Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Posted

[quote name='LouisvilleFan' timestamp='1303183855' post='2230053']
eHow.com does not strike me as a reliable source of information about anything.
[/quote]
:o

say it ain't so!

LouisvilleFan
Posted

[quote name='Light and Truth' timestamp='1303184215' post='2230055']
Were you ever in a Catholic club before converting?
[/quote]

Wouldn't say so... went to a couple of Catholic youth events/retreats. I suppose if there's any practical truth to the eHow article, it is definitely possible to get around RCIA, as long as you receive the sacraments.

Posted

i have a friend that received private instruction and then entered the Church at Easter.

if my husband ever converts then he will also probably do private instruction, as i don't want him to go through RCIA and have to re-teach him.

MissScripture
Posted

[quote name='Lil Red' timestamp='1303263713' post='2230401']
i have a friend that received private instruction and then entered the Church at Easter.

if my husband ever converts then he will also probably do private instruction, as i don't want him to go through RCIA and have to re-teach him.
[/quote]
Why do I get the feeling you don't have much faith in your RCIA instructors? :|

Posted

[quote name='MissScripture' timestamp='1303263872' post='2230402']
Why do I get the feeling you don't have much faith in your RCIA instructors? :|
[/quote]
:| no reason to get that feeling at all. :|

Posted

[quote name='Lil Red' timestamp='1303264144' post='2230406']
:| no reason to get that feeling at all. :|
[/quote]

I understand Red perceived hesitance. There are, in my area, lots of RCIA programs that are subpar and just do not really teach you or teach you what my instructor called "Catholic Superstition" e.g. you have to pray the rosary (you don't). I was blessed my RCIA instructor has her MTh from the Angelicum and has a degree in Cannon Law. She taught us well. We had to meet once a week for three hours plus there were a number of 3 or 4 hour long Saturday classes.

Posted

[quote name='emilier98' timestamp='1303264827' post='2230413']
I understand Red perceived hesitance. There are, in my area, lots of RCIA programs that are subpar and just do not really teach you or teach you what my instructor called "Catholic Superstition" e.g. you have to pray the rosary (you don't). I was blessed my RCIA instructor has her MTh from the Angelicum and has a degree in Cannon Law. She taught us well. We had to meet once a week for three hours plus there were a number of 3 or 4 hour long Saturday classes.
[/quote]
that sounds great!! :)

I'm more concerned with RCIA programs being taught by ex-nuns with a penchant for heresy.

EcceNovaFacioOmni
Posted

My grandfather felt like he was too old for RCIA, so he talked to the pastor. He gave him a self-study program and baptized him after Mass a while back. No big deal.

Posted

[quote name='Lil Red' timestamp='1303265047' post='2230416']
that sounds great!! :)

I'm more concerned with RCIA programs being taught by ex-nuns with a penchant for heresy.
[/quote]

Oh dear. I fortunately have not heard of any of those. I think you're in my area of the world so if you want the name of the parish I went through i would be happy to give it to you. I very much understand wanting quality private instruction. Even with the cradle Catholics I know and I know a lot thanks to going to a Catholic university I see lots of really, really bad catechisis. It always amazes me what they have been taught is doctrine. Many of them have been taught that the church teaches that all other faiths are invalid and hold no truth. Grrrr. Ok. Done with my soap box now. Thank you all.

I hope you find a great instructor for your husband and congrats!!!!

Posted

[quote name='emilier98' timestamp='1303275664' post='2230452']
Oh dear. I fortunately have not heard of any of those. I think you're in my area of the world so if you want the name of the parish I went through i would be happy to give it to you. I very much understand wanting quality private instruction. Even with the cradle Catholics I know and I know a lot thanks to going to a Catholic university I see lots of really, really bad catechisis. It always amazes me what they have been taught is doctrine. Many of them have been taught that the church teaches that all other faiths are invalid and hold no truth. Grrrr. Ok. Done with my soap box now. Thank you all.

I hope you find a great instructor for your husband and congrats!!!!
[/quote]
well, he's not converting yet...but there is hope. :) thank you.

Debra Little
Posted

[quote name='Light and Truth' timestamp='1303175530' post='2229995']
Typo.

One of my friends whom I met in the Newman club said I would probably be bored in it, so I thought I'd look it up.
[/quote]

you didn't know. hugz

Anastasia13
Posted (edited)

[quote name='LouisvilleFan' timestamp='1303262112' post='2230391']
Wouldn't say so... went to a couple of Catholic youth events/retreats. I suppose if there's any practical truth to the eHow article, it is definitely possible to get around RCIA, as long as you receive the sacraments.
[/quote]
I frequently met with a Catholic campus minister and hung out at a Catholic Campus Ministry Center my first two years in college. I'm not sure how many Bible studies were held, but I suppose to be fair it was more educational discussion one-on-one and social stuff and a couple of Bible studies plus one retreat that I went on. To be fair I have since only attended up to two events per quarter most of the time when returning to uni. I learned so much from that minister, but we both left my old university at the same time and I never got back in touch. :(

Were you baptized and confirmed Lutheran with a long history of regular church attendance/fellowship/some service all-be-it not Catholic and slightly studied under an Orthodox deacon? (Let's test how in my shoes you are.)

Edited by Light and Truth
LouisvilleFan
Posted

[quote name='Light and Truth' timestamp='1303346403' post='2230702']
I frequently met with a Catholic campus minister and hung out at a Catholic Campus Ministry Center my first two years in college. I'm not sure how many Bible studies were held, but I suppose to be fair it was more educational discussion one-on-one and social stuff and a couple of Bible studies plus one retreat that I went on. To be fair I have since only attended up to two events per quarter most of the time when returning to uni. I learned so much from that minister, but we both left my old university at the same time and I never got back in touch. :(

Were you baptized and confirmed Lutheran with a long history of regular church attendance/fellowship/some service all-be-it not Catholic and slightly studied under an Orthodox deacon? (Let's test how in my shoes you are.)
[/quote]

Hmm... my first Bible study in college was part of Intervarsity and co-lead by a Baptist and a Catholic (not that I thought anything of it at the time). Yes, baptized and confirmed Lutheran and while I never studied under any Orthodox clergy, a couple from my old Baptist church actually ended up being received into the Orthodox Church a year or two after I became Catholic. Definitely learned a lot to appreciate about Eastern Christianity from attending their parish a few times. RCIA didn't teach me much theologically, but I enjoyed hearing different peoples' stories about God drew them into the Church, sometimes over many years or even decades. Not every conversion story must reference the Church Fathers :saint:

Posted

In my experience, it is much better for someone to go through individual instruction as opposed to RCIA. RCIA tends to slant liberal and doesn't give a full representation of the total of Catholicism, just that which has been promoted in the last 40+ years.

Unless you know the priest who is teaching the RCIA program and can show that he will give 100% orthodox instruction through RCIA, I would seek out a priest who will do that and take instruction from him.

If RCIA is 100% orthodox and is taught by a priest who will cover all the necessary requisites, I would shy away.

My opinion.

TeresaBenedicta
Posted

[quote name='Cam42' timestamp='1303540051' post='2231330']
In my experience, it is much better for someone to go through individual instruction as opposed to RCIA. RCIA tends to slant liberal and doesn't give a full representation of the total of Catholicism, just that which has been promoted in the last 40+ years.

Unless you know the priest who is teaching the RCIA program and can show that he will give 100% orthodox instruction through RCIA, I would seek out a priest who will do that and take instruction from him.

If RCIA is 100% orthodox and is taught by a priest who will cover all the necessary requisites, I would shy away.

My opinion.
[/quote]

I don't think it's fair to lump RCIA with liberal trends. There are liberal RCIA programs... and there are orthodox RCIA programs. I went through a fantastic RCIA. I now teach RCIA and it's certainly not 'liberal'. It's just like anything the Church right now... you can find liberal and you can find orthodox.

Archaeology cat
Posted

[quote name='TeresaBenedicta' timestamp='1303541246' post='2231334']
I don't think it's fair to lump RCIA with liberal trends. There are liberal RCIA programs... and there are orthodox RCIA programs. I went through a fantastic RCIA. I now teach RCIA and it's certainly not 'liberal'. It's just like anything the Church right now... you can find liberal and you can find orthodox.
[/quote]
True. After I converted, I sat in on an RCIA class (most who were converting at that time were in uni, and the priest thought my presence might help, since I was in grad school), and it was completely orthodox. The priest was really good.

Anastasia13
Posted

[quote name='LouisvilleFan' timestamp='1303539595' post='2231329'] Not every conversion story must reference the Church Fathers :saint:
[/quote]
What do you mean?

Posted

[quote name='TeresaBenedicta' timestamp='1303541246' post='2231334']
I don't think it's fair to lump RCIA with liberal trends. There are liberal RCIA programs... and there are orthodox RCIA programs. I went through a fantastic RCIA. I now teach RCIA and it's certainly not 'liberal'. It's just like anything the Church right now... you can find liberal and you can find orthodox.
[/quote]

Sure it is. RCIA is not one universal set of teachings which every Catechumen must go through. Notice that I said that it tends to slant left, not that all do. I also said that if you could find one which is 100% orthodox then it is ok.

Right now the RCIA program could be anything from listening to Corapi all the way to studying [u]Catholicism[/u] by Fr. Richard McBrien. There is no consistency in how the program is administered and that is a problem. While you may be teaching an orthodox RCIA program that doesn't mean that the next parish over is.

Also, there is no need to tolerate anything in the Church which is not 100% orthodox. Again, this is my view and one that is certainly justifiable.

TeresaBenedicta
Posted

[quote name='Cam42' timestamp='1303565233' post='2231359']
Sure it is. RCIA is not one universal set of teachings which every Catechumen must go through. Notice that I said that it tends to slant left, not that all do. I also said that if you could find one which is 100% orthodox then it is ok.

Right now the RCIA program could be anything from listening to Corapi all the way to studying [u]Catholicism[/u] by Fr. Richard McBrien. There is no consistency in how the program is administered and that is a problem. While you may be teaching an orthodox RCIA program that doesn't mean that the next parish over is.

Also, there is no need to tolerate anything in the Church which is not 100% orthodox. Again, this is my view and one that is certainly justifiable.
[/quote]

The [i]Rite[/i] itself is universal. Although, as you say, the teaching that goes along with is left to the discretion of the pastor. The importance of RCIA in of itself is not so much in the teaching, but in the [i]Rite[/i]-- the process of conversion in and with the Church. The instruction is, in a sense, secondary. Certainly not to say that the instruction isn't important! On the contrary.

What I mean to say is that the instruction can take place in various ways-- through group classes, individual sessions with the priest, individual study of materials, etc. But the [i]Rite[/i] ought to be participated in by all (with rare exceptions). Technically speaking, one could go through the Rite up through receiving the sacraments without instruction, and then be catechized [i]after[/i] receiving the sacraments, during the period of mystagogy.

But that's what I mean when I say that the RCIA is not liberal or orthodox. It is a Rite of the Church, for the initiation of adults. The instruction (or lack thereof) that goes along with it is secondary.

Posted

[quote name='TeresaBenedicta' timestamp='1303566445' post='2231365']
The [i]Rite[/i] itself is universal. Although, as you say, the teaching that goes along with is left to the discretion of the pastor. The importance of RCIA in of itself is not so much in the teaching, but in the [i]Rite[/i]-- the process of conversion in and with the Church. The instruction is, in a sense, secondary. Certainly not to say that the instruction isn't important! On the contrary.

What I mean to say is that the instruction can take place in various ways-- through group classes, individual sessions with the priest, individual study of materials, etc. But the [i]Rite[/i] ought to be participated in by all (with rare exceptions). Technically speaking, one could go through the Rite up through receiving the sacraments without instruction, and then be catechized [i]after[/i] receiving the sacraments, during the period of mystagogy.

But that's what I mean when I say that the RCIA is not liberal or orthodox. It is a Rite of the Church, for the initiation of adults. The instruction (or lack thereof) that goes along with it is secondary.
[/quote]

How in the world did the Church bring people into the Church before 1972. This [i]RITE[/i] as you put it, isn't a [i]RITE[/i] in the same sense as the Roman Rite or the Latin Rite, but rather it is an order of doing business. It is not mandatory of someone to go through the [i]RITE[/i] in order to become Catholic. It wasn't unitl 1988 that the USCCB (that non-binding organization) made it "official."

It is entirely possible that someone can be brought into the Church without going through the [i]RITE[/i] as envisioned by the current RCIA program. Also, the [i]RITE[/i] is not universal. The way that it is administered in one parish is not how it will be done in another. So, the [i]RITE[/i] has no consistency. Some of the scrutinies may be ommitted, some others may not. Some of the [i]RITE[/i] will be public, some of it not. It all depends on the pastor and that is wholly inconsistent of how a [i]RITE[/i] should be administered.

As I stated, it is possible for one to go through individual instruction and be brought into the Church without RCIA. I would strongly suggest seeking out the orthodoxy of the program that one is looking into and that he not engage in anything which is not 100% orthodox. If one cannot be found, I would suggest seeking out a priest who is known for being 100% faithful to Catholicism and receive instruction from him.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...