Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Heresy...at Church?!


Recommended Posts

Posted

As an outsider looking in I don't know all the details, but I do think a lot of the problems could be solved by returning the Catholic schools to a system where they are taught by religious sisters and priests.

Posted

[quote name='MissyP89' post='1665739' date='Sep 28 2008, 01:37 PM']I'm in the Diocese of Camden, so I know what you're going through, though I'm not sure it's that bad down here. CCD is terrible...all I learned in eight years was that Jesus loves me, parables, sexual sins are wrong, and prayers I can parrot at you in my sleep. :( And they wonder why every single person, self included, fell away after Confirmation? It should have never happened.

Pray for the Church in Jersey. Heck, pray for it everywhere--it scares me that I'm often the only one under 30 at the Saturday night Mass...[/quote]


I agree full heartidly. If only during high school at least they would teach some theology and explain the teachings (reasoning behind the teachings, not jsut the teachings themselves) - young adults would graduate from highschool with such firmer and stronger faith.

Posted

[quote name='Domine ut Videam' post='1666091' date='Sep 28 2008, 10:18 PM']While, I wouldn't go so far as to call this heresy, if it truly bothers you then I would bring it up with the Archbishop. As philothea said, you got our bishop (meyers) and he is solid. I'm pretty sure he won't allow any funny business to go on in his Diocese(s). Your parish will be in my prayers.[/quote]
+J.M.J.+
agreed. if you are upset, HisChild, go to your priest, and then your bishop, then your archbishop, and on up the line.

Don John of Austria
Posted

[quote name='HisChildForever' post='1665740' date='Sep 28 2008, 02:37 PM']No, she was actually saying that if the younger generation doesn't get educated in the Catholic school system, Catholicism will be wiped out.

Our parish wouldn't suffer if they closed the school. There's rarely any young people at Mass anyway, it's adults who make up our parish pews.[/quote]


Well the Catholic School system in the Untied States was founded to prevent exactly that. I would say it depends what you mean by wiped out. Christ promised that the gates of Hell would not prevail, but not that they wouldn't beat the tarnation out of her. Would you say 50 people hiding in a cave when Christ comes agian would be a Church that was wiped out. I probably would, going from a 1,000,000,000 to 50, but Christ promise would have still been kept.


I looked at this expecting to see something really scary, I mean I have heard Panthiesm and Monism preached from the pulpit, this is mearly a biit over the top.

I think your principal had a poor choice of words, but was largly right. Priest should get up from the pulpit and tell their parish members that they are OBLIGED to send there children to Catholic school. I would prefer that they do what they used to and delare it a mortal sin not to, but I know that that is unlikely.


Unfortuantly as a Catholic school teacher I had to make a choice, teach at one or send my children to one, so I went over to the dark side and am now in a Public school.

I would sooner die than send my children to the Moral hellhole that the public schools are. Make no mistake the Public School system is here to make you good obediant citizens, it is opposed to Catholicism just as the Liberal Democratic system it supports is .

Don John of Austria
Posted

[quote name='goldenchild17' post='1666247' date='Sep 29 2008, 11:37 AM']As an outsider looking in I don't know all the details, but I do think a lot of the problems could be solved by returning the Catholic schools to a system where they are taught by religious sisters and priests.[/quote]


Well we would need a lot more sisters and priest.


And the most liberal theology i was ever taught was by nuns.

Don John of Austria
Posted

[quote name='Didacus' post='1666255' date='Sep 29 2008, 12:01 PM']I agree full heartidly. If only during high school at least they would teach some theology and explain the teachings (reasoning behind the teachings, not jsut the teachings themselves) - young adults would graduate from highschool with such firmer and stronger faith.[/quote]


Wow, this is so weird to me, even what I concidered very very sad Catholic high schools, taught such things in high school. I spent years fighting the "religion class is the only reason for our existance" fight. But even in the schools that I concidered very soft on religion students came out knowing quite a bit of theology. The good ones, well I used to know as choold that the 6th graders new the Old Testement ( which was 6th grade religion) better than most priest. Of course you could fail religion there too, it was not a fluff course.

Don John of Austria
Posted

[quote name='Mari Therese' post='1665820' date='Sep 28 2008, 04:10 PM']My catholic high school was terrible. I lost my Faith there...I should of stayed in public school. Archbishop Fulton Sheen was right, "If you want [your children] to lose their faith, send them to Catholic school."[/quote]


Did you go in Canada? The schools are quite differant there do to the Government funded school system.

Don John of Austria
Posted

[quote name='Pontifex' post='1666119' date='Sep 29 2008, 01:28 AM']I am completely for Catholic Education. Regardless of any need for strengthening of the Religious cirriculum, the fact remains that at a Catholic school you can pray, talk about your faith, and go to mass during the week. At a public school the government has complete control and with the way things are looking that is a very scary reality. We need to support our Catholic schools because they are a better alternative to public, secularized, godless institutions that poison our youth with relativism.

Having said that, I understand the need for reform in Catholic education but we shouldn't turn our back on it. I'm dealing with that right now. In my observance, people simply don't want to make the sacrifices necesarry to keep Catholic schools open, but they are indeed worth it. Even the watered down version of Catholic education is worth saving.

Proud Pastor of struggling school,

Fr. Burns[/quote]



Bless you father, I have seen few Pastors who wupported there schools, most don't want to be trouble with them.
I agree with you about people not wanting to make sacrifices.

I was really disgusted to hear people tell me that they couldn't afford to send there child to Catholic school, and then see them in there 40,000 dollar SUV.

Posted

[quote name='Don John of Austria' post='1666402' date='Sep 29 2008, 03:44 PM']I was really disgusted to hear people tell me that they couldn't afford to send there child to Catholic school, and then see them in there 40,000 dollar SUV.[/quote]
+J.M.J.+
exactly! or people who complain they don't have the money who have cable and internet and cell phones (and of course, every child has one too, donchaknow?), expensive cars, name brand clothing, name brand food (versus store brand), etc. etc. people simply do not know how to make sacrifices, especially when it counts (like their children's education!). i fully expect to give up a lot of things so that my children can have a good Catholic education - which in my city is a lot better (not great though) than the horror stories told here.

Posted

[quote name='Pontifex' post='1666119' date='Sep 29 2008, 01:28 AM']I am completely for Catholic Education. Regardless of any need for strengthening of the Religious cirriculum, the fact remains that at a Catholic school you can pray, talk about your faith, and go to mass during the week. At a public school the government has complete control and with the way things are looking that is a very scary reality. We need to support our Catholic schools because they are a better alternative to public, secularized, godless institutions that poison our youth with relativism.[/quote]
Father, while this may be the case in parts of the country, it has not been in my experience. At my school there are several Christian organizations and multiple events (FCA, See You At The Pole both come to mind) in which one is free to pray and to talk about his faith. As a matter of fact, where I come from, we seem to have a problem with teachers erring on the side of being so-called "Bible thumpers" than we do being secular and liberal.

Don John of Austria
Posted

[quote name='Lil Red' post='1666410' date='Sep 29 2008, 05:54 PM']+J.M.J.+
exactly! or people who complain they don't have the money who have cable and internet and cell phones (and of course, every child has one too, donchaknow?), expensive cars, name brand clothing, name brand food (versus store brand), etc. etc. people simply do not know how to make sacrifices, especially when it counts (like their children's education!). i fully expect to give up a lot of things so that my children can have a good Catholic education - which in my city is a lot better (not great though) than the horror stories told here.[/quote]


My mother paid my CS tuition every month, because of that it took 2 years to afford the plumbing work to fix the Hot water heater. My mother heated water on the stove and carried it into the bathroom for every persons bath for 2 years, but my sister and I went to Catholic school.
it cost about 2 1/2 months of our tuition, she could have had it fixed whenever but she saved and scrimped and did not sacrifce our Catholic Education. I get really annoyed with people who tell me that they just can't do it.

Posted

[quote name='Don John of Austria' post='1666421' date='Sep 29 2008, 04:04 PM']My mother paid my CS tuition every month, because of that it took 2 years to afford the plumbing work to fix the Hot water heater. My mother heated water on the stove and carried it into the bathroom for every persons bath for 2 years, but my sister and I went to Catholic school.
it cost about 2 1/2 months of our tuition, she could have had it fixed whenever but she saved and scrimped and did not sacrifce our Catholic Education. I get really annoyed with people who tell me that they just can't do it.[/quote]
+J.M.J.+
totally understand. my parents paid for all 9 of their children to receive some or all of Catholic schooling. first year's tuition was a measly $400 or something like that. (back in 1961 or so!) :lol: they never had cable, they have internet now (but it's dial up), they drove old, used cars. special occasions like birthdays or Christmas were always a home affair (no eating out). for a time, they went on food stamps. they put themselves through college, too, at the same time (in the 80s and 90s).

the problem is that people just don't want to sacrifice.

Posted

[quote name='Don John of Austria' post='1666393' date='Sep 29 2008, 04:33 PM']Well we would need a lot more sisters and priest.


And the most liberal theology i was ever taught was by nuns.[/quote]

oh yeah, definitely. You definitely don't have to tell me about the related problems :), just throwing out an opinion.

Posted

Well, then all the really catholic homeschoolers, the fanatical ones, get together and start this super creepy Catholic school.

I don't know which one is worse. I've seen them all over, especally in New England.

And its just CREEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEPY. Its not going back to the 1950's its just really fanatical "the devil wears red pj's and pokemon will steal your soul" kinda wierd.

Posted

i've got to really agree with Eagle Eye to an extent. Here's our local Catholic school: Have you been kicked out of public school? Are your parents willing to throw three grand a semester so you can be valedictorian? Then come on in!

Seriously, a friend wanted to be Valedictorian at our public school, but didn't have the grades. Her parents sent her to Catholic school so that she could be the valedictorian because it was less rigorous and more full of people who didn't care about their academics. She became valedictorian easily because she no longer felt academically challenged, and the majority of those there were the cast offs from the public school system. They got our refuse so badly that my school, which is the county equivalent of an inner city school, had less drugs seized when they brought the drug dogs through than the Catholic school does.

I'm told in the old days when the Sisters still taught there, it was far different. Rigorous coursework, religious instruction, etc. From what I hear everyone in the church hierarchy in the state is trying to clean it up from the way it is now, but with limited funding and limited people willing to teach it isn't easy.

Posted (edited)

[quote name='Don John of Austria' post='1666398' date='Sep 29 2008, 04:40 PM']Did you go in Canada? The schools are quite differant there do to the Government funded school system.[/quote]
Yes, I went to Catholic school in Canada. The schools here are equally funded by the government. The only difference between public and catholic school is that you need 4 religion/sociology credits, and you go to Mass once in awhile. I had a non catholic gym teacher for religion class. 70% of the teachers had a problem with the authority of the Church, and the teachings of the Faith. I recently talked to the chaplain who is very excited that they have 5 teachers who know the Faith for this years religion classes. Sorry if I sound a little jaded folks :rolleyes:

I am thankful though, that school is free for anyone who wishes to send there kid to the Catholic school system. All large Catholic families are welcome! My highschool was very socially aware, the students were always very active in fundraising and volunteering their time for good causes.

Edited by Mari Therese
Posted (edited)

nm

Edited by goldenchild17
Posted

Wow, the relative quality of Catholic schools really seems to vary by area.

Last I knew, in Chicago everyone who could possibly afford it went to Catholic school, whatever their religion, because the public schools are so bad.

Domine ut Videam
Posted

How disheartening reading this is. :sadder:

I've only ever attended Catholic schools and have had nothing but positive, faith-enriching experiences. Going to a Catholic High School certainly didn't cause me to lose my faith, but quite the opposite. All of these other schools will be in my prayers. I'm sorry that so many of you have had negative encounters with the Catholic School system. Please be assured that not all Catholic Schools are like that.

Posted

[quote name='Domine ut Videam' post='1666526' date='Sep 29 2008, 05:25 PM']How disheartening reading this is. :sadder:

I've only ever attended Catholic schools and have had nothing but positive, faith-enriching experiences. Going to a Catholic High School certainly didn't cause me to lose my faith, but quite the opposite. All of these other schools will be in my prayers. I'm sorry that so many of you have had negative encounters with the Catholic School system. Please be assured that not all Catholic Schools are like that.[/quote]

"i went to Catholic high school. i didn't even know what the Blessed Sacrament was until after i got into the faith." -friend of mine.

around here, the teachers certifying the future Catholic teachers are teaching them heresy. only maybe 1 or 2 out of 50 say anything. who knows how many of them even know the difference.

around here, the ones who teach the truth are asked to leave or else are fired because parents don't like the truth taught to their children. (granted maybe they could have worded what they said differently).

if you graduated from a solidly orthodox Catholic university (current rankings), it's a red flag you may be trouble. if you want to follow our Holy Father or what is taught from Rome, you may be trouble. if you have a child-like faith in God, you may be trouble.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...