cmotherofpirl Posted November 29, 2004 Posted November 29, 2004 [quote name='popestpiusx' date='Nov 29 2004, 10:31 AM'] Cmom, I have a question. It's kind of chicken and egg question. Which came first, feminism or men's abandonment of true manly virtue. There is no question that one of the major problems of society is the absence (or scarcity) of real men infused with true manly virtue (to be distinguished from machoism). Did feminism rise as a result of this void, or did feminsim cause men to retreat? [/quote] My precaffeine ramble: Neither are a cause, both are the result of the 60's idea that all authority is bad. Feminism started long ago when women decided to protest their unequal and unjust and unethical treatment by men, when women were virtual slaves of the husbands. I would actually trace most of it back to the French Revolution and naturalism. But in the quest for freedom, women threw out the baby with the bathwater. In removing restrainsts on divorce, women unintentionally gave permission to men to run away from their responsibilites with little or no punishment. We took away all the social constructs that forced men to take care of the children they produced and protected women and children. Men abandoned their roles because its easier and because we let them. By demanding the right to work, we set up the idea that women should work, and finally demand they have to work.From being for equality in the workplace, we now actually punish who wanted to stay home and raise babies. We wanted equal pay for equal work, and protection from unendurable abusive marriages, we got far more than we bargained for, with mostly dire results. Most women did not buy into feminism as it was strumpeted, so the radical female type took it over and have pushed it to its stupidity we see today. Feminism didn't cause men to retreat, it gave them permission. :angry:
popestpiusx Posted November 29, 2004 Posted November 29, 2004 (edited) I think I would agree with that, with the additional statement that men failed by stepping back and allowing it to happen. Had men reacted the way they should have, the radical feminist movement would have died, in my opinion. I think ultimately the blame must be placed on men who ceased to act with manly virtue. They (or I should say, we) abandoned our post. Edited November 29, 2004 by popestpiusx
homeschoolmom Posted November 29, 2004 Posted November 29, 2004 [quote name='popestpiusx' date='Nov 29 2004, 11:53 AM'] I think I would agree with that, with the additional statement that men failed by stepping back and allowing it to happen. Had men reacted the way they should have, the radical feminist movement would have died, in my opinion. [/quote] How do you suggest they should have reacted...? and to what time period are you referring?
popestpiusx Posted November 29, 2004 Posted November 29, 2004 (edited) [quote name='homeschoolmom' date='Nov 29 2004, 12:56 PM'] How do you suggest they should have reacted...? and to what time period are you referring? [/quote] In general I would say it has happened over the course of the last 200 years, though most noticeably that last hundred with issues such as women’s suffrage. Of course, it got its greatest boost from the 1950's on with people like Betty Friedan and company. That was the crucial moment when men ultimately failed to see it for what is was, a social revolution. The entire fabric of society was torn asunder. This is the same time period, not coincidently, produced the Pill, which was merely a precursor to legal abortion. How are men responsible? They were bought off. If they had fewer children and then the wives were free to enter the workplace (which resulted in a whole other revolution of sorts), which made more money for them to spend on toys: nicer houses in suburbia, more fashionable cars to replace the family station wagon, etc. etc. Men like toys. Men like sex. The feminist revolution allowed them to have both, with fewer "negative" repercussions. How should they have reacted? They should have used the authority they had as the heads of households, or of businesses, or as politicians, or whatever, to re-enforce the social order and not be cowed by a few noisy feminazis. God made each sex with distinct gifts. They are equal in human dignity, but not in social role. Modern egalitarianism is detrimental to the dignity of women because it slaps God in face and basically tells Him that he didn't know what he was doing when he "formed them in the womb". Edited November 29, 2004 by popestpiusx
Deeds Posted November 29, 2004 Posted November 29, 2004 [quote name='popestpiusx' date='Nov 29 2004, 05:53 PM'] I think I would agree with that, with the additional statement that men failed by stepping back and allowing it to happen. Had men reacted the way they should have, the radical feminist movement would have died, in my opinion. I think ultimately the blame must be placed on men who ceased to act with manly virtue. They (or I should say, we) abandoned our post. [/quote] I think men failed more by their treatment of women throughout history. Denying them education, denying them voting rights, and so on - in other words, by subduing them and supporting the idea that women should be seen and not heard. When that bubble burst, no wonder the momentum led to the balance swinging too far to the other side. Not that I blame men for it - both sexes are equally at fault.
homeschoolmom Posted November 29, 2004 Posted November 29, 2004 PSPX, thanks for your reply. I agree that our society has traded people (childen especially) for toys... But I'm uncertain still about what you think should have been done. ie, how far in "progress" was good and at what point did it become bad? ex. was it good to allow girls to go to school? college? was it good to allow single women the ability to earn a living? what about married women? during WWII? Should women have any property rights?
theculturewarrior Posted November 29, 2004 Posted November 29, 2004 Sometimes I feel like women hate me. Could this be a trickle down effect?
AngelofJesus Posted November 29, 2004 Posted November 29, 2004 It's funny how I like to think men as inferior to women. They say behind every good man is a greater woman. Be it a wife or a mother. They are the only ones that I think that can drive a man up the wall. I ah... better stay out of this thread because I want to be neutral like my comments.
Balthazor Posted November 29, 2004 Author Posted November 29, 2004 [quote name='homeschoolmom' date='Nov 29 2004, 05:36 PM'] PSPX, thanks for your reply. I agree that our society has traded people (childen especially) for toys... But I'm uncertain still about what you think should have been done. ie, how far in "progress" was good and at what point did it become bad? ex. was it good to allow girls to go to school? college? was it good to allow single women the ability to earn a living? what about married women? during WWII? Should women have any property rights? [/quote] If we didn't I :napoleon: and my motley crew of northwoods amazon princesses :blood: would sack hawaii, cede from the union and establish a society where women did have voting rights, college.....etc...... and maybe tcw could come with us.....depending which cabinett position needs filling. I already have a secretary of defense and state, and I am sure that HS mom would not mind being secretary of education......
Thy Geekdom Come Posted November 29, 2004 Posted November 29, 2004 [quote name='Balthazor' date='Nov 29 2004, 06:53 PM'] If we didn't I :napoleon: and my motley crew of northwoods amazon princesses :blood: would sack hawaii, cede from the union and establish a society where women did have voting rights, college.....etc...... and maybe tcw could come with us.....depending which cabinett position needs filling. I already have a secretary of defense and state, and I am sure that HS mom would not mind being secretary of education...... [/quote] I'd join...can I be secretary of "Getting Down" Ah, Simpsons memories...
Balthazor Posted November 29, 2004 Author Posted November 29, 2004 Yeah I would let you on the island too....you can be secretary of "getting down".....but you are paid in platform shoes. hmmm.....I am gonna need one of those shiny black cars with the little flags if I am going to be dictatorrrr......er .....benevolent executive president of the country of Hawaii.
LovingIt! Posted November 30, 2004 Posted November 30, 2004 [quote name='XIX' date='Nov 29 2004, 12:15 AM'] Sometimes I wonder--just wonder, if I'll find more women in Heaven. [/quote] You certainly find more women in church
Moosey Posted November 30, 2004 Posted November 30, 2004 The only thing I hate about being a woman is my period...and I even then I still appreciate it because it enables me to get pregnant. And I want to have a baby darnit (not now of course, but someday) So in a way, I'm happy being a woman. Thank you God for making me a woman because I can take part in creating life! WOOHOO!! :roll: :newlyweds: okay Im good
Spiritual_Arsonist Posted November 30, 2004 Posted November 30, 2004 [quote name='Balthazor' date='Nov 28 2004, 05:21 PM'] Guys don't have to deal with even half the carp we do. They don't get periods, they don't get pregnant, they get paid more, they are almost always stronger, they don't have menapause, they get to be priests. And for a while the daft evened things out...girls didn't get drafted. But now I am almost sure that if there ever was a draft we would be included. I don't get it. Women are in general more spiritual than men and tend to have a stronger belief in God. And yet he throws all this carp on us. It ain't equal....it never will be, I don't even feel like I have the same human dignity as a guy. [/quote] God does not hate women. There are differences between these two sexes and there is nothing wrong with saying that. People perceive problems due to their sex because they may not understand what to do with these things and feelings. Its about WHO we are, not what happens to us (like the menopause and more emotionality) Be 100% woman.
Thy Geekdom Come Posted November 30, 2004 Posted November 30, 2004 [quote name='Moosey' date='Nov 29 2004, 08:28 PM'] The only thing I hate about being a woman is my period...and I even then I still appreciate it because it enables me to get pregnant. And I want to have a baby darnit (not now of course, but someday) So in a way, I'm happy being a woman. Thank you God for making me a woman because I can take part in creating life! WOOHOO!! :roll: :newlyweds: okay Im good [/quote] Hehe...Moosey said, "period." jk I don't think I'd like getting those...gotta respect women for putting up with it...
cathgirl Posted November 30, 2004 Posted November 30, 2004 I agree w/ you Moosey! That doesn't bother me a lot, but it still bugs me! My teacher read us a poem today on why it is so great to be a woman!
Thy Geekdom Come Posted November 30, 2004 Posted November 30, 2004 [quote name='cathgirl' date='Nov 29 2004, 09:28 PM'] I agree w/ you Moosey! That doesn't bother me a lot, but it still bugs me! My teacher read us a poem today on why it is so great to be a woman! [/quote] Because you get to be graced with the unbelievably wonderful presence of us men? jk...more like unbelievably unbearable, I know...
cmotherofpirl Posted November 30, 2004 Posted November 30, 2004 [quote name='homeschoolmom' date='Nov 29 2004, 07:36 PM'] PSPX, thanks for your reply. I agree that our society has traded people (childen especially) for toys... But I'm uncertain still about what you think should have been done. ie, how far in "progress" was good and at what point did it become bad? ex. was it good to allow girls to go to school? college? was it good to allow single women the ability to earn a living? what about married women? during WWII? Should women have any property rights? [/quote] Women needed equality in the vote place, property rights, pay scale, and education. We did not need the poverty that is the result of easy divorce laws, we did not need forced into minimun wage jobs with no health care when our husbands abandon us after putting them thru grad school. On the other hand, I don't think marriages that have fallen apart should tie up a persons life forever either. ``
homeschoolmom Posted November 30, 2004 Posted November 30, 2004 [quote name='cmotherofpirl' date='Nov 29 2004, 09:53 PM'] Women needed equality in the vote place, property rights, pay scale, and education. We did not need the poverty that is the result of easy divorce laws, we did not need forced into minimun wage jobs with no health care when our husbands abandon us after putting them thru grad school. On the other hand, I don't think marriages that have fallen apart should tie up a persons life forever either. `` [/quote] Yeah... My mom was sort of in the same situation that I gather you were in, Cmom. I'm interested to hear what PSPX will say...
cmotherofpirl Posted November 30, 2004 Posted November 30, 2004 I have seen both sides of it. I have been on the abandoned side, but I have friends who are staying in dead marriages as well. Both are bad, but thwere seems there is no good way either.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now