Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Heresy...at Church?!


Recommended Posts

HisChildForever
Posted

I'll get to the heresy part in a minute.

My brother went to Mass last night, and told me that instead of the homily, they had a 15 minute powerpoint presentation (of all things) about the changes they plan to make to the school (the only Catholic school in town, and it's Kindergarten through 8th). Now, we're talking about a not-so-great educational institution (although they insist it's top notch) where each grade literally has only fifteen kids, and their technology, elective courses, and after school activities (like sports) don't even compare with our public school system. But instead of improving what needs to be improved, they have a goal of one million dollars (amidst this economic crisis our country is going through) to beautify the school. At the end of Mass, everyone was asked to fill out a volunteer sheet (if they could spare some time) and leave it in the pews.

I am going to assume that there were some complaints, because at noon Mass, we simply had the Principal speak to us for about five minutes (again, no homily). Nothing about money was mentioned, but rather, volunteering. We weren't exactly told what we would be volunteering for, mind you. Instead of simply being informed of the volunteer slips, they were actually collected right then and there, which made all of us who didn't fill it out (I have work the days they would be meeting) feel terrible. My dad, who is an usher, said there were only 11 slips total, and there were probably around 70 people there today. [I need to note that I have a small town of 8,000 people.]

She did a good job insulting those of us who attended public school by saying that the Catholic school children are our "only hope" of furthering our religion.

Here's the heresy:
She also said that while we would all like to believe that Catholicism will endure, we all know sadly that this will not be, unless our Catholic school children are properly educated because the Catholic school kids are our hope for the future.

A Catholic school principal said that. Even though Jesus told Peter that the gates of Hell will never prevail against the Church. So, basically, if we don't muster up the ridiculous amount of cash they are asking for (which is going towards all the wrong things), and if we don't enroll our children into their school, then eventually the Church - not OUR church, HOLY MOTHER CHURCH - will fail and disappear over time. Because everything has to do with the state of our Catholic schools.

She also made a bold lie by saying that the "talk on the street" is about how great the Catholic school is doing, which simply isn't true. The reason why their 7th and 8th grades are 2x smaller than the younger grades is because the kids all leave and come to our high school, which is 7th-12th.

No one clapped for her when she was done. And my parish is very clap-friendly. We actually had another speaker after Mass (this is the proper time!) who was speaking about a retreat for women, and everyone clapped for her.

Our parish needs better CCD instruction (the kids in the Catholic school also needing better religious curriculum) and more hardcore homilies, not the soft homilies where Catholic doctrine is ignored and the faith is treated like a walk in the park.

Just looking for opinions. :saint:

Posted

well, the truth is that in your town catholocism may not endure. Catholocism as a whole will go on. However, I truly believe that in some towns...in some contries....there is no more catholocism.

Posted

I'm in the Diocese of Camden, so I know what you're going through, though I'm not sure it's that bad down here. CCD is terrible...all I learned in eight years was that Jesus loves me, parables, sexual sins are wrong, and prayers I can parrot at you in my sleep. :( And they wonder why every single person, self included, fell away after Confirmation? It should have never happened.

Pray for the Church in Jersey. Heck, pray for it everywhere--it scares me that I'm often the only one under 30 at the Saturday night Mass...

HisChildForever
Posted

[quote name='Autumn Dusk' post='1665734' date='Sep 28 2008, 02:30 PM']well, the truth is that in your town catholocism may not endure. Catholocism as a whole will go on. However, I truly believe that in some towns...in some contries....there is no more catholocism.[/quote]

No, she was actually saying that if the younger generation doesn't get educated in the Catholic school system, Catholicism will be wiped out.

Our parish wouldn't suffer if they closed the school. There's rarely any young people at Mass anyway, it's adults who make up our parish pews.

HisChildForever
Posted

[quote name='MissyP89' post='1665739' date='Sep 28 2008, 02:37 PM']I'm in the Diocese of Camden, so I know what you're going through, though I'm not sure it's that bad down here. CCD is terrible...all I learned in eight years was that Jesus loves me, parables, sexual sins are wrong, and prayers I can parrot at you in my sleep. :( And they wonder why every single person, self included, fell away after Confirmation? It should have never happened.

Pray for the Church in Jersey. Heck, pray for it everywhere--it scares me that I'm often the only one under 30 at the Saturday night Mass...[/quote]

Diocese of Newark here.

Good for you, we never learned sexual sins. :wacko:

Posted

I'm so sick of the protestantization within the Church in America.
<_<

Posted

Well, when Oral Roberts said God told him he'd die unless people sent in enough money it worked pretty good for him. Fear is always a good motivator.

Posted

Fun I've gotten that speech before at church...a Baptist church. With private Christian schools.

Posted

[quote name='HisChildForever' post='1665741' date='Sep 28 2008, 02:39 PM']Diocese of Newark here.

Good for you, we never learned sexual sins. :wacko:[/quote]

:o A few years ago you guys got our (fabulous) Bishop!! :weep:

I suppose you need him more than we do, though. Peoria is pretty well-behaved.

puellapaschalis
Posted

When the Catholic hierarchy was re-established in Great Britain the bishops held Catholic education so important that the building and establishment of Catholic schools was given a higher priority than the building of parish churches.

Posted

My catholic high school was terrible. I lost my Faith there...I should of stayed in public school. Archbishop Fulton Sheen was right, "If you want [your children] to lose their faith, send them to Catholic school."

Posted

Unfortunately Catholic schools will pull that number when they want your support, but then (generally, not always) they don't do enough to really teach the faith to the kids.

Domine ut Videam
Posted

[quote name='HisChildForever' post='1665741' date='Sep 28 2008, 02:39 PM']Diocese of Newark here.[/quote]

While, I wouldn't go so far as to call this heresy, if it truly bothers you then I would bring it up with the Archbishop. As philothea said, you got our bishop (meyers) and he is solid. I'm pretty sure he won't allow any funny business to go on in his Diocese(s). Your parish will be in my prayers.

Posted

I am completely for Catholic Education. Regardless of any need for strengthening of the Religious cirriculum, the fact remains that at a Catholic school you can pray, talk about your faith, and go to mass during the week. At a public school the government has complete control and with the way things are looking that is a very scary reality. We need to support our Catholic schools because they are a better alternative to public, secularized, godless institutions that poison our youth with relativism.

Having said that, I understand the need for reform in Catholic education but we shouldn't turn our back on it. I'm dealing with that right now. In my observance, people simply don't want to make the sacrifices necesarry to keep Catholic schools open, but they are indeed worth it. Even the watered down version of Catholic education is worth saving.

Proud Pastor of struggling school,

Fr. Burns

Posted

I think this is why we should pray for more vocations within the Church, especially to the Dominican Communities or to any community that teaches. That way we'll have great Catholic schools being taught by awesome women in habit :)

Posted

lots of employees at Catholic schools don't seem very Catholic at all. their authorities seem more like secular business people. even the parents, teachers and children around here seem to be devoid of what our church is severely lacking - basic catechesis on our faith.. *sigh*

the leaders just don't take the faith seriously at all. there is a severe lack of the spiritual. like you said, Matthew 16 and the "gates of the netherworld" means pretty much nothing to them. they are just thinking practically, "as man does, and not as God does". it's about the numbers and the money they get from each student, not about relying on faith in God.

i remember reading about a school where they want a free Catholic education for everyone, so they rely on the community and keep it affordable for every student. despite their dire financial situation, somehow God is keeping them afloat. they have faith. call me a hopeless romantic, but isn't this how we are supposed to be?

eagle_eye222001
Posted

Here is my experience with Catholic Education.

-Tuition goes up 8%-10% a year. :shock:

-We talk about being Christ-centered and get caught-being-Christ-like slips which you use as raffle tickets for school dollars to buy extra recess or dress-down days.

-If you want friends, act tough, do popular stuff, and maybe then we will acknowledge you.

-Religious education: uhhhhhhhh, I forgot.

Here is my family's experience with public education

-tuition: free

-easier to make friends

-more Christian friendly environment (not lying. We found the public schools to have nicer kids in general). Even the Christmas productions had songs from different religions (Christianity, Judaism, etc)

____________________

Now, what is public or private better? Better yet, can the Open-to-Life-from-God parents of 8 children afford Catholic education for 8 kids - grade school and high school? NO. It is way to expensive. Only the cafateria Catholic families of Closed-Life-to-God with 2 kids can afford Catholic education and generally both parents need jobs.

Basically, the families that really try to live out the Catholic lifestyle CANNOT afford Catholic education and the families with the controlled two kids CAN. This is a problem and provides great ammo for people who want to say the Catholic Church only caters to the rich.

I know some families cannot have as many kids as they are open too and I know some families like this...so I am not picking on them by any means...I was just generalizing for brevity.

If Catholic education had any pluses in the past......their gone now. The state of Catholic education, especially religious education on Catholicism has lost its wings and is beginning to call MAYDAY! :rip:

The reality is kids get confirmed, get out...and you never see them at mass again. Why?

When I was enrolled in the 6th grade at my parish grade school, there were waiting lists for every grade. Now, there is one grade with one class and pretty much all the rest have room.

I see two big problems...

The Catholic faith is not being taught effectively AND parents are not helping their kids learn the faith and instead rely exclusively on the schools to teach the faith.

After 7 years of Catholic education, I could not defend any of my beliefs and had pretty much forgotten everything. 95% of what I know about my faith is due to my own initiative.

Don't get me wrong, my parents are true Catholics and they do promote Catholicism in the family (weekly mass, family rosary, active participation in religious holidays), so I had discipline for the faith so after I was confirmed, I began to seriously look at my faith. Isn't that backwards? You become confirmed and then you look at your faith closer? Anyway, I was a disciplined acting Catholic but I lacked depth.

There was a Protestant guy who was in my :french: class in high school and during the summer of junior year, we debated a few time. I lost pretty badly :spanking: . Why? I had 6 years of Catholic education. Difference? He knew his faith. I didn't :bash: What wasn't I taught? Rather, what was being taught to me?

Kids grow up. Get confirmed, meet Protestant, Protestant rattles of 2-3 verses, Catholic kids goes "ahhhhhhhhhhh....Bible....what's that :surrender: :bigshock: ? and then go to non-denominational church for cookies and chips after the service. :drpepper:


Sorry but I have a cousin who started to go to another church (non-denominational) and the big raving part of it was the chips and cookies after the service. I have seen the Catholic faith deteriorate ridiculously on both sides of my family. :sadwalk: Why? Cuz no one knows why they are Catholic. :unsure:


The only reason the Catholic number in the U.S. are not seriously declining are because of Hispanic immigrants.

The Hispanics are coming in Catholic and the white people are losing big-time and falling to "convenient" churches. Churches where it pretty much all goes as long as everyone is smiling and singing by the :camp:

I think kids need to learn the Catechism and there needs to be greater emphasis on basic Apologetics. :shield: :sword:

The Catholic Church is not losing on theological grounds...it's losing horribly on lack of BASIC Catholic Apologetics and lack of Catechism knowledge.

I am probably preaching to the choir on this though. :yawn:

If this post sounded like a person severely frustrated with his family's Catholic Education Experience :getaclue: ...you read well.

I am sorry to say this...but public education has been better than private education for my family. That is a fact. If Catholic education wants to continue and survive...something must be done.

You may be out of :popcorn: so I will stop here. I think I may have rambled just a bit. It is time I :shutup:

Posted

[quote name='Pontifex' post='1666119' date='Sep 28 2008, 11:28 PM']I am completely for Catholic Education. Regardless of any need for strengthening of the Religious cirriculum, the fact remains that at a Catholic school you can pray, talk about your faith, and go to mass during the week. At a public school the government has complete control and with the way things are looking that is a very scary reality. We need to support our Catholic schools because they are a better alternative to public, secularized, godless institutions that poison our youth with relativism.

Having said that, I understand the need for reform in Catholic education but we shouldn't turn our back on it. I'm dealing with that right now. In my observance, people simply don't want to make the sacrifices necesarry to keep Catholic schools open, but they are indeed worth it. Even the watered down version of Catholic education is worth saving.

Proud Pastor of struggling school,

Fr. Burns[/quote]

indeed Father, we should support them, but then i'm seeing a trend where the strongest families are turning to home schooling. honestly if i were to raise i family, i'd home school them as well, as i'd just be too terrified to send them anywhere around here..

we pray for our Catholic schools, especially your struggling school. on the bright side i guess if you weren't struggling, you wouldn't be as close to Christ!

eagle_eye222001
Posted

[quote name='MandyKhatoon' post='1666120' date='Sep 29 2008, 01:43 AM']I think this is why we should pray for more vocations within the Church, especially to the Dominican Communities or to any community that teaches. That way we'll have great Catholic schools being taught by awesome women in habit :)[/quote]

A very possible solution and like-able solution. I like this idea as you get actual Catholics in the classroom (yes, I had non-Catholics at my grade school-granted the religion teacher was Catholic but still) and it helps with the finances of the school.

My Mom has mentioned to me she hopes to see this happen...and I agree. This is a definitive partial solution to the Catholic school crises. Along with more emphasis on Catechism and Apologetics.......come on just basic stuff so a Protestant can't just walk all over us. It's amazing the number of arguments against the Church that hang on verse and is refuted by like 20.

Posted

[quote name='johnnydigit' post='1666132' date='Sep 29 2008, 03:28 AM']indeed Father, we should support them, but then i'm seeing a trend where the strongest families are turning to home schooling. honestly if i were to raise i family, i'd home school them as well, as i'd just be too terrified to send them anywhere around here..[/quote]
That's what I was going to say. I've been home-schooled all my life, and now that I take my faith seriously, I'm ever thankful to my parents for making that decision. I can honestly say I have no desire to go to a public, private, or Catholic school.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...