Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Heresy...at Church?!


Recommended Posts

Posted

its not just the dressing in long skirts, its the fact they call it a sin to dress in anything but a long skirt...and girls aren't allowed to swim in anything thats much more revealing than a wetsuit with a skirt. That the MUST wear it. If a women wants to do it, so be it, but forcing a girl to wear skirts in the heat of the summer, and stinging cold of winter when they have no say is wrong. Pants are not evil. And there not going to be lesbians if they wear them. Believe me, they are taught as such.

Its the protesting with infants or small children when its snowing outside. I don't find anythin wrong with an adult peaceful protest, but I think that under no circumstances should a child, (espcally one under the age of reason) be encouraged or permitted to protest.

And like I said in my first post its the "pokemon/pogs/disney...insert whatever is poplular...is the work of the devil" mindset. The complete isolation from reality. I'm not saying they should go out and read cozmo but being able to know something occuring in the world outside would be nice.

Posted

When I was in catholic school, our basketball team played a team from a evangelical christian school. Their girls wore long culottes instead of shorts (this was back when basketball uniforms had short shorts). They looked pretty silly, but played really tough. I've never had that many people dare throw an elbow at me. Granted they only did it once, but I had to admire their willingness to elbow an enforcer. It was like they were trying to prove something because they felt so silly.

Posted

[quote name='Autumn Dusk' post='1667174' date='Sep 30 2008, 05:01 PM']its not just the dressing in long skirts, its the fact they call it a sin to dress in anything but a long skirt...and girls aren't allowed to swim in anything thats much more revealing than a wetsuit with a skirt. That the MUST wear it. If a women wants to do it, so be it, but forcing a girl to wear skirts in the heat of the summer, and stinging cold of winter when they have no say is wrong. Pants are not evil. And there not going to be lesbians if they wear them. Believe me, they are taught as such.

Its the protesting with infants or small children when its snowing outside. I don't find anythin wrong with an adult peaceful protest, but I think that under no circumstances should a child, (espcally one under the age of reason) be encouraged or permitted to protest.

And like I said in my first post its the "pokemon/pogs/disney...insert whatever is poplular...is the work of the devil" mindset. The complete isolation from reality. I'm not saying they should go out and read cozmo but being able to know something occuring in the world outside would be nice.[/quote]

heresay, generalization, and exaggeration. i used to think the same as you, then i realized what the real reality was. you don't have to know a thing about the evils of the world if you want to live a holy life. it's evil, and there will always be evil. nothing new there. knowledge of what is "popular" is completely unnecessary. if a family chooses to raise their kids to a higher moral standard which you can't relate to or understand, leave it at that. to criticize so negatively is just uncharitable.

anywho, off topic. everyone is at a different point in their spiritual journey and in a different state of life. some desire to take their spirituality to another level, some choose to remain where they are in certain things. all i know is, God says to continually grow in holiness and convert. the moment you are comfortable, you are already dead.

HisChildForever
Posted

[quote name='Don John of Austria' post='1667124' date='Sep 30 2008, 05:27 PM']Simply put, because I am suspicious of all Catholic school abuse stories. I have heard some really impressive stories about classrooms, THAT I WAS SITTING IN AT THE TIME IT "HAPPENED".[/quote]

Okay. Let me run and go tell my parents that. I'm sure they've lied to me.

Posted

[quote name='HisChildForever' post='1667319' date='Oct 1 2008, 12:00 AM']Okay. Let me run and go tell my parents that. I'm sure they've lied to me.[/quote]

:mellow: yeah, somehow the entire board has been deceived by trusted authority figures in their lives. Dad's best friend obviously self inflicted his childhood Catholic school wounds. :rolleyes:

Posted (edited)

I think the public vs catholic school debate varies from place to place, since the catholic school in one place may be the better option, or vice versa

The next person irl who insults homeschoolers is going to get a right hook to his jaw :)

Edited by notardillacid
princessgianna
Posted

[quote name='Don John of Austria' post='1666392' date='Sep 29 2008, 04:32 PM']Priest should get up from the pulpit and tell their parish members that they are OBLIGED to send there children to Catholic school. I would prefer that they do what they used to and delare it a mortal sin not to,[/quote]
but it ISN"T a mortal sin! and that would be great! Catholic school is so expansive only the rich can afford it !! What is a mortal sin is to afford Catholic Education is go on the Pill and not be open to life! My Catholic School experience-bad! The children made fun of my family because my parents have more than 2 kids! The Public School experience-my mom got a card from the school congratulating her on her newborn baby! The Catholic school -"you had another one?!?!?!?" with no support! My sister was not accepted at the Catholic school-because she had leaning disability the public school-they accepted her and out of "hey lets see what we can do " and they were so sweet to talk and was so nice to my sister and they wanted to help her learn! My Public school experience-awesome! we did not always agree but we accepted each other regardless of religious beliefs!

The public school was WAY more Christ like than the Catholic school ever hopes to be!

I would like to see reform! very much so! but Catholic schools aren't what they used to be!

princessgianna
Posted (edited)

[quote name='Excelsior1027' post='1666238' date='Sep 29 2008, 10:21 AM']That's what I was going to say. I've been home-schooled all my life, and now that I take my faith seriously, I'm ever thankful to my parents for making that decision. I can honestly say I have no desire to go to a public, private, or Catholic school.[/quote]
i went to Public then when the Catholic school had room i changed schools! i so regretted it! :sadder:
now i am being homeschooled and loving every minute of it! :love:
though if i had to choose for some random reason and the Catholic Schools around me stayed the same-i would pick Public! sad i agree but true!

Edited by princessgianna
Posted

+J.M.J.+
i think what it comes down to is personal experience. some peeps have a great experience with their CS - others don't. to discount one or the other as wrong, it's just silly. :hippie:

princessgianna
Posted

[quote name='Lil Red' post='1667376' date='Sep 30 2008, 10:43 PM']+J.M.J.+
i think what it comes down to is personal experience. some peeps have a great experience with their CS - others don't. to discount one or the other as wrong, it's just silly. :hippie:[/quote]
thanks for pointing that out! I am sorry if what i said seemed to harsh! it has been my personal experience. I honestly would love to see the Catholic school reform and with the help of that one order JPll started i see hope! Pax- :))

Posted

[quote name='Lil Red' post='1667376' date='Oct 1 2008, 12:43 AM']+J.M.J.+
i think what it comes down to is personal experience. some peeps have a great experience with their CS - others don't. to discount one or the other as wrong, it's just silly. :hippie:[/quote]

iawtc and the hippie mod smilie.

Don John of Austria
Posted

[quote name='HisChildForever' post='1667319' date='Sep 30 2008, 11:00 PM']Okay. Let me run and go tell my parents that. I'm sure they've lied to me.[/quote]


okay, you do that, then maybe they can read the rest of the post and if they want to talk to me about it I will happly do so.

Don John of Austria
Posted

[quote name='princessgianna' post='1667359' date='Sep 30 2008, 11:29 PM']but it ISN"T a mortal sin! and that would be great! Catholic school is so expansive only the rich can afford it !! What is a mortal sin is to afford Catholic Education is go on the Pill and not be open to life! My Catholic School experience-bad! The children made fun of my family because my parents have more than 2 kids! The Public School experience-my mom got a card from the school congratulating her on her newborn baby! The Catholic school -"you had another one?!?!?!?" with no support! My sister was not accepted at the Catholic school-because she had leaning disability the public school-they accepted her and out of "hey lets see what we can do " and they were so sweet to talk and was so nice to my sister and they wanted to help her learn! My Public school experience-awesome! we did not always agree but we accepted each other regardless of religious beliefs!

The public school was WAY more Christ like than the Catholic school ever hopes to be!

I would like to see reform! very much so! but Catholic schools aren't what they used to be![/quote]

I assure you my family was not rich please see above post. I am not rich, I drive a 1977 dodge pickup with holes in the floor board, when my children ride with me I have to make sure that nothing they are not holding anything they really care about, it has to be in a bag or something because if they drop it it could literally fall out of the bottom of my truck and be gone forever. I fix my own cars I roofed my own house, I wear old cloths, I live in a small house "on the edge of the hood", my son goes to Catholic school, no financial aid, you don't have to be rich, you just have to have priorities.

AS for the flaws of your Catholic School, well make no mistake, I think that the Priest should be cleaning house there as well.

Don John of Austria
Posted (edited)

[quote name='BG45' post='1667340' date='Sep 30 2008, 11:14 PM']:mellow: yeah, somehow the entire board has been deceived by trusted authority figures in their lives. Dad's best friend obviously self inflicted his childhood Catholic school wounds. :rolleyes:[/quote]


Not what I said. Please go read the entire post.



That said, yeah I have known a tremendous number of people who lied to their children about all kinds of things.

Did I ever tell you about the time one of my students found out she was adopted while we were studying genetics? 14 years of being lied to.

Edited by Don John of Austria
Don John of Austria
Posted

I have noticed a disturbing trend on these boards... people ask for evidence, recieve evidence and then pretend that such evidence was not presented. They then move on to something to nit-pick at and attack rather than respond to the evidence.

Interesting.

Posted (edited)

Ah but I did read the entire post Don John and interpreted it in a certain way that most of the thread seems to have based on the wording.

Not to be condescending in the least...I want to give you, and everyone else a piece of advice I was given. Don't get upset, it's the internet. There are far more pressing things in real life than proving others wrong online. It's a piece of advice I try to follow because it keeps my blood pressure down. I just stink at it a lot of times.

Edited by BG45
Posted

[quote name='notardillacid' post='1667351' date='Oct 1 2008, 05:22 PM']I think the public vs catholic school debate varies from place to place, since the catholic school in one place may be the better option, or vice versa

The next person irl who insults homeschoolers is going to get a right hook to his jaw :)[/quote]

I will help you!!1!

Posted

[quote name='johnnydigit' post='1667317' date='Sep 30 2008, 11:59 PM']heresay, generalization, and exaggeration. i used to think the same as you, then i realized what the real reality was. you don't have to know a thing about the evils of the world if you want to live a holy life. it's evil, and there will always be evil. nothing new there. knowledge of what is "popular" is completely unnecessary. if a family chooses to raise their kids to a higher moral standard which you can't relate to or understand, leave it at that. to criticize so negatively is just uncharitable.

anywho, off topic. everyone is at a different point in their spiritual journey and in a different state of life. some desire to take their spirituality to another level, some choose to remain where they are in certain things. all i know is, God says to continually grow in holiness and convert. the moment you are comfortable, you are already dead.[/quote]

[b]
[color="#FF0000"][size=4]Don't you dare[/size][/color][/b] tell me this is "heresay, generalization, and exaggeration" I don't know what goes on in California but this happens and is happening JUST AS I SAY IT in New England, especally the parts that are still rural.

Catholics are bad, the protestant bands are even worse.

Its not no knowlege of what's popular its no knowlege of what's going on, period. Who's canadates for presidency, etc. Its not just not knowing about Brittany Spears, its not knowing anything thats going on. By one's own free choice (not locked in a compound) the only news you get is through leaders. Forget science, math and technology, home making is the way to go. Forget higher education, the only valuable work is work that actually gets your hands dirty.

I DO know, I DID see and I was a part of that world in a way in north new england. And the group that I was in was not the only one, b/c through the internet (that was restricted to leaders) found others. Its a humiliating, horrible and by having poor catholic schools these groups are growing by disturbing numbers.

There needs despriatly to be a happy medium.

It dosn't make me uncomfortable it makes me queezy! Its a horrid way to live. We can grow in holiness without manufacturing fanatics.

goldenchild17
Posted

[quote name='Autumn Dusk' post='1667121' date='Sep 30 2008, 04:26 PM']There's definatly some extremism going on becuase ordinary catholic schools are not meeting parents desire's and they develop more drasic ideas. parents who want to get their children away from the loose morals in public school and the lack of quality education in private schools will homeschool. Not everyone can homeschool, so splinter groups develop. Thises splinter groups attract weak parents who don't know much about the faith into a kind of wierd catholic extremism that is just creepy. I've seen it happen many times and its sad. Only when catholics go extreme they dress in long skirts, protest at abortion clinics and refuse to participate in current american ways of life. ITs like those mormans in texas but without the forced icolation.[/quote]

:rolleyes:

goldenchild17
Posted

[quote name='Autumn Dusk' post='1667174' date='Sep 30 2008, 06:01 PM']its not just the dressing in long skirts, its the fact they call it a sin to dress in anything but a long skirt...and girls aren't allowed to swim in anything thats much more revealing than a wetsuit with a skirt. That the MUST wear it. If a women wants to do it, so be it, but forcing a girl to wear skirts in the heat of the summer, and stinging cold of winter when they have no say is wrong. Pants are not evil. And there not going to be lesbians if they wear them. Believe me, they are taught as such.

Its the protesting with infants or small children when its snowing outside. I don't find anythin wrong with an adult peaceful protest, but I think that under no circumstances should a child, (espcally one under the age of reason) be encouraged or permitted to protest.

And like I said in my first post its the "pokemon/pogs/disney...insert whatever is poplular...is the work of the devil" mindset. The complete isolation from reality. I'm not saying they should go out and read cozmo but being able to know something occuring in the world outside would be nice.[/quote]

:rolleyes:

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...