Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

GeorgiiMichael
Posted

I'm just going to interject about how this thread progressed, not about the actual subject matter.

 

Augusta, you're clearly very concerned for your friend, hence the start of this thread and the tone of your continued responses. However, much of the blame for people not "getting" what you're trying to say lies with you. Saying "re-read this post and that post" don't help on the phorum, or around the internet at large. When people aren't "getting it" the best thing to do is re-word your point and add additional details. You jumped right in and accused people of being judgmental instead of trying to help them to better understand. Even with our resident trolls, the people of Phatmass are incredibly charitable, and this thread would have gone better if you'd explained yourself more, earlier on. Your original post was incredibly vague as to your friend's position, and made it sound like she was being a bit of a snob.

 

The reason people have responded the way they have, is because they didn't have all the facts and because either they were themselves non-virgins or they know very nice non-virgins who have recommitted to a life of chastity; a similar situation seems to have been the catalyst for this discussion. I know when you brought up tattoos, I had a similar reaction. I'm a great guy, who happens to have 3 tattoos with the intention to get more. It raises my hackles a little bit when people say that they'd never marry a person with tattoos. It feels like I'm being discriminated against, along with my fellows who also have tattoos. Have people not acted charitably to your friend? Certainly, but I'd say that is "What Gives". Are they right? Definitely not. Your friend does have legitimate reasons for wanting to only marry a virgin. But when people feel like they are being discriminated against, and they don't have all of the facts, they tend to get defensive. 

 

I do hope you stay. You'd be a great addition to the phamily!

 

Pax,
GeorgiiMichael

Posted

So people who don't agree with you and your pal 100% have a "sickness"? Ok, then. I was pretty sure conversation was futile several pages ago,  now I have proof.

 

Did I say that? No. Why are you making those assumptions in bad faith? Please read the whole thread (including my replies). You've missed several of my points.

 

You aren't seeking genuine conversation, you want to be coddled and agreed with.

Actually I am, but thank you for assuming otherwise. I came here for answers. The way I got them told me a lot more than what they said.

 

 

-AK

Posted

*sigh* You missed the point by a long shot. Please. I'm begging you. Read the thread. Please.

 

Trust me. You'll probably want to delete your recent posts after.

 

 

-AK
 

 

*sigh* I know I said I would leave and normally I'm good at it, but I really think you're missing an important point.

It doesn't matter if it's you, your friend, or anyone else. Really, it doesn't.

 

The topic of this thread isn't specific to your friend or anyone else, no matter how much you may personally care and feel for your friend. Valuing virginity the same way you would value some physical characteristic or some other advantage in marrying someone is not the right reason to marry them. Period. 

Having said that, I think I've made my peace within this discussion. 

Posted

Just one last comment before I'm through. The encyclical on perpetual virginity has nothing to do with the discussion. What you're arguing over is the value of virginity that is given to another person through marriage. The encyclical discusses the gift of virginity to God and to society, which is a completely different concept since, duh, the virginity stays intact until death (and there is even discussion of a 'second virginity' after marriage ends with the death of a spouse and after reconciling one's sins, so if unspoiled virginity is good enough for God, why can't it be good enough for a mere human?). Even the discussion on marriage is strictly about the primacy of the state of perpetual virginity OVER marriage. Virginity given to a spouses in marriage in the sense in which Jason Evert speaks, however, is not what was being discussed.  

 

We've clearly misunderstood each other. It wasn't really intended to be related (as it's not the main question I'm trying to have answered). The progression:
 

"It strikes me as illogical to hold virginity so high."
"I think the Church does."
"False."
http://www.papalencyclicals.net/Pius12/P12SACRA.HTM

 

And I'm not really arguing over anything (at least intentionally). I feel I've been dragged into a debate that was never supposed to happen, all because others have jumped to conclusions. Anyhow, we'd better end this line of conversation as it's not productive.

 

 

-AK



If you didn't want people to comment on it, you probably shouldn't have asked the question in the first place. 

Please read the whole thread. Please. It's not about me, it's about my friend.

 

 

-AK


 

Posted

That's what happens sometimes on Phatmass. We're a BIG group of passionate people and sometimes our conversations are long and winding.

IcePrincessKRS
Posted

Did I say that? No. Why are you making those assumptions in bad faith? Please read the whole thread (including my replies). You've missed several of my points.

 

Actually I am, but thank you for assuming otherwise. I came here for answers. The way I got them told me a lot more than what they said.

 

 

-AK

 


I have read every single post in this thread. You've accused almost every person who has replied to you of having "bad faith assumptions" or being "judgmental" or "the attitude, or should I say 'sickness'." You throw around a lot of accusations without actually taking in any of the points that other people have offered. I'm not making assumptions in bad faith, I'm looking at what you've said and you don't come across as actually caring what we say to you unless we're agreeing with you. if we don't agree then we're some slew of bad stuff. It feels like you are making "bad faith assumptions" (by the way, that's a really stupid phrase) against all of us. You've accused people of making ugly statements about your friend and, really, no one has. The whole thread is just silly.

Posted

*sigh* I know I said I would leave and normally I'm good at it, but I really think you're missing an important point.

It doesn't matter if it's you, your friend, or anyone else. Really, it doesn't.

 

The topic of this thread isn't specific to your friend or anyone else, no matter how much you may personally care and feel for your friend. Valuing virginity the same way you would value some physical characteristic or some other advantage in marrying someone is not the right reason to marry them. Period.

My friend has never suggested the reason she would marry someone is because they were a virgin. You've misread my earlier posts. You don't do any justice to your points (or your time) if you argue for something no one is opposed to.

 

 

-AK
 

Posted

Good grief. Seven pages already. dUSt, where's the "cat-fight" emoticon? How come there's never an emoticon to express how I feel?!

Posted

I'm just going to interject about how this thread progressed, not about the actual subject matter.

 

Augusta, you're clearly very concerned for your friend, hence the start of this thread and the tone of your continued responses. However, much of the blame for people not "getting" what you're trying to say lies with you. Saying "re-read this post and that post" don't help on the phorum, or around the internet at large. When people aren't "getting it" the best thing to do is re-word your point and add additional details. You jumped right in and accused people of being judgmental instead of trying to help them to better understand. Even with our resident trolls, the people of Phatmass are incredibly charitable, and this thread would have gone better if you'd explained yourself more, earlier on. Your original post was incredibly vague as to your friend's position, and made it sound like she was being a bit of a snob.

 

The reason people have responded the way they have, is because they didn't have all the facts and because either they were themselves non-virgins or they know very nice non-virgins who have recommitted to a life of chastity; a similar situation seems to have been the catalyst for this discussion. I know when you brought up tattoos, I had a similar reaction. I'm a great guy, who happens to have 3 tattoos with the intention to get more. It raises my hackles a little bit when people say that they'd never marry a person with tattoos. It feels like I'm being discriminated against, along with my fellows who also have tattoos. Have people not acted charitably to your friend? Certainly, but I'd say that is "What Gives". Are they right? Definitely not. Your friend does have legitimate reasons for wanting to only marry a virgin. But when people feel like they are being discriminated against, and they don't have all of the facts, they tend to get defensive. 

 

I do hope you stay. You'd be a great addition to the phamily!

 

Pax,
GeorgiiMichael

 


i heart you. :)
 

Posted


I have read every single post in this thread. You've accused almost every person who has replied to you of having "bad faith assumptions" or being "judgmental" or "the attitude, or should I say 'sickness'." You throw around a lot of accusations without actually taking in any of the points that other people have offered. I'm not making assumptions in bad faith, I'm looking at what you've said and you don't come across as actually caring what we say to you unless we're agreeing with you. if we don't agree then we're some slew of bad stuff. It feels like you are making "bad faith assumptions" (by the way, that's a really stupid phrase) against all of us. You've accused people of making ugly statements about your friend and, really, no one has. The whole thread is just silly.

You're free to make that call.

 

 

without actually taking in any of the points that other people have offered

You don't honestly believe that to be true, do you? Of course I've taken in points made by others.

 

Given the misunderstanding evident in your reply, I think it's best for both of us if we just end this line of conversation.

 

 

-AK
 

GeorgiiMichael
Posted

Did you read my post or....

Posted (edited)

Augusta, EVERYONE HERE AGREES that your friend was treated BADLY and that what they did was WRONG.

 

We agree. Attitudes like that are wrong. We are NOT saying the same things as those people.

 

Please take a deep breath. It's OK. No one is attacking virgins, virginity, or who she wants to marry.

 

The way you're behaving isn't conducive to a productive, healthy, charitable discussion. Even your initial post was hostile and accusatory. That's not the right way to start things off.

Edited by MissyP89
IcePrincessKRS
Posted

 

 

You don't honestly believe that to be true, do you?

 

Yes, yes I do.

Posted

Augusta, EVERYONE HERE AGREES that your friend was treated BADLY and that what they did was WRONG.

 

We agree. Attitudes like that are wrong. We are NOT saying the same things as those people.

 

Please take a deep breath. It's OK. No one is attacking virgins, virginity, or who she wants to marry.

 

The way you're behaving isn't conducive to a productive, healthy, charitable discussion. Even your initial post was hostile and accusatory. That's not the right way to start things off.

 


i heart you too. :love:

GeorgiiMichael
Posted


i heart you. :)
 

 

 

Augusta, EVERYONE HERE AGREES that your friend was treated BADLY and that what they did was WRONG.

 

We agree. Attitudes like that are wrong. We are NOT saying the same things as those people.

 

Please take a deep breath. It's OK. No one is attacking virgins, virginity, or who she wants to marry.

 

The way you're behaving isn't conducive to a productive, healthy, charitable discussion. Even your initial post was hostile and accusatory. That's not the right way to start things off.

 

I ran out of props but you both have them in my heart.

Posted

Valuing virginity the same way you would value some physical
characteristic or some other advantage in marrying someone is not the
right reason to marry them. Period

 

I don't get this and wonder if it is English.

 

I don't get what the angst is in this thread.

There is nothing wrong with having "virgin" as one of your "must haves" for a potential spouse. So, you virgin seekers, cross off all the non-virgins on your list. And all you non-virgins cross off the virgin seekers. See how this works?

 

eliminate the butthurt

Posted


i heart you too. :love:

I heart your arm. :love:
GeorgiiMichael
Posted

I don't get this and wonder if it is English.

 

I don't get what the angst is in this thread.

There is nothing wrong with having "virgin" as one of your "must haves" for a potential spouse. So, you virgin seekers, cross off all the non-virgins on your list. And all you non-virgins cross off the virgin seekers. See how this works?

 

eliminate the butthurt

 

But the butts hurt so much. 

 

SO MUCH.

Posted

I don't get this and wonder if it is English.

 

I don't get what the angst is in this thread.

There is nothing wrong with having "virgin" as one of your "must haves" for a potential spouse. So, you virgin seekers, cross off all the non-virgins on your list. And all you non-virgins cross off the virgin seekers. See how this works?

 

eliminate the butthurt

 

LOL.

Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.
×
×
  • Create New...