Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Welcome To Club Unicorn


Recommended Posts

franciscanheart
Posted

[quote name='r2Dtoo' timestamp='1339729281' post='2444884']Correct me if I'm wrong, but I'm guessing in Catholicism eating an entire box cookies would qualify as gluttony which is a sin ans is never permissible. Sex on the other hand is allowed in marriage, so what's wrong with saying these people are marrying because they need sex? Does that mean that's all they want or need? No, of course not, but they do need it.
[/quote]
You're too assumptive. Not everyone gets married because they "need" sex. And you seem to be missing the point: people don't need sex. You've been brainwashed by society. Congratulations on that.

Posted

[quote name='franciscanheart' timestamp='1339729436' post='2444886']
You're too assumptive. Not everyone gets married because they "need" sex. And you seem to be missing the point: people don't need sex. You've been brainwashed by society. Congratulations on that.
[/quote]
Congratulations on being brainwashed by the Catholic Church. People do need sex. Happy mastur--er, never mind. That might be a banned word here. Laters.

IcePrincessKRS
Posted

[quote name='r2Dtoo' timestamp='1339729281' post='2444884']
I have no idea how anyone misread what I orginally said to begin with.[/quote]

Didn't this whole line of discussion start because you said that if people who "need" sex can't have it they're liable to kill themselves?

[quote]Oh look. A trap. How adorable. Avoiding...[/quote]

I'm sorry that you can't handle the truth of the fact that you said something offensive about a woman you don't know anything about.

[quote]Correct me if I'm wrong, but I'm guessing in Catholicism eating an entire box cookies would qualify as gluttony which is a sin ans is never permissible. Sex on the other hand is allowed in marriage, so what's wrong with saying these people are marrying because they need sex? Does that mean that's all they want or need? No, of course not, but they do need it.
[/quote]

Like I said, you should be clear and concise in every post. Then no one will misunderstand you. But, I still think marrying just because you "need" sex is kind of a lousy reason to get married. There should be a whole helluva lot more to it than that. If sex is your main motive it's probably not going to last long. Sex should be the culmination of all those other things combined, not the primary goal.

KnightofChrist
Posted (edited)

[quote name='r2Dtoo' timestamp='1339729281' post='2444884']
Oh look. A trap. How adorable. Avoiding...
[/quote]

Oh look a dodge to avoid admitting you attacked the woman's character.


[quote name='r2Dtoo' timestamp='1339729281' post='2444884']
Correct me if I'm wrong, but I'm guessing in Catholicism eating an entire box cookies would qualify as gluttony which is a sin ans is never permissible. Sex on the other hand is allowed in marriage, so what's wrong with saying these people are marrying because they need sex? Does that mean that's all they want or need? No, of course not, but they do need it.
[/quote]

Again, the Human race "needs" the conjugal act to survive as a species, individual human beings however do not "need" the conjugal act or sexual gratification to survive.

Edited by KnightofChrist
franciscanheart
Posted

[quote name='r2Dtoo' timestamp='1339729607' post='2444887']
Congratulations on being brainwashed by the Catholic Church. People do need sex. Happy mastur--er, never mind. That might be a banned word here. Laters.
[/quote]
Happy masturbating? Is that what you were going for? We talk about that here, and most faithful Catholics recognize that that too is unnecessary for fulfillment, happiness and peace.

I HEAR WHAT YOU'RE SAYING. And there are times I might even want to agree with you. But the truth is this: I do not need sex.

Can the lack of sex take a toll on relationships -- with other people and with one's self? Yes! Absolutely. I understand that a bad sex life, lack of sex, etc can certainly have an affect on people. However, there are ways of working through and around that.

The desire for sex is very real and often very strong. Some people do struggle more than others with sexual temptation. What I would say, however, is that in some cases, people "need" to get married and have sex with their spouse in order to avoid sinning by masturbating or fornicating. I don't think anyone has denied that some people should get married in order to REDUCE their near occasions of sin.

IF HOWEVER, marriage and sex were not possible for someone, we (a good majority here) believe that they could do without and not suffer physically because of it IF THEY WERE ADDRESSING THE ISSUE. Some people actually might physically and mentally suffer, but having sex isn't always the answer. There is a lot of grace to be obtained by struggling through temptation -- especially temptation toward sex.

Posted

i'd just like to point out how weird it is that for once, the topic [i]started[/i] with gay sex and has ended up talking about straight sex.

PhuturePriest
Posted

[quote name='Lil Red' timestamp='1339730537' post='2444891']
i'd just like to point out how weird it is that for once, the topic [i]started[/i] with gay sex and has ended up talking about straight sex.
[/quote]

It's a crazy world we live in.

Posted

Actually, Biologically speaking, humans do need sex to avoid perishing.

Posted

[quote name='r2Dtoo' timestamp='1339721530' post='2444808']
But you do have a sex life, correct? You people are reading way too much into what I'm saying. Just because sex is necessary for a marriage and for lovers does [i]not[/i], let me repeat this, does [size=8]not[size=4] mean[/size][/size] that nothing more than sex exists in the relationship.
[/quote]
[quote name='r2Dtoo' timestamp='1339721758' post='2444810']
Nobody needs a hand grenade up their butt. People do need sex however.
[/quote]

I think you are confusing desire for need.

IcePrincessKRS
Posted

[quote name='Jesus_lol' timestamp='1339751903' post='2444947']
Actually, Biologically speaking, humans do need sex to avoid perishing.
[/quote]

Because the human race needs sex for procreation so we don't die out as a species? That was already covered. By KoC at least twice, and I'm pretty sure a couple other people as well.

Posted

Im sure i can be forgiven for not having read all of KoC's posts. :P

PhuturePriest
Posted

[quote name='IcePrincessKRS' timestamp='1339787342' post='2445088']
Because the human race needs sex for procreation so we don't die out as a species? That was already covered. By KoC at least twice, and I'm pretty sure a couple other people as well.
[/quote]

And me. You can't forget me.

PhuturePriest
Posted

[quote name='Lil Red' timestamp='1339730537' post='2444891']
i'd just like to point out how weird it is that for once, the topic [i]started[/i] with gay sex and has ended up talking about straight sex.
[/quote]

I think it's most amazing that it started out with gay sex, led to talking about straight sex, and ended talking about masturbation. Quite a mix of things, if I may say so myself.

Posted

[quote name='franciscanheart' timestamp='1339730030' post='2444890']
Happy masturbating? Is that what you were going for? We talk about that here, and most faithful Catholics recognize that that too is unnecessary for fulfillment, happiness and peace.

I HEAR WHAT YOU'RE SAYING. And there are times I might even want to agree with you. But the truth is this: I do not need sex.

Can the lack of sex take a toll on relationships -- with other people and with one's self? Yes! Absolutely. I understand that a bad sex life, lack of sex, etc can certainly have an affect on people. However, there are ways of working through and around that.

The desire for sex is very real and often very strong. Some people do struggle more than others with sexual temptation. What I would say, however, is that in some cases, people "need" to get married and have sex with their spouse in order to avoid sinning by masturbating or fornicating. I don't think anyone has denied that some people should get married in order to REDUCE their near occasions of sin.

IF HOWEVER, marriage and sex were not possible for someone, we (a good majority here) believe that they could do without and not suffer physically because of it IF THEY WERE ADDRESSING THE ISSUE. Some people actually might physically and mentally suffer, but having sex isn't always the answer. There is a lot of grace to be obtained by struggling through temptation -- especially temptation toward sex.
[/quote]
I have tried living this life before myself it does not work, and is just flat out embarrassing besides. I mean telling a man twice my age that I masturbate, and how often I do it when I'm like 14, seriously? Why? And no, that he can't repeat it outside the Confessional didn't make it any less embarrassing. Once more, it didn't work, I tried everything I could think of, I got rid of vulgar music and started listening to Christian music, I prayed as often as I could, I tried working out, I tried everything for almost 10 years and [i]nothing helped[/i]. Those desires did not go away. Maybe they do for some of you here that's great, but not everyone can do that.

Posted

good call..

quit and give in.

seems to have worked wonders for you.

PhuturePriest
Posted

[quote name='r2Dtoo' timestamp='1339792228' post='2445150']
I have tried living this life before myself it does not work, and is just flat out embarrassing besides. I mean telling a man twice my age that I masturbate, and how often I do it when I'm like 14, seriously? Why? And no, that he can't repeat it outside the Confessional didn't make it any less embarrassing. Once more, it didn't work, I tried everything I could think of, I got rid of vulgar music and started listening to Christian music, I prayed as often as I could, I tried working out, I tried everything for almost 10 years and [i]nothing helped[/i]. Those desires did not go away. Maybe they do for some of you here that's great, but not everyone can do that.
[/quote]

So you are applying your own experiences to every person on the planet? Just because you have problems with self-mastery does not mean every person on the earth needs sex.

PhuturePriest
Posted

[quote name='r2Dtoo' timestamp='1339792228' post='2445150']
I have tried living this life before myself it does not work, and is just flat out embarrassing besides. I mean telling a man twice my age that I masturbate, and how often I do it when I'm like 14, seriously? Why? And no, that he can't repeat it outside the Confessional didn't make it any less embarrassing. Once more, it didn't work, I tried everything I could think of, I got rid of vulgar music and started listening to Christian music, I prayed as often as I could, I tried working out, I tried everything for almost 10 years and [i]nothing helped[/i]. Those desires did not go away. Maybe they do for some of you here that's great, but not everyone can do that.
[/quote]

Wait, you said you tried once more? So you tried twice? How does twice apply in ten years? I'm no mathematician, but these numbers just don't add up.

Posted

[quote name='r2Dtoo' timestamp='1339792228' post='2445150']
I have tried living this life before myself it does not work, and is just flat out embarrassing besides. I mean telling a man twice my age that I masturbate, and how often I do it when I'm like 14, seriously? Why? And no, that he can't repeat it outside the Confessional didn't make it any less embarrassing. Once more, it didn't work, I tried everything I could think of, I got rid of vulgar music and started listening to Christian music, I prayed as often as I could, I tried working out, I tried everything for almost 10 years and [i]nothing helped[/i]. Those desires did not go away. Maybe they do for some of you here that's great, but not everyone can do that.
[/quote]

Been there done that, same thing. Literally for 9-10 years. Then I got engaged and was like "whoa I need to shape up for my soon to be wife". It was a struggle and I wasn't perfect. Then I got married, and [b]it was still difficult. [/b]Easier, but difficult. A wife is not a machine used to serve the man's desires. Finally it's not a problem anymore, but [b]it wasn't easy, it wasn't quick, and just being married isn't what cured it.[/b]

Posted (edited)

[quote name='FuturePriest387' timestamp='1339792478' post='2445158']
So you are applying your own experiences to every person on the planet? Just because you have problems with self-mastery does not mean every person on the earth needs sex.
[/quote]
Um, I never said everyone did, actually. Oh, and if anyone here is applying his own experiences to every person on the planet it's you. Everyone can be celibate because you can? Really?

[quote name='FuturePriest387' timestamp='1339792552' post='2445160']
Wait, you said you tried once more? So you tried twice? How does twice apply in ten years? I'm no mathematician, but these numbers just don't add up.
[/quote]
The "once more" was me reiterating that it did not work which I mentioned in the earlier sentence.

Edited by r2Dtoo
PhuturePriest
Posted

[quote name='r2Dtoo' timestamp='1339792743' post='2445164']
Um, I never said everyone did, actually. Oh, and if anyone here is applying his own experiences to every person on the planet it's you. Everyone can be celibate because you can? Really?


The "once more" was me reiterating that it did not work which I mentioned in the earlier sentence.
[/quote]

Everyone can be celibate because everything is possible with God. That was my point. Some people are not called to be and that is fine, but they could remain celibate technically.

It doesn't work after a few tries. You were in the Navy, you should know when you get knocked down you get back up on the horse. If it doesn't work at first, try it again. It will work eventually. It is not easy, it never was easy, and nobody claimed it was easy. I know just how not easy it is. But you know what? I tried again and again, and I eventually learned self-mastery. It's been almost a year now without one problem. It's possible. The question lies within how dedicated you are. It is of course easy to lose hope. I lost hope many times. But you try anyway. I know some people that had to try for fifteen years and they finally quit for good. I was a fortunate case and it was only a problem for me for three years. Every person is different and some struggle more. But that doesn't mean you get the luxury to quit, and it definitely doesn't give you the right to claim everyone needs sex because you have self-mastery problems.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...