Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Welcome To Club Unicorn


Recommended Posts

cmotherofpirl
Posted

[quote name='Tab'le Du'Bah-Rye' timestamp='1339548940' post='2444123']
Did your penis get erect to fertilise your wife and create your children ? Than obviously you kind of like women too. Thats what i'm thinking anyway and didn't read the whole post i just stopped at the "What do you mean when you say your gay? " I can't click the link bcoz this is my brothers com. Did he have sex with his wife or where they ivf babies. And if he did than possibly the Homosexual front is a longing to belong to a group that is a minority or possibly an attempt to be charitable to the homo-sexual minortity... Thats all my opinion, an outsider that has 3 achilles heals and one of them is lust, but over time God is working with me.


JESUS iz LORD
St Paul "persistance bears fruits of hope."
[/quote]

Since you didn't actually read it, why did you comment?

Posted

[quote name='Slappo' timestamp='1339543350' post='2444094']
The first thing that comes to mind is I wonder how many people back in the day before "coming out" was socially ok had marriages similar to this.
[/quote]

and how many of them were miserable? I gotta say, for the one anecdote i have just read of this working out, i have heard countless more of divorce, suicide and other clearly not ideal situations, because people felt a need to do things "the normal way".

[quote name='FuturePriest387' timestamp='1339543029' post='2444092']
A very wonderful post. If only more people with SSA knew there was such a thing as a real marriage with actual happiness for them as well. It seems people have the idea that if they aren't attracted to the person the way people normally are than they will be miserable. I'm glad someone spoke up about it.
[/quote]

As for how unlikely this is to happen to most people, consider this thought experiment. Could you imagine marrying your best male friend, kissing, having sex and raising a family, and never having sex with or dating the women you were actually attracted to? Can you imagine enjoying that?

because i know i cant. what this dude has is pretty razzle dazzle for him, but that kind of situation cannot be "made"

Posted

His testimony is beautiful, sensitive, touching, and pretty theologically sound (he made some distinctions that quite impressed me!). I think his discussion of what makes a truly wonderful sex life is something that can't be said enough. And I think his understanding of sex is quite good (Mormon Theology of the Body, anyone?). Another great point implied but not explicitly stated in his blog post: Arousal is not connected only to sexual orientation and attraction, so the ability to consummate one's marriage and beget children is not connected only to one's sexual orientation and attraction. (Need convincing on that last point? What about the involuntary arousal of someone being raped?)

PhuturePriest
Posted

[quote name='TheoGrad07' timestamp='1339552806' post='2444148']
His testimony is beautiful, sensitive, touching, and pretty theologically sound (he made some distinctions that quite impressed me!). I think his discussion of what makes a truly wonderful sex life is something that can't be said enough. And I think his understanding of sex is quite good (Mormon Theology of the Body, anyone?). Another great point implied but not explicitly stated in his blog post: Arousal is not connected only to sexual orientation and attraction, so the ability to consummate one's marriage and beget children is not connected only to one's sexual orientation and attraction. (Need convincing on that last point? What about the involuntary arousal of someone being raped?)
[/quote]

Exactly. It's not just about arousal but about pleasure. If something feels good you're going to be aroused whether you are attracted or not. However, I just about died when I wrote that, so that's all I am going to say for the subject at the moment.

Posted

[quote name='r2Dtoo' timestamp='1339547353' post='2444120']
I think this is something most gay men would do if given the chance. I don't prescribe to this "people choose to be gay" idea that many Christians think. It's easy for heterosexual Catholics to think all gays who didn't find that special girl in high school can live celibate lives "with God's grace". Maybe some people gay and straight can do that, but certainly not all of them. People who can truthfully live a celibate life are very, very rare and it's ridiculous to assume that any random gay guy can refrain from sex.

I don't know how I feel about showing this to gay middle/high school kids. That might make them think that if they put some effort into opposite-sex relationships they can have this too. That would be a misinterpretation in my view. To me it sounds more like this couple got "love at first sight", and while that's great for them no amount of work can accomplish that. If you find that great, but if you don't you don't.
[/quote]

It's sad that many Christians feel this way, yes. But when a Catholic says that SSA is disordered, he doesn't necessarily mean that it's that person's fault for feeling that way, nor does he insist that it's something that's curable. But chosing to act on your disordered desires is problematic, and the Church not only believes that you can master your desires with God's grace, but that you MUST do so in order to live a virtuous life.

We know of many other sins that stem from disordered desires of different kinds, and SSA/homosexuality is not different in that regard.

Posted

[quote name='Jesus_lol' timestamp='1339552743' post='2444147']
and how many of them were miserable? I gotta say, for the one anecdote i have just read of this working out, i have heard countless more of divorce, suicide and other clearly not ideal situations, because people felt a need to do things "the normal way".[/quote]
You raise several good points, but doing things the abnormal way here can lead to depression, drug use, homelessness and suicide. It's really not that easy being a GLBT youth in America. I don't know why so many think it is.



[quote]As for how unlikely this is to happen to most people, consider this thought experiment. Could you imagine marrying your best male friend, kissing, having sex and raising a family, and never having sex with or dating the women you were actually attracted to? Can you imagine enjoying that?

because i know i cant. what this dude has is pretty razzle dazzle for him, but that kind of situation cannot be "made"
[/quote]
There is a difference between being friends and "love at first sight".

Posted

[quote name='arfink' timestamp='1339554239' post='2444165']
It's sad that many Christians feel this way, yes. But when a Catholic says that SSA is disordered, he doesn't necessarily mean that it's that person's fault for feeling that way, nor does he insist that it's something that's curable. But chosing to act on your disordered desires is problematic, and the Church not only believes that you can master your desires with God's grace, but that you MUST do so in order to live a virtuous life.

We know of many other sins that stem from disordered desires of different kinds, and SSA/homosexuality is not different in that regard.
[/quote]
Expecting that persons who cannot live celibate lives to refrain from sex is not only asking them to perform an impossible task, but putting them at risk of suicide if actually attempted.

cmotherofpirl
Posted

[quote name='r2Dtoo' timestamp='1339554340' post='2444166']
You raise several good points, but doing things the abnormal way here can lead to depression, drug use, homelessness and suicide. It's really not that easy being a GLBT youth in America. I don't know why so many think it is.
[/quote]

Why do you assume its "abnormal" to make a conscious decision to live as a married couple to raise a family? We are not slaves to our passions, as if we have no control of our genitals.

cmotherofpirl
Posted

[quote name='r2Dtoo' timestamp='1339555981' post='2444177']
Expecting that persons who cannot live celibate lives to refrain from sex is not only asking them to perform an impossible task, but putting them at risk of suicide if actually attempted.
[/quote]
Seriously you will not die from lack of sex, but you could die from lack of relationships, they are not the same thing, please do not confuse the two.

Posted

[quote name='r2Dtoo' timestamp='1339555981' post='2444177']
Expecting that persons who cannot live celibate lives to refrain from sex is not only asking them to perform an impossible task, but putting them at risk of suicide if actually attempted.
[/quote]Can you cite a study that ugly people die sooner or commit suicide at a greater rate than the pretty people? Or are you saying that social mores should not have any expectation of maturity, self-control, self-discipline, or any resistance to our basest instincts and urges?

Posted

Wait, there are suddenly a whole lot of people who physically cannot live celibate lives now? Fascinating.

Let me ask you a question: are you having sex with someone right now, at this very moment? Would you just suddenly drop your duds at the bus stop because you just couldn't control yourself?

Sure, I'll buy that there are some people who are so messed up inside that they cannot resist the opportunity to have sex, just as I am sure there are people who are so addicted to crack/alcohol/whatever that they can't resist either. But we know that's not the norm, and we treat it as such. We don't want to actively encourage people to act that way, because it's obviously disordered.

It's why the Church can legitimately ask her people to master their desires.

Posted

[quote name='FuturePriest387' timestamp='1339553481' post='2444161']Exactly. It's not just about arousal but about pleasure. If something feels good you're going to be aroused whether you are attracted or not. However, I just about died when I wrote that, so that's all I am going to say for the subject at the moment.
[/quote]I don't think that TheoGrad or Mr. Weed meant to say it's about pleasure, but about intimacy.

Posted

[quote name='Lil Red' timestamp='1339532700' post='2444026']
Wow. A very brave [s]post[/s] novel. And I suspect there are more like him than we know.
[/quote]
Yeah. tl;dr.

IcePrincessKRS
Posted

[quote name='r2Dtoo' timestamp='1339554340' post='2444166']
You raise several good points, but doing things the abnormal way here can lead to depression, drug use, homelessness and suicide. It's really not that easy being a GLBT youth in America. I don't know why so many think it is.

[/quote]

Where did ANYONE say it's easy?

Posted

[quote name='IcePrincessKRS' timestamp='1339600963' post='2444276']


Where did ANYONE say it's easy?
[/quote]The positive use of sexuality is rarely if ever easy for people, no matter their sexual orientation or position in life. The Church constantly calls us to something higher than base animal sexuality, but I have yet to hear anyone reasonable describe this as an easy calling.

:huh: I completely agree with you... Where did anyone even suggest that dealing with same-sex attractions, or even sexual attractions in general is easy? Rarely is it so, though fortunately grace aids greatly.

Vincent Vega
Posted

Not sure how I feel about that. I guess if it's working out for this guy, that's great, but I would hardly recommend this as an alternative to chastity for SSA individuals.

franciscanheart
Posted

[quote name='USAirwaysIHS' timestamp='1339605950' post='2444298']
Not sure how I feel about that. I guess if it's working out for this guy, that's great, but I would hardly recommend this as an alternative to chastity for SSA individuals.
[/quote]
Right, and he definitely addresses that this won't work for everyone and he understands not everyone will even WANT this. Also, I think chastity might be the wrong word -- or just not the best one; perhaps "celibacy" is better. Or maybe you meant chastity for reasons I haven't assumed. [shrug]

Vincent Vega
Posted

[quote name='franciscanheart' timestamp='1339606422' post='2444300']Also, I think chastity might be the wrong word -- or just not the best one; perhaps "celibacy" is better. Or maybe you meant chastity for reasons I haven't assumed. [shrug]
[/quote]
I guess you're right...though I'd suppose that in most cases with SSA that the terms would be synonymous?

franciscanheart
Posted

[quote name='USAirwaysIHS' timestamp='1339606511' post='2444302']
I guess you're right...though I'd suppose that in most cases with SSA that the terms would be synonymous?
[/quote]
Yeah, I guess that's a fair supposition.

Posted

[quote name='USAirwaysIHS' timestamp='1339606511' post='2444302']I guess you're right...though I'd suppose that in most cases with SSA that the terms would be synonymous?
[/quote]Chastity is the virtue of living out our sexuality in accord with our present state of life. All people are called to chastity. Even in marriage I am supposed to act chastely toward my wife. That means that this story is a prime example of chastity, not an alternative to it.

Celibacy is the renunciation of sexual intercourse alone. I think that it would be most proper to say that this is an alternative to celibacy and a wonderful example of chastity.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...