Dave Posted July 20, 2005 Posted July 20, 2005 (edited) At the parish near my house, where I often go for daily Mass, the congregation sings a hymn right at the beginning and right at the end of Mass. Unfortunately, the woman who chooses the hymns doesn't always choose the best ones, and we end up singing "On Eagle's Wings," "Gather Us In," "Here I Am Lord," "Be Not Afraid," "You Are Near," etc. I'm tempted to go to her the next time there's a bad song and ask her to avoid certain hymns from now on (of course, whether or not she'd actually avoid them is probably another matter entirely). But should I? Remember this is daily Mass, where we sing a capella. Edited July 20, 2005 by Dave
homeschoolmom Posted July 20, 2005 Posted July 20, 2005 Gather up the Gather songbooks and burn them...
thessalonian Posted July 20, 2005 Posted July 20, 2005 What's wrong with those if I might ask. I love "On Eagle's Wings" and "Be Not Afraid".
Brother Adam Posted July 20, 2005 Posted July 20, 2005 (edited) Do something constructive like pray for the salvation of souls and quit being so nitpicky btw, it looks like you've about hit 5000 posts. Congrads! Edited July 20, 2005 by Brother Adam
the_rev Posted July 20, 2005 Posted July 20, 2005 I love most of those songs mentioned, Be not afraid, City of God, Gather us in what exactly is wrong with them?
Dave Posted July 20, 2005 Author Posted July 20, 2005 Homeschoolmom-- The hymnals aren't Gather but Glory and Praise, which is just as bad or even worse. Thessalonian-- I seriously hope you're joking! But if not, then the reason why they smell of elderberries is because they're so folk-sounding -- not really the type of music appropriate at Mass. It's Mass, not a hootenanny! Also, songs like "Be Not Afraid" has the congregation singing God's part. I think that's inappropriate. Heck, even when I was a Protestant, I never saw songs in the hymnal where the congregation pretended to be God!
Brother Adam Posted July 20, 2005 Posted July 20, 2005 I think you're handing around people with SSPX tendencies too much. btw, what is hootenanny?
dspen2005 Posted July 20, 2005 Posted July 20, 2005 my and friend and I, simply do not sing terrible and ambiguous songs... the worst song for daily mass -- "MORNING HAS BROKEN" -- can someone say, 'barf'?
thessalonian Posted July 20, 2005 Posted July 20, 2005 [quote name='Dave' date='Jul 20 2005, 03:40 PM']Homeschoolmom-- The hymnals aren't Gather but Glory and Praise, which is just as bad or even worse. Thessalonian-- I seriously hope you're joking! But if not, then the reason why they smell of elderberries is because they're so folk-sounding -- not really the type of music appropriate at Mass. It's Mass, not a hootenanny! Also, songs like "Be Not Afraid" has the congregation singing God's part. I think that's inappropriate. Heck, even when I was a Protestant, I never saw songs in the hymnal where the congregation pretended to be God! [right][snapback]651380[/snapback][/right] [/quote] Perhaps you can site some cannons for us that you can bring to the priest with your complaint. Also, shall we avoid reading God's part when we read the scriptures. Really. Your arguements never even crossed my mind and I doudt they will again after this thread. There's alot bigger fish to fry in the Church than some songs you don't like.
thessalonian Posted July 20, 2005 Posted July 20, 2005 [quote name='dspen2005' date='Jul 20 2005, 03:44 PM']my and friend and I, simply do not sing terrible and ambiguous songs... the worst song for daily mass -- "MORNING HAS BROKEN" -- can someone say, 'barf'? [right][snapback]651388[/snapback][/right] [/quote] Amen to that.
Dave Posted July 20, 2005 Author Posted July 20, 2005 To those who wonder what's wrong with such "hymns," go to [url="http://www.adoremus.org/Musictoc.html"]http://www.adoremus.org/Musictoc.html[/url] ... take a look at some of the articles there, especially: [url="http://www.adoremus.org/399Scalia.html"]http://www.adoremus.org/399Scalia.html[/url] [url="http://www.adoremus.org/499Pasley.html"]http://www.adoremus.org/499Pasley.html[/url] [url="http://www.adoremus.org/0901BringsMusicShock.html"]http://www.adoremus.org/0901BringsMusicShock.html[/url] [url="http://www.adoremus.org/1102MassMusic.html"]http://www.adoremus.org/1102MassMusic.html[/url] [url="http://www.adoremus.org/0603SacredMusic.html"]http://www.adoremus.org/0603SacredMusic.html[/url]
Noel's angel Posted July 20, 2005 Posted July 20, 2005 sometimes this place makes me bewildered.... Can I remind you that you are not at Mass because of the songs
homeschoolmom Posted July 20, 2005 Posted July 20, 2005 Well, I don't mind too much from the Gather songbook, despite what I said. However, it would be nice to have some variety. And it would also be nice if we were singing more praise-oriented songs.
Dave Posted July 20, 2005 Author Posted July 20, 2005 (edited) [quote name='Brother Adam' date='Jul 20 2005, 04:42 PM']I think you're handing around people with SSPX tendencies too much. btw, what is hootenanny? [right][snapback]651383[/snapback][/right] [/quote] Whoa ... that's not true! I've hated music like that for years, ever since I discovered [url="http://www.adoremus.org"]http://www.adoremus.org[/url] ... you'd do well to check it out. And a hootenanny is a type of sing-along. Edited July 20, 2005 by Dave
homeschoolmom Posted July 20, 2005 Posted July 20, 2005 [quote name='Dave' date='Jul 20 2005, 03:52 PM']And a hootenanny is a type of sing-along. [right][snapback]651408[/snapback][/right] [/quote] yeeeeee-haw....
homeschoolmom Posted July 20, 2005 Posted July 20, 2005 Honestly, I'm just thankful to have daily mass...
Dave Posted July 20, 2005 Author Posted July 20, 2005 (edited) [quote name='thessalonian' date='Jul 20 2005, 04:44 PM']Perhaps you can site some cannons for us that you can bring to the priest with your complaint. Also, shall we avoid reading God's part when we read the scriptures. Really. Your arguements never even crossed my mind and I doudt they will again after this thread. There's alot bigger fish to fry in the Church than some songs you don't like. [right][snapback]651389[/snapback][/right] [/quote] This falls not so much in the realm of canon law but of common sense and good taste. And your comparing it to "reading God's part in Scripture" is apples and oranges. At least in Mass readings there's always "Jesus said ... " or "Thus says the Lord ..." at the beginning of quotations from God. Besides, who are you to belittle my arguments and tell me they're not important? I suggest you go to [url="http://www.adoremus.org"]http://www.adoremus.org[/url] and read the articles there carefully and thoroughly. Edited July 20, 2005 by Dave
Recommended Posts