Maximilianus Posted December 4, 2018 Posted December 4, 2018 phatmass is like a pub you used to frequent daily, but now visit on occasion. At one time it was vibrant and you looked forward to spending time there. Now when you go to the pub you don't recognize many or the place is empty. Long time patrons that were staples of activity have long gone, or just come inside to down a shot of spirits, pass some pleasantries then disappear like a fog that has been dissipated by the dawning of the morning sun. You have a vague recognition of some of the patrons. A few you have seen at the pub since your very first day there, but you really don't know them, so you don't even make any kind of contact, you just let them imbibe in peace. Every once in a while you run into an old acquaintance, but the relationship has devolved to where they are almost strangers again. You see other old acquaintances across the bar in a booth. They acknowledge you with a raise of their glass or a nod and quickly turn back to their already in progress conversation with another vaguely familiar patron. Every once in a while there is a bar scuffle, sometimes between individuals, sometimes it's an affair with multiple patrons, but the pub owner quells the conflict. You look around the dimly lit hall, at the empty seats, stools, booths, and sigh. You think of when they used to be filled, of the abundance of good natured revelry, exchange of ideas, exchange of experiences, the sometimes tense contentions and mutual reinforcement of ideals and beliefs. So you sit at the bar, all alone, staring at your pint and looking at the myriad of faded and tired advertisements on the walls of various beverages while in the background someone attempts to play Gary Jules's version of 'Mad World' on an old piano. You smile at the faint familiarity, turn back and finish your malty beverage, then leave the establishment. As you walk home you pass other pubs, some you have been to before, some you don't care to enter. None of them look particularly inviting. So you enter a bookstore, head to the Catholic section that has a half a dozen books. You see the NAB, CCC, Catholicism for dummies, 2 books by popular heterodox authors and a misplaced copy of "Green Eggs and Ham". Fin
BG45 Posted December 5, 2018 Posted December 5, 2018 Mostly I think it's that people got married, had kids, got jobs, etc. Life is busy. I'm on 6 committees, teaching 4 classes a semester, have 180 advisees, and just submitted the first draft of an invited book chapter. For me it's that being busy mostly, and being at a point in life where I avoid drama due to an anxiety issue. Personally, I don't buy the "all forums are gong downhill thanks to social media bit", I'm on one scifi forum that has more Mediators of Meh than Phatmass has active posters, because it's such a vibrant place and it still maintains a sense of community; likewise another board I sometimes frequent has about the same level of traffic as PM did back in the day. Unfortunately, part of it is also probably things like how nunsense was apparently asked to leave, or how some posters got soft-banned where their every post has to be approved by a Mediator of Meh or Dust (e.g. Crosscut). There's also the part about how the poor witness of Phatmass cost a few former members their faith in Christ and His Church as well, though that's for them to share with whom they please.
Guest Posted December 5, 2018 Posted December 5, 2018 4 hours ago, BG45 said: There's also the part about how the poor witness of Phatmass cost a few former members their faith in Christ and His Church as well, though that's for them to share with whom they please. No offence but I find it lame a website or its poster's would cause someone to lose their faith in Christ and His Church. Unless the website was a conspiracy site or something disproving Jesus and Catholicism. Although it wouldn't be Catholic then. I literally got banned for a 1000 years by Catholic Answers with no warnings for arguing with a poster who was spewing out racism and saying probably only Catholics will get to Heaven. I wasn't cursing but being very blunt with this poster in an unfriendly tone. The fact some Mediator of Meh banned me a 1000 years for this without a warning doesn't make me lose my faith in Jesus or Catholicism. If it did I had no sincere faith to begin with. I just accept the fact most of these Catholic media sites are filled with people like this. And when I say "like this" I don't intend to say it in a way to present myself as the victim and the better person. I just know I don't see eye to eye with a lot of these people who are previlant on forums and on the radio. I'm not about to let them rob me of my faith. I even still listen to them on the radio and read what they write and take away the good stuff that helps me. I feel bad there are actual people who lost their faith because of Phatmass. But at the same time I can't help to also feel it's really lame. I'm lame in a lot of areas too so we're in the same boat. Whoever these people are will be included in my next Rosary and I pray their faith is restored.
Anomaly Posted December 5, 2018 Posted December 5, 2018 #1 Reason: Because dUSt rarely posts and is minimally involved in the website. That is the lack of leadership personality needed.
Lilllabettt Posted December 5, 2018 Posted December 5, 2018 5 hours ago, Josh said: No offence but I find it lame a website or its poster's would cause someone to lose their faith in Christ and His Church. Unless the website was a conspiracy site or something disproving Jesus and Catholicism. Although it wouldn't be Catholic then. I literally got banned for a 1000 years by Catholic Answers with no warnings for arguing with a poster who was spewing out racism and saying probably only Catholics will get to Heaven. I wasn't cursing but being very blunt with this poster in an unfriendly tone. The fact some Mediator of Meh banned me a 1000 years for this without a warning doesn't make me lose my faith in Jesus or Catholicism. If it did I had no sincere faith to begin with. I just accept the fact most of these Catholic media sites are filled with people like this. And when I say "like this" I don't intend to say it in a way to present myself as the victim and the better person. I just know I don't see eye to eye with a lot of these people who are previlant on forums and on the radio. I'm not about to let them rob me of my faith. I even still listen to them on the radio and read what they write and take away the good stuff that helps me. I feel bad there are actual people who lost their faith because of Phatmass. But at the same time I can't help to also feel it's really lame. I'm lame in a lot of areas too so we're in the same boat. Whoever these people are will be included in my next Rosary and I pray their faith is restored. Did they really ban you 1000 years? I have to say I appreciate the dramatic flourish. 1,000 yrs is more beautiful than "perma ban." I used to tell bad Catholics they should consider leaving the church. When I say bad, I dont mean sinners. I mean people who just dont believe that what the Church teaches is a sin, is a sin. Because I believe God prefers an honest atheist to a hypocritical Catholic, who mouths the words I'm Catholic but who's heart says "no." And, I still believe this, honestly. I think people who confront who they are have a better chance at conversion one day too vs someone who stays comfy as a cultural catholic. And I, personally, know that I value integrity more than other things. So I would 100% burn my catholic culture to the ground if I didnt think it was true. Part of it is I expect others to value the same things, and I am irritated when they dont. But, I repented from that, because i realized its above my pay grade. I have too much fear and trembling that people could die in mortal sin because of my advice. Maybe they would anyway, because they dont see a need to confess sexual sin, for example. But who knows what path their soul might take, better to leave it to God than to puppet master people. So, it is needed to take care what we say or do. On the other hand. Ive heard it said there are two sins. Giving scandal and being scandalized. Giving scandal is like murder, being scandalized is like suicide. Like you said. committing spiritual suicide because of a message board would seem to be seriously lame. One would think people value their relationship with Jesus more than that - if they were believers to begin with.
Guest Posted December 5, 2018 Posted December 5, 2018 (edited) 1 hour ago, Lilllabettt said: Did they really ban you 1000 years? I have to say I appreciate the dramatic flourish. 1,000 yrs is more beautiful than "perma ban." Yes haha I first thought it was a 2 week ban or something. Then I tried logging back in a month later and still couldn't. Then finally saw the 3018 lol I don't really care. I still browse the site and find a lot of the discussions there interesting. And bizarre if I'm being honest. I even opened a new account again after realising the until 3018 ban. And I couldn't resist getting immediately involved in a "Is there sex in Heaven" thread (started by another poster) and putting up quotes from Peter Kreeft insinuating there might be. And then again getting very combative with a poster who was 100% opposed to what I was saying and talking down to me like I was a 5 year old. So I was banned again for 1000 years and the additional reason given this time was for opening a second account. I don't think banning someone without a warning for a 1000 years is a good idea. Especially on a Catholic site but then again I see how they want to keep the conversation there completely respectful and this is a great way to accomplish it. And it's not like I can't open another account and now I know if I'm going to dialogue there it has to be with no sarcasm or disrespecting of posters in anyway. And that's cool I get it. Edited December 5, 2018 by Guest
MIKolbe Posted December 5, 2018 Posted December 5, 2018 I'm not a Mediator of Meh anymore. That's why.... That and chump is filtered.. Mainly the foolish person thing, tho.
Ice_nine Posted December 5, 2018 Posted December 5, 2018 Probably the people that left. This place was always some strange enclave of internet Catholicism. We had discussions here that probably wouldn't fly on other Catholic phorums, and a lot of people who I think were willing to challenge the status quo but still hold fast to the faith. That was pretty dope to me. (Pardon the pun but I found phatmass searching the morality of marijuana usage and was a bit shocked and intrigued to find out that most people here didn't think it was the smoke of Satan). I sometimes wonder where people have gone. I know it's a lot of the having families and being busy and all of that. There was some clique-ish stuff going on. I don't think I was ever cool enough to be a part of that, but I kind of wanted to be. I don't remember. Anyhow, yeah the people left. This place didn't really attract new active members as often enough to compete with the well established community here. And because it was kind of insular and hard to penetrate, when those people left there was no influx of people to replace them. They are after all part of what made this place interesting. So yeah, I wish some of the old members would poke around sometime, just so I know what they're up to. Who knows. It's weird cause like some of them could be dead or in prison or something and I'd be none the wiser. I've thought about irresponsibly using my Mediator of Meh powers to hunt some of them down, but alas I leave them to their peace.
Seven77 Posted December 6, 2018 Posted December 6, 2018 5 hours ago, Ice_nine said: So yeah, I wish some of the old members would poke around sometime, just so I know what they're up to. Who knows. It's weird cause like some of them could be dead or in prison or something and I'd be none the wiser. I've thought about irresponsibly using my Mediator of Meh powers to hunt some of them down, but alas I leave them to their peace. I think that it would be a good use of your mediator of meh superpowers to see what they are up to. Might inspire them to come back…
tinytherese Posted December 6, 2018 Author Posted December 6, 2018 17 hours ago, Josh said: I feel bad there are actual people who lost their faith because of Phatmass. But at the same time I can't help to also feel it's really lame. I'm lame in a lot of areas too so we're in the same boat. Whoever these people are will be included in my next Rosary and I pray their faith is restored. Yea, it's no excuse, but it's understandable considering how hard it can be to feel unwelcome or like an outsider. It doesn't justify leaving though. The Catholic Answers Forum is a weird place. I sometimes find myself on reading some threads though despite this. Banning people without any warning is rather extreme. If there's a problem, why not discuss it?
little2add Posted December 7, 2018 Posted December 7, 2018 (edited) the scandals involving sexual abuse by Catholic priests hasn't helped. Being or talking about being catholic, hence the diminished attraction of this and other sites devoted to catholic faith, etc. Edited December 7, 2018 by little2add
Ice_nine Posted December 7, 2018 Posted December 7, 2018 On 12/5/2018 at 8:45 PM, Seven77 said: I think that it would be a good use of your mediator of meh superpowers to see what they are up to. Might inspire them to come back… My powers aren't that super. I can see their emails, but who knows if the email the registered with is what they even use.
Lilllabettt Posted December 7, 2018 Posted December 7, 2018 On 12/5/2018 at 9:12 PM, tinytherese said: Yea, it's no excuse, but it's understandable considering how hard it can be to feel unwelcome or like an outsider. It doesn't justify leaving though. The Catholic Answers Forum is a weird place. I sometimes find myself on reading some threads though despite this. Banning people without any warning is rather extreme. If there's a problem, why not discuss it? I would describe CA as "rigid". Whereas, phatmass is/was a modem of dynamic orthodoxy. There was the "phishy" tag but other than that the members themselves argued down heterodox ideas.
Jack4 Posted December 8, 2018 Posted December 8, 2018 When I joined, there were discussions. There were threads. When the phorum was more or less dead, I stopped visiting much.
Ziggamafu Posted December 9, 2018 Posted December 9, 2018 (edited) Hello. I joined in...something like 2007? Earlier? Can’t remember. Brother Adam, PhatCatholic, St Olaf, Aloysius (?), uhhh... the hardcore Eastern Catholic whose username I can’t remember... I don’t know. I’d like to know where they all ended up. Here I am, logging in for the first time in nearly a decade... Don’t recognize anyone. On 12/1/2018 at 5:54 AM, cruciatacara said: I know nunsense personally. She was basically kicked off the forum - dust told her the other posters had voted and they considered her to be a trouble maker. Naturally she felt unwelcome after that. You won't get her back here again. She's very happy in her life and doesn't need the validation of phatmass. I lurk here mainly, but the place really has gone downhill since I first joined. I think some people started taking things too seriously and wouldn't allow any dissenting opinions. Maybe that's not it, I don't know. But your comment was kind and I will pass it on to her if I see her. Dust... https://goo.gl/images/25gNdx Edited December 9, 2018 by Ziggamafu
Jack4 Posted December 9, 2018 Posted December 9, 2018 46 minutes ago, Ziggamafu said: Hello. I joined in...something like 2007? Earlier? Can’t remember. May 27, 2004 is your join date.
Ziggamafu Posted December 9, 2018 Posted December 9, 2018 5 minutes ago, Jack4 said: May 27, 2004 is your join date. Makes sense...received my first Communion in Easter ‘05. Wild visiting this place again...and sort of sad. I remember the Eastern guy: Apotheoun.
CountrySteve937 Posted December 9, 2018 Posted December 9, 2018 I remember joining in 2013 or 2011. I lost my old account t, so had to make a new one. It is sad logging back in, and seeing most of the old people gone. That’s life, I suppose. Nothing is ever permanent.
Ash Wednesday Posted December 10, 2018 Posted December 10, 2018 On 12/5/2018 at 3:05 PM, Lilllabettt said: On the other hand. Ive heard it said there are two sins. Giving scandal and being scandalized. Giving scandal is like murder, being scandalized is like suicide. Like you said. committing spiritual suicide because of a message board would seem to be seriously lame. One would think people value their relationship with Jesus more than that - if they were believers to begin with. I tend to agree -- without excusing behavior on the boards or on social media for any Catholic, I think if people fall away because of something online, there was something seriously amiss and their faith was on shaky ground already. Naturally we are supposed to help more than hurt people in a vulnerable place, but I know a great deal of people who would leave the Church because of personal issues but they didn't really believe everything about Catholicism in the first place and it gave them an excuse to leave. I remember a girl in our college youth group left the church because she had some kind of awkward falling out with a guy she had a crush on. She stopped going to the campus mass and youth group altogether to avoid him and started attending another fellowship. More or less my memory isn't exact but I think I asked her why she wouldn't want to practice as a Catholic or go to mass, and the conversation led to her saying that "it doesn't matter." That was the underlying deeper problem -- to go to another church really just didn't make a lot of difference to her. On the flip side, there are many saints that were poorly treated by many of their own in the Church, including their own superiors at times, but they endured with kindness and patience because their convictions just that strong.
dominicansoul Posted December 10, 2018 Posted December 10, 2018 you know a forum is dead when you see spam showing up as the top active threads...
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now