Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Brother Adam
Posted

[quote name='Lil Red' timestamp='1303265047' post='2230416']
that sounds great!! :)

I'm more concerned with RCIA programs being taught by ex-nuns with a penchant for heresy.
[/quote]

Hey! Stop talking about my church!

Posted

[quote name='Brother Adam' timestamp='1303569683' post='2231371']
Hey! Stop talking about my church!
[/quote]

If I remember correctly, Brother A., you posed this same question during your RCIA class? What insight can you give there?

TeresaBenedicta
Posted

[quote name='Cam42' timestamp='1303568985' post='2231370']
How in the world did the Church bring people into the Church before 1972. This [i]RITE[/i] as you put it, isn't a [i]RITE[/i] in the same sense as the Roman Rite or the Latin Rite, but rather it is an order of doing business. It is not mandatory of someone to go through the [i]RITE[/i] in order to become Catholic. It wasn't unitl 1988 that the USCCB (that non-binding organization) made it "official."

It is entirely possible that someone can be brought into the Church without going through the [i]RITE[/i] as envisioned by the current RCIA program. Also, the [i]RITE[/i] is not universal. The way that it is administered in one parish is not how it will be done in another. So, the [i]RITE[/i] has no consistency. Some of the scrutinies may be ommitted, some others may not. Some of the [i]RITE[/i] will be public, some of it not. It all depends on the pastor and that is wholly inconsistent of how a [i]RITE[/i] should be administered.
[/quote]

Dude, calm down. Did you come back to phatmass just to get argumentative and zealous? Because that's what a lot of your posts seem to be so far.

I'm aware of when RCIA was instituted for the Church. And I wasn't making any claim that it's equivalent to a rite in the sense of Roman Rite. I also never said it was mandatory. But I [i]did[/i] say that one ought to go through it, because that is the norm set down for entrance in the Church today. And for good reason, I might add.

Posted

[quote name='TeresaBenedicta' timestamp='1303571787' post='2231378']
Dude, calm down. Did you come back to phatmass just to get argumentative and zealous? Because that's what a lot of your posts seem to be so far.

I'm aware of when RCIA was instituted for the Church. And I wasn't making any claim that it's equivalent to a rite in the sense of Roman Rite. I also never said it was mandatory. But I [i]did[/i] say that one ought to go through it, because that is the norm set down for entrance in the Church today. And for good reason, I might add.
[/quote]

Zeal for the Catholic faith is not a bad thing. I am not arguing with you, I am making statements which are not inconsistent to Catholicism. I'm glad that you you know w.hen RCIA was instituted in the Church (I think that "for the Church" is a bit obtuse, as it is not mandatory, as you note, which I noted first.)

You think that one ought to go through it and that is fine, I think that also, which I have said all along, btw...IF it is 100% orthodox. IF it is not, then I suggest that one find a priest to get instruction from who is 100% orthodox. Which is what I have said for about the 5th time now. Do you disagree with that?

Also, I am completely calm. I have not been anything other than reasonable and I have stated that what I put forth is my opining. It is nothing that is set in stone, but rather it is what one Catholic can say to another. I'm sorry that you disagree with it, but it is just as valid a view as going through RCIA.

eustace scrubb
Posted

I'm tired of trying to find an RCIA program in this city that's orthodox. Easter came and went and I'm still not confirmed. I've done so much Catholic Apologetics (based on what I've read and studied) to Protestant non-denominational Christians and non-Christians that to have to go through RCIA [i]despite not being able to physically handle it (even through private study)[/i], drives me nuts. I fully understand needing to enter community with other Catholics and agree with that, but that just doesn't exist here. The only thing like that in my area is all the way across town, I lost my transportation to it, and I despite [b][i]repeated[/i][/b] requests for help, have been ignored. It's infuriating and frustrating. This is absolutely ridiculous. Do I have any other options???

Vincent Vega
Posted

You don't have to be confirmed/received at Easter.

Archaeology cat
Posted

[quote name='USAirwaysIHS' timestamp='1303841996' post='2233474']
You don't have to be confirmed/received at Easter.
[/quote]
Very true. I entered the Church in December 2004.

tinytherese
Posted

For the giggles.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hA7imD94a54

LouisvilleFan
Posted

[quote name='eustace scrubb' timestamp='1303839815' post='2233453']
I'm tired of trying to find an RCIA program in this city that's orthodox. Easter came and went and I'm still not confirmed. I've done so much Catholic Apologetics (based on what I've read and studied) to Protestant non-denominational Christians and non-Christians that to have to go through RCIA [i]despite not being able to physically handle it (even through private study)[/i], drives me nuts. I fully understand needing to enter community with other Catholics and agree with that, but that just doesn't exist here. The only thing like that in my area is all the way across town, I lost my transportation to it, and I despite [b][i]repeated[/i][/b] requests for help, have been ignored. It's infuriating and frustrating. This is absolutely ridiculous. Do I have any other options???
[/quote]

If you're in Cincinnati area, what about St. Gertrude? Don't know what to say about rides besides the bus. It's difficult getting involved in any community... modern society is very transitional and many young adults are not settled on any one parish (or career/city/marriage/etc). God doesn't always call us to the most orthodox or joyful or welcoming communities and I think you'll find that just about every parish has a few parishioners who are more faithful than you might expect.

[quote name='USAirwaysIHS' timestamp='1303841996' post='2233474']
You don't have to be confirmed/received at Easter.
[/quote]

Isn't that Easter in the southern hemisphere?

  • 1 year later...
Posted

How things do stay the same...

Posted (edited)

I was confirmed this past Divine Mercy Sunday—praise God!—and did not, technically, go through RCIA. The parish's RCIA schedule conflicted with my university class schedule, and I was in a mighty hurry to receive the Eucharist. I met once a week (sometimes more) with the world's most holy sponsor, and was confirmed on schedule with the others who went through RCIA. So far as I know, I am the only one of my "class" who regularly attends Mass and confession, volunteers at the parish, reads extensively on Catholicism, is still in weekly contact with my sponsor (whom I now refer to as my godmother), etc.

 

So, I think it really depends on the person. A priest is probably the best person to discern what an individual needs. I am a "self-starter", very cerebral, and there was no way I was going to get confirmed without understanding the basics of what the Church teaches. I really did not need RCIA. It would have just frustrated me. It moved WAY too slow (and was way less orthodox than my sponsor). My sponsor worked with me at my pace. God bless her. She will go straight to heaven.  :angel:

Edited by curiousing
Basilisa Marie
Posted

1.  THREAD NECROMANCY.    :dead:  

 

2.  I nearly had a heart attack at seeing Teresa Benedicta's post...seeing as she's off being an extremely busy Sister Maria Asterone Dodeka with the SSVMs and has next to no time for letters, let alone the internet. :) 

 

3. Oh, Cam42.  

 

4. During my freshman year of college my dad joined the Church (from being ELCA Lutheran) a few years ago, and he never did RCIA.  He just got "re-confirmed" during a daily mass.  He did meet with our priest (and his pastor) a few times to talk things over.   So I guess the point is that RCIA can be a great tool for introducing someone to the faith, but what's really important is that they've got the faith and the knowledge to be "ready."  

4b. I only found out my dad was converting the DAY BEFORE IT HAPPENED.  You'd think my mom would have mentioned something sooner during the hundred or so phone calls a week I received from her.... :hehe2:

Posted (edited)
3. Oh, Cam42.  

 

4. During my freshman year of college my dad joined the Church (from being ELCA Lutheran) a few years ago, and he never did RCIA.  He just got "re-confirmed" during a daily mass.  He did meet with our priest (and his pastor) a few times to talk things over.   So I guess the point is that RCIA can be a great tool for introducing someone to the faith, but what's really important is that they've got the faith and the knowledge to be "ready." 

 

What happened with Cam42? Wasn't he a church scholar back in the day?

 

I wonder if that would have been possible for me. I was ELCA, confirmed, read a couple Catholic Apologetics books, and took a 9 week compendium of the Catholic Catechism course 3 years ago.

 

It's interesting that this happened so often.

 

P.S. Better necromancy than necrophilia.

Edited by Light and Truth
Posted

What happened with Cam42? Wasn't he a church scholar back in the day?

 

Cam is a cool dude. :) He is running a small, excellent blog these days. He has lots of strong opinions and I, for one, always appreciate hearing them from him.

 

http://traddyiniowa.blogspot.ca/

Posted

Congratulations Curiousing! :)

 

And Cam, ah Cam, one of only two Phatmassers to ever manage to make it onto my Ignore list because he couldn't treat me like a civilized human being.  I'm not unthankful he's gone.

Posted

Congratulations Curiousing! :)

 

And Cam, ah Cam, one of only two Phatmassers to ever manage to make it onto my Ignore list because he couldn't treat me like a civilized human being.  I'm not unthankful he's gone.

 

this.

Posted


If you're in Cincinnati area, what about St. Gertrude? 

 

A solid choice, if I do say so myself.  

 

I was actually just talking to someone who went through absolutely no formation, and received baptism, 1st communion, and confirmation at once.  

Posted

A solid choice, if I do say so myself.  

 

I was actually just talking to someone who went through absolutely no formation, and received baptism, 1st communion, and confirmation at once.  

 

None? Why?

Basilisa Marie
Posted

I wonder if that would have been possible for me. I was ELCA, confirmed, read a couple Catholic Apologetics books, and took a 9 week compendium of the Catholic Catechism course 3 years ago.

 

 

I dunno; I would say probably not, but it depends on the priest.  My dad had been attending mass with my family for about ten years, was pretty active helping my mom do events at church (set up and take down, that sort of thing) before he converted. There was another guy in a similar situation that entered the Church with him.  Like others said in this thread, a very large part of RCIA is helping a candidate or catechumen form relationships and find a place in the parish community. 

Archaeology cat
Posted

Ooh, this reminds me that the 8th anniversary of me entering the Church is tomorrow!

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...