Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Posted

If my fiance ends up coming to my college (she might, she's not deciding colleges based on that though, on my advice... though I definitely wouldn't mind if she pulled a Topanga) I'm thinkin our engagement might last a year or less, and our betrothal might last a year or more, well, probably until we're both out of college or something, I want to bend over backwards to attempt to make sure we won't even have to use NFP!

If she doesn't end up coming to my college, our engagement will probably last a bit longer, maybe 2 years or more, and our betrothal will probably last until we're both out of college or beyond that.

Anyway, I absolutely postively love her, even when I dont love her I love her. haha, it's paradoxically true!

"Marriage is a duel to the death which no man of honour should decline" -G.K. Chesterton

Posted

Aw, cool. :)

Posted
:D:

Actually, depending on when I think the time is right it's likely that those numbers for engagement might get a lot shorter and those numbers for betrothal get a lot higher (meaning I want to get betrothed sooner).

:cool:
Laudate_Dominum
Posted

If you ask me, secular engagement is an unnecessary step. A solemn engagement in the Church (aka betrothal) is better. :D:

Posted (edited)

[quote name='Aloysius']"Marriage is a duel to the death which no man of honour should decline" -G.K. Chesterton [/quote]

Marriage is an arrangment in which a man trades half his groceries in order to get the other half cooked.


PAX

The Great and Magnificent T-Bone

Edited by T-Bone
Laudate_Dominum
Posted

I was once thinking of doing "normal" engagement and then betrothal, but why not just save the engagement ring for the betrothal? Otherwise your lady's ring finger will start to get cluttered. :hehehe:

Plus canonically it seems weird, since betrothal is engagement. You'd be pseudo-engaged (from the perspective of canon law) and then really engaged. Or to put it more precisely, you'd be engaged outside the Church and then engaged in the Church. It's not morally wrong by any means, but by analogy it seems something like having a civil marriage and then later getting married in the Church.

Posted

well I've already proposed engagement, and she accepted-- so we are engaged. I want to make it into a betrothal, which is something I think different in kind than engagement.

I guess if I could plan all the circumstances, my ideal situation would be to have an arranged marriage from birth, the two of us being friends from a very young age, and having a betrothal ceremony at an EXTREMELY young age. lol

but since I haven't planned the circumstances, the road laid out for us is a bit symbolic of converting the modernism into which we were born, by first taking the step of secular engagement, then religious betrothal, then marriage.

Laudate_Dominum
Posted

[quote name='Aloysius' date='Dec 4 2005, 07:10 AM']well I've already proposed engagement, and she accepted-- so we are engaged.  I want to make it into a betrothal, which is something I think different in kind than engagement.

I guess if I could plan all the circumstances, my ideal situation would be to have an arranged marriage from birth, the two of us being friends from a very young age, and having a betrothal ceremony at an EXTREMELY young age.  lol

but since I haven't planned the circumstances, the road laid out for us is a bit symbolic of converting the modernism into which we were born, by first taking the step of secular engagement, then religious betrothal, then marriage.
[right][snapback]810436[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]
That's cool. If I go to St. Boniface this morning I'll try to remember to bring my book on betrothal!! :yahoo:

Posted

sweet! that'd be awesome!

if I get Fr. Myers to do the betrothal, I'll so invite you (and maybe a few other phatmassers if they so desired to finally meet the mysterious aloysius, haha, we shall see)

Laudate_Dominum
Posted

[quote name='Aloysius' date='Dec 4 2005, 07:20 AM']sweet!  that'd be awesome!

if I get Fr. Myers to do the betrothal, I'll so invite you (and maybe a few other phatmassers if they so desired to finally meet the mysterious aloysius, haha, we shall see)
[right][snapback]810442[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]
awesome!

btw, if Fr. Myers is unsure about the canonical status of betrothal I've got it covered because I wrote to the USCCB and the Secretariat for Doctrine and Pastoral Practices assured me that it is still perfectly legitimate and that my understanding of the canon law and everything is correct.
:cool:

Posted

yeah I was actually thinking of asking you for the full text of the letter sent back to you (you posted an excerpt on phatmass the one time)

we're not going to ask him for a little while, though. probably earliest we'd plan on doing it is this spring-ish.

Posted

[quote name='Laudate_Dominum' date='Dec 4 2005, 07:35 AM']awesome!

btw, if Fr. Myers is unsure about the canonical status of betrothal I've got it covered because I wrote to the USCCB and the Secretariat for Doctrine and Pastoral Practices assured me that it is still perfectly legitimate and that my understanding of the canon law and everything is correct.
:cool:
[right][snapback]810448[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]
dude, post that freakin letter. i would love to read it and it would be an invaluable resource for the directory :woot:

Laudate_Dominum
Posted

Most of the letter wasn't all that relevant. The main part was the beginning. My question was about the ceremony from the old Roman Ritual and the canonical status of betrothal, and this opening statement from the Bishop confirms that my impression was correct.

"Your inquiry regarding a Catholic ceremony for betrothal (or solemn engagement) has been forwarded to me for a response. [b]I am able to confirm that your research has led you in all of the right directions[/b], including the most recent complementary norm from the USCCB implementing c. 1062! This remains the current norm for the Latin Church in the United States and, to my knowledge, there are no plans currently underway within the Conference to revise it."

Posted

the letter you sent them, indicating exactly where your research had led you, would be the valuable part then because that's what they were confirming.

Posted

yea, u should post the letter u wrote to them :D:

Laudate_Dominum
Posted

Also, while I admit betrothal isn't talked about much in post-Vatican II stuff, but actually the USCCB marriage preparation handbook, "Faithful to Each Other Forever", which came out in 1989 makes the disctinction I make between secular engagement and a "solemn blessing" which would "bring an added spiritual dimension" to this event.

So basically I assert (and the Secretariat for Doctrine and Pastoral Practices would seem to agree) that betrothal is still a practice that ought to be encouraged among Catholic couples.

Don't even get me started because I could ramble for hours about the benefits of betrothal.. I love it. :)

Posted

you should also write a tract about it, including a list of all the pertinent documents on betrothal :)

Laudate_Dominum
Posted

I remember that I asked if the ceremony from the old Roman Ritual could still be used (which it can). And I said that from what I can gather betrothal is the appropriate way for Catholic couples to approach engagement (which would seem to be the case even if we're not exactly hearing about it).
And I asked about the quasi-sacramentality of betrothal in the Church.
And I then mentioned an old (1940's) pastoral manual that gave a bunch of reasons why couples should have a solemn engagement in the Church (betrothal) and asked if this still applies or if the Church, by being quite silent on the matter, is in effect discouraging the practice (which it is not). I concluded by saying that to the best of my knowledge betrothal is something that ought to be encouraged because of.. blah blah..

Despite the fact that the response did not address all my statements individually, I understand the reply to be an endorsement and affirmation of my stance.

:cool:

Posted

so, basically, u don't have a copy of your letter........

franciscanheart
Posted

betrothal is awesome but i dont see a lot of guys going for it :ohno:

congratulations again aloysius!

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...