Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Posted

My thoughts direct me towards the concept of the "Appeal to Common Practice."

 

-AK
 

What's appeal to common practice?

Posted

In choosing whom I go out with, I generally ignore all the criteria you've mentioned, tbh (except personality. And even then, I've gotten that one wrong before, so...)I don't think it's ok to say "I won't date/marry you based on whether or not you are X,Y,or Z."   I wouldn't date someone I wasn't attracted to, no. However, I wouldn't say no to someone just because they're not my idea of the ideal good looking opposite sex. To choose to only marry a virgin is to ignore EVERY OTHER FACET of that person; it is to focus solely on one aspect and that aspect reduces them to an object. To reduce a person to an object - especially a sexual object - is anti Christian. 

 

Deuteronomy 22

New International Version (NIV)

22 If you see your fellow Israelite’s ox or sheep straying, do not ignore it but be sure to take it back to its owner. 2 If they do not live near you or if you do not know who owns it, take it home with you and keep it until they come looking for it. Then give it back. 3 Do the same if you find their donkey or cloak or anything else they have lost. Do not ignore it.

4 If you see your fellow Israelite’s donkey or ox fallen on the road, do not ignore it. Help the owner get it to its feet.

5 A woman must not wear men’s clothing, nor a man wear women’s clothing, for the Lord your God detests anyone who does this.

6 If you come across a bird’s nest beside the road, either in a tree or on the ground, and the mother is sitting on the young or on the eggs, do not take the mother with the young. 7 You may take the young, but be sure to let the mother go, so that it may go well with you and you may have a long life.

8 When you build a new house, make a parapet around your roof so that you may not bring the guilt of bloodshed on your house if someone falls from the roof.

9 Do not plant two kinds of seed in your vineyard; if you do, not only the crops you plant but also the fruit of the vineyard will be defiled.[a]

10 Do not plow with an ox and a donkey yoked together.

11 Do not wear clothes of wool and linen woven together.

12 Make tassels on the four corners of the cloak you wear.

Marriage Violations

13 If a man takes a wife and, after sleeping with her, dislikes her 14 and slanders her and gives her a bad name, saying, “I married this woman, but when I approached her, I did not find proof of her virginity,” 15 then the young woman’s father and mother shall bring to the town elders at the gateproof that she was a virgin. 16 Her father will say to the elders, “I gave my daughter in marriage to this man, but he dislikes her. 17 Now he has slandered her and said, ‘I did not find your daughter to be a virgin.’ But here is the proof of my daughter’s virginity.” Then her parents shall display the cloth before the elders of the town, 18 and the elders shall take the man and punish him. 19 They shall fine him a hundred shekels[b] of silver and give them to the young woman’s father, because this man has given an Israelite virgin a bad name. She shall continue to be his wife; he must not divorce her as long as he lives.

20 If, however, the charge is true and no proof of the young woman’s virginity can be found, 21 she shall be brought to the door of her father’s house and there the men of her town shall stone her to death. She has done an outrageous thing in Israel by being promiscuous while still in her father’s house. You must purge the evil from among you.

22 If a man is found sleeping with another man’s wife, both the man who slept with her and the woman must die. You must purge the evil from Israel.

23 If a man happens to meet in a town a virgin pledged to be married and he sleeps with her, 24 you shall take both of them to the gate of that town and stone them to death—the young woman because she was in a town and did not scream for help, and the man because he violated another man’s wife. You must purge the evil from among you.

25 But if out in the country a man happens to meet a young woman pledged to be married and rapes her, only the man who has done this shall die. 26 Do nothing to the woman; she has committed no sin deserving death. This case is like that of someone who attacks and murders a neighbor, 27 for the man found the young woman out in the country, and though the betrothed woman screamed, there was no one to rescue her.

28 If a man happens to meet a virgin who is not pledged to be married and rapes her and they are discovered, 29 he shall pay her father fifty shekels[c] of silver. He must marry the young woman, for he has violated her. He can never divorce her as long as he lives.

30 A man is not to marry his father’s wife; he must not dishonor his father’s bed.[d]

Posted

We definitely have the right to sit down and figure out what it is we want or need in a potential spouse. Everyone is different. I know for some it can be hard marrying/giving yourself to someone knowing they've already shared that experience with someone else.

And this is one of the arguments for virgins wanting to marry virgins. The reason I came here is because there are people in my friends life who are praying that she does not find someone to marry because of her desire to only marry a virgin. The reason much of the discussion here is enlightening is due also to the fact that nearly all of the language, bad faith assumptions, and general arguments are common between quite a few people here and the aforementioned individuals in my friend's life. I came here wondering why people would do something so awful, and I had the "pleasure" of having it all demonstrated right before my eyes. Now I understand the anguish I see in her, and now I understand where it all comes from.

 

 

They tend to be eviscerated because -- and this is the honest truth -- most people we have seen in this community wanting to marry a virgin *are* unforgiving and condescending toward others.

I think there is a fairly obvious mistake in carrying over assumptions between people. Given my previous comment about how many here ignored my first few posts and mentioned completely unrelated things, I think this observation is well-founded.

 

 

That is not a reflection on you, Augusta. But conversations about this subject in the past have turned heated and very personal. People who are not virgins were treated as though they were unworthy of a virgin's love or damaged goods. A lot of people were hurt. Again, that has nothing to do with you ... but please try to be patient as this is a sensitive topic in the phamily.

While it doesn't immediately come across that way, I will trust the fact that it isn't a reflection on me (I'm only the messenger). Some people seem to overlook the fact that virgins are sometimes attacked for doing nothing wrong. It's not even logical (i.e. "Do the right things, get attacked anyway"). I will try to be sensitive, but keep in mind that I bear the sorrows of my close friend.


 

 

I mean this in charity and love: I can't help but notice your original post seems highly defensive and almost confrontational. Perhaps a little gentleness and a helpful explanation of why you'd like to marry a virgin would have better results.

 

As I mentioned in my original post, I'm here on a "fact-finding mission" on behalf of a friend, who, as I mentioned above, is very distraught at the similar treatment she has received.

 

 

God bless you. Welcome aboard!

Thank you. I hope to stay a while. We'll see how that goes.

 

 

-AK

 

 


 

FutureCarmeliteClaire
Posted

This is one of those threads that makes me feel like VS is a really, really pleasant place and that I should go back there.

 

dp34sKF.png

Posted

This is one of those threads that makes me feel like VS is a really, really pleasant place and that I should go back there.

VSers love their drama too. I have seen those threads that get locked. Y'all are wack. :|

FutureCarmeliteClaire
Posted

VSers love their drama too. I have seen those threads that get locked. Y'all are wack. :|

Lol, that was my point. I left VS months ago. The drama was one of the many reasons.

Posted

There are two sides to the coin.

 

What I think the virgins seeking virgins are saying is.

"I don't want to invest my time in someone who has been romantically, emotinally and sexually attached to another becuase I want for us to give this gift to eachother"

 

What I think many people express is:

Why hold my mistake, or others mistakes against me/them

 

What I believe is that in marriage two people sholder eachother's burdans.  In essance someone's past and sins become your own.  Lets say that there was a woman who was in her late 40's, dating a man who was in his late 40's when the possiblity of children was very small.  The man had 3 disabled adult nieces who were the children of his much older brother who he was expected to care for.  The woman would be within her right to say, I do not think that my ability to handle things extends to your 3 disabled nieces.  No one would blame her for this judgment...some would find her callous, but expecting her to take on the burdan is not reasonable.  Hopefully, the man will find a woman who is willing, but why should the woman be told she is "bad" for not wanting to take on the burdans?

This addresses partially what my friend feels. Her religious education (including the "chastity talks") have left a certain perspective with her. The term "temporal consequences" comes to mind. What I find interesting (and notable) is that the sensitivity non-virgins have to being rejected (or just the discussion of it) immediately reflects "temporal consequences" in my friend's mind. I think there is also some aspect that is emotionally painful to her; I cannot see why someone should marry another who's past actions cause them emotional pain. It seems imprudent and really quite nonsensical.

 

-AK
 

Posted

Augusta, you have not introduced yourself to us yet. :) Tell us all about yourself!

Posted

If it makes you feel any better, these threads usually Ho downhill so fast that the get closed, so you probably won't have to endure it for long.

I was a virgin, my husband wasn't. I didn't expect him to be either. It would have been cool if he had been, but he wasn't. It didn't make him defective, or non-marry able. He also has Schizophrenia. That also wasn't a deal-breaker. Now if he had been a smoker, forget about it.


Is someone allowed to reject a person because of a mental illness? What are they allowed to reject people on? What criteria do you think are appropriate, and which are not? (In your opinion, that is.)

 

-AK



To be fair to Augusta, I think the assumption here is that he is arguing like Norseman, and I am not sure that is entirely fair. I am finding him slightly disagreeable, but I think he is here essentially with good intentions.

ETA: I also think he is overreacting somewhat to critiques. :)

 

I'm a women. And I'm here for someone else.

 

-AK
 

Posted

Augusta, thanks for your reply.

 

I think I understand more of the situation now. It's sad that your friends are treating your other friend like that. It's not fair or Christian.

 

I want to make one point that I think is crucial here, though.

 

There is a BIG difference between saying "I would like to marry a virgin." and "If they're not a virgin, I won't even consider it."

 

One is a preference, and the other is shutting the door on good people who have made mistakes. At the very least, it's my belief that everyone deserves a fair chance. I think Jesus loved that way.

 

To pass over someone without getting to know them on the sole basis of their sexual status seems presumptive. Again, that's just my feeling. 

 

It's as if the thought is, "Oh, you're not a virgin? I'm sorry. You don't qualify to be with me anymore."

 

Note: I am NOT trying to be mean here and my intentions are pure. I am just explaining what that feels like from the position of the person who has sinned. 

Posted


 

I'm a women. And I'm here for someone else.

 

-AK
 

Neat. Tell us more. :bounce: Debates are more fun when you know the person with whom you are debating.

Posted (edited)

Neat. Tell us more. :bounce: Debates are more fun when you know the person with whom you are debating.

 

I'm not debating. I'm also stopping for a bit. I need people to read my replies before responding or posting something. Many have completely ignored everything I've said and simply posted what appears to be a "standard response." Also, I've explained a bit about myself in the original post. It seems everyone has pretended not to have read it...

 

@Hasan: Several of your comments are really quite crude. They border on hateful. Are you mocking or trolling?

 

 

-AK

Edited by Augusta
Posted

I'm not debating. I'm also stopping for a bit. I need people to read my replies before responding or posting something. Many have completely ignored everything I've said and simply posted what appears to be a "standard response."

 

@Hasan: Several of your comments are really quite crude. They border on hateful. Are you mocking or trolling?

 

 

-AK

Ok, pretend I said "discussing" instead. :smile3:

 

Hasan is a troll, but he is a pretty friendly one, so ignore him. Then if you mock him mercilessly sometime later on you will earn his respect.

Trial by fire and all that.

Posted (edited)

Not everyone here believes the same thing. Try to take things with a grain of salt on here.

 

p.s. A little kindness and charity goes a long, long way, even if they don't return the favor. Defensiveness breeds defensiveness.

Edited by MissyP89
Posted

@Hasan: Several of your comments are really quite crude. They border on hateful. Are you mocking or trolling?

 

 

-AK

 

I find this comment borderline hateful. I have reported you to the mods.  

Posted

Augusta, thanks for your reply.

 

I think I understand more of the situation now. It's sad that your friends are treating your other friend like that. It's not fair or Christian.

 

I want to make one point that I think is crucial here, though.

 

There is a BIG difference between saying "I would like to marry a virgin." and "If they're not a virgin, I won't even consider it."

 

One is a preference, and the other is shutting the door on good people who have made mistakes. At the very least, it's my belief that everyone deserves a fair chance. I think Jesus loved that way.

 

To pass over someone without getting to know them on the sole basis of their sexual status seems presumptive. Again, that's just my feeling. 

 

It's as if the thought is, "Oh, you're not a virgin? I'm sorry. You don't qualify to be with me anymore."

 

Note: I am NOT trying to be mean here and my intentions are pure. I am just explaining what that feels like from the position of the person who has sinned. 

 

out of props, but i'm totally propping this. :)

 

Posted

I find this comment borderline hateful. I have reported you to the mods.  

I find this comment borderline butthurt. I have reported you to the Babby Brigade.

Posted

out of props, but i'm totally propping this. :)

 

 

I love you too, babe. 

Posted

I find this comment borderline butthurt. I have reported you to the Babby Brigade.

:pinch:

Posted

So Augusta... what I am getting out of this is that there is some reason that your friend only wants a virgin, but it is a totally great Christian reason...but what is it??

 

And I agree that it is TERRIBLE that people would pray that she never finds someone, even if they question her motives, they are judging someone for perceived judging???? That's just silly.

Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.
×
×
  • Create New...