Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Posted

[quote name='Aloysius' date='Dec 5 2005, 03:44 PM']at 25+, you're more likely to have created a spirit of individualism, and it's hard to submit that to a life-long relationship where two become one.  getting married while you're still developing your self-identiy is better because then you incorporate that other person into your self-identity.
[right][snapback]812595[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]
This is a silly statement. If one does not yet have a "self-identity," he is probably not mature enough for marriage, whether he is 18 or 38!

My parents were both over 25 when they were married, and are still happily married over 30 years later!

And getting married young by no means guarantees a lasting marriage. Many of my older male relatives married young and their first marriages were failures, but they're later marriages lasted.
This is not uncommon - see the Johnny Cash biopic "Walk the Line."

I am not condoning divorce and remarriage here - I agree that is a bad thing - but merely saying that it is a fallacy that the age of the couple when married determines how long the marriage will last.

The reason many of today's later marriages fail is that oftentimes these people have gone through a series of transitory sexual "relationships" before finally settling down and tying the knot with someone. By the time they marry, they have already established a pattern of behavior that will set themselves up for divorce.

I think purity, chastity, and seriousness of purpose is a lot more important in determining whether a marriage succeeds or fails than age or "self-identity."

Posted

[quote name='Aloysius' date='Dec 7 2005, 02:59 PM']perhaps then, you should check my first post and the timelines that involved quite a few years....
[/quote]

I did, and thought your argument was silly.

blovedwolfofgod
Posted

Everyone is such a rush to be married. 19 yrs old and engaged?

Ash Wednesday
Posted

Someone could very easily say that biology is secular and doesn't necessarily take faith into account, either. So to poo poo statistics, and yet trumpet certain scientific and biological facts of a certain age bracket is inconsistent, IMHO.

Posted

not so much... statistics being secular means that they reflect what happens in the secular world, but when a strong faith and an understanding that divorce isn't even an option is a factor statistics are quite different for those faithful Catholics.

biology universally attests that human beings naturally are ready for sex at young ages, and the only moral outlet for that is marriage according to the Church. human Catholics with strong faith and everything are the same biologically.

Posted

[quote name='Cow of Shame' date='Dec 7 2005, 09:13 PM']I did, and thought your argument was silly.
[right][snapback]816004[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]
:unsure: I'm not sure I understand this... my argument for a long engagement to be certain about marriage is silly?

[quote]This is a silly statement. If one does not yet have a "self-identity," he is probably not mature enough for marriage, whether he is 18 or 38![/quote]
certainly a self-identity... I'm just thinking of people who establish themselves so individually that to enter into marriage means to get pre-nup agreements, completely distinct bank accounts, and all that kinda stuff. they're at a stage where they so want to hold onto their individual selves that they won't let themselves be vulnerable to another individual, though they'll still share the same bed.

Laudate_Dominum
Posted

[quote name='Aloysius' date='Dec 7 2005, 02:59 PM']L_D's statement that statistics are secular is important because that means it doesn't take into account the factor of the FAITH and the concept that ending a marriage isn't even an option because the two people understand so well the permanence of it.
[right][snapback]815701[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]
yeah, that's basically what I meant. If I were to do statistics based on the people I've known who married very young (by todays standards) I can think of one such couple who actually divorced, and they are the only one that I know for a fact became sexually active before they married.

I can remember in sex education class being told to wait until you're like 30 to get married because of xyz. But this ideology also said, "if you feel like getting married at all", and they assumed you'd obviously start having sex much sooner, hopefully in high school or even junior high.

I guess part of the idea is that you should be experimenting and getting your kicks while you're young so that when you finally settle down you would have been able to have sex with lots of different people. I mean heck, if you're young why not enjoy it? Marriage is something to do when you've passed your prime and need someone so that you won't have to be alone. And of course marriage involved kids which are a threat to the lifestyle of hedonistic irresponsible sexual activity.

I think in an ideal society most people would get married in their teen years. This is when one begins to feel the call of sexuality in their body, its the natural time to leave father and mother and be joined to your spouse.

I can see how devaluing marriage would involve convincing people that they shouldn't get married until they're older and older. It fits the ideals of the sexual revolution nicely. Less child bearing years, more fornication in society, more baggage when you get married, etc..

I can think of arguments based on the "maturity" thing that support younger marriages. I think that perspective starts with the presupposition that older marriages are more desirable.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...