Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Twilight?  

46 members have voted

You do not have permission to vote in this poll, or see the poll results. Please sign in or register to vote in this poll.

Recommended Posts

Posted

[quote name='pan!c139' post='1628212' date='Aug 15 2008, 04:18 PM']Everyone I know that's read those books (a lot of people, actually) all loved the books, especially the fourth. :mellow: The second one isn't great because it's so sad. But the first, and fourth especially are great, and the third is good.[/quote]


The first is my favorite, then New Moon, than Eclipse, than Breaking Dawn.

So like, in order I guess.

Lol I never realized that until just now when I wrote them out.

ANYWAY. I've always been a big Jacob supporter though.

I liked Breaking Dawn, but I thought it was extremely far fetched, even for this series.

:idontknow:

Posted

Far-fetched in what way?

Posted (edited)

[quote name='pan!c139' post='1628984' date='Aug 16 2008, 02:59 PM']Far-fetched in what way?[/quote]

I'll PM you, to prevent giving away spoilers.

EDIT: Actually, no. Tell me when you're done with Breaking Dawn then I'll PM you so I don't give anything away for you.

Edited by iggyjoan
Posted

I finished Breaking Dawn like a week ago. :) I read it in 24 hours, it was pretty much glued to my face.

Posted

Ha that's great :) It took me 2 days, I think. I read Twilight, New Moon, and Eclipse in a day though.

Not the same day, a day for each book.

I PMed you.

Posted

haha, when I read that I thought you read all three in the same day.

I was like, you've got some mad reading skills girl.

Posted

It took me a week to read Twilight (cuz I was at summer camp and we had like no time to ourselves at all), but I finished New Moon and Eclipse in a day and a half or two days, and Breaking Dawn in a day. I read really fast with those books lol.

Posted

Just thought that I would let you know that I just finished Twilight....... :o



I told night that I would have to run out and buy the others.....



Thanks for suggesting that i read it. I started Thursday and finished last night :))

Posted

This is how the world ends
This is how the world ends
This is how the world ends

Not with a bang, but a whimper

Posted

^ AH shutup.

I told you it was good Faith!! Hahaha. Yeah as soon as I read the first one, I [b]HAD[/b] to read the next three! The second one you kind of have to push yourself to read because it's really sad, but the third and fourth are great!

Posted

[quote name='pan!c139' post='1630495' date='Aug 18 2008, 12:11 PM']^ AH shutup.

I told you it was good Faith!! Hahaha. Yeah as soon as I read the first one, I [b]HAD[/b] to read the next three! The second one you kind of have to push yourself to read because it's really sad, but the third and fourth are great![/quote]


[spoiler]I went through a depression with Bella. [/spoiler]

And it's in spoiler tags not because it's a spoiler but because it's weird and slightly embarrassing.

But it's true. I didn't eat at all that day.

Posted

Hahaha. I kind of did too! But I did eat. I almost cried when Jacob left her. I was so sad - really really really sad when Edward did, but it was too much when Jacob did too.

Posted

i loved the first three books, the second, was absolutely essential to the saga, to start to define bella and jacob's relationship

the fourth, was definitely not as good, but i couldn't help not to love it, because i'm head over heals for the whole series.
haha


but i don't understand how it can be called far-fetched, it is afterall about vampires inlove with humans. :)

it does have that fairytale/fanfic ending

but it makes me happy

ha i'm a sucker for happy endings

Posted

^ LOL so am I!!! OMG I am in love with Jacob as much as I am with Edward!!! :love: I like all the books. :D

Posted

[quote name='pan!c139' post='1636363' date='Aug 24 2008, 01:41 AM']^ LOL so am I!!! OMG I am in love with Jacob as much as I am with Edward!!! :love: I like all the books. :D[/quote]


i couldn't stand jacob for the longest time, i thought he was soo immature and...just agravating about the whole situation..but i understand...why people love hime now, i can tell espically int he 4th.

:)

Posted

Yeah, in the fourth, but I also loooooooved him in the third! :lust: He was so sweet! He's funny too!

Posted

I'm going to make a "Team Jacob" tshirt. :D

rizz_loves_jesus
Posted

To be honest, I'm not really sure what all the hype is about... I like the books and I think they're interesting, but they can't even compare to Harry Potter :P Like, it seemed like Bella was more obsessed with Edward than in love with him. And Edward has no weakness, either- he's perfect. And Bella and Edward never fight, it's always lovey dovey love.

Even with all of that, though, they're really interesting books, I couldn't put any of them down
:P

Posted

They did fight a lot actually, but it wasn't any SERIOUS fights...but yeah, I agree a bit with the obsession...she loved him, but it was like she needed him for herself, and not because she decided to love him, you know? :idontknow:

I think that's why I liked Jacob so much, because he was more human - he made mistakes.

I've never read Harry Potter, so there. :P I like Twilight better haha.

Posted (edited)

The only things that really bothered me about Jacob were that one he forced a kiss out of Bella (assault,) two after the kiss he was all "I know that you really do love me too you're just refuse to admit it," and then he totally manipulated Bella into letting him kiss her.

Not that I hate Jacob. He just made some decisions that made him look like a jerk. I still want him to be happy though. I hope that he imprints with someone in Breaking Dawn. I haven't finshed it yet so don't spoil it for me.

Edited by tinytherese

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...