Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Posted

Alright so I got back from my brothers new church. I can see how he likes it its very vibrant with music and the pastor is lively. I think it is really good for him, but personally after going I just couldn't stop thinking how blessed I am to be Catholic. I have no doubt they have faith but its very unorganized and I'm not sure on the educational background of the pastor (how he translates). It was my first Protestant experience I felt a bit uncomfortable (I got looks after I made the sign of the cross after opening prayer). Oh well hopefully after he fully cleans up his life he will eventually come back to the Catholic Church. God willing

Posted

i had some of the same sort of experience. when i was staying with a host family in guatemala, i accompanied them to church twice. i am not sure what type of church it was, but their was loud bouncy music, all in spanish and it had people collapsing and speaking in tongues every few minutes during the dancing and stuff. and lots of tearful speeches by many of the members.

i didn't understand a thing, and it was 4 hours long. i pretty much fixated on a guitar leaning against one of the walls and just imagined myself playing solos over all the music.
most awkward and boring time of my life.

Posted (edited)

[quote name='Sacred Music Man' post='1754149' date='Jan 17 2009, 11:54 PM']...i pretty much fixated on a guitar leaning against one of the walls and just imagined myself playing solos over all the music.[/quote]
I do that too.

Edited by Sacred Music Man
Posted

I know what you mean - I've had similar reactions in Protestant churches. I think the key is what you say yourself - "I'm sure they have faith" - think of it that way. We Catholics can't share eucharist with other Christians, but we can share prayer - and I guess we ought to share as much as we can of what we can.

Good job in supporting your brother.

Posted

[quote name='Jesus_lol' post='1754100' date='Jan 17 2009, 10:53 PM']i had some of the same sort of experience. when i was staying with a host family in guatemala, i accompanied them to church twice. i am not sure what type of church it was, but their was loud bouncy music, all in spanish and it had people collapsing and speaking in tongues every few minutes during the dancing and stuff. and lots of tearful speeches by many of the members.

i didn't understand a thing, and it was 4 hours long. i pretty much fixated on a guitar leaning against one of the walls and just imagined myself playing solos over all the music.
most awkward and boring time of my life.[/quote]

Sounds like the folks that we refer to as "Los Aleluyas" in Puerto Rico, which I think are Pentecostals.

Posted

[quote name='Giolla' post='1754088' date='Jan 17 2009, 11:31 PM']Alright so I got back from my brothers new church. I can see how he likes it its very vibrant with music and the pastor is lively. I think it is really good for him, but personally after going I just couldn't stop thinking how blessed I am to be Catholic. I have no doubt they have faith but its very unorganized and I'm not sure on the educational background of the pastor (how he translates). It was my first Protestant experience I felt a bit uncomfortable (I got looks after I made the sign of the cross after opening prayer). Oh well hopefully after he fully cleans up his life he will eventually come back to the Catholic Church. God willing[/quote]

I used to go to Catholic mass on a saturday night. About 90% of the congregation were 60 or over. There was one other young girl there, quite pretty, but she only rocked up occassionally. That was it. I never felt comfortable, I always felt alone. There was no sense of community, it was a formality for most people. I enjoyed going to christian churches because the sermons were interesting, the singing was great and there was a real spirit and zest for the lord. Mass was so repetitive and dull, same thing every week.

Posted

I know you are trying to make a point by playing the "opposite" game, but it really isn't working.

Posted

[quote]Mass was so repetitive and dull, same thing every week.[/quote]

Ah. So you went to Church because you [i]wanted something out of it[/i]?

Posted

[quote name='Brother Adam' post='1754233' date='Jan 18 2009, 06:05 AM']I know you are trying to make a point by playing the "opposite" game, but it really isn't working.[/quote]

I'm not playing "opposites", I was pointing out how it's shortcomings. If a protestant attended a Catholic mass first thing he'd probably do is go and report to his friends "reminds me how fortunate I am to be a christian".

Posted (edited)

[quote name='Selah' post='1754245' date='Jan 18 2009, 07:43 AM']Ah. So you went to Church because you [i]wanted something out of it[/i]?[/quote]

Doh! I beg thee to forgive me for thy selfishness! I was pointing out how mass fails to engage young people, or rather, how protestant church provides a better outlet for young people to celebrate god and grow in their faith.

Edited by bonkers
Posted

I appreciate your point, [b]bonkers[/b], but [b]Giolla[/b] was just sharing his own experience. It's always awkward to attend church if you don't have much connection to the people or worship style. Over time, you can get accostomed to it, and feel more comfortable.

We can either point out what we think is negative about each, or we can look for what is worthwhile and valuable about each.

I always think it is funny when people comment on the musical style, because obviously that completely varies from church to church, and for Catholic churches, from mass to mass! My recommendation is to find one you can put up with rather that attend church where all you are going to do is hate the music the whole time. Not that it has to be perfect - I think CS Lewis was of the opinion that all church music was bad - but it should be tolerable, at least.

But maybe I'm biased, because I'm comfortable with traditional hymns with full organ, a cappella Latin chant, or modern praise and worship music - I just love praising God with song :)).

Posted

[quote name='bonkers' post='1754248' date='Jan 18 2009, 09:23 AM']Doh! I beg thee to forgive me for thy selfishness! I was pointing out how mass fails to engage young people, or rather, how protestant church provides a better outlet for young people to celebrate god and grow in their faith.[/quote]
if you want entertainment, go see a movie. if you want to understand what a catholic mass is all about close your mouth and open your heart.
it's a worship service.

Posted

Protestant services seem empty and self-serving to me, now. However, this is only because the service is treated as "proper" Sunday worship - the "high point", so to speak. Therein lies the negativity for me. If this factor were removed than the services would be treated as nothing more than an inspirational seminar. It is awesome to feel a shared energy and appreciation amongst those with whom we have much in common; especially in the context of a live performance of music and an excellent orator. The tragedy is in mistaking this for true worship, which always and everywhere requires representative sacrifice. Anything less is merely worship in spirit, which of course is a good and laudable thing; yet, isolated from worship in body, there is no representative sacrifice - only the memory of one - and the celebration therefore turns into an occasion of replacement sacrifice. Moreover, the Old Covenant was given worship in both forms. Is New Covenant worship less than, equal to, or great than its predecessor?

Posted

[quote name='bonkers' post='1754222' date='Jan 18 2009, 05:02 AM']I used to go to Catholic mass on a saturday night. About 90% of the congregation were 60 or over. There was one other young girl there, quite pretty, but she only rocked up occassionally. That was it. I never felt comfortable, I always felt alone. There was no sense of community, it was a formality for most people. I enjoyed going to christian churches because the sermons were interesting, the singing was great and there was a real spirit and zest for the lord. Mass was so repetitive and dull, same thing every week.[/quote]

You don't go to church to be entertained you go to learn the word of God and participate in the Mass. For me Mass is entertaining enough without have a rock band playing during the consecration. I feel rock music is a great form of worship but has no room during Mass (personal opinion) I personally like chant or typical hymns.

All I was doing was supporting my brother and I told him I was proud of him for cleaning up his life and going to church. I also told him I would go every once in a while if he needed more support.

Posted

[quote]if you want entertainment, go see a movie. if you want to understand what a catholic mass is all about close your mouth and open your heart.
it's a worship service.[/quote]

^ This

Archaeology cat
Posted

[quote name='Ziggamafu' post='1754256' date='Jan 18 2009, 02:14 PM']Protestant services seem empty and self-serving to me, now. However, this is only because the service is treated as "proper" Sunday worship - the "high point", so to speak. Therein lies the negativity for me. If this factor were removed than the services would be treated as nothing more than an inspirational seminar. It is awesome to feel a shared energy and appreciation amongst those with whom we have much in common; especially in the context of a live performance of music and an excellent orator. The tragedy is in mistaking this for true worship, which always and everywhere requires representative sacrifice. Anything less is merely worship in spirit, which of course is a good and laudable thing; yet, isolated from worship in body, there is no representative sacrifice - only the memory of one - and the celebration therefore turns into an occasion of replacement sacrifice. Moreover, the Old Covenant was given worship in both forms. Is New Covenant worship less than, equal to, or great than its predecessor?[/quote]
You put it very well, I think.

Posted

[quote name='apparently' post='1754255' date='Jan 18 2009, 10:12 AM']if you want entertainment, go see a movie. if you want to understand what a catholic mass is all about close your mouth and open your heart.
it's a worship service.[/quote]

Yes, one which totally fails to engage young people. At least the christian churches are trying to save souls and reach out to the youth. Mass provides little outlet for people to grow in and share their faith with others, it's a practical failure when you consider that the pews are virtually void of young people.

cmotherofpirl
Posted

[quote name='bonkers' post='1754290' date='Jan 18 2009, 10:52 AM']Yes, one which totally fails to engage young people. At least the christian churches are trying to save souls and reach out to the youth. Mass provides little outlet for people to grow in and share their faith with others, it's a practical failure when you consider that the pews are virtually void of young people.[/quote]
Last I check church was supposed to be about worshipping God, not getting entertained. The problem is that we have trained the current generation from diapers on up [ think Sesame Street] to be entertained by something rather than engaged in something, and to think its all about MY feelings. Religion isn't based on feelings. You go to Mass to receive Jesus Christ in the Eucharist, its not a discussion club.
Most of the catholic kids I know stopped going in college, but as they got married and settled down they are all back in the pews. None of the protestant kids however have returned to their churches.

Posted

[quote name='cmotherofpirl' post='1754295' date='Jan 18 2009, 10:00 AM']Last I check church was supposed to be about worshipping God, not getting entertained. The problem is that we have trained the current generation from diapers on up [ think Sesame Street] to be entertained by something rather than engaged in something, and to think its all about MY feelings. Religion isn't based on feelings. You go to Mass to receive Jesus Christ in the Eucharist, its not a discussion club.
Most of the catholic kids I know stopped going in college, but as they got married and settled down they are all back in the pews. None of the protestant kids however have returned to their churches.[/quote]

You keep banging on about "entertainment" like it's the core theme of these services, it's not. The core theme is god, some entertainment is integrated into the service to spiritually energise people and bring them closer to god. I think this 'holier than thou' attitude demeans the evangelistic efforts of christian churches given they are far more successful in bringing people to god than catholics. You can blame the "training" of the current generation all you want, fact is the church hasn't adapted and people are seeking spiritual fulfillment elsewhere.

cmotherofpirl
Posted

[quote name='bonkers' post='1754301' date='Jan 18 2009, 11:22 AM']You keep banging on about "entertainment" like it's the core theme of these services, it's not. The core theme is god, some entertainment is integrated into the service to spiritually energise people and bring them closer to god. I think this 'holier than thou' attitude demeans the evangelistic efforts of christian churches given they are far more successful in bringing people to god than catholics. You can blame the "training" of the current generation all you want, fact is the church hasn't adapted and people are seeking spiritual fulfillment elsewhere.[/quote]
What "God" are they bringing them to?
the party God, the wealth and prosperity God, the Jesus is my best bro God, the Jesus really didn't say that God, the God that agrees with whatever the people want - all the false Gods??

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...