Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

The Totally Unoffical Phatmass US Presidential Election Poll


The Totally Unoffical Phatmass US Presidential Election Poll  

62 members have voted

You do not have permission to vote in this poll, or see the poll results. Please sign in or register to vote in this poll.

Recommended Posts

Posted

Now I know how Catholics in Spain must have felt in the 1930s...

LittleWaySoul
Posted
6 hours ago, Anomaly said:

Catholic as used in the article and by most people.  Someone who identifies themselves as Catholic and considerd Catholic by the Church.

Except that the qualifications Peace set out in his previous comment are more or less the qualifications that the Church has for continued membership and full communion, as far as I am aware. So actually, the article sounds like it's only talking about people who identify as Catholic, not necessarily people who are considered to be Catholics in good standing by the Church.

Posted
9 hours ago, LittleWaySoul said:

Except that the qualifications Peace set out in his previous comment are more or less the qualifications that the Church has for continued membership and full communion, as far as I am aware. So actually, the article sounds like it's only talking about people who identify as Catholic, not necessarily people who are considered to be Catholics in good standing by the Church.

You know, as well as I, with almost of all of those things, you're still A Catholic, just not in a state of grace.  You aren't excommunicated for missing mass, skipping confession, poor catechesis, etc.   Otherwise, on any given day, Catholics would be counted in the hundreds of thousands, not in excess of a billion.   Or maybe just a couple of thousand registered US voters are perfectly Catholic Catholic which makes my point.    Generally, the majority of Catholics do not vote with abortion as a primary moral principle.   They see it as equally important as torture or healthcare access.   "It's okay to vote for a Democrat that protects and supports abortion if they are for Government Healthcare" is not the same as not voting for a Democrat  who supports and promotes abortion if their opponents don't support abortion and/or want to limit them AND do not support Givernment Healthcare.  

HisChildForever
Posted (edited)

Also, while certainly not a Trump fan, if Wikileaks revealed that people in his campaign were saying this about Islam, there would be such an uproar on every major news outlet.

EDIT: Oh dear I meant to post this in the Wikileaks Clinton thread. Can a moderator please move it for me? Sorry :/

Edited by HisChildForever
Posted
1 hour ago, Anomaly said:

Generally, the majority of Catholics do not vote with abortion as a primary moral principle.   They see it as equally important as torture or healthcare access.   "It's okay to vote for a Democrat that protects and supports abortion if they are for Government Healthcare" is not the same as not voting for a Democrat  who supports and promotes abortion if their opponents don't support abortion and/or want to limit them AND do not support Givernment Healthcare.  

Your assertion was that most pro-life Catholics compromise their pro-life position by voting for pro-choice candidates, because those pro-choice candidates support things such as Universal Health Care. As I wrote before, this is merely a figment of your imagination. You have not produced any data that supports that assertion.

You have only produced data that indicates that roughly 50% of people who profess to be Catholic typically vote for pro-choice candidates. Among the people who profess to be Catholic, roughly 50% disagree with the Church's teaching on abortion. In other words, among those who profess to be Catholic, roughly 50% are pro-choice, and roughly 50% are pro-life. The article that you referenced indicates this:

Quote

Polling shows a majority of Catholics classify themselves as pro-life; a 2009 poll showed a 52% majority identifying as pro-life.[53] Pew Research, combining polls from 2011 and 2013, notes that over half (53%) of white Catholics believe abortion should be legal in all or most cases, with 41% saying it should be illegal in all or most cases. Among Hispanic Catholics, 43% say it should be legal in all or most cases, while 52% say it should be illegal in all or most cases.[54]

It is rather likely that most of the 50% of professed Catholics who vote for pro-choice candidates are comprised by the 50% of professed Catholics who are personally pro-choice. Why? Because people who are pro-choice tend to vote Democrat. How may pro-choice Republicans do you know?

Is this really that difficult to understand?

Let's make a simple example:
 

Quote

 

Total Professed Catholics: 10

Professed Catholic 1: Agrees with the Church's teaching on abortion. Personally pro-life. Votes Republican.

Professed Catholic 2: Agrees with the Church's teaching on abortion. Personally pro-life. Votes Republican.

Professed Catholic 3: Agrees with the Church's teaching on abortion. Personally pro-life. Votes Republican.

Professed Catholic 4: Agrees with the Church's teaching on abortion. Personally pro-life. Votes Republican.

Professed Catholic 5: Agrees with the Church's teaching on abortion. Personally pro-life. Votes Republican.

Professed Catholic 6: Disagrees with the Church's teaching on abortion. Personally pro-choice. Votes Democrat.

Professed Catholic 7: Disagrees with the Church's teaching on abortion. Personally pro-choice. Votes Democrat.

Professed Catholic 8: Disagrees with the Church's teaching on abortion. Personally pro-choice. Votes Democrat.

Professed Catholic 9: Disagrees with the Church's teaching on abortion. Personally pro-choice. Votes Democrat.

Professed Catholic 10: Disagrees with the Church's teaching on abortion. Personally pro-choice. Votes Democrat.

 

The Wikipedia article indicates that roughly 50% of professed Catholics are personally pro-life, and that roughly 50% of professed Catholics vote Democrat.  These criteria hold in my example above, yet in my example not a single Catholic who agrees with the Church's teaching on abortion (in other words, a Catholic who is personally pro-life) has voted for a pro-choice candidate.

Can you now understand why the data you have presented does not support your assertion that there are a significant number of pro-life Catholics who vote Democrat?

Posted
2 hours ago, Peace said:

Your assertion was that most pro-life Catholics compromise their pro-life position by voting for pro-choice candidates, because those pro-choice candidates support things such as Universal Health Care. As I wrote before, this is merely a figment of your imagination. You have not produced any data that supports that assertion.

You have only produced data that indicates that roughly 50% of people who profess to be Catholic typically vote for pro-choice candidates. Among the people who profess to be Catholic, roughly 50% disagree with the Church's teaching on abortion. In other words, among those who profess to be Catholic, roughly 50% are pro-choice, and roughly 50% are pro-life. The article that you referenced indicates this:

It is rather likely that most of the 50% of professed Catholics who vote for pro-choice candidates are comprised by the 50% of professed Catholics who are personally pro-choice. Why? Because people who are pro-choice tend to vote Democrat. How may pro-choice Republicans do you know?

Is this really that difficult to understand?

Let's make a simple example:
 

The Wikipedia article indicates that roughly 50% of professed Catholics are personally pro-life, and that roughly 50% of professed Catholics vote Democrat.  These criteria hold in my example above, yet in my example not a single Catholic who agrees with the Church's teaching on abortion (in other words, a Catholic who is personally pro-life) has voted for a pro-choice candidate.

Can you now understand why the data you have presented does not support your assertion that there are a significant number of pro-life Catholics who vote Democrat?

I never said "pro-life" Catholics, nor did the article.   I said Catholics.  Despite your intimations to the contrary, we both know what was said and meant.  If I said most Catholics have children, you'd claimed most priests, are practicing Catholic, don't have kids and tell me I'm wrong.   

Complain about people who identify as Catholic, complain about poor catechesis, complain about ambiguous bishops.   Don't complain I'm wrong and that makes the other things better. 

Posted
23 minutes ago, Anomaly said:

I never said "pro-life" Catholics, nor did the article.   I said Catholics.  Despite your intimations to the contrary, we both know what was said and meant.

Whatever.

Posted (edited)
On 10/11/2016 at 5:46 PM, little2add said:

 this will not be the last time the Hillary campaign will commit political sabotage against Trump. Since they don’t have logical solutions, they will attempt to distract us with a negative focus on Trump.

“It doesn’t matter whether they’re lying or not,” Carson, a Trump supporter and adviser, said in an appearance on Morning Joe Friday. “What matters is that the train is going off the cliff. We’re taking our eye off of that and we’re getting involved in other issues that should be taken care of later.”

Ben Carson

 

for instence:

WASHINGTON (Reuters) - A U.S. Navy destroyer was targeted on Saturday in a failed missile attack from territory in Yemen controlled by Iran-aligned Houthi rebels, the third such incident in the past week, U.S. officials said.

Multiple surface-to-surface missiles were fired at the USS Mason sailing in international waters in the Red Sea but the warship used on-board countermeasures to defend itself and was not hit, one defense official said, citing initial information.

The latest attack could provoke further retaliation by the U.S. military, which launched cruise missiles on Thursday against three coastal radar sites in Houthi-controlled areas in Yemen in response to the two previous failed missile firings against the Mason.

the above story , that could easily expand into a nuclear exchange with Russia is hardly noted or talked about by the media???

Edited by little2add
<3 PopeFrancis
Posted

When Hillary wins, impeachment process will start faster than one can say bureaucracy.

:smile2:

 

 

Posted
1 hour ago, <3 PopeFrancis said:

When Hillary wins, impeachment process will start faster than one can say bureaucracy.

:smile2:

 

 

Not likely.  The attempted cover is worse than what she may have done, but those actors are remiv d from her.   It would be hard to pin it in her, even if she asked for it and things weren't done by eager associates that don't need explicit directions.  It's not all on Hillary.  

Posted (edited)
30 minutes ago, dairygirl4u2c said:

I am shocked that you've heard of Politifact!    Politifact was partially created by one of the local papers in Tampa Bay, "The Times", which has always been the "liberal" paper.   They just bought the competition, the more mainstream, older, "Tampa Tribune".   

The Tampa Bay Times is a good newspaper, and does some great journalism, but it isn't known as a center it's or unbiased paper.    

Politifact is widely referenced in local TV political talk shows.   The criticism (by liberal and conservative) is it "fact checks" things that are opinions or open to interpretation and selects "trendy topics".  What it compares and opines on aren't really "facts".

Politifact is intended to sell papers by discussing trending topics, not really be an unbiased review of all pertinent issues or even topics that can be factually determined.   It is interesting and generally informative, if you understand what they're doing and take it with a grain of salt.  I wouldn't put it in the same category as left leaning "FAIR", but certainly it isn't completely unbiased. 

Edited by Anomaly
Posted

Watching the 3rd debate. Rubio would have done so much better of a job on the abortion question. 

Posted

What scares me about Trump is how badly he'd behave when interacting with political leaders of other countries. And for that matter with those in the U.S.

Posted
On 10/14/2016 at 9:32 PM, Norseman82 said:

Now I know how Catholics in Spain must have felt in the 1930s...

 

I'm not seeing parishes burned to the ground and people rounded up and shot in the streets for their belief in the Church.  To compare our current political climate to the Red Terror of 1930s Spain is an insult to those who gave their lives for their beliefs and were victims of that period.

 

On 10/13/2016 at 1:22 PM, dominicansoul said:

Hilary

Two questions, from reading your posts on every thread.  First, do you intentionally mis-spell that candidate's name every post (and if so, why)? 

 

Second, why is Donald Trump, "Trump", but Hillary Clinton is "Hillary"?  That's just a general thing I've pondered through the election, and noticed that I've done it as well.

 

Posted
15 hours ago, Peace said:

Watching the 3rd debate. Rubio would have done so much better of a job on the abortion question. 

You should have seen Rubio debate Murphy this week.  It may be on YouTube.    They're both running for US Senate.   I watched part.   Did not see them discuss abortion, but I'm sure it came up. Rubio is very anti abortion and the Dems are slamming him for it. 

Rubio had an excellent response for supporting Trump.   He said Trump isn't his 20th choice for president, and it's Rubio's job to challenge Trmp if Rubio and Trump get elected.  But Trump is still better than Hillary as far as abortion, Hyde Ammendment, etc.

Posted
23 minutes ago, Anomaly said:

You should have seen Rubio debate Murphy this week.  It may be on YouTube.    They're both running for US Senate.   I watched part.   Did not see them discuss abortion, but I'm sure it came up. Rubio is very anti abortion and the Dems are slamming him for it. 

Rubio had an excellent response for supporting Trump.   He said Trump isn't his 20th choice for president, and it's Rubio's job to challenge Trmp if Rubio and Trump get elected.  But Trump is still better than Hillary as far as abortion, Hyde Ammendment, etc.

Thanks. I will try to find it. I would love to see a Rubio / Haley ticket in 2020.

Posted

Me, not so much. Rubio is a bit too much a political machine creature though I do like many if his positions.   My wife (not US born) loves him.  He helped us out with a passport issue a few years ago.  Rubio needs to do a full term, full time, as a senator.  

Rubio was ahead until recently.  The gap narrowed significantly because the Dems are selling anti-abortion as anti-woman.   Evil Republicans are anti-women as evidenced by being anti-abortion, even with a Zika infection.   That is a HUGE issue.  Nobody sees the duplicity of saying it's okay to kill a burdensome person as a "life respectful" choice.   It's sociopathic.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...