qfnol31 Posted May 14, 2006 Posted May 14, 2006 [font="Arial"][size=2] [quote name='cappie' post='970240' date='May 3 2006, 07:34 PM'] Ethicist Fr Bill Uren of Newman College at the University of Melbourne has said that the mooted Vatican "permission" for Catholics to use condoms to counter the HIV/AIDS epidemic is merely an application of the traditional "double effect" principle of Catholic moral theology.[/quote] [quote name='hot stuff' post='980722' date='May 13 2006, 09:33 PM']No Zach Some of them take the position that it could be a case of double effect in this particular case. None of them have argued against any infallible teachings. Reread what has been posited . [/quote] I read. [/size][/font][font="Arial"][size=2][b][quote]Neither is it valid to argue, as a justification for sexual intercourse which is [i]deliberately contraceptive,[/i] that a lesser evil is to be preferred to a greater one, or that such intercourse would merge with procreative acts of past and future to form a single entity, and so be qualified by exactly the same moral goodness as these. Though it is true that sometimes it is lawful to tolerate a lesser moral evil in order to avoid a greater evil or in order to promote a greater good," it is never lawful, even for the gravest reasons, to do evil that good may come of it (18)—in other words, to intend directly something which of its very nature contradicts the moral order, and which must therefore be judged unworthy of man, [i]even though the intention is to protect or promote the welfare of an individual, of a family or of society in general.[/i] Consequently, it is a serious error to think that a whole married life of otherwise normal relations can justify sexual intercourse which is deliberately contraceptive and so intrinsically wrong.[/quote][/b] I've also read His Holiness's encyclical on it. [/size][/font] Double effect only applies to acts which are not intrinsically evil.
Peccator Posted May 14, 2006 Posted May 14, 2006 I see this has been mentioned....I just like to add a few years ago a young women doctor accidently pricked her finger while handeling a blood sample - with the result that she was infected by the HI virus.(this is true by the way and I knew the couple..) She got tested after about 5 months, and it was confirmed that she got infected despite using high amounts of anti-retrovirals. She told her fiancee about her infection and he still married her. Now what does one make of this case..... T
God Conquers Posted May 14, 2006 Posted May 14, 2006 Alright, I'm going to weigh in here because of this: Dr. Janet Smith was at a conference I was attending yesterday and was aked this question about condoms and aids. She said she is highly doubtful of the accuracy of the media's beliefs on this point. There is likely a commission... however, as in 1967 it is probably looking at the question "How do we teach the world the Church's stance?" [b]not[/b] "Should the Church change its stance?" But even IF the CHurch were to change its stance, as it is being HIGHLY pressured to do, would this change the transmission rates of HIV? FIRST: Who are the highest transmitters? Fornicators, alduterers and homosexuals. I can just see it now: The pope is broadcast releasing a new stance... Fornicators, adulterers and homosexuals all over Africa and the world see him and say "Thank God, I can start using condoms." I don't think so. SECOND: The hard cases. Women abused by their husbands (or maybe the other way around... i dunno it could happen). Will using a condom help these women? The answer must be no. Why? First off, condom use only DELAYS the transmission of the HIV. Also, lack of contraception is not the problem here, but SPOUSAL ABUSE. If there were a village where men were intermittently hitting their wives with baseball bats we wouldn't go in and give them helmets. We need to put people on the ground to help men understand how to treat women with DIGNITY, not to hand women condoms. So what is the solution? We can't say "Here's the problem" without offering an end to it. 1) What I stated above: EDUCATION. These people are uneducated, but NOT uneducable. They can and must be proposed the Truth of what the Church teaches. 2)NATURAL FAMILY PLANNING When a woman understands her cycle, she becomes empowered with knowledge of her fertility. At least, if not delaying aids transmission, it allows her to become scarce during her periods of fertility, so that she does not have children who have the HIV (if she does not want) And keep in mind this is in a situation of abuse, not an "open to life" marriage. If everybody else is giving out more condoms than people in Africa, why does the Church need to give out condoms too? It's ridiculous. It is a wedge, an attempt to make the CHurch open up on this case, so it will cave in on all cases. The Church will stand firm. Come on... we're talking about Pope Benedict!!!!!!!
Cam42 Posted May 14, 2006 Posted May 14, 2006 [quote name='hot stuff' post='980007' date='May 13 2006, 10:27 AM'] I'm bumping this thread because something has been bugging me and I feel that this point has been overlooked. The Holy Father requested that there be further examination and discussion on the topic of condoms with regards to married couples where one is HIV positive. He asked for discussion. If there is going to be discussion, some good, orthodox and solid theologians will argue a point that will eventually be deemed to be in error. If discussion is requested, then there has to be multiple points of view. Some will eventually be shown to be in error. But does that make it proper to villify or condemn those who argue the side that is in error? No it does not. But that is the sense that I've gotten from this discussion Some theologians may argue a point they don't necessarily endorse to shed more light on a subject. Some may argue a point that they believe. But they are doing it by request. It will be the case where some theologians are arguing a side that the Church will eventually rule differently from. But that does not mean that these bishops and theologians will not ( or are not currently ) assenting their will to the Church. This is starkly different than a rogue priest openly defying Church teachings on subjects that are not open for discussion. All of these theologians are assenting their will by engaging in this dialogue. We need to remember that. [/quote] Well said Himester.
Jaime Posted May 15, 2006 Posted May 15, 2006 [quote name='qfnol31' post='980895' date='May 14 2006, 10:17 AM'] [font="Arial"][size=2] I read. [/size][/font][font="Arial"][size=2][b][/b] I've also read His Holiness's encyclical on it. [/size][/font] Double effect only applies to acts which are not intrinsically evil. [/quote] You've proved my point These theologians might be in error. The Church may decide that this can't be a case double effect. HOWEVER, if they are arguing the case of double effect YOU are in error by saying they are arguing against infallible teachings.
Fidei Defensor Posted May 15, 2006 Posted May 15, 2006 [quote name='God Conquers' post='981094' date='May 14 2006, 03:44 PM'] Who are the highest transmitters? Fornicators, alduterers and homosexuals. I can just see it now: The pope is broadcast releasing a new stance... Fornicators, adulterers and homosexuals all over Africa and the world see him and say "Thank God, I can start using condoms." I don't think so. [/quote] Exactly. The people who want the Church to change are only looking for the Church to condone what they are already doing. They aren't going to stop, regardless of what the Church says. People are always charging the Church and Pope with "killing millions of innocent AIDS victims" by not "allowing condoms." But who are these people with AIDS in the first place? I'm certain they arent concerned with what the Pope has to say about condoms. They probably still got AIDS even with the use of condoms. One would think that if you had AIDS, you would be considerate enough of your spouse to not want to give them AIDS too, especially when you know that not even condoms can stop it. But some people will do anything for pleasure. Either that or they are just sleeping around, in which case, what the Pope says still doesnt matter to them.
qfnol31 Posted May 15, 2006 Posted May 15, 2006 [quote name='hot stuff' post='981176' date='May 14 2006, 07:56 PM']You've proved my point These theologians might be in error. The Church may decide that this can't be a case double effect. HOWEVER, if they are arguing the case of double effect YOU are in error by saying they are arguing against infallible teachings.[/quote] First, this doesn't make sense. Second, the teaching is infallible that condoms cannot be used for a licit purpose, even double effect cannot apply here. The Church has already said such in His Holiness, Pope Paul VI that it can't be a double effect case. Third, they are saying condoms and such are licit. How am I in error and they are not? I'm kinda disturbed that so many people on here cannot see how they are not explicitly in error regarding the infallible teachings set forth in Humanae Vitae. Lastly, hot stuff, what point did I prove? No one's responded to Todd's sound thinking on this I see.
qfnol31 Posted May 15, 2006 Posted May 15, 2006 I'm really kinda surprised that people on here will stand up for dissenting theologians or theologians in error, but if someone on here disagrees with part of the Catechism... How many people here have read Humanae Vitae? Can anyone say what it says in this respect?
Laudate_Dominum Posted May 15, 2006 Posted May 15, 2006 [quote name='qfnol31' post='981308' date='May 14 2006, 10:49 PM'] First, this doesn't make sense. Second, the teaching is infallible that condoms cannot be used for a licit purpose, even double effect cannot apply here. The Church has already said such in His Holiness, Pope Paul VI that it can't be a double effect case. Third, they are saying condoms and such are licit. How am I in error and they are not? I'm kinda disturbed that so many people on here cannot see how they are not explicitly in error regarding the infallible teachings set forth in Humanae Vitae. Lastly, hot stuff, what point did I prove? No one's responded to Todd's sound thinking on this I see. [/quote] Yes, and there are other magisterial moral teachings which in my estimation definitively clarify the proper application of the principle of double-effect. The condom thing fails to meet two of the criteria which a situation must meet in order for the principle to even apply. If the Church were to make a concession for condoms it would be a slippery slope. Actually, it would be the downfall of Catholic sexuality morality. I think some people know this and that's why there is such a to do about it. The heterodox liberal contingent would have injected a fatal poison. If my evaluation is correct then this situation is impossible since the Holy Spirit protects the Church from teaching error in an official capacity. But I can see the possibility of a quasi-authoritative document being passed off as official Church teaching and there being a great attack made upon the Church. This has already happened many times in the past few decades. People still want to pretend that "Environment and Art" for example means something.
Jaime Posted May 15, 2006 Posted May 15, 2006 [quote name='qfnol31' post='981308' date='May 14 2006, 11:49 PM'] First, this doesn't make sense. Second, the teaching is infallible that condoms cannot be used for a licit purpose, even double effect cannot apply here. The Church has already said such in His Holiness, Pope Paul VI that it can't be a double effect case. Third, they are saying condoms and such are licit. How am I in error and they are not? I'm kinda disturbed that so many people on here cannot see how they are not explicitly in error regarding the infallible teachings set forth in Humanae Vitae. Lastly, hot stuff, what point did I prove? No one's responded to Todd's sound thinking on this I see. [/quote] Sorry you're disturbed. But take your statement one step further. Because what you're actually saying is that you're kinda disturbed that Pope Benedict XVI asked for further discussion. You think maybe he's read Humanae Vitae? I'm gonna guess yes on that one. Pope Benedict XVI has demonstrated on multiple occassions that he is smarter on theology than you, I or anybody else on this board. If a theologian were to argue for contraception, they would be stating that the infallible teaching of Humanae Vitae is wrong and they would be wrong. But none of the articles posted have argued that. Not one has said "Oh yeah, contraception is good". They have argued about the ethical nature of the containment of disease. Their argument is this "Does the curtailing of transmission of HIV translate into willfully impeding procreation?" And if the answer to that question is no, then it does not contradict Humanae Vitae. That is where you are in error. [quote]I'm really kinda surprised that people on here will stand up for dissenting theologians or theologians in error, but if someone on here disagrees with part of the Catechism...[/quote] Ok well here's the difference Zach. The Catechism is put forth by the Magisterium. Its been discussed and reviewed. Where the Church stands is clear and defined. In the case of condoms being used by married couples where one is HIV positive, there is current discussion to discern where the Church should stand. The use of contraceptives are condemned. The use of prophylactics have not been fully defined. We aren't going to vote on it. The Holy Father and/or the Magisterium will make a final decision and we will be guided by that decision. When issues are being fully defined, there will be discussion. Theologians will pose arguments from all sides. Thoughtful discernment will occur. Answers don't fall out of the sky! There is not one single truth that we live by that has not gone through this process. Not one Zach. Prior to Ineffabilis Deus, there were good, solid theologians who argued against the Immaculate Conception. Were they branded heretics after it had been declared? Well they would have been if they continued to argue against it. But they had the same opportunity that we have every day. They had the opportunity to assent their will to the Church. The Holy Father is not going to say "Let's investigate [insert issue here] but if you've offered an opinion that is contrary to what the Church finally decides, you'll be ousted as a heretic" That wouldn't promote a very thoughtful investigation now would it? Understand this distinction I am not defending opinions that are contrary to the teachings of the Church. I am defending the full process of investigation and discernment that the Church has implemented since the Council of Nicea. Making sense now?
qfnol31 Posted May 15, 2006 Posted May 15, 2006 I have yet to find a reliable resource that backs up any of your premises, such as the fact that Pope Benedict called for a general discussion on this. I'm pretty up on his theology. Reading his books and interviews helped shape my theology years ago. And actually, your post makes no sense for one reason...Humanae Vitae already answered those theologians. They have been all responded to quickly, not just those that say contraception is bad. If you read the encyclical, which I assume you already have, it states tons more than that contraception is an evil thing. It says, as I posted above, that there isn't a justification for things like condoms, even lesser of two evils or double effect. It isn't that these theologians are allowed to discuss, for that's already been silenced by the Papal Magisterium. Condoms as prophylactics I'm pretty sure are condemned. Humanae Vitae is perfectly clear on this issue, too. Also, Catechism doesn't share in the same infallibility as Humanae Vitae. Makes their transgressing from it all the worse...
Apotheoun Posted May 15, 2006 Posted May 15, 2006 There is absolutely no evidence to show that Pope Benedict XVI has asked for a general debate on this issue. Nevertheless, the teaching of Pope Paul VI is quite clear on this topic, because anything that separates the unitive and procreative principles of the conjugal act, destroys the finality (i.e., the end) of that act, and as a consequence, dehumanizes both the act itself and the spouses. With this doctrine in mind, it is clear that condoms are inherently evil because they not only prevent procreation -- if used correctly -- but also because they destroy the unitive principle of the marital act, which must always include a complete donation of self on the part of the spouses. Thus, a husband must surrender himself to his wife through the ejaculation of his semen into her vagina, with the possibility of the transmission of new life, and a wife must surrender herself to her husband by the reception of his semen, with a complete openness to the possibility of the procreation of new life that this act of love necessarily involves. In other words, the unitive principle of the conjugal act involves a reciprocal gift of self on the part of the spouses, and anything -- which for any reason -- puts up a barrier to this complete and total surrender of self on the part of the spouses is by definition immoral. Now it is quite clear that condoms are destructive of both the unitive and procreative ends which are intrinsic to the marital act, because the proper use of a condom frustrates the will of the Creator, which is inscribed into the very nature of man and woman, and in the process turns the conjugal act, which is meant to be a selfless act of love, into a type of mutual masturbation. The following quotation from [u]Humanae Vitae[/u] makes clear the constant and irrevocable teaching of the Magisterium on this issue: ". . . the Church, calling men back to the observance of the norms of the natural law, as interpreted by its constant doctrine, teaches that each and every marriage act must remain open to the transmission of life. That teaching, often set forth by the Magisterium, is founded upon the inseparable connection, willed by God and unable to broken by man on his own initiative, between the two meanings of the conjugal act: the unitive meaning and the procreative meaning. Indeed, by its intimate structure, the conjugal act, while most closely uniting husband and wife, capacitates them for the generation of new lives, according to the laws inscribed in the very being of man and of woman. By safeguarding both of these essential aspects, the unitive and the procreative, the conjugal act preserves in its fullness the sense of true mutual love and its ordination towards man's most high calling to parenthood." [Pope Paul VI, [u]Humanae Vitae[/u], nos. 11 and 12] As is clear from what Pope Paul VI taught in [u]Humanae Vitae[/u], condoms -- if used properly -- are destructive of the true purpose of the marriage act, because the use of a condom frustrates both the unitive and the procreative principles inherent in the act, and in the process turns a selfless act of total surrender to one's spouse in love and fidelity, into a selfish act for the sake of a few moments of physical pleasure.
Jaime Posted May 15, 2006 Posted May 15, 2006 [quote] Condoms as prophylactics I'm pretty sure are condemned. Humanae Vitae is perfectly clear on this issue, too.[/quote] Well you're pretty wrong. Humanae Vitae talks about disease once in the document. (And you're not going to like it ) And it never refers to the prophylactic nature of anything. Humanae Vitae talks about the infallible teaching on the transmission of life. [quote]With that doctrine in mind, it is clear that condoms are inherently evi[/quote] NO Appy you know this. Things CANNOT be intrinsically evil. It is the intent and action that has intrinsic good or evil. Condoms in and of themselves cannot hold any intrinsic value.
Apotheoun Posted May 15, 2006 Posted May 15, 2006 [quote name='hot stuff' post='981492' date='May 15 2006, 10:49 AM'] [. . .] Appy you know this. Things CANNOT be intrinsically evil. It is the intent and action that has intrinsic good or evil. Condoms in and of themselves cannot hold any intrinsic value. [/quote] hot stuff, You should know that quoting someone out of context is never right. Now, let's look at the whole of the sentence that I wrote: "With this doctrine in mind, it is clear that condoms are inherently evil because they not only prevent procreation -- [b]if used correctly[/b] -- but also because they destroy the unitive principle of the marital act, which must always include a complete donation of self on the part of the spouses." Now the context makes clear my meaning, because I have not said that a condom -- as a simple piece of rubber -- is inherently evil, what I have said is that condoms "if used correctly" are evil because they destroy the unitive principle of the conjugal act, which of its very nature requires that a husband ejaculate his semen into his wife's vagina. hot stuff, With that out of the way, please provide the pertinent quotation from Pope Benedict XVI that shows that he is calling for a "general" debate among theologians and the lay faithful on this issue. God bless, Todd
Jaime Posted May 15, 2006 Posted May 15, 2006 I've not said that the Holy Father asked for a general debate. He has asked that it be investigated. That's been confirmed by multiple news sources. And most certainly in the age of instant communication, its going to be discussed by and commented on by serious theologians. (And a few armchair theologians as well) Its human nature. There is nothing scandalous about the discussion. If anything, its going to help educate folks on what the teachings of the Church are. And the reason I jumped on your wording is because there are people on the board that truly believe that condoms in and of themselves are intrinsically evil. I wasn't just picking nits
God Conquers Posted May 15, 2006 Posted May 15, 2006 The likelihood that he opened discussion on this is not very good. The media has been known to misconstrue papal commissions. What has likely happenned is that a commission has been formed to discuss HOW the Church approach the world on this matter. Not whether the teaching should be changed. People can talk and take any opinion that they like. And we can disagree with them all we want. The Church will always hold and teach this traditionally, always has and always will.
Thumper Posted May 15, 2006 Posted May 15, 2006 Just to jump back into the pool . . . . Here’s how I understand the application of the principle of double effect in this matter. I’m taking the criterion for double effect from that bastion of all theologian knowledge, Wikipedia (en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Double_Effect). In this case, I think they’ve laid out the criterion correctly and it was a handy place to find it. If other criteria should be considered in relation to double effect, please let me know. From Wikipedia: 1. The act may not be inherently wrong. It must in itself be either good or at least morally neutral. 2. The person making the act must not actually intend to accomplish the bad effect, but must simply not be able to avoid it while accomplishing the good effect. If there is any way to accomplish the good while avoiding the bad, then that should be done. 3. The good effect must be at least as directly an effect of the action as the bad effect is. In particular, the good effect must not be caused by the bad effect, which would be prohibited. 4. The benefit of the good effect must be weighed against the harm of the bad effect, and the bad must not outweigh the good. This comparison must be done with prudence and reflection. From Thumper: What is the act and intent? Attempting to prevent the transmission of disease during marital sexual intercourse through the use of a condom as a prophylactic. What is the double effect? Contraception. In response to the four criteria above: 1a: It is not inherently wrong to attempt to prevent the transmission of disease during marital sexual intercourse using a prophylactic; and a condom is a type of prophylactic. 2a: The couple’s intent is to prevent disease, not to contracept; using the condom as a prophylactic is highly likely to result in contraception. Nevertheless, there is no other way to attempt to prevent the transmission of certain diseases during marital sexual intercourse apart from using a condom. 3a: The good effect is as much a result of the action as the bad effect. The bad effect of contraception does not cause the good effect of the prevention of disease transmission. 4a: Here’s where I think the debate really centers. IMHO, the harm of the bad effect does not outweigh the benefit of the good effect. The physical and emotional unity of sexual intercourse is not the goal of our existence; but it is an extremely important part of the marriage relationship and should not be dismissed as being less important than procreation. Obviously, others differ. But I think this is the point that the magisterium will be attempting to articulate.
God Conquers Posted May 15, 2006 Posted May 15, 2006 All this "double effect" talk really just seems like proportionality... Thumper is right, the bad effect outweighs the good. We can never prevent a moral evil by committing another moral evil.
Thumper Posted May 15, 2006 Posted May 15, 2006 [quote name='God Conquers' post='981662' date='May 15 2006, 02:08 PM'] All this "double effect" talk really just seems like proportionality... Thumper is right, the bad effect outweighs the good. We can never prevent a moral evil by committing another moral evil. [/quote] Hey--thanks for agreeing with me, but I think you misread my post. I actually said that the bad effect does NOT outweigh the good.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now