Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

How Feminism Fails Women


Recommended Posts

Posted

[quote name='notardillacid' post='1774490' date='Feb 7 2009, 02:27 AM']Are you sure she was on the ticket with the 'pop star'?[/quote]

hm?

Posted

Very interesting subject.

My girlfriend does not like the prospect of me making all the decisions in our future marriage. If there is one! I don't like that idea either. Yet some Bible fundamentalists claim that a woman's place is to submit. Controversial stuff.

Archaeology cat
Posted

[quote name='Wolf' post='1774555' date='Feb 7 2009, 01:30 PM']Very interesting subject.

My girlfriend does not like the prospect of me making all the decisions in our future marriage. If there is one! I don't like that idea either. Yet some Bible fundamentalists claim that a woman's place is to submit. Controversial stuff.[/quote]
Submitting doesn't mean being mindless & just doing as you are told. And it would be pretty much impossible for you to make [i]all [/i]the decisions. ;)

Posted

[quote name='Archaeology cat' post='1774565' date='Feb 7 2009, 09:02 AM']Submitting doesn't mean being mindless & just doing as you are told. And it would be pretty much impossible for you to make [i]all [/i]the decisions. ;)[/quote]
I quite agree.

I wasn't saying those are my views, but I do know plenty of people who take "submissive" to mean that a woman should be silent. It's very difficult - both myself and my girlfriend struggle with those texts.

Posted (edited)

[quote name='Wolf' post='1774566' date='Feb 7 2009, 10:06 AM']I quite agree.

I wasn't saying those are my views, but I do know plenty of people who take "submissive" to mean that a woman should be silent. It's very difficult - both myself and my girlfriend struggle with those texts.[/quote]

For what its worth - I know not everyone posting to this thread is Roman Catholic - Pope John Paul II (via Christopher West's teaching on JP II's Theology of the Body) says that a wife does not submit to her husband's will but to his love. I think the term (also in the Scripture) wife is extremely significant in that it represents a very particular (for Catholics - sacramental) relationship and therefore it (and the Scripture teaching) does not exist in a vaccuum - remember too, that the Scripture teaching to the wife comes after the Scripture addressed to the husband which says he must love his wife as Christ loves the Church (willing to die for her)...it is this sacrificial love to which the wife submits.

I know fundamentalists who like to "expand" the word wife to woman but that is not the teaching nor the intent of the Scripture.....apart from the oneness of the married relationship (husband and wife are the same body, spiritually/Scripturally speaking) the exhortation to submit does not exist in Scripture. Except of course that we are all called to submit to each other in love.

I think the words wife and woman are worth differentiating. I believe the Scripture being referred to here in at least one post is Paul's letter to the Ephesians Chapter 5 (hmmm or is it 6..I forget) that is certainly my reference point. It speaks only to the married relationship.

Any old woman is not required to submit to any old man.

Whether or not a woman can be both feminine and soft while at the same time strong and independent is another story. Someone posted the question "have you ever tiried it" (i.e. being soft & feminine at the same time as independent and strong) - I guess I have another question by "at the same time" are we meaning to say the same "moment" - like hours, second minutes"? I can see that might be difficult but it's certainly possible for a woman to be both soft and feminine an strong and independent in her personhood.

Just my .02

Pax

*edited for typo

Edited by osapientia
TotusTuusMaria
Posted (edited)

"Let us begin by calmly comparing the actual life of women as it generally is today and with our requirements. Many of the best women are almost overwhelmed by the double burden of family duties and professional life - or often simply of only gainful employment. Always on the go, they are harassed, nervous, and irritable. Where are they to go get the needed inner peace and cheerfulness in order to offer stability, support, and guidance to others? Even when there is mutual love and recognition of achievements, there are small daily frictions between a woman and her husband and children; this results in uneasiness throughout the entire household and a slackening of relationships in the home. Along with this, there are many superficial and unstable women who chase after pleasure to fill their inner void, who marry and are divorced; often the home and children are abandoned either to themselves or to domestics, strangers who are no more conscientious than the mothers themselves. If it is necessary for them to seek gainful employment, they do so only as a means to an end, i.e., to make a living and to grasp life's pleasures to the nth degree; in their case, one can speak neither of profession or of ethos. They are like shifting quicksand. The breakdown of family life and the decline of morals are actually connected with the increase in number of such women and can only be checked by reducing their number; this can be done with the help of a qualified educational system for young girls.[b] Finally, we would consider the group of women, by no means negligible, who choose a profession suitable to their ability and inclination. Among them may be found quite a few who discover, after their initial gratification, that their expectations are unfulfilled and they long to be elsewhere. Frequently, this is due to their having taken pains to fill their post "just like a man." They have neither searched for nor found the ways and means to make their feminine nature fruitful in professional life; and the denied, stifled nature asserts itself. [/b]" - St. Edith Stein.

The women in the article sounds like the kind pointed out by St. Edith lastly. It is very sad.

It is difficult to balance independence, strength, and remain feminine and soft.... it really is. You can't be both at the same time without great grace. When I lead one of the committees I am on I am independent and strong. I am bossy and stern... and it is very difficult to be "in charge" and still remain soft and feminine... it is difficult. You have to be sensitive and aware. You have to be patient and understanding. You have to balance the independent and career nature not trusting anyone and doing everything yourself and then that feminine nature that submits and gives over and trusts.... it is hard and anyone who says it is not just hasn't tasted it yet.

[u]
However, I do think it possible and that is with grace.[/u] You look at St. Catherine of Siena, St. Edith Stein, Bl. Anna Maria Taigi, St. Teresa of Avila, Bl. Mother Teresa, Mother Angelica, and my godmother who was both a nurse and mother that imparted the faith to three children and was ever aware of and accomplished her duties at home... [b]all women who when you think of them balanced careers or powerful stations in the church and yet remained feminine and true to their maternal nature. [u]And I believe this was only accomplished by the power of grace. [/u]
[/b]

"Contrary to this sad image of the average woman, one can still find true heroines in all walks of life. They perform wonders on the job in families, professions, and the seclusion of the cloister. All of us are familiar with them from the church records and also from personal experience. There are the mothers who, radiating all warmth and light in the home, raise as many as nine children and impart to them and to their own children full blessings for their entire lives; and these women are magnanimous as well towards all strangers in need. There are the minor instructors and officials who support an entire fmaily from their salary and look after domestic affairs before and after the professional work; yet, they can also find time and money for different church and charitable functions. There are the nuns who wrestle for endangered souls in nocturnal prayer, assuming voluntary penances for their sins. What is the source of their strength? How explain all their achievements which one might often declare to be impossible by nature? How account for that unruffled peace and cheerfulness even in the keenest nervous and emotional stress? [b]Only by the power of grace can nature be liberated from its dross, restored to its purity, and made free to receive divine life."[/b] - St. Edith Stein

I think the woman in the article was not only done in by the feminist movement which told her she should seek after profession and not give in to maternal inclinations, but also by the world which told her [u][b]she[/b][/u] can do everything, when reality she can't. It is only by grace...

"Teresa can do nothing. Jesus and Teresa can do everything." - St. Teresa of Avila

Edited by TotusTuusMaria
Posted

[quote name='HisChildForever' post='1774389' date='Feb 7 2009, 12:15 AM']Not so sure about this statement because women can be "soft and feminine" [b]and[/b] "independent and strong" at the same time.[/quote]


Well I just read this article and saw the statement you are not sure about...

I have to say I thought the article was a bit "whiny". Seems like the women quoted are a bit on the "blamey" side....it's feminism's fault, it's mom's fault, oh if only I'd had other choices presented to me etc etc. When was there ever a time when women were not becoming wives and having babies...yes, more women during the time this author was growing up were chossing careers rather than marriage but I'm absolutely certain that all around these women were other women having babies and husbands and carrying dough in their hands. I know that because I grew up basically around the same time...I'm a bit older than she but not by that much.

Please don't get me wrong. I think what passes for feminism nowadays is regrettable to say the least. One thing I agree in part with from the article is that the choice to be a wife and mother ought to have parity with the choice for a career. The reason I agree only in part is because I believe the roles of wife and mother are so important I think they are a "higher" choice then career. Gosh I'm so "linear" and I'm not even a guy <wink>...wasn't sure what other word I could use there. They certainly produce far more lasting and globally significant "results".

By the way - not to be "fresh" but IF whiny/blamey = soft/feminine - count me out.

Just another .02

cmotherofpirl
Posted

[quote name='Wolf' post='1774566' date='Feb 7 2009, 10:06 AM']I quite agree.

I wasn't saying those are my views, but I do know plenty of people who take "submissive" to mean that a woman should be silent. It's very difficult - both myself and my girlfriend struggle with those texts.[/quote]
When a man loves his wife as he loves himself, and a woman loves her husband as much as she loves herself there usually not too many problems. :) Nobody expects the guy to make [b]all[/b] the decisions, each of you have your strengths and weaknesses, and it would be silly if you do the finances if she was an economics major. A wife certainly has no call to be silent or make not make her wants, desires, and needs known. Each of you has your set of responsibilities.
Its the husband's job as head of the family [ the responsibility and authority] to make the best decisions for the family as a whole, not just what works for him. If he has to work extra hours etc to support his family that is his responsibility, he has to sacrifice his wants and desires for the sake of the family. So no he can't go to bars or sit glued to the TV when his wife is trying to put the kids to bed because its his job to support his wife. And she can't be out running shopping and hanging with her friends and not taking care of the family either. Each of you has your proper role.
You may call this "stereotypical" but stereotypes are not always a bad thing. Its not that society dumped this roles on us for a whim, its because the roles within the general scheme of things WORK! They are not laid in stone, do not have a strict set of rules, but generally are a way to exist within your natural skills and competencies to make family life work.

Posted

Very wise and thoughtful reply.

I do struggle sometimes with the people in my church who seek to apply those Scriptures in a very oppressive way.

cmotherofpirl
Posted

[quote name='Wolf' post='1774768' date='Feb 7 2009, 01:06 PM']Very wise and thoughtful reply.

I do struggle sometimes with the people in my church who seek to apply those Scriptures in a very oppressive way.[/quote]
Why would your church have different rules, you are listed as Catholic?

Posted

[quote]Why would your church have different rules, you are listed as Catholic?[/quote]

The church itself doesn't have different rules, but some members place a very literal interpretation on the "submission" Scriptures.

HisChildForever
Posted (edited)

[quote]It is difficult to balance independence, strength, and remain feminine and soft.... it really is. You can't be both at the same time without great grace. When I lead one of the committees I am on I am independent and strong. I am bossy and stern... and it is very difficult to be "in charge" and still remain soft and feminine... it is difficult. You have to be sensitive and aware. You have to be patient and understanding. You have to balance the independent and career nature not trusting anyone and doing everything yourself and then that feminine nature that submits and gives over and trusts.... it is hard and anyone who says it is not just hasn't tasted it yet.[/quote]

This...is just ridiculous. And I am really sorry if that is offensive, but my jaw just dropped when I read that.

Should women then avoid leading committees - and, with this mindset - management positions, political positions, law enforcement positions? teaching positions? Should women just stay at home until a suitable husband comes along to ensure their femininity?

As a side note, I find it ironic how anti-feminists see "independence" as weak and feminists see "femininity" as weak. In my opinion, both parties are [b]incredibly[/b] wrong. A woman can be both.

Furthermore, you are doing a lot of stereotyping. First of all no one should be "bossy" - man or woman. That is just plain rudeness. However, what is wrong with a woman being stern? Is a mother not stern with her children while disciplining them? Does stern = masculine? Furthermore, does sensitive = feminine? Should we then tell men to avoid sensitivity since they are acting like women? How absurd.

I would like to hear your opinion on consecrated virgins. They are single and living in the world. Do you believe they are not feminine since they have to support themselves and really focus on their career for comfortable living?

I know that might come off as a rant, but quite frankly it offends me. It offends me because I do not feel particularly called to the married life and it seems like you are implying (forgive me if I am mistaken) that the only way for a woman to be truly feminine is if she is married. Seeing as I am pretty career-driven and eager to follow that dream job, it also seems like I cannot be feminine at the same time. Which is ludicrous, because if you ask anyone who knows me they would laugh if you called me anything other than a "girly girl."

Edited by HisChildForever
cmotherofpirl
Posted

[quote name='Wolf' post='1774797' date='Feb 7 2009, 01:17 PM']The church itself doesn't have different rules, but some members place a very literal interpretation on the "submission" Scriptures.[/quote]


I think you should give them this. :)

[url="http://www.vatican.va/roman_curia/congregations/cfaith/documents/rc_con_cfaith_doc_20040731_collaboration_en.html"]http://www.vatican.va/roman_curia/congrega...oration_en.html[/url]

and this:
[url="http://www.ewtn.com/library/PAPALDOC/JP2MULIE.HTM"]http://www.ewtn.com/library/PAPALDOC/JP2MULIE.HTM[/url]

TotusTuusMaria
Posted

[quote name='HisChildForever' post='1774836' date='Feb 7 2009, 01:28 PM']This...is just ridiculous. And I am really sorry if that is offensive, but my jaw just dropped when I read that.

Should women then avoid leading committees - and, with this mindset - management positions, political positions, law enforcement positions? teaching positions? Should women just stay at home until a suitable husband comes along to ensure their femininity?

As a side note, I find it ironic how anti-feminists see "independence" as weak and feminists see "femininity" as weak. In my opinion, both parties are [b]incredibly[/b] wrong. A woman can be both.

Furthermore, you are doing a lot of stereotyping. First of all no one should be "bossy" - man or woman. That is just plain rudeness. However, what is wrong with a woman being stern? Is a mother not stern with her children while disciplining them? Does stern = masculine? Furthermore, does sensitive = feminine? Should we then tell men to avoid sensitivity since they are acting like women? How absurd.

I would like to hear your opinion on consecrated virgins. They are single and living in the world. Do you believe they are not feminine since they have to support themselves and really focus on their career for comfortable living?

I know that might come off as a rant, but quite frankly it offends me. It offends me because I do not feel particularly called to the married life and it seems like you are implying (forgive me if I am mistaken) that the only way for a woman to be truly feminine is if she is married. Seeing as I am pretty career-driven and eager to follow that dream job, it also seems like I cannot be feminine at the same time. Which is ludicrous, because if you ask anyone who knows me they would laugh if you called me anything other than a "girly girl."[/quote]

You know, I really think you need to chill and possibly re-read my post as it is obvious you either didn't read it all or are just :blink:

cmotherofpirl
Posted

[quote name='HisChildForever' post='1774836' date='Feb 7 2009, 01:28 PM']This...is just ridiculous. And I am really sorry if that is offensive, but my jaw just dropped when I read that.

Should women then avoid leading committees - and, with this mindset - management positions, political positions, law enforcement positions? teaching positions? Should women just stay at home until a suitable husband comes along to ensure their femininity?

As a side note, I find it ironic how anti-feminists see "independence" as weak and feminists see "femininity" as weak. In my opinion, both parties are [b]incredibly[/b] wrong. A woman can be both.

Furthermore, you are doing a lot of stereotyping. First of all no one should be "bossy" - man or woman. That is just plain rudeness. However, what is wrong with a woman being stern? Is a mother not stern with her children while disciplining them? Does stern = masculine? Furthermore, does sensitive = feminine? Should we then tell men to avoid sensitivity since they are acting like women? How absurd.

I would like to hear your opinion on consecrated virgins. They are single and living in the world. Do you believe they are not feminine since they have to support themselves and really focus on their career for comfortable living?

I know that might come off as a rant, but quite frankly it offends me. It offends me because I do not feel particularly called to the married life and it seems like you are implying (forgive me if I am mistaken) that the only way for a woman to be truly feminine is if she is married. Seeing as I am pretty career-driven and eager to follow that dream job, it also seems like I cannot be feminine at the same time. Which is ludicrous, because if you ask anyone who knows me they would laugh if you called me anything other than a "girly girl."[/quote]
I think you that maybe you should read the post again. slowly.

puellapaschalis
Posted

I'm a single woman living more or less on her own and who is to all intents and purposes financially independant. I could have as many guys as I like round here, climb all the career ladders I wanted to, travel whereever I pleased (once I'd worked long enough to have the money), you name it. It's not all it's cracked up to be.

I'm not called to marriage either.

</useless_personal_anecdotery>

Posted

Maybe I am wrong but I think you are both saying the same thing. You can be all those things. However, not at the same time. When you are leading a committee then you need to bring forth the strong leadership qualities that you possess. When you are caring for children the strong leadership qualities may not be the hat you want to put on. So you have the soft, loving motherly characteristics.

This is of course not designed for everyone. There are women out there who cannot lead and are not strong in the sense of a leadership strong. They just do not possess those qualities. We all have different characteristic qualities. We are all different. However, I think that we can pick and choose which qualities to use when.

In my workplace, I need to be caring and kind and all those other characteristics that would fall under the category of "soft and feminine" towards my patients. There are times that I need to use those qualities that fall under "independent and strong". When addressing patients (at least ones that are not combative) I am "softer". Often times, (and I really mean often) I have to address doctors with a less than "soft" attitude. I need to be assertive, strong, independent and fight for my patient. More than once I had to discuss with doctors about a change in patient's condition where they seemed to write it off.

One instance the doctor wanted to order a psychological consult for a patient who was continually vomiting and refusing to eat. I told her that the patient seemed like she was becoming a little depressed by her current situation but did not need a consult because of her vomiting and refusing to eat. The doctor said, "But she is acting like a child. She didn't even eat what I offered her." (the doc offered a piece of meatball) I said, "Doctor, did you ever see the food that they have to eat? Spaghetti never sat well with this patient. Furthermore, she ate a whole coagulated milk sandwich without any problem. Maybe she knew that the meatball would not do her stomach very well. Also, if you vomitted almost every time you ate, wouldn't you be a little hesitant to eat? What is happening is a learned response. 'Everytime I eat, I throw up'. What would you do?" In that incident I could not be "soft" if I did I would not have gotten my point across. Upon returning to the patient's room I was able to go back to the "caring and kind" Meg.

Also, independent doesn't necessarily mean that we don't need anyone. We are all connected. Even the most independent person depends on at least one person if not more. It is not a sign of weakness. It is being human. However, I do no need someone to make me feel like I am a human or I do not need someone else to make me happy. That is my independence. My independence is being able to go here and there without having to report to someone about my whereabouts. (I do tell my folks when I am going out though). My independence is being able to be HUMAN.

I am strong. I am independent. I am caring. I am friendly. I am feminine. I am a woman. These are my qualities. Everyone is different. Even men are different in their own gender.

Alrighty,
Meg

Posted

[quote name='TotusTuusMaria' post='1774581' date='Feb 7 2009, 11:26 AM']"
It is difficult to balance independence, strength, and remain feminine and soft.... it really is. You can't be both at the same time without great grace. When I lead one of the committees I am on I am independent and strong. I am bossy and stern... and it is very difficult to be "in charge" and still remain soft and feminine... it is difficult. You have to be sensitive and aware. You have to be patient and understanding. You have to balance the independent and career nature not trusting anyone and doing everything yourself and then that feminine nature that submits and gives over and trusts.... it is hard and anyone who says it is not just hasn't tasted it yet.[/quote]


I don't agree that "anyone who says it is not just hasn't tasted it yet". How do you know that? It's entirely possible that women with a lot of experience in management may just have acquired the skills to be very balanced. It may very well be difficult when one is starting out - I find young people in mangement to be far more "bossy and stern" than their older (successful) counterparts. Because of a situation beyond my control I am currently out in the workforce again. I have 25+ years experience - much of it in upper management in a mostly male field. I lead men and women every single day of every single week and I would be utterly shocked to find any one of them who considers me "bossy". In fact, the number of names on the waiting list to get onto my team is longer than the number of allocated for the entire project.....not all of that is about me personally (I'm grateful to God to say that some of it is) - it happens to be a very successful team working on a very interesting project.

In my considerable experience "bossy" is an attitude in need of adjustment and it often reflects a fair amount of insecurity (or at the very least inexperience). That kind of attitude won't take anyone very far. There isn't a person on my team who regards me as anything other than feminine - I have learned to lead from my center - the true self that God gave me (and YES, I agree that Grace is an uncomparable gift here) - my center is decidedly feminine whether or not I happen to be at the head of a conference table.

I am not trying to be picky about your words but in context I do think you mean it the way I am interpreting. If I'm wrong about that, I will stand corrected.

Women in just about every role/walk of life there is are called upon to lead in one way or another - mothers lead children and often have to be strong and stern in their correction, the same goes for superiors in religious houses, ditto for women in corporate positions. This is not a lack of femininity.

I think that one would be hard pressed to say that the wife described in Proverbs 31 is anything but strong and independent...and still she is the pride and joy of her husband. At least the Scriptures seem to indicate that a Godly husband (with a Godly wife) is pleased by a strong and independent woman. Furthermore there doesn't appear to be any conflict with femininity because that Chapter is regularly regarded as depicting the Scriptural feminine ideal.


Pax

TotusTuusMaria
Posted

[quote name='picchick' post='1775017' date='Feb 7 2009, 02:26 PM']Maybe I am wrong but I think you are both saying the same thing. You can be all those things. However, not at the same time.[/quote]

I wrote (which she would know if she read the entire post before she went off on me) that I believe a woman can be all those things at the same time. It is difficult, but I believe she can do it with the grace of God, as so many heroic women have.

However, she did not read the post. I am wondering if anyone did besides cmom :unsure:

I liked your post picchick. ;)

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...