Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

How Important Is Liking A Girl's Native Language?


Recommended Posts

Posted (edited)

[quote name='Aloysius' timestamp='1353622044' post='2514884']
I have a date with a Belgian girl on Tuesday (all Belgian students here treat weekends like weekdays and go home and weekdays like weekends for some reason, it is very strange).

Personally, I don't really like Dutch, lol. I prefer Spanish or French or Latin, heck I actually prefer other Germanic Languages over it, like German, even Irish with gutteral sounds is preferable, hard to explain but something about it just kind of annoys me lol, the gutteral sounds just don't fit to me like they kinda do in other languages. probably some kind of visceral culture shock/home sickness while I wait in line for food at the end of long days of classes has given me this prejudice. Although in particular situations any foreign language spoken by a girl can still be kind of attractive. (I woulda gone with a temperature adjective with an extra consonant but I always try to be extra polite about terms on phatmass, this isn't serious cats or anything this is a respectable establishment :cyclops:)

So how important is liking a girl's native language? lol :P jk on that question really but I'd be interested in stories from people who've dated outside of their own native language, but yeah, hmm.. interesting. in the past I have usually slow-played associations/friendships first before ever ending up in a date situation, this is probably the blindest I've been before a first date since 9th grade actually, all I really know is her first name and the language she speaks lol. just kinda threw it out there and am now waiting to see where the chips fall.
[/quote]

I've dated a few ladies whose native languages were Spanish, German, and Polish. I had Spanish in high school (plus I worked in a restaurant with a lot of Spanish-speakers), never took German, and had some Polish in college (plus my family ancestry is Polish and I live on the NW side of Chicago, so culturally she was not foreign to me at all!). So I had enough familiarity with Spanish and Polish to navigate the language differences. But what is also important is would you want your children to grow up bilingual learning both languages? Would you be willing to learn the language? Do you like the culture?

Edited by Norseman82
Posted

I only date women whose culture I hold in contempt.

theculturewarrior
Posted

Aloysius,


If you want to be in a serious relationship with a woman, you have to take her native culture seriously, and part of that, perhaps the most significant part, is her native language or the language her culture is attached to. I think that probably the reason you do not like Dutch is because you haven't looked at it in the right light. You haven't heard that one bit of poetry or prayer that allows you to look at the world through Flemish eyes. It might also help you to be self-aware of your own culture. I presume that you are a native English speaker, which probably means that your culture has been a spectacle for the entire world, and she might be wrestling with that herself.

I would say give a shot. It is a very superficial reason to reject what could be the love of your life.

Posted

Culture is silly. Anyone who takes it seriously is making a terrible mistake.

Posted

[quote name='theculturewarrior' timestamp='1353821282' post='2516210']
Aloysius,


If you want to be in a serious relationship with a woman, you have to take her native culture seriously, and part of that, perhaps the most significant part, is her native language or the language her culture is attached to. I think that probably the reason you do not like Dutch is because you haven't looked at it in the right light. You haven't heard that one bit of poetry or prayer that allows you to look at the world through Flemish eyes. It might also help you to be self-aware of your own culture. I presume that you are a native English speaker, which probably means that your culture has been a spectacle for the entire world, and she might be wrestling with that herself.

I would say give a shot. It is a very superficial reason to reject what could be the love of your life.
[/quote]
Basically, Al, you are a filthy racist. :|

theculturewarrior
Posted

It seems as though I have said something controversial, and I am clueless about what that could be. I do take culture very seriously, and I would be interested in knowing what mistake I am making.

Posted

[quote name='theculturewarrior' timestamp='1353821969' post='2516217']
It seems as though I have said something controversial, and I am clueless about what that could be. I do take culture very seriously, and I would be interested in knowing what mistake I am making.
[/quote]
You're taking something very silly seriously.

You might have a different definition of culture, though. I don't think it's controversial, at all. It's just nonsense.

Culture includes all the little social niceties, manner of dress, dances, songs, croutons like that. And it's all silliness. Some of it might have a practical function, but things like not showing the bottom of your foot, or wearing kilts, or setting table a certain way is all nonsense. I indulge in some of it, but it's not serious.

Posted

[quote name='Freedom' timestamp='1353653722' post='2515183']

I think I may be the wrong gender for you... your avatar is pleasant to look at, who is he? Is he a soccer/football player?
[/quote]
Your approach to dating is more like what I wish I had when I was younger.

My avatar is rather pleasant, isn't he? He currently coaches Real Madrid, formerly Chelsea, Porto, and Barcelona. He was The Tablet's (UK Catholic periodical) 2006 7th most influential lay Catholic. Beautifully arrogant with a reason to be, he has won some 20 trophies in football/soccer including at least one a year since 2005, perhaps since 2003 if memory serves. He speaks Catalan, Spanish, French, Portuguese, and English. He has an honorary masters degree from somewhere. He is a master strategist with a very Portuguese way style of communication that makes him fun to watch sometimes including an interview where he made his nickname "The Special One." He sadly had a 2 year affair while living in England as a coach (I think his wife was mostly living in continental Europe with the kids at the time), and if not for that and generally how well we would fit me, he far out does any man I'll probably ever get the chance to date.

Posted

Culture is something that is meant to be sc[color=#000000]r[/color]ewed around with. :hehe:

Posted

[img]http://img27.imageshack.us/img27/2381/deadwood003.png[/img]

Posted (edited)

[quote name='Winchester' timestamp='1353823187' post='2516234']
You're taking something very silly seriously.

You might have a different definition of culture, though. I don't think it's controversial, at all. It's just nonsense.

Culture includes all the little social niceties, manner of dress, dances, songs, croutons like that. And it's all silliness. Some of it might have a practical function, but things like not showing the bottom of your foot, or wearing kilts, or setting table a certain way is all nonsense. I indulge in some of it, but it's not serious.
[/quote]
[QUOTE=]In the 20th century, "culture" emerged as a central concept in [url="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anthropology"]anthropology[/url], encompassing the range of human phenomena that cannot be attributed to genetic inheritance. Specifically, the term "culture" in American anthropology had two meanings: (1) the evolved human capacity to classify and represent experiences with [url="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Symbol"]symbols[/url], and to act imaginatively and creatively; and (2) the distinct ways that people living in different parts of the world classified and represented their experiences, and acted creatively. [b]Distinctions are currently made between the physical artifacts created by a [url="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Society"]society[/url], its so-called [url="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Material_culture"]material culture[/url] and everything else,[sup][url="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Culture#cite_note-Macionis.2C_Gerber_2010_53-3"][3][/url][/sup] the intangibles such as language, customs, etc. that are the main referent of the term "culture".[/b][/QUOTE]
There are also aspects such as power distance, high or low context, individualism vs. collectivism, uncertainty avoidance, and values orientations affect a lot of how people behave and interaction. Understanding how different cultures relate to those in addition to the superficial things you mentioned allows a person to not only get along, but predict behavior in order to be more successful when working with them, and in your case, better screw with them.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Culture
[url="http://www.sagepub.com/upm-data/42958_2_The_Cultural_Context.pdf"]http://www.sagepub.c...ral_Context.pdf[/url]
Other source~communications class.

Edited by Light and Truth
theculturewarrior
Posted (edited)

Trying to sow dissent among the sheep by talking about racism.... that is not what culture is for and I am not for it either.. Culture is meant to be relished and celebrated. I am not talking about social niceties. I don't know which fork is the salad fork and I don't care, but I can appreciate food from all over the world. I can talk about the news with people from all over the world, not just the U.S. Culture is a lens that God has given us to perceive everything, even our Catholic Faith. For that reason, Aloysius (to whom my comment was originally addressed) I receommend giving the Dutch language a chance. Every language is beautiful, because it is an expression of the human imagination. You just have to get the point where you are able to see it through Flemish eyes.

[quote name='Nihil Obstat' timestamp='1353823403' post='2516239']
Culture is something that is meant to be sc[color=#000000]r[/color]ewed around with. :hehe:
[/quote]

Edited by theculturewarrior
Posted

[quote name='theculturewarrior' timestamp='1353828746' post='2516262']
I am not talking about social niceties.
[/quote]
Excellent, because that is the farthest thing from what I am doing at this precise moment. ;)

Posted

[quote name='Nihil Obstat' timestamp='1353828960' post='2516264']
Excellent, because that is the farthest thing from what I am doing at this precise moment. ;)
[/quote]
This is anything but the norm?

Posted

[quote name='Light and Truth' timestamp='1353830680' post='2516271']
This is anything but the norm?
[/quote]
Depends on the subject. I would say it is nearly a 50-50 split.

Posted

I'm just kidding around here tcw, I have a bachelors in Anthropology and I'm actually getting a master's degree in Anthropology right now and I am fully appreciative of cultures both the popular way the term is used and all the various ways it's constructed in different theories and deconstructed in others (really understanding the concept is much more complex than the wikipedia article would have it). If I in any way led you to believe I was serious about this thread, I apologize ;) Like I said at the beginning, any annoyance I ever have at Dutch is totally based on culture-shock, homesickness, tiredness and hunger while waiting in line for food lol. To the modern reflexive ethnographer, acknowledging these things keeps you from getting a false sense of objectivity that blinds you to the subjectivity that you can never escape.

And of course seeing as I don't even know the girl that well, this was just my silly way of telling phatmass I had a date and inviting all the advice and jeers of the phat-masses.

Posted

Like I said: Silliness.

Posted

[quote name='Nihil Obstat' timestamp='1353831140' post='2516277']
Depends on the subject. I would say it is nearly a 50-50 split.
[/quote]
Ok, that's about what I figured.

Posted

[quote name='Aloysius' timestamp='1353831272' post='2516278']culture-shock,
[/quote]
I figure a little culture shock every now and then is good for us. Forces us to grow and expand our ideas about humanity, human life, and interacting with this strange beings we call people.

Posted

[quote name='Light and Truth' timestamp='1353838378' post='2516287']
I figure a little culture shock every now and then is good for us. Forces us to grow and expand our ideas about humanity, human life, and interacting with this strange beings we call people.
[/quote]

Light and Truth is deep.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...