or y behaviour is sinful is effective for you because you believe in sin and don't want to offend God. Telling you it leads to Hell is effective because you believe in Hell.

However none of that harsh language will work for someone in an irregular situation who isn't a strong Catholic. If I go around telling the gay people or cohabitating people I know that their sexual behaviour is "disordered" and that for that reason they need to repent or go to Hell they're not going to listen. What they will do is write me off as judgmental and want nothing more to do with me. That's why it's important that Catholics, including our leaders, use a language that is both intelligible and attractive to the mass of people who aren't devout Catholics, because the "harsh language" you're advocating simply won't be effective for them. 

 

I adamantly refuse to once again explain the two sides of the Truth and why we can't be selective about it. If you want to know my thoughts in detail about this, read my other posts.

 

Also, it's different if they're not Catholic. Everything when it comes to evangelization is different if they're not Catholic.

Posted

Yeah, I don't think you're seeing the point or comprehending the issues as they often play out in the world today.

 

We're not talking about one lapsed Catholic gay wiccan hindu vegetarian martial artist, we're talking about a vast population who's often very hateful and very militant against Catholics.

 

And the Pope is saying that both sides have to come to a middle ground.  Part of that middle ground, however, does involve changing some language that is not divine (eg from the Bible) so that people can understand it better.

 

Language is a powerful tool but gets dated.  I mean just look at when people begin the Our Father or Hail Mary.  I know traditionalists who just about loose their top if you say "the" and "your" rather than "thee" and "tho".   And "thee" is not really Biblical, the Latin/Aramaic dosn't add up...its just how it was translated into English back in the 1500's.  Those languages don't even have classifiers.   So to change our language, weither it be thee's or anything else is part of a natural evolution of culture and language and, yes, even feeling.
 

 

This point about language is incredibly important.

 

For this reason I think it's about time the Church got rid of the "intrinsically disordered" language. The word "disordered" is understood in a teleological/aristotelian sense by about 0.1% of the population. It's far, far too easy for poorly catechised Catholics and non-Catholics to read that word in the Catechism (or, dare I say it, hear Cardinal Burke use it about 12 times in an interview) and think that the Church teaches gay people are suffering from a mental illness. Sadly that makes people think we view gay people as sick and they put us in the same camp as the 'ex-gay boot camp' and 'pray the gay away' fundamentalist Protestant groups who actually do regard homosexuality as a mental illness. 

 

Mental illness is what the word "disorder" commonly means in English, and its a pity the bishops didn't think of this problem when they were translating the Catechism into English. Someone who speaks a romance language fluently can correct me, but I don't think the word 'disorder' has the same medical connotations in Spanish, Italian, French, etc, as it does in English. 

Posted

Pretty sure FP knows that already, pretty sure this thread needs to die. 

 

Yeah, sorry. Reminder for next time: read thread first, then post. Don't do it the other way round :P

veritasluxmea
Posted

Yeah, sorry. Reminder for next time: read thread first, then post. Don't do it the other way round :P

been there done that

Posted

Studies I've seen say 18 for men and 30 for women.

 

 

http://www.foxnews.com/health/2013/07/04/health-myth-do-men-really-hit-their-sexual-peak-at-18/  Testosterone output is highest but males need time to "build it up" in their system so they have the largest amount of testosterone in their system about 10 years later.  But yes, men at 18 are more at risk for things like accidental arousal because the output is so high...however, they do not have enough overall to be considered at their sexual peak.

 

This point about language is incredibly important.

 

For this reason I think it's about time the Church got rid of the "intrinsically disordered" language. The word "disordered" is understood in a teleological/aristotelian sense by about 0.1% of the population. It's far, far too easy for poorly catechised Catholics and non-Catholics to read that word in the Catechism (or, dare I say it, hear Cardinal Burke use it about 12 times in an interview) and think that the Church teaches gay people are suffering from a mental illness. Sadly that makes people think we view gay people as sick and they put us in the same camp as the 'ex-gay boot camp' and 'pray the gay away' fundamentalist Protestant groups who actually do regard homosexuality as a mental illness. 

 

Mental illness is what the word "disorder" commonly means in English, and its a pity the bishops didn't think of this problem when they were translating the Catechism into English. Someone who speaks a romance language fluently can correct me, but I don't think the word 'disorder' has the same medical connotations in Spanish, Italian, French, etc, as it does in English. 

 

 

From my understanding the problem stems from Latin and finds itself in other Indo-European languages, so Italian and Spanish would be affected.  Languages like Polish, Taglong and Russian not so much.  A Polish priest I knew loved Jackie Chan...the idea that someone foreign became America's hero...  He had this saying "English cuts like a bullet when you only need a nice light karate chop"  Now that doesn't make the world's most sense, but I've heard it from other priests raised in other languages that English (and Spanish, but that less so) have a horrible way of being demoralizing and degrading.

 

If you look at the 3 Popes, and subtract out the environmental factor of their upbringing and their personalities, much of their doctrine is affected by the language they spoke.  It's no surprise to me that a German pope used harsher language than a Polish one, and that a Spanish speaking Pope has different ideals than his predecessor.

Posted

I appreciate the discussion, everyone. Thanks for weighing in!

Posted

http://www.foxnews.com/health/2013/07/04/health-myth-do-men-really-hit-their-sexual-peak-at-18/  Testosterone output is highest but males need time to "build it up" in their system so they have the largest amount of testosterone in their system about 10 years later.  But yes, men at 18 are more at risk for things like accidental arousal because the output is so high...however, they do not have enough overall to be considered at their sexual peak.

 

 

 

From my understanding the problem stems from Latin and finds itself in other Indo-European languages, so Italian and Spanish would be affected.  Languages like Polish, Taglong and Russian not so much.  A Polish priest I knew loved Jackie Chan...the idea that someone foreign became America's hero...  He had this saying "English cuts like a bullet when you only need a nice light karate chop"  Now that doesn't make the world's most sense, but I've heard it from other priests raised in other languages that English (and Spanish, but that less so) have a horrible way of being demoralizing and degrading.

 

If you look at the 3 Popes, and subtract out the environmental factor of their upbringing and their personalities, much of their doctrine is affected by the language they spoke.  It's no surprise to me that a German pope used harsher language than a Polish one, and that a Spanish speaking Pope has different ideals than his predecessor.

 

Except your linguistics lessons isn't consistent. If Latin is the problem, then what influence (apart from a smattering of vocabulary) would it have on a German speaker? 

Posted

Except your linguistics lessons isn't consistent. If Latin is the problem, then what influence (apart from a smattering of vocabulary) would it have on a German speaker? 

 

German has a few Latin  words, but its more of the Indo-European problem rather than simply Latin.  Latin is the biggest offender, but not the only one.

 

Posted

German has a few Latin  words, but its more of the Indo-European problem rather than simply Latin.  Latin is the biggest offender, but not the only one.

 

Make up your mind! 

 

Also just realizing this was probably in response to Aragon's post? Well, the CCC (official Latin) states that "Haec propensio, obiective inordinata" which in English is rendered "This inclination, which is objectively disordered." The offending word, I would presume is inordinata. Which, if you look at in any Latin/English Dictionary, could only translate (in the context) as disordered.  

 

Actually, considering this discussion is already so far afield, this could actually be resurrected into a fruitful conversation! I think the linguistic difference does hold some weight, but not for the reasons you think. Ecclesiastical and Medieval Latin evolved such that they became increasingly juridical. Indeed, the Romanisation of the Western Church, going back to the 4th century, can largely be seen in the importation of the Roman legal system by the Church. Following this development from this time, through the Middle Ages and into Modernity could actually show some of what you're trying to say, and indeed, in the interpretation of the Second Vatican Council, most scholars note a shift in language; from a legal genre to a more literary genre. 

 

But that doesn't have much to do with the language of the Bible. Or the difference between using formal equivalence or dynamic equivalence to translate the liturgy. 

Basilisa Marie
Posted

 

What would you say is the main difference between the apostates of that time and the active homosexuals and divorced and remarried of today?

 

The apostates were expected to repent and sin no more.

 

Do you think the 2 modern day groups of Speshul Sinners should be required to repent and sin no more like ordinary thieves, liars, racists, murderers, wife beaters are? Why or why not?

 

 

 

:rolleyes: 

 

As I've already told you, the whole issue with allowing certain divorced and remarried people to communion is for those who are trying to make a good effort to repent, but our annulment process is long, laborious, and imperfect, and sometimes there are other goods to be achieved by, say, allowing the couple to still live together (though not engaging in the marital act). It may be an occasion of sin for the couple, but maybe there are other goods to be achieved - this is what I understand to be one of the questions at the synod. So how much repentance is enough repentance? How much suffering is enough suffering? 

 

And as far as others, the Church HAS decided to recognize the good in other religions insofar as they participate in the truth of Catholicism.  See the Vatican documents. So it's not that far of a logical jump to recognize the good in irregular relationships as part of a greater effort to reach out to them to bring them closer to Christ through conversion.  Do we really, truly believe that there is absolutely nothing good in a long-term, stable, loving same-sex relationship? Yes, we can't tell people that it's a-okay to engage in homosexual (or premarital) sexual activities. But do we also want to say that those activities have destroyed any good that the couple may experience from their relationship? 

People who are in habits of mortal sin of an addictive nature (say, a sexual sin) should go to confession after they commit the sin before they receive communion.  But the Church also mercifully recognizes that sometimes, the addiction can sometimes render those acts venial instead of mortal, because the person wasn't truly free to choose that act. It's not realistic to expect a person with a sinful addiction to quit cold turkey after they go to confession once, we do expect them to make their best effort to fight it, and we encourage frequent confession and reception of communion to help strengthen that person against sin so they can overcome it with grace. This isn't a totally new idea. People lead messy lives, and conversion and holiness is a process. This whole thing is about trying to figure out the best way to help people in that process.  Maybe no changes will be made. That'd be fine, I trust that the bishops are going to try to figure out what's best. 

PhuturePriest
Posted

Yeah, sorry. Reminder for next time: read thread first, then post. Don't do it the other way round :P

 

It's nothing I haven't done myself time and again. :P

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...