Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Posted

you can just tell when someone has read chesterton and/or belloc... it's so obvious. :cool:

photosynthesis
Posted

me or L_D? i only read Orthodoxy

Posted

Financially sound eh? Define sound. My father doesn't have a degree and he has 6 children. I dont have a college trust fund, but I have a wonderful couple of parents I'll tell ya. My grandparents married when they were 19 and 21. They've been married ever since, and they still flirt with eachother. They had 4 kids, and they still live in they house they bought when they were "kids". My aunt and uncle married when they were 18 and 19. They are still married now and love eachother very much 4 years later.
Maybe Im biased, but I believe that if the two have a Christlike love for eachother, nothing will destroy that. I don't see why waiting until youre both 25+ guarantees a successful marriage. Yeah you might have a few more bucks in the bank, but is that so important?

When Christ is not the center of the relationship, thats when you have problems.

Posted

25+ marriages I think tend to be more likely to fail

photosynthesis
Posted

my parents were over 25 and financially sound, and they divorced

Posted

at 25+, you're more likely to have created a spirit of individualism, and it's hard to submit that to a life-long relationship where two become one. getting married while you're still developing your self-identiy is better because then you incorporate that other person into your self-identity.

photosynthesis
Posted

well, marriage is becoming one flesh, not one person. You will always have your individual self even if/when you get married.

Posted

[quote name='Aloysius' date='Dec 5 2005, 03:58 PM']I'm working on it!  the problem is I feel like I have a DaVinci-style ADD (and would never dream of wanting medication for it, it's just my personality)

Like I said: the ideal situation is that we don't have to use NFP.  The ideal situation also includes probably: me writing a best-selling book, or me buying a large plot of land with a group of people and building a city on it, or me refining my piano skills and becoming a famous concert pianist, or uhhh what's that major of mine in college again? anthropology?  yeah, or me becoming a big-shot anthropologist that discovers the bones of Adam and Eve frozen on the moon... or me getting some sort of journalist job, or me becoming a shepherd and selling wool sweaters, or a combination of any or all of those previously mentioned things or maybe something else...
[right][snapback]812413[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]
Al, you need to cut back on that drinking!

Posted

[quote name='Aloysius' date='Dec 5 2005, 05:44 PM']at 25+, you're more likely to have created a spirit of individualism, and it's hard to submit that to a life-long relationship where two become one.  getting married while you're still developing your self-identiy is better because then you incorporate that other person into your self-identity.
[right][snapback]812595[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]
Like I said . . .

Posted

I know you're joking, but that's just darn annoying

I'm describing my personality and my daydreams about my future... and my opinion about young marriage being the best form of marriage...

and again, for the millionth time, I've never been drunk in my life.

Posted (edited)

[quote]Financially sound eh? Define sound. My father doesn't have a degree and he has 6 children. I dont have a college trust fund, but I have a wonderful couple of parents I'll tell ya. My grandparents married when they were 19 and 21. They've been married ever since, and they still flirt with eachother. They had 4 kids, and they still live in they house they bought when they were "kids". My aunt and uncle married when they were 18 and 19. They are still married now and love eachother very much 4 years later.
Maybe Im biased, but I believe that if the two have a Christlike love for eachother, nothing will destroy that. I don't see why waiting until youre both 25+ guarantees a successful marriage. Yeah you might have a few more bucks in the bank, but is that so important? [/quote]
I mean financially secure as in having enough money for food for two, shelter and nappies for a potential bambino. I'm in college and I wouldn't be able to provide that yet.

As for 25+ marriage, I said that was a personal opinion, but looks like I'd better get cracking on the husband thing since I'm nearly over the hill at 21. As we're all sharing anecdotal evidence, my parents got married in their thirties and IMO have the most stable marriage in the entire world. My boyfriend's parents got married at 19 and 21. They weren't financially secure (his dad was still in college). They divorced 10 years later. Not that I'm saying that [i]proves[/i] anything, mind.

Edited by Deeds
Posted

of course none of these individual examples proves anything..

but historically speaking, young marriages have been the greatest pillars of society and the most successful.

biologically speaking, they make the most sense. and that biological fact says certain things about natural law.

daugher-of-Mary
Posted

I think it's not so much the age as the intention. My parents promised eachother the day they got married that they wouldn't even consider divorce. They've been through some hellish experiences in their 27 years of marriage, but they're still in love and still married. I guess the question should be, husbands are you willing to be crucified for your bride as Christ was for His Church? Wife, are you willing to love your husband unconditionally, and yes, be sumissive to him?

franciscanheart
Posted

i would not put so much stress on the age - even a young age. fine, get married young. it works. but dont say that at 25+ the marriages are doomed to fail. im pretty sure there are a good handful of phatmassers on here that are 25+, single, and called to married life. in fact i know one personally. i know that he will make a wonderful husband and father. i know that he could handle giving up his "freedom" to be in a committed relationship and still retain his individuality but through his spouse in Christ.

another thing.... while some people work out young and poor, others dont. want to accuse them of not loving enough or not trusting in Christ enough? how rude. i dont think it is anyone's place to judge anyone elses love or faith in Christ. it is one thing to like faithfully in poverty but one must be prudent.

Posted

no one said they didn't have enough love or faith in Christ, that was your own straw man you built. good job knocking it down though :D: I completely agree not to judge others that way

anyway, I was just talking trendilogically (lol that's prolly not a word) I didn't mean to say all 25+ marriages would fail, but I do believe the ideal for marriage is younger, just based on common sense observation of natural law.

anyway, I believe any relationship can work (unless something like physical or emotional abuse enters into the situation). I don't accept at all the "not loving the other person anymore" argument-- I say so what you're married to them, you better learn to love them again because the two of you are one flesh and not loving them is like not loving a peice of yourself (again, exclude all cases of abuse and such).

most modern relationships fail because people enter into them with crazy expectations that will never be met. you don't just not love someone anymore and end your marriage. you don't just get so angry that you end your marriage. that's not supposed to even be an option, at all ever, and when that's not an option it's a lot different ballgame. leaving your legitimate spouse should be, to the married person, an option akin to chopping off your own head-- it just isn't done. even someone that got to the point of wanting to kill themselves probably wouldn't chop off their own head, it's impossible unless you have your own guillotine. same thing, ending a marriage should be unthinkable and impossible even if you did decide to think about it.

Posted

[quote name='hugheyforlife' date='Dec 6 2005, 08:18 AM']i would not put so much stress on the age - even a young age. fine, get married young. it works. but dont say that at 25+ the marriages are doomed to fail. im pretty sure there are a good handful of phatmassers on here that are 25+, single, and called to married life. in fact i know one personally. i know that he will make a wonderful husband and father. i know that he could handle giving up his "freedom" to be in a committed relationship and still retain his individuality but through his spouse in Christ.

another thing.... while some people work out young and poor, others dont. want to accuse them of not loving enough or not trusting in Christ enough? how rude. i dont think it is anyone's place to judge anyone elses love or faith in Christ. it is one thing to like faithfully in poverty but one must be prudent.
[right][snapback]813143[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]


I hope you didn't interpret what I said as putting down 25+ year olds who aren't married yet. :unsure:
My point was that if Christ isn't the center thats when you have problems, not just when you get married young and poor.

Posted (edited)

What concerns me more than age/financial security is the amount of time dating and the projected length of engagement. In what I've seen, long engagements have a way of breaking down after a year or so. Engagement/betrothal is a commitment to marry someone. It has this force propelling you towards marriage. If that force is resisted, I've seen it to be problematic.

I also think that there's greater temptation to fornicate, because you've got a stronger commitment, and sometimes it feels like you're "virtually married anyway".

Edited by scardella
Posted

Aloysius,

I think it is great that you are considering marriage at so young. However I would have to warn you, proceed with caution, this is a lifetime commitment you are about to embark upon.

Currently in my relationship with my girlfriend we have a similar history with you two. We have known each other for 6/ 7 years and have been dating for over 2 years.

I cannot imagine getting engaged during college! There is so much growing you will do during that time. You will either grow together, or you will grow apart. If you jump into this headfirst you may find your self in shallow water.

The depth of actually knowing someone and growing with them takes a lot of time. I know I still feel that I am just starting to know my girl friend despite being good friends for over 5 years prior to dating but I still don’t think we are ready for engagement yet.

I suggest you pray very hard about this.

I also would suggest that you and her take a trip together. It doesn’t have to be anything expensive or long (I would suggest a week though). Maybe go camping or something in nature that way you have a full week with her that you will really find out how you get along together.

Also I would suggest that you take several personal retreats away from her to truly contemplate this. Also sit with your priest one on one, man to man to truly discuss this.

I only give you these tips for your sake. There are so many marriages that end in divorce and separation it is not even funny. Here at my work place over 75% of the men are divorced. The key here is to set a firm foundation on the rock that is Christ Jesus. Grow with each other, do not jump into anything, let things happen, let the Lord work his will with you two.

Perhaps the lord is calling you to another vocation all together. Who knows. Just be careful.

You are in my prayers friend.

Posted

thanks for the advice. trust me, it's under control.

college=no big deal. really. okay, so i've only been here for one semester-- it's still no big deal. it's hyped up way too much.

and like I said, I would love an arranged marriage, I wouldn't even mind an arranged marriage in which I met the girl for the first time at the altar getting married.

of course, that's not to trivialize the specialness of the one specific girl that I have chosen, I honestly love her. but that "love" that everyone talks about isn't the stuff that makes marriages-- it's WILL.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...