Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group Ă—
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Kids Making Their Own First Communion Bread


Recommended Posts

KnightofChrist
Posted

[quote name='iggyjoan' post='1271529' date='May 11 2007, 08:38 PM']i dont really get what the big deal is about the ingredients. its still Jesus, right? it shouldnt matter what it is before its consencrated(i think thats the right word)[/quote]

I understand your point, yet the ingredients are very important.

[url="http://hoosiercatholic.org/cgi-bin/ambo/ambo.pl?record=38"]SOURCE[/url]
[quote]Dear Faithful Scribe,

Why is it that communion bread can only be made out of flour and water? and no other ingredients?

Dear Devoted Believer,

The bread of the Eucharist is the bread from the Passover Supper. This ancient ritual recalls the flight of the Jews from Egypt which account we have in the book of Exodus. From this tradition the bread that is used is that of people on the move and in a hurry to get moving. It is the most basic of bread because they were traveling light, not carrying all sorts of luxurious food ingredients with them, only the most basic wheat flour. There was no time to allow the bread to rise so it was a most simple task of mixing the flour and water, patting it flat, and sticking it into an oven. Check out the kosher section of your grocery store and you will see the contemporary Jewish version of this bread as matzo.

Sometimes people have tried to be creative by making the bread a bit more succulent. some places will make their own bread and add such lovely tasting ingredients as honey or cinnamon. This is not appropriate in that it robs the bread of its meaning as the Passover bread and makes it seem more like a scone at Starbucks. Not that Your Faithful Scribe has anything against Starbucks’ scones. In fact, Your Faithful Scribe delights in them (especially the lemon-cranberry ones accompanying a grande Americano with an extra shot.) Scones, however, do not Eucharistic bread make.

The Eucharistic bread is intended to remind us that Jesus is our nourishment for our journey. The asceticism of the form this nourishment takes helps us realize that the delight of our senses on this earthly journey must make way for the divine transformation of something so simple as baked flour and water into the body of Jesus Christ.[/quote]

Totus Tuus
Posted (edited)

[quote name='iggyjoan' post='1271529' date='May 11 2007, 09:38 PM']i dont really get what the big deal is about the ingredients. its still Jesus, right? it shouldnt matter what it is before its consencrated(i think thats the right word)[/quote]

Yeah, like the previous poster said, ingredients really are a big deal. Whether we see the logic in it or not, the Eucharist cannot be validly consecrated if there are any ingredients added which are not supposed to be. I'm sure we've all heard of times when sweet bread, french bread, etc., have been used during the service. Those things can't be transubstantiated into the Body and Blood of Our Lord.

Edited by Totus Tuus
Piccoli Fiori JMJ
Posted

Here is a great podcast about the Jewish Passover and the Catholic Mass. They have a whole series about Jewish traditions and practices caried over into Catholicism and transformed by Christ.
[url="http://web.mac.com/cicdc/iWeb/KStreet/CICpod/F055EBBB-D082-4CF5-8900-65B09D9DC2A3.html"]http://web.mac.com/cicdc/iWeb/KStreet/CICp...B09D9DC2A3.html[/url]

Ave Maria Totus Tuus
Posted

Thanks for everyone's comments! Very informative.

Posted

ummm I dont know about that.... What has happened to the church? surely you people dont think this is ok?

homeschoolmom
Posted

[quote name='Akalyte' post='1271779' date='May 12 2007, 09:10 AM']ummm I dont know about that.... What has happened to the church? surely you people dont think this is ok?[/quote]
Think that [i]what[/i] is okay? Baking the bread? Someone has to make it.

Paddington
Posted

It wouldn't be First Communion for whoever eats the booger. That should settle it, IMO. Kids shouldn't make their own bread.

Posted

I know that it is a traditional custom in some of the Eastern Churches for a different family to donate the altar bread every week, although I think they administer in loaf cubes. I would be worried about the round host falling apart or having a lot of crumbs. It would probably be a good idea to check with the local Bishop to make sure everything meets standards.

Posted

I think it is not a very good idea. I think it makes the children more focussed on the human, earthly bread, and for children, this can easily create an atmosphere where they overlook what it truly is ("look mom, I made that!!" , mom: "that is Jesus honey" kid: "no, I made it with mrs.sunday school" mom: "sigh").

I get that it is a fun project, and we did something like that to practice in rehearsal (we made our own "practice" bread), but when it came to the real thing, it was not about entertaining us, it was about Mass.

bonoducchi
Posted

I would honestly like to see a parish in which all the bread was baked by God's people assembled there. The hosts we receive today are not even reminiscent of the Passover bread which Christ used to institute the sacrament. Prefab little wafers do not give the fullest experience of bread being transubstantiated because we are not using a "common thing made holy". We are using a food made in a way that is foreign to most of us. Why not make real unleavened bread, that has imperfections and blemishes. What symbolism that is, since we too are offered at Mass (we are incensed at the preparation of the gifts), with all our blemishes and imperfections. Perfectly round Styrofoam wafers don't seem to convey the deeper theology of transubstantiation as well as more common forms of unleavened wheat bread.

bonoducchi
Posted

[quote name='prose' post='1271901' date='May 12 2007, 12:45 PM']I get that it is a fun project, and we did something like that to practice in rehearsal (we made our own "practice" bread), but when it came to the real thing, it was not about entertaining us, it was about Mass.[/quote]

I'm nto sure it was about entertaining kids. It may have been a way to show them that these are [i]our [/i]gifts, humble as they are, offered to God.

Posted

VIILiturgist... I... uhh....


agree :unsure:

:sigh:

what is the world coming to when I agree with VIILiturgist? a dull place lacking diversity.. :(

lol :P: jk

Seriously, though, think back into the history of the Latin Rite. We didn't always have industrially-standard hosts.

Posted

Well, the bread is always something "human hands have made," just like the wine is "work of human hands." It's not like they have to be a product of the particular worshiping community to be meaningful in that way. I really don't see a problem with the little kids making the communion bread, except that if it were common practice, there would surely be abuses that crept in. Otherwise it seems kind of neat.

Also, I don't know how "real" unleavened bread would contribute to a greater understanding of transubstantiation... The idea is that the Host is no longer bread at all. So would an increase in breadyness (:hehehe: I made a new word) really help with that?

bonoducchi
Posted

[quote name='Aloysius' post='1271947' date='May 12 2007, 02:09 PM']VIILiturgist... I... uhh....
agree :unsure:

:sigh:

what is the world coming to when I agree with VIILiturgist? a dull place lacking diversity.. :(

lol :P: jk

Seriously, though, think back into the history of the Latin Rite. We didn't always have industrially-standard hosts.[/quote]

Would it help if I told you (a good Irish boy) that I am Italian? I'm sure we could have many pleasurable hours beating each other up in the alley!

Posted

that's better. let's take this outside.

hehehe

Posted

For Eastern Catholics this new Roman [i]practice[/i] really is irrelevant, since "first" communion is given to babies (just after they are baptized and chrismated) in the Eastern Churches.

bonoducchi
Posted

[quote name='Maggie' post='1271949' date='May 12 2007, 02:14 PM']Also, I don't know how "real" unleavened bread would contribute to a greater understanding of transubstantiation... The idea is that the Host is no longer bread at all. So would an increase in breadyness (:hehehe: I made a new word) really help with that?[/quote]

What did Jesus use? Did say, "first, make a thin wafer out of flour and water. Then take and eat it, this is my body." No, he took bread and gave it to his disciples. Having something that doesn't look like what we call it doesn't make sense. If I never had seen a host, before, I would have no clue it was bread. It looks like an hor's d'ouerve.

Not to say that hosts are "unworthy"....just seems like we could be using something better.

To say nothing of the swill some places call wine....Carlo Rossi...heavens and saints preserve us!

Posted

so are typical hosts made by machine then? I would assume they're not even touched by someone.

bonoducchi
Posted

[quote name='Didymus' post='1271967' date='May 12 2007, 02:41 PM']so are typical hosts made by machine then? I would assume they're not even touched by someone.[/quote]

To my knowledge, its pretty mechanical. Its not as if some person is standing there, cutting each perfect circle out of the dough.

I order a box of 30,000 hosts every 2 weeks, so I doubt its a very human process.

Posted

I don't think regular looking bread would be a better choice. The form of the Eucharistic host that we use in the West expresses that the Eucharist is not mere bread, it is something very special, something perfect and supernatural. The host also has an aesthetic purpose in Eucharistic adoration, because it can be easily held in a monstrance. The Eastern Churches do not use the same host, but I'm pretty sure they don't just randomly take apart the bread and consecrate it. They use neat cubes of bread, and they also use a spoon to administer by intinction. The Eucharist began in a simple context, but the Church's understanding of the Real Presence has deepened over the centuries, and there is no reason to go back to the form of the early Church merely because it was the early Church. The use of bread that looks common may give the impression that we are celebrating a human banquet, and this is the last thing we need in an age when Catholics are poorly catechized about the Holy Eucharist.

[quote]The liturgy of the early ages is most certainly worthy of all veneration. But ancient usage must not be esteemed more suitable and proper, either in its own right or in its significance for later times and new situations, on the simple ground that it carries the savor and aroma of antiquity. The more recent liturgical rites likewise deserve reverence and respect. They, too, owe their inspiration to the Holy Spirit, who assists the Church in every age even to the consummation of the world. They are equally the resources used by the majestic Spouse of Jesus Christ to promote and procure the sanctity of man.

--Pope Pius XII, Encyclical Letter "Mediator Dei"[/quote]

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...