Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Posted

Jesuit says Vatican condom concession would be nothing new


Ethicist Fr Bill Uren of Newman College at the University of Melbourne has said that the mooted Vatican "permission" for Catholics to use condoms to counter the HIV/AIDS epidemic is merely an application of the traditional "double effect" principle of Catholic moral theology.

Crikey reports that Fr Uren, responding to a front page feature in The Independent today, said that "I am surprised that The Independent's Rome correspondent is quite so positive about the likelihood of an imminent change in the Catholic Church's position on the use of condoms to counter the AIDS epidemic."

He quoted The Independent story as saying that "the Catholic Church is on the brink of a historic change of approach over condoms". The UK paper reports that the forthcoming Vatican document is set to approve the use of condoms in a marriage where one partner is infected with HIV/AIDS and the other is not.

Fr Uren said that that if the use of condoms in this way was approved by the Church, it will not be an innovation, "still less, a capitulation".

"A number of distinguished moral theologians have been advocating such a change for a number of years, and the movement has gained momentum recently with the support of half a dozen cardinals whose representations could not be so easily ignored by the Vatican," he said.

Fr Uren said that he expects the Vatican review will not depart with traditional principles of moral theology.

He said the 1968 encyclical letter on contraception, Humanae Vitae, only forbade the use of contraceptives when they were used for exclusively contraceptive purposes.

"One could use contraceptives for other therapeutic purposes – for 'rebound' fertility therapy, for a female athlete wishing to prevent menstruation, etc – provided, as in these instances, the intention was not primarily contraceptive," he said.

Fr Uren argues that "double effect" line of reasoning in the encyclical could be applied to cases of AIDS-infected conjugal relationships where the intention is not contraceptive but life-saving.

He said this argument would be more persuasive to the "sophisticated theological mind of Benedict XVI" than the "lesser evil" argument, as avocated by the former archbishop of Milan Cardinal Carlo Maria Martini.

"Whatever the time-line, one can only welcome the Vatican's intention to review the hitherto hard-line prohibition on the use of condoms," Fr Uren said.

Meanwhile, the ABC reports on the mixed international responses to Cardinal Martini's interview in Italian weekly magazine L'Espresso last month - which sparked off the debate over condoms - including the views of Martin Rhonheimer, an Opus Dei priest and Professor of Ethics and Political Philosophy at the Opus Dei University in Rome.

Fr Rhonheimer told the ABC that the Church does not teach how to render less immoral intrinsically immoral behaviour, such as sex outside marriage.

But "somebody who is not ready to change behaviour, he at least shows a kind of responsibility if he tries to prevent infection [of AIDS]," he said. "I think that's commonsense."

Fr Rhonheimer said that the position of the Church has not changed on the issue. But Church's position "has to be clarified in these issues, and that in consequence, certain theological approaches to it should be modified".

"Many theologians believe that the norm of contraception told by the encyclical Humanae Vitae, Paul VI, has already settled the question, but I think this is not true," he said.

"Humanae Vitae specifically tackled the problem of responsible parenthood and contraception, that is, the question of intentionally separating one's sexual behaviour from its meaning of serving the transmission of life.

"From the moral point of view, using a condom to prevent infection simply has nothing to do with contraception, it's another question," he said.

"So while the good and normal way of preventing infection is to abstain from the act which might transmit the disease, of course, that's abstinence. This perhaps is not always possible," he said.

"It's clear that a married man, for example, who is infected and uses a condom to protect his wife from infection, is not actually to render procreation impossible, so he's not doing a contraceptive act."

Fides_et_Ratio
Posted

That is so wrong.

The press is going to get a real let down when this study was just so the Vatican can REAFFIRM its position on contraception, no matter what. Condoms will never be permitted to enter the sexual relationship in Catholic theology. End of story.

Posted

Good article, Cappie!

I think Fr. Uren and Fr. Rhonheimer have carefully articulated that this would not be a rejection of Humanae Vitae, but rather an application of the principle of double effect. The intent is not to contracept, but is rather to use condoms as prophylactics. And using condoms in that manner does not violate Humanae Vitae.

And Fr. Rhonheimer's from Opus Dei, so I find it difficult to believe that he can be labeled as a liberal dissenter.

Fides_et_Ratio
Posted

[quote name='Thumper' post='970329' date='May 3 2006, 10:35 PM']
Good article, Cappie!

I think Fr. Uren and Fr. Rhonheimer have carefully articulated that this would not be a rejection of Humanae Vitae, but rather an application of the principle of double effect. The intent is not to contracept, but is rather to use condoms as prophylactics. And using condoms in that manner does not violate Humanae Vitae.

And Fr. Rhonheimer's from Opus Dei, so I find it difficult to believe that he can be labeled as a liberal dissenter.
[/quote]
That's disgusting (don't take offense). Why put that risk the spouse at all? For even wearing a condom would greatly risk the infection of the spouse with HIV. What happens if it breaks? What if there's a hole, or tear? What if it's not disposed of properly?

You're going to have to lay out the principle of double effect for me, cuz I'm not seeing its application. One can NEVER permit a lesser evil when the good effect is ignored. Procreation is INSEPARABLE from the conjugal act. If one cannot procreate, then one cannot engage in intercourse. This would be a rejection of Humanae Vitae... in the gravest sense. We are not animals. We do not NEED to have sex, married or not. If one spouse has a deadly disease, then they should not risk passing on that disease to their beloved. That's not love. That's lust.


EDITED to add: Futhermore, condoms only reduce, and do NOT eliminate the risk of passing on the infection. Go to any website about condoms and read the long list of do's and don'ts of proper condom usage. This would be of virtually NO EFFECT in poor countries like those ravaged by HIV/AIDS in Africa... why? You need proper lubrication, and there are about 10 more rules of absolute necessity that constitute "proper condom use". Who's going to spend the money for all the condoms and lubrication and classes on proper condom usage? And who's going to enforce proper usage to keep spouses safe?

Theoketos
Posted

Proportionalism makes me laugh.

Thy Geekdom Come
Posted

[quote name='Theoketos' post='970366' date='May 3 2006, 10:25 PM']
Proportionalism makes me laugh.
[/quote]
Yeah...and the more proportionalism there is, the more you laugh. :mellow:

Laudate_Dominum
Posted

talk about heretical moral theology. Or better yet, immoral theology.

Theoketos
Posted

[quote name='Laudate_Dominum' post='970428' date='May 3 2006, 10:13 PM']
talk about heretical moral theology. Or better yet, immoral theology.
[/quote]

I think that Charles Curran offers that class at SMU...

Posted

[quote name='Thumper' post='970329' date='May 3 2006, 08:35 PM'] Good article, Cappie!

I think Fr. Uren and Fr. Rhonheimer have carefully articulated that this would not be a rejection of Humanae Vitae, but rather an application of the principle of double effect. The intent is not to contracept, but is rather to use condoms as prophylactics. And using condoms in that manner does not violate Humanae Vitae.

And Fr. Rhonheimer's from Opus Dei, so I find it difficult to believe that he can be labeled as a liberal dissenter.
[/quote]

Double effect cannot apply in a case of an intrinsically evil act.


[quote name='Theoketos' post='970366' date='May 3 2006, 09:25 PM'] Proportionalism makes me laugh. [/quote]

It's true...double effect in this case is actually an application of proportionalism, meaning that the two acts are proportional.

However, as I've mentioned before, sex is [i]not[/i] primarily for the unity of the spouse.

We have to be careful to retain that an intrinsically evil act is an intrinsically evil act, no matter the due circumstances...Intentionally preventing conception by artificial methods or performing the act that does is intrinsically evil when it is done intentionally (maybe there's something in the water that makes it an accident, but when a condom is used it's always intentionally done).

Posted

[quote name='Theoketos' post='970366' date='May 4 2006, 01:25 PM']
Proportionalism makes me laugh.
[/quote]

Veritatis Splendor sums up the error nicely: "[Proportionalism], while acknowledging that moral values are indicated by reason and by Revelation, maintain[s] that it is never possible to formulate an absolute prohibition of particular kinds of behavior which would be in conflict, in every circumstance and in every culture, with those values." Given the fact that the Ten Commandments, among other teachings, seem very absolute, one would think that it is difficult to hold such a view. The Pope explains the way in which the Proportionalists endeavor to bypass such a fundamental barricade: "The criteria for evaluating the moral rightness of an action are drawn from the weighing of the non-moral or pre-moral goods to be gained and the corresponding non-moral or pre-moral values to be respected. For some, concrete behavior would be right or wrong according as whether or not it is capable of producing a better state of affairs for all concerned."

It is precisely because of the conclusion that there are no universal, morally absolute, intrinsically evil acts that the Church entirely rejects the Proportionalist view. Though the Proportionalists may be acting out of good intentions, the Church cannot in any way make allowances for their teachings. The Pope understands that Proportionalism is an attempt to "provide liberation from the constraints of a voluntaristic and arbitrary morality of obligation which would ultimately be dehumanizing," for, without any real choice, a person is not using his reason and freedom of choice, which distinguish him from the animals. But Proportionalism is one of the "false solutions, linked in particular to an inadequate understanding of the object of moral action." Circumstances and intention can play a very important role in moral action, but they "can never transform an act intrinsically evil by virtue of its object into an act 'subjectively' good or defensible as a choice."

Posted

[quote name='Thumper' post='970329' date='May 3 2006, 08:35 PM'] Good article, Cappie!

I think Fr. Uren and Fr. Rhonheimer have carefully articulated that this would not be a rejection of Humanae Vitae, but rather an application of the principle of double effect. The intent is not to contracept, but is rather to use condoms as prophylactics. And using condoms in that manner does not violate Humanae Vitae.

And Fr. Rhonheimer's from Opus Dei, so I find it difficult to believe that he can be labeled as a liberal dissenter.
[/quote]

I figured out another thing that I find very troubling in your statement. You seem to imply that by the intent alone the act can be good, but I think the one who defined Natural Law Theory as it is commonly accepted would disagree with how you worded that (St. Thomas, Summa Theologiae). Intention must necessarily be good for a good action, but if the exterior act is intentionally willed (willed purposefully) and is evil itself, the whole act is evil. This is in the Prima Secundae Questions 18-21 of the Summa Theologiae for reference's sake.

[quote name='Humanae Vitae']
[font="Times"][size=3]14. Therefore We base Our words on the first principles of a human and Christian doctrine of marriage when We are obliged once more to declare that the direct interruption of the generative process already begun and, above all, all direct abortion, even for therapeutic reasons, are to be absolutely excluded as lawful means of regulating the number of children. (14) Equally to be condemned, as the magisterium of the Church has affirmed on many occasions, is direct sterilization, whether of the man or of the woman, whether permanent or temporary. (15)[/size][/font]

[font="Times"][size=3][b]Similarly excluded is any action which either before, at the moment of, or after sexual intercourse, is specifically intended to prevent procreation—[i]whether as an end or as a means.[/i] (16)[/b][/size][/font]

[font="Times"][size=3][b]Neither is it valid to argue, as a justification for sexual intercourse which is deliberately contraceptive, that a lesser evil is to be preferred to a greater one, or that such intercourse would merge with procreative acts of past and future to form a single entity, and so be qualified by exactly the same moral goodness as these. [/b]Though it is true that sometimes it is lawful to tolerate a lesser moral evil in order to avoid a greater evil or in order to promote a greater good," [b]it is never lawful, even for the gravest reasons, to do evil that good may come of it (18)—in other words, to intend directly something which of its very nature contradicts the moral order, and which must therefore be judged unworthy of man, [i]even though the intention is to protect or promote the welfare of an individual, of a family or of society in general.[/i] Consequently, [i]it is a serious error to think [u]that a whole married life of otherwise normal relations can justify sexual intercourse[/u] which is deliberately contraceptive and so intrinsically wrong.[/i][/b] [/size][/font]

[center][font="Times"][size=3][i]Lawful Therapeutic Means[/i][/size][/font][/center]
[font="Times"][size=3]15. On the other hand, the Church does not consider at all illicit the use of those therapeutic means necessary to cure bodily diseases, even if a foreseeable impediment to procreation should result there from—provided such impediment is not directly intended for any motive whatsoever. (19)[/quote][/size][/font]


I quoted this last paragraph for a reason knowing it will probably come up if this is continued. The AIDS scenario is most definitely not inclusive of a cure and the contraceptive is not done to cure the disease. That is talking more about a non-abortifacient pill that would prevent pregnancy which isn't meant to come into the sexual act at all. It does happen to come in, though only indirectly.

The condom is specifically meant to "allow" the sex.

Also, how are the men getting AIDS? Some through needles, some through extra-marital affiars, but those who have it before marriage ought not marry because their marriage is not meant to lead to procreation. If I knew that I was sterile I personally wouldn't marry because the marriage is not meant to procreate in that case. (That's slightly different, but I think it illustrates my point.)

Oh, emphasis is all mine in the encyclical.

Era Might
Posted (edited)

As usual, I won't be holding my breath for this "revolutionary" decree from the Holy See. And if something is issued, I wouldn't be surprised if it's the exact opposite of what is being reported. Remember the document on homosexuality? First it was gonna permit homosexual Priests, then it was gonna ban them. The media throws something out there and hopes it sticks. But the devil is in the details. ^_^

By the way, it would help to look back at what CARDINAL Ratzinger had to say on the topic:

[quote]The problem of educational programs in specifically Catholic schools and institutions requires particular attention. [b]These facilities are called to provide their own contribution for the prevention of AIDS, in full fidelity to the moral doctrine of the church, without at the same time engaging in compromises which may even give the impression of trying to condone practices which are immoral, for example, technical instructions in the use of prophylactic devices[/b].

In a society which seems increasingly to downgrade the value of chastity, conjugal fidelity and temperance, and to be preoccupied sometimes almost exclusively with physical health and temporal well-being, the church's responsibility is to give that kind of witness which is proper to her, namely an unequivocal witness of effective and unreserved solidarity with those who are suffering and, at the same time, a witness of defense of the dignity of human sexuality which can only be realized within the context of moral law. [b]It is likewise crucial to note, as the board statement does, that the only medically safe means of preventing AIDS are those very types of behavior which conform to God's law and to the truth about man which the church has always taught and today is still called courageously to teach[/b].

[url="http://www.newadvent.org/library/docs_df88ai.htm"]http://www.catholic.net/Catholic Church/Periodicals/Fa...7/morality.html[/url][/quote]
He also quotes approvingly an article in L'Osservatore Romano:

[quote]To seek a solution to the problem of infection by promoting the use of prophylactics would be to embark on a way not only insufficiently reliable from the technical point of view, but also and above all, unacceptable from the moral aspect. Such a proposal for 'safe' or at least 'safer' sex -- as they say -- ignores the real cause of the problem, namely, the permissiveness which, in the area of sex as in that related to other abuses, corrodes the moral fiber of the people.[/quote]

Edited by Era Might
Posted (edited)

What I don't undertand in all this is that if you enter into intercourse without the intent of being open to life regardless of your intent wouldn't you be in contradiction to church teachings? (either for personnel protection against aids, or simply for sexual gratification with contraceptive intent).

I cannot accept that the Church would take a stance of double effect or 'lesser evil'; neither of these concepts have their place in oliness which is what the church teaches.



[quote]"One could use contraceptives for other therapeutic purposes – for 'rebound' fertility therapy, for a female athlete wishing to prevent menstruation, etc – provided, as in these instances, the intention was not primarily contraceptive," he said.[/quote]

Anyone want to play 1 000 001 excuses? 'Cause that's just how many excuses I would be able to come up with if given the green light to find one. You can square that number if you involve teenagers.






[quote]To seek a solution to the problem of infection by promoting the use of prophylactics would be to embark on a way not only insufficiently reliable from the technical point of view, but also and above all, unacceptable from the moral aspect. Such a proposal for 'safe' or at least 'safer' sex -- as they say -- ignores the real cause of the problem, namely, the permissiveness which, in the area of sex as in that related to other abuses, corrodes the moral fiber of the people.[/quote]

Edited by Didacus
Posted (edited)

Playing devil's advocate here. (and don't bite my head off)

I agree that anything reported in the press concerning the Church needs a huge dose of salt. (Especially the Italian press) However to further discussion on the topic...


It reads to me that IF it is being considered, it is being done so under double effect. The example that I've been learning and discussing (in another thread) is ectopic pregnancy. All abortion is condemned. But the removal of the phallopian tube is not considered an abortive process even though it terminates the pregnancy.

If it is being considered under these conditions of double effect

* the act itself must be good or morally neutral
* the good effect must be a result of the act and not of the evil effect
* the evil effect must not be directly willed, but may be foreseen and tolerated
* the good effect outweighs the evil effect, or the two are at least comparable


Now that's how I'm reading the argument. The Church will make its decision known (if any) and we will abide by it. But for the sake of discussion, doesn't this have some validity?

Oh and I forgot to mention. Condoms don't have any intrinsic value in and of themselves. It is the act that has intrinsic value to it.

Edited by jaime
Fides_et_Ratio
Posted

I disagree with your "intrinsic value" comment. Condoms are contraceptive. That is their intrinsic value--that is what a condom is designed to do. Would you also suggest that RU-486 pills have no intrinsic value?

Posted

[quote name='Fides_et_Ratio' post='971610' date='May 4 2006, 06:52 PM']
I disagree with your "intrinsic value" comment. Condoms are contraceptive. That is their intrinsic value--that is what a condom is designed to do. Would you also suggest that RU-486 pills have no intrinsic value?
[/quote]

I don't know what the Church has said about RU-486 specifically. But I do know that the Church has no official teachings on condoms being intrinsically evil. The Church has taught that for something to be intrinsically evil, it must be a human act. Things have no intrinsic value.

If a couple engages in contraception, that is intrinsically evil. Purchasing a condom is not.

Fides_et_Ratio
Posted

[quote name='hot stuff' post='971631' date='May 4 2006, 09:00 PM']
I don't know what the Church has said about RU-486 specifically. But I do know that the Church has no official teachings on condoms being intrinsically evil. The Church has taught that for something to be intrinsically evil, it must be a human act. Things have no intrinsic value.

If a couple engages in contraception, that is intrinsically evil. Purchasing a condom is not.
[/quote]
I don't know if I could agree with that.. buying a condom would be supporting the contraceptive industry.

But regardless... USE of a condom in the conjugal act can be nothing but contraceptive. If a couple uses a condom to avoid transmitting bodily fluid to one another what is necessary for that plan to succeed? Whatever your answer, it would include the act also being somehow contraceptive-- for one cannot conceive without the exchange of bodily fluids in sexual intercourse.

Posted

[quote name='Fides_et_Ratio' post='971665' date='May 4 2006, 07:22 PM']
I don't know if I could agree with that.. buying a condom would be supporting the contraceptive industry.

But regardless... USE of a condom in the conjugal act can be nothing but contraceptive. If a couple uses a condom to avoid transmitting bodily fluid to one another what is necessary for that plan to succeed? Whatever your answer, it would include the act also being somehow contraceptive-- for one cannot conceive without the exchange of bodily fluids in sexual intercourse.
[/quote]


Well in literal terms it is contraceptive and its prophylactic.

Buying a condom can be compared to buying a gun. It is what is done with gun that is intrinsically evil or not. Making condom balloon animals is not intrinsically evil.

Fides_et_Ratio
Posted

[quote name='hot stuff' post='971683' date='May 4 2006, 09:39 PM']
Well in literal terms it is contraceptive and its prophylactic.

Buying a condom can be compared to buying a gun. It is what is done with gun that is intrinsically evil or not. Making condom balloon animals is not intrinsically evil.
[/quote]
I don't think it's quite akin to buying a gun. Hunting animals is/can be done for food. There are legitimate uses for guns.

There are no legitimate uses for contraceptives.

Thus, supporting the gun industry is not necessarily sinful as guns have a legitimate purpose in hunting (because not all guns are used for murder). Supporting the contraceptive industry, however, is always sinful because contraception is always gravely sinful and grave injustice to marriage and the conjugal act.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...