Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Why Am I Not A Phatmasser?


Recommended Posts

Posted

I rather like St. Hasa Perm

 

Or is it St. Hasa of Perm... the most Eastern City in Russia...?

 

http://www.uraltourism.com/perm.php

 

 

As far as the earlier options,  'Regulator of Phatmassers' might sound like a laxative, but probably better than 'Regulator of Butthurt'.   Just sayin....

Posted

I keep expecting to log in and find this thread locked with this picture from a mod:

1312079441945.jpg

  • 4 months later...
Anastasia13
Posted (edited)

It's also probably so that lurkers don't get confused and think you're Catholic when you post an opinion that might be contrary to what the Catholic Church believes, and no one is around to contradict you. Just like how Phisy is supposed to be someone who claims they are Catholic but doesn't agree with/follow/whatever all of the Church's teachings. There are HUNDREDS of lurkers at any given time (HI ALL!  YOU SHOULD MAKE AN ACCOUNT AND JOIN US! :) ). 

 

This is also why I cannot completely and only be identified as an Oriental Orthodox, and thus I cannot be accurately labeled here.

Edited by Light and Truth
Anastasia13
Posted (edited)

Because you're a non-Catholic.

 

A priest who does Tridentine Mass told me otherwise. I'm just not your kind.

Edited by Light and Truth
Nihil Obstat
Posted

A priest who does Tridentine Mass told me otherwise. I'm just not your kind.

047462c0.jpg

Anastasia13
Posted

Better question: why is this a thread?

 

Because I had a question and wanted to understand better (freaky, I know!) what I had said that made that change that seemed sudden after I had talked less about what church I attend

 

By the time I had the dignity and respect of a real answer, I had learned enough to disagree more with my title.

Anastasia13
Posted (edited)

This is what it is. If you want that thing you consider to be a more inclusive tag, convert. :like:

October, 2012, but special for people like this, we can now go with "Ash-hadu an la ilaha ill Allah."

Edited by Light and Truth
Posted

A priest who does Tridentine Mass told me otherwise. I'm just not your kind.

And he was right. The members of the ancient Apostolic Churches of the East are Catholics, they're just not Roman Catholics.

Basilisa Marie
Posted

LT, if you want to be recognized as Orthodox, you probably shouldn't be impersonating a Muslim. :)

Anastasia13
Posted (edited)

LT, if you want to be recognized as Orthodox, you probably shouldn't be impersonating a Muslim. :)

 

I want those who claim to follow Rome to acknowledge:

-the Roman documents that note that the Catholic church exists where the Eucharist is validly celebrated

-the unique relationship that exists from a Roman perspective with the Eastern churches not in full-communion as differentiated from its relationships with other groups

-the Roman documentation that we have the same faith

 

If representing a Catholic perspective as differentiated from another is important, then I believe this is an issue that goes beyond the recognition of my catholicism.  I am but one person. This affects many. I can give you several issues with my own labeling, but I believe this fails to fully represent the Catholic perspective, and that is troubling. There is a distinction between recognizing the administrative differences and disregarding any catholocity even from a Roman perspective-I support the first and object to the second, particularly on a Catholic forum.  I am thus not labeled accurately according to Rome or Etchmiadzin, in contradiction to your official faith and mine.  This issue is not whether or not I am recognized as Orthodox, but rather that.

 

If anyone truly believes I am Muslim, let them see my user title, my about me section in my profile, read more than a couple of my posts, and think about what might be left off vs. what might be acceptable from a Middle Eastern Christian perspective.

Edited by Light and Truth
Posted

I want those who claim to follow Rome to acknowledge:

-the Roman documents that note that the Catholic church exists where the Eucharist is validly celebrated

-the unique relationship that exists from a Roman perspective with the Eastern churches not in full-communion as differentiated from its relationships with other groups

-the Roman documentation that we have the same faith

 

If representing a Catholic perspective as differentiated from another is important, then I believe this is an issue that goes beyond the recognition of my catholicism.  I am but one person. This affects many. I can give you several issues with my own labeling, but I believe this fails to fully represent the Catholic perspective, and that is troubling. There is a distinction between recognizing the administrative differences and disregarding any catholocity even from a Roman perspective-I support the first and object to the second, particularly on a Catholic forum.  I am thus not labeled accurately according to Rome or Etchmiadzin, in contradiction to your official faith and mine.  This issue is not whether or not I am recognized as Orthodox, but rather that.

 

If anyone truly believes I am Muslim, let them see my user title, my about me section in my profile, read more than a couple of my posts, and think about what might be left off vs. what might be acceptable from a Middle Eastern Christian perspective.

 

LT, the tiny little place on our avatars is not meant to contain a theological treatise on what it means to be in communion with the Holy See. I don't think so anyway.

 

It doesn't make any judgment about your actual spiritual membership in the Church or the state of your soul or your status in the eyes of God. That isn't dUst's pay grade nor does he claim it is, that I have seen.

 

What is his job, I think, is making things on this website make sense.

 

I could be a rip-roaring gay-rights-organizing Communist atheist in the real world. But if I come on phatmass and claim to be Catholic and never utter one word about my true beliefs guess what! I will have and keep the member title you are so desperate for.

 

Or I can be the most wonderful Christian in the world in real life, 99.9999999999999% Catholic in my speech, actions and spiritual practices. But if I also happen to publicly post on phatmass, "I am Orthodox" I would get the non-Catholic label.

 

This is not casting me into outer darkness or proclaiming I am not a member of the true church or not part of the body of Christ etc etc etc.

 

It's a category on a web phorum.

 

That's it.

 

You write "this affects many" and I assure you that it doesn't. The number of Orthodox of any variety who care about the administrative system on a (relatively) obscure web forum are very few. In addition many Orthodox don't agree with the Roman position that we more or less have the same faith. Perhaps your true beef should be with them.

 

You're very obsessed with this, and if it bothers you that much the resolution is as simple as calling your local parish to being the RCIA process.

Posted

Light and Truth. What is your proposed solution?

Nihil Obstat
Posted

Obviously I do not speak for her, but I think most people would be content if she were in the same group as Apo.

Posted

Obviously I do not speak for her, but I think most people would be content if she were in the same group as Apo.

The religion field is freely chosen--so I don't understand why she is not?

Posted (edited)

Obviously I do not speak for her, but I think most people would be content if she were in the same group as Apo.

 

If by that you mean Eastern Catholic, note my objection here. While I do not use the EC tag and will not unless there is a corresponding Western/Roman tag, I object to it being conferred on a non-EC, meaning one who does not hold communion with Rome. Just as if I were on an Orthodox forum, I would not insist on being labeled Orthodox, but would take the tag made for me.

 

 

This entire thing was tl;dr. What's the problem with the Oriental Orthodox tag?

Edited by Byzantine
Posted

OK, I have created an all encompassing, "None of the above" field. Hope that works.

Posted

OK, I have created an all encompassing, "None of the above" field. Hope that works.

 

I love it!!

dominicansoul
Posted

dUSt should include "albigensian" :P

Nihil Obstat
Posted

I had thought we were talking about the member group, i.e. commoner, CM, non-Catholic, etc.. I thought that is the part that L&T objected to. Perhaps I misunderstood?

Posted

If by that you mean Eastern Catholic, note my objection here. While I do not use the EC tag and will not unless there is a corresponding Western/Roman tag, I object to it being conferred on a non-EC, meaning one who does not hold communion with Rome. Just as if I were on an Orthodox forum, I would not insist on being labeled Orthodox, but would take the tag made for me.

 

 

This entire thing was tl;dr. What's the problem with the Oriental Orthodox tag?

It is simply inaccurate to deny the name Catholic to Eastern Orthodox or Oriental Orthodox, because their Churches are true Churches and as true Churches they manifest the one Holy Catholic and Apostolic Church. I object to the denial of the word Catholic to members of those Churches, as Rome itself does in the various documents and agreements it has signed with those ancient Apostolic Churches.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...