Jaime Posted May 5, 2006 Posted May 5, 2006 (edited) Fides I understand your opinion But the reality is that condoms have no intrinsic value to them. The Church's teaching is clear on intrinsic evil. It must be a human action. And what I'm asking for the sake of discussion is, since there is a dual purpose of condoms, can the rules of double effect be applied in the case of a married couple where one is HIV positive? Think about the ectopic pregnancy example. Is it applicable? Again the argument being posed (not by me) is that there is no disagreement with the Church's teaching on contraception. The Church's stance is clear Edited May 5, 2006 by jaime
Paphnutius Posted May 5, 2006 Posted May 5, 2006 [url="http://www.phatmass.com/phorum/index.php?showtopic=47409"]Link to topic discusses in former apologetics phorum.[/url] I would maintain that the good end is brought about by an evil, thus rednering the principle of double effect inapplicable.
Fides_et_Ratio Posted May 5, 2006 Posted May 5, 2006 [quote name='hot stuff' post='971692' date='May 4 2006, 09:47 PM'] Fides I understand your opinion But the reality is that condoms have no intrinsic value to them. The Church's teaching is clear on intrinsic evil. It must be a human action. And what I'm asking for the sake of discussion is, since there is a dual purpose of condoms, can the rules of double effect be applied in the case of a married couple where one is HIV positive? Think about the ectopic pregnancy example. Is it applicable? Again the argument being posed (not by me) is that there is no disagreement with the Church's teaching on contraception. The Church's stance is clear [/quote] There is not a dual purpose to condoms. The purpose of a condom is to prevent the transfer of bodily fluid (which itself, by nature) is contraceptive. They are not HIV protection because they do not (and cannot) 100% guarantee that the partner will not be infected. Can they lessen the RISK? Yes, but that it is a highly unnecessary risk to place on the uninfected spouse.
Jaime Posted May 5, 2006 Posted May 5, 2006 No I'm sorry Fides. The perfect example is a condom used between two men. It is only used as a prophylactic. There is nothing contraceptive about it. (Yes again the act is intrinsically evil, I'm just clarifying the dual purpose for condoms)
Apotheoun Posted May 5, 2006 Posted May 5, 2006 No one has to have sex; and so, there can be no comparison between the use of condoms for sexual activity and an ectopic pregnancy, which is life threatening if left untreated. Thus, abstinence from sexual activity is the the only answer to stopping the spread of life threatening infectious diseases. The so-called "safe sex" arguments are founded upon faulty logical and the promotion of immoral activity.
Fides_et_Ratio Posted May 5, 2006 Posted May 5, 2006 [quote name='hot stuff' post='971714' date='May 4 2006, 10:13 PM'] No I'm sorry Fides. The perfect example is a condom used between two men. It is only used as a prophylactic. There is nothing contraceptive about it. (Yes again the act is intrinsically evil, I'm just clarifying the dual purpose for condoms) [/quote] So the makers of condoms intended them to be used for homosexual sex? Doubtful, highly doubtful. Nonetheless, I don't see how this applies. Homosexual sex is entirely different from heterosexual sex. In intercourse between a man and woman the condom IS contraceptive. And the condom in that case CANNOT be not-contraceptive. By it's very "nature" of disallowing the transfer of bodily fluid it is contraceptive in heterosexual sex. In heterosexual sex you cannot remove the contraceptive purpose of a condom. [quote name='Apotheoun' post='971720' date='May 4 2006, 10:19 PM'] No one has to have sex; and so, there can be no comparison between the use of condoms for sexual activity and an ectopic pregnancy, which is life threatening if left untreated. Thus, abstinence from sexual activity is the the only answer to stopping the spread of life threatening infectious diseases. The so-called "safe sex" arguments are founded upon faulty logical and the promotion of immoral activity. [/quote] You said it better. Even the FDA says that using a condom is not "safe" sex. There is no such thing. Stay safe, stay abstinent.
luciana Posted May 5, 2006 Posted May 5, 2006 [b]Vatican officials clarify: teaching on condoms unchanged[/b] : [url="http://www.cwnews.com/news/viewstory.cfm?recnum=43792"]http://www.cwnews.com/news/viewstory.cfm?recnum=43792[/url] [b]Church ‘will not budge one inch’ on issue of condom use, says Cardinal Lopez Trujillo[/b] [url="http://www.catholicnewsagency.com/new.php?n=6641"]http://www.catholicnewsagency.com/new.php?n=6641[/url] Look for Vatican News, Zenit, or the above two for reporting of the issues. Careful what you read in the liberal media, that will find someone to support what they want, or twist the words to make it seem so. Below is also a quote that I quoted before in one of the previous posts on the issue. I added the bold. [quote]QUOTE Tolerating condoms to prevent AIDS amounts to letting the camel park his proverbial nose in the tent; soon the rest of the beast will take up permanent residence inside and he will likely bring his friends along, too. Cardinal Ratzinger had it right when, in 1988, he responded to a point about condoms in the U.S. bishops' statement, The Many Faces of AIDS. He noted that allowing condoms to prevent AIDS is "a kind of behavior which would result in at least the facilitation of evil," not merely its toleration. Catholic moral teaching sometimes permits a person to tolerate a lesser evil that one cannot eradicate without causing a greater one. [b]But, argued Cardinal Ratzinger, promoting condom use as a way of preventing AIDS does not simply tolerate an existing evil, it facilitates evil. That a Christian may not do, even for a good end, as Pope John Paul II reminds us in Veritatis splendor.[/b][/quote] from here: here: <a href="http://www.catholic.net/Catholic Church/Periodicals/Faith/0102-97/morality.html" target="_blank">http://www.catholic.net/Catholic Church/Periodicals/Fa...7/morality.html</a> Here are some articles on EWTN which I was just reading on morality and cooperation in evil inc. in the ectopic pregnancy example.: [url="http://www.ewtn.com/library/PROLIFE/EXCEPT.TXT"]http://www.ewtn.com/library/PROLIFE/EXCEPT.TXT[/url] [url="http://www.ewtn.com/library/ISSUES/ZAIDS.HTM"]http://www.ewtn.com/library/ISSUES/ZAIDS.HTM[/url] -- on condoms/ morality esp. in regards current AIDS criaia in Africa.uganda ' [url="http://www.ewtn.com/library/THEOLOGY/COOPRTN.HTM"]http://www.ewtn.com/library/THEOLOGY/COOPRTN.HTM[/url] [url="http://www.ewtn.com/library/THEOLOGY/COOPRTN.HTM#3"]http://www.ewtn.com/library/THEOLOGY/COOPRTN.HTM#3[/url] -- in this one scroll down to "the sale of Contaceptives" section interesting in regards to Fides and hot stuff's discussion.
Fides_et_Ratio Posted May 5, 2006 Posted May 5, 2006 luciana.. you rock. CNA has an article from today... [url="http://www.catholicnewsagency.com/new.php?n=6641"]http://www.catholicnewsagency.com/new.php?n=6641[/url] [quote]Church ‘will not budge one inch’ on issue of condom use, says Cardinal Lopez Trujillo Vatican City, May. 04, 2006 (CNA) - In an exclusive interview with Colombia’s Radio Cadena Nacional (RCN), Cardinal Alfonso Lopez Trujillo, president of the Pontifical Council for the Family, said the Catholic Church would not back down from its long-standing teaching on condoms and the prevention of AIDS. The cardinal told RCN that the Vatican “maintains unmodified the teaching on condoms” and said the recent statements by Italian Cardinal Maria Martini “are nothing more than his own personal opinions which do not reflect [Church] teaching.” Cardinal Lopez Trujillo said [u]Pope Benedict XVI has not ordered any studies about modifying the prohibition on condom use.[/u] “As a dicastery we do not have any instruction or any indication to the contrary, to carry out a study about something new with regards to condoms,” he stated. The Colombian prelate said Cardinal Martini “should explain how the condom prevents AIDS if it is true he said it is a lesser evil.” [u]The Church believes the only way to truly combat AIDS, Cardinal Lopez Trujillo said, is through fidelity and chastity, which are the only morally acceptable means.[/u] Contraception, the Church teaches, damages the integrity of the full gift of self, which is intrinsic to the sexual act.[/quote]
Desert Walker Posted May 5, 2006 Posted May 5, 2006 [quote name='Thumper' post='970329' date='May 3 2006, 07:35 PM'] Good article, Cappie! I think Fr. Uren and Fr. Rhonheimer have carefully articulated that this would not be a rejection of Humanae Vitae, but rather an application of the principle of double effect. The intent is not to contracept, but is rather to use condoms as prophylactics. And using condoms in that manner does not violate Humanae Vitae. And Fr. Rhonheimer's from Opus Dei, so I find it difficult to believe that he can be labeled as a liberal dissenter. [/quote] Thumper... I'm sorry, don't take this the wrong way, but this issue is not decided on Fr. Rhonheimer's ability to "carefully articulated" an intellectual position. It is thoroughly possible to carefully articulate yourself straight into doctrinal error. And his membership in Opus Dei lends no credit to his unspoken claim to orthodoxy, it merely makes his heterodoxy more repulsive. To say that you can use a condom in order to "safely" engage in the conjugal act is quite similar to saying that you can walk on the surface of the planet Mars by imagining yourself doing so while walking in the Arizona desert. It is impossible to say that the conjugal act remains the conjugal act when a condom is used in supposedly "consumating" it. When this is done, the conjugal act ceases to be the conjugal act, but rather, becomes mutual masturbation.
toledo_jesus Posted May 5, 2006 Posted May 5, 2006 [quote name='Apotheoun' post='971720' date='May 4 2006, 09:19 PM'] No one has to have sex; and so, there can be no comparison between the use of condoms for sexual activity and an ectopic pregnancy, which is life threatening if left untreated. Thus, abstinence from sexual activity is the the only answer to stopping the spread of life threatening infectious diseases. The so-called "safe sex" arguments are founded upon faulty logical and the promotion of immoral activity. [/quote] why don't the bigwigs get this basic point??????
MC IMaGiNaZUN Posted May 5, 2006 Posted May 5, 2006 you know i am totally against the whole condoms thing. But the thing that troubles me is In order for the sacrament of marriage to be consummated, there must be the sexual act. But if one of them has AIDS... That is what makes this a dilemma at all. SHALOM
qfnol31 Posted May 5, 2006 Posted May 5, 2006 [quote name='MC IMaGiNaZUN' post='972134' date='May 5 2006, 09:28 AM'] you know i am totally against the whole condoms thing. But the thing that troubles me is In order for the sacrament of marriage to be consummated, there must be the sexual act. But if one of them has AIDS... That is what makes this a dilemma at all. SHALOM [/quote] If one of them has AIDS they shouldn't get married. It is a marriage not focused on procreation at all and not a marriage for the right reasons.
Jaime Posted May 13, 2006 Posted May 13, 2006 I'm bumping this thread because something has been bugging me and I feel that this point has been overlooked. The Holy Father requested that there be further examination and discussion on the topic of condoms with regards to married couples where one is HIV positive. He asked for discussion. If there is going to be discussion, some good, orthodox and solid theologians will argue a point that will eventually be deemed to be in error. If discussion is requested, then there has to be multiple points of view. Some will eventually be shown to be in error. But does that make it proper to villify or condemn those who argue the side that is in error? No it does not. But that is the sense that I've gotten from this discussion Some theologians may argue a point they don't necessarily endorse to shed more light on a subject. Some may argue a point that they believe. But they are doing it by request. It will be the case where some theologians are arguing a side that the Church will eventually rule differently from. But that does not mean that these bishops and theologians will not ( or are not currently ) assenting their will to the Church. This is starkly different than a rogue priest openly defying Church teachings on subjects that are not open for discussion. All of these theologians are assenting their will by engaging in this dialogue. We need to remember that.
Laudate_Dominum Posted May 13, 2006 Posted May 13, 2006 [quote name='hot stuff' post='980007' date='May 13 2006, 08:27 AM'] I'm bumping this thread because something has been bugging me and I feel that this point has been overlooked. The Holy Father requested that there be further examination and discussion on the topic of condoms with regards to married couples where one is HIV positive. He asked for discussion. If there is going to be discussion, some good, orthodox and solid theologians will argue a point that will eventually be deemed to be in error. If discussion is requested, then there has to be multiple points of view. Some will eventually be shown to be in error. But does that make it proper to villify or condemn those who argue the side that is in error? No it does not. But that is the sense that I've gotten from this discussion Some theologians may argue a point they don't necessarily endorse to shed more light on a subject. Some may argue a point that they believe. But they are doing it by request. It will be the case where some theologians are arguing a side that the Church will eventually rule differently from. But that does not mean that these bishops and theologians will not ( or are not currently ) assenting their will to the Church. This is starkly different than a rogue priest openly defying Church teachings on subjects that are not open for discussion. All of these theologians are assenting their will by engaging in this dialogue. We need to remember that. [/quote] Well said hot stuff.
Anastasia13 Posted May 13, 2006 Posted May 13, 2006 [quote name='qfnol31' post='972571' date='May 5 2006, 01:21 PM'] If one of them has AIDS they shouldn't get married. It is a marriage not focused on procreation at all and not a marriage for the right reasons. [/quote] What if neither have aids, they get married, are going to the reception, then there is a car accident, then either one of them needs a transfusion, and the transfulsion is contaminated with aids or through some means they are contaminated by someone else with them who has aids? That would leave two people getting married without having aids but having aids in the way of consumating their marraige.
Fides_et_Ratio Posted May 13, 2006 Posted May 13, 2006 If one became HIV positive then they could abstain from consummating their marriage out of love for their spouse and their spouse's health.
Apotheoun Posted May 14, 2006 Posted May 14, 2006 The Pope has not called for a [i]general[/i] debate about the use of condoms by married individuals with HIV. That being said, and prescinding from the argument about whether or not condoms can be used in order to supposedly prevent the spread of HIV among married couples, it is one thing for the current Pope to call for an examination of a particular moral issue by the dicastries of the Roman Curia, so that he can give an authoritative response to a pressing concern, and quite another thing for members of the hierarchy (priests, bishops, and even cardinals) to publicly speak out in favor of something already condemned several times by the previous Pope of blessed memory. The public airing of private views by many bishops (and even some cardinals) on the issue of condom use in order to supposedly stop the spread of HIV (bearing in mind the fact that condoms are not 100 percent effective even as birth control, and that they are not designed to stop the spread of infectious diseases), reminds me of what happened when the findings of the so-called "birth control" commission appointed by Pope John XXIII, and later expanded by Pope Paul VI, were leaked to the press. The result of that public scandal has been nearly 40 years of unending public dissent by various "factions" within the Church on the issue of artificial contraception. Until Pope Benedict XVI gives his response, a Catholic is not free to argue for the use of condoms in a marriage for any reason, because as everyone knows, the ends do not justify the means.
qfnol31 Posted May 14, 2006 Posted May 14, 2006 The problem with some speculation is that it obviously contradicts some of the previous teachings. Infallible teachings cannot be changed, and some of these men seem to take the opinion that it can.
Jaime Posted May 14, 2006 Posted May 14, 2006 [quote name='qfnol31' post='980680' date='May 13 2006, 08:51 PM'] The problem with some speculation is that it obviously contradicts some of the previous teachings. Infallible teachings cannot be changed, and some of these men seem to take the opinion that it can. [/quote] No Zach Some of them take the position that it could be a case of double effect in this particular case. None of them have argued against any infallible teachings. Reread what has been posited .
Era Might Posted May 14, 2006 Posted May 14, 2006 Yah, I think there is some room for permissable speculation. That doesn't mean it's right, or that I agree with it, but the Church's teaching is always going to have room for nuance and what not. The only problem I have is that a lot of people aren't just putting it out there as a possibility, but they are flat out telling people it's ok. Even though the Church may not have addressed condoms vis a vis AIDS in a formal way, I think the common consent of theologians has been strongly against it, including Joseph Ratzinger. I just wish they would say, "This is not the teaching of the Church, and until the Holy See approves or condemns this proposition, you must hold continence as the only valid answer". And then make a formal request for a response from the Holy See. Maybe try to do so through the African Bishops' conference so that it will be more likely to get a response.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now