Apotheoun Posted May 15, 2006 Posted May 15, 2006 The Church defines the conjugal act as, the natural act of intercourse whereby "a man in some fashion, even though imperfectly, [i]penetrates the vagina and immediately effects, in a natural manner, [b]a semination[/b][/i], at least partial, [i]within the vagina[/i], with this reservation that the entire male organ need not enter the vagina." [Declaration of the Holy Office, dated 12 Feb. 1941; see Fr. Nicholas Halligan, O.P., [u]The Administration of the Sacraments[/u], page 471] Thus, if the ejaculation of seminal fluid is prevented, a true conjugal act has not occurred, and one has committed in its place a gravely disordered and immoral action, because he has destroyed both the unitive and the procreative aspects inherent to the marital act. Finally, the principle of double effect does not apply to the use of condoms, because, as Pope Paul VI reaffirmed, one may not do evil -- which in this particular circumstance (i.e., the use of condoms) involves the evil of destroying both the unitive and procreative principles of the conjugal act -- so that good may come of it. Abstinence from sexual activity is the only moral option that can be used in order to prevent the spread of the HIV virus.
Fides_et_Ratio Posted May 16, 2006 Posted May 16, 2006 Thumper... It is not a case of double effect because condoms do not prevent disease. Condoms MAY help prevent the transmission of HIV, but there is NO guarantee. Condoms are not foolproof. It would be delibrately placing the spouse at risk with each conctracepive act.
qfnol31 Posted May 16, 2006 Posted May 16, 2006 (edited) [quote name='hot stuff' post='981492' date='May 15 2006, 12:49 PM'] Well you're pretty wrong. Humanae Vitae talks about disease once in the document. (And you're not going to like it ) And it never refers to the prophylactic nature of anything. Humanae Vitae talks about the infallible teaching on the transmission of life.[/quote] I've read that part and use it too. I know what it says. [quote]NO Appy you know this. Things CANNOT be intrinsically evil. It is the intent and action that has intrinsic good or evil. Condoms in and of themselves cannot hold any intrinsic value. [/quote] You prove all that is un-Catholic about NNL. I'm sorry, you've proved it. [Actions!] Things are intrinsically evil in themselves, not by intent. [I've re-edited, sorry.] Todd's right. Your interpretation is a new one that has only arisen in the last century...please don't mislead people here to think it's older. It's not. YES, [actions] can be intrinsically evil. Intent does not change the evil of the action. But let's not argue that here. This is not the place for us to bring up NNL and TNL. If you want to discuss it and argue about things like that I have an old thread in the debate table. I originally said things, I meant actions. Sorry about that. Edited May 16, 2006 by qfnol31
frozencell Posted May 16, 2006 Posted May 16, 2006 Condoms are just wrong. No matter what. If you have a partner with AIDS then you shouldn't try to protect yourself from that. Love in marriage is a completely open and accepting action, no matter the consequences. If I was in this situation I would not take measures to protect myself from my wife.
Fides_et_Ratio Posted May 16, 2006 Posted May 16, 2006 [quote name='frozencell' post='981895' date='May 15 2006, 10:38 PM'] Condoms are just wrong. No matter what. If you have a partner with AIDS then you shouldn't try to protect yourself from that. Love in marriage is a completely open and accepting action, no matter the consequences. If I was in this situation I would not take measures to protect myself from my wife. [/quote] Why wouldn't you just abstain from relations soas to not expose yourself to the disease. You would have a grave reason in that instance to not engage in the conjugal act. There's no need to cut 2 lives short... life is good in itself, don't take measures to shorten your own.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now