CatholicsAreKewl Posted April 22, 2013 Posted April 22, 2013 That was my point. Mass murder and such are not intrinsically contradictory to a lack of belief in God. I never claimed an atheist cannot have morality. I've never heard of this supposed journal entry. Source? It seems if it existed, some anti-Catholic would have quoted it to me by now. There's no evidence that he considered himself Catholic in his adult life. Now that's just not fair to Hitler. I kid, I kid. Sorry, apparently it was in the diary of General Gerhard Engel that Hitler said that to him. Regardless, I think what Hitler called himself was irrelevant. He was obviously at odds with Church teaching.
CatholicsAreKewl Posted April 22, 2013 Posted April 22, 2013 (edited) Please apply this logic to the Boston bombings whereby one was well educated, living here since the age of 8, the other wanting to fight in the Olympics. Or to the Beltway Sniper or the Fort Hood murderer. And where are these well educated muslims, here in the US marching in the streets over the crimes against humanity by those who they share a "faith?" You're right. But these people do not represent a majority. I agree with the notion that Muslims should be more vocal on their stances against terrorism. If you were to ask the overwhelming majority of Muslims in America, they would be agains these acts. The Qur'an has a hard stance against terrorism (5:32): "For that cause We decreed for the Children of Israel that whosoever killeth a human being for other than manslaughter or corruption in the earth, it shall be as if he had killed all mankind, and whoso saveth the life of one, it shall be as if he had saved the life of all mankind." There are some groups, like Al Qaeda, that have a funny way of twisting this logic to allow it in some conditions (They used the fact that the United States is a Democracy to claim its citizens are directly responsible for American foreign policies). The point of islam is world domination, all must be converted to this "faith" or they are to be killed. No, that is not completely accurate. traditional Sunni Islam argues for global conquest but I think most traditionalists have other non-violent methods of achieving this goal. The "convert or die" ordeal applies to pagans. Christians and Jews are protected as long as they pay a tax. There are some that argue that modern day Christians are technically pagan because they worship three Gods (in reference to the trinity). However, I'm pretty sure this is a rarely held view. There are 109 verses in their "koran" that state to kill non-believers and those who do not join the fight on the non-believers are hypocrites or told their god will send them to hell. This is the interesting part. Many Muslims will argue that the Qur'an is referring to the specific battles waged at the time of Muhammad. They'll also argue that these battles were defensive in nature. Regardless, it's extremely inaccurate to say that most Muslims follow a literal application of these verses in modern times. With this as the basis of their faith, it is impossible to be a "faith" of peace and we see this ALL around the globe. Wherever they set up, they do much harm. Whether it is moving into Italy and suing to have the Crucifix removed from public buildings, to mercilessly murdering innocents. It is isn't lack of education, it is the "religion" itself that is the issue and at some point, our open arms must turn to containing them where they can do no more harm. This is a point made by some who have left Islam. However, It's hard to label a whole religion as evil or bad. That's way too general. You can say Salafi Islam is horrible or the traditional jurisprudence is horrible. However, the overwhelming majority of Muslims do not follow the extreme version of Islam. Peter Kreeft does a good job of explaining what I'm saying: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UMtqCapeVRA Truthfully, these people are still fighting the Crusades, believing they can carry on as they did in the 1300's and we are acting like nothing more than sheep to be slaughtered. Well, some are. Catholics and Muslims have a lot of misconceptions about each other. You can easily tell through reading works by Muslims that many Islamic scholars are extremely ignorant about what Christians (they usually specifically refer to Catholics) believe. Catholics also have this problem with Islam. I think the way to change this is through dialogue. Edited April 22, 2013 by CatholicsAreKewl
StMichael Posted April 22, 2013 Posted April 22, 2013 On 9/11, on 5th avenue in Brooklyn, after the towers fell, the islamic residents were in the streets handing out candy. The firehouse that was right around the corner, half the men from that house were killed. I am sorry, if the majority are not jihadists, they celebrate it, if they don't celebrate it, they say nothing to stop it. What happened after Mehmet Ali AÄŸca was almost successful in murdering the leader of the Roman Catholic Church? Nothing. Other faiths, be it Christian, Jewish, Jehovah Witness, etc. have done what to these people? In the US alone, there has been 4 deadly attacks in just over 2 months: 2/7/13 - Buena Vista, NJ - A Muslim targets and beheads two Christian Coptic immigrants. 3/24/13 - Ashtabula, OH - A Muslim convert walks into a church service with a Quran and guns down his Christian father while praising Allah. 4/15/13 - Boston, MA - Foreign-born Muslims describing themselves as 'very religious' detonate two bombs packed with ball bearings at the Boston Marathon, killing three people and causing several more to lose limbs. 4/19/13 - Boston, MA - Jihadists gun down a university police officer sitting in his car. Various others: 8/6/2003 - Houston, TX - After undergoing a 'religious revival', a Saudi college student slashes the throat of a Jewish student with a 4" butterfly knife, nearly decapitating the young man. 6/16/2006 - Baltimore, MD - A 62-year-old Jewish moviegoer is shot to death by a Muslim gunman in an unprovoked terror attack. 6/25/2006 - Denver, CO - Saying that it was 'Allah's choice', a Muslim shoots four of his co-workers and a police officer. 7/28/2006 - Seattle, WA - An 'angry' Muslim-American uses a young girl as hostage to enter a local Jewish center, where he shoots six women, one of whom dies. 2/13/2007 - Salt Lake City, UT - A Muslim immigrant goes on a shooting rampage at a mall, targeting people buying Valentine's Day cards at a gift shop and killing five. 2/12/2009 - Buffalo, NY - The founder of a Muslim TV station beheads his wife in the hallway for seeking a divorce. 4/12/2009 - Phoenix, AZ - A man shoots his brother-in-law and another man to death after finding out that they visited a strip club, in contradiction to Islamic values. 12/4/2009 - Binghamton, NY -A non-Muslim Islamic studies professor is stabbed to death by a Muslim grad student in revenge for 'persecuted' Muslims. In total, there have been over 70 attacks in the US by muslims resulting in the death of over 3100 people and 1,000's more who have been maimed, injured, etc. At what point do we not hold this "faith" responsible? You're right. But these people do not represent a majority. I agree with the notion that Muslims should be more vocal on their stances against terrorism. If you were to ask the overwhelming majority of Muslims in America, they would be agains these acts. The Qur'an has a hard stance against terrorism (5:32): "For that cause We decreed for the Children of Israel that whosoever killeth a human being for other than manslaughter or corruption in the earth, it shall be as if he had killed all mankind, and whoso saveth the life of one, it shall be as if he had saved the life of all mankind." There are some groups, like Al Qaeda, that have a funny way of twisting this logic to allow it in some conditions (They used the fact that the United States is a Democracy to claim its citizens are directly responsible for American foreign policies). No, that is not completely accurate. traditional Sunni Islam argues for global conquest but I think most traditionalists have other non-violent methods of achieving this goal. The "convert or die" ordeal applies to pagans. Christians and Jews are protected as long as they pay a tax. There are some that argue that modern day Christians are technically pagan because they worship three Gods (in reference to the trinity). However, I'm pretty sure this is a rarely held view. This is the interesting part. Many Muslims will argue that the Qur'an is referring to the specific battles waged at the time of Muhammad. They'll also argue that these battles were defensive in nature. Regardless, it's extremely inaccurate to say that most Muslims follow a literal application of these verses in modern times. This is a point made by some who have left Islam. However, It's hard to label a whole religion as evil or bad. That's way too general. You can say Salafi Islam is horrible or the traditional jurisprudence is horrible. However, the overwhelming majority of Muslims do not follow the extreme version of Islam. Peter Kreeft does a good job of explaining what I'm saying: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UMtqCapeVRA Well, some are. Catholics and Muslims have a lot of misconceptions about each other. You can easily tell through reading works by Muslims that many Islamic scholars are extremely ignorant about what Christians (they usually specifically refer to Catholics) believe. Catholics also have this problem with Islam. I think the way to change this is through dialogue.
CatholicsAreKewl Posted April 22, 2013 Posted April 22, 2013 (edited) On 9/11, on 5th avenue in Brooklyn, after the towers fell, the islamic residents were in the streets handing out candy. The firehouse that was right around the corner, half the men from that house were killed. I am sorry, if the majority are not jihadists, they celebrate it, if they don't celebrate it, they say nothing to stop it. Well, it's hard to stop a group who isn't under your control. Islam isn't a unified structure like Catholicism is. The majority who don't believe in the hard-line beliefs won't have much of an impact on those that have their own view of the religion. What happened after Mehmet Ali AÄŸca was almost successful in murdering the leader of the Roman Catholic Church? Nothing. Other faiths, be it Christian, Jewish, Jehovah Witness, etc. have done what to these people? My friend, you have many strong points. This example weakens your arguments. Mehmet has made statements calling himself Christ eternal. He does not seem mentally stable enough to represent any group. In the US alone, there has been 4 deadly attacks in just over 2 months: 2/7/13 - Buena Vista, NJ - A Muslim targets and beheads two Christian Coptic immigrants. 3/24/13 - Ashtabula, OH - A Muslim convert walks into a church service with a Quran and guns down his Christian father while praising Allah. 4/15/13 - Boston, MA - Foreign-born Muslims describing themselves as 'very religious' detonate two bombs packed with ball bearings at the Boston Marathon, killing three people and causing several more to lose limbs. 4/19/13 - Boston, MA - Jihadists gun down a university police officer sitting in his car. Various others: 8/6/2003 - Houston, TX - After undergoing a 'religious revival', a Saudi college student slashes the throat of a Jewish student with a 4" butterfly knife, nearly decapitating the young man. 6/16/2006 - Baltimore, MD - A 62-year-old Jewish moviegoer is shot to death by a Muslim gunman in an unprovoked terror attack. 6/25/2006 - Denver, CO - Saying that it was 'Allah's choice', a Muslim shoots four of his co-workers and a police officer. 7/28/2006 - Seattle, WA - An 'angry' Muslim-American uses a young girl as hostage to enter a local Jewish center, where he shoots six women, one of whom dies. 2/13/2007 - Salt Lake City, UT - A Muslim immigrant goes on a shooting rampage at a mall, targeting people buying Valentine's Day cards at a gift shop and killing five. 2/12/2009 - Buffalo, NY - The founder of a Muslim TV station beheads his wife in the hallway for seeking a divorce. 4/12/2009 - Phoenix, AZ - A man shoots his brother-in-law and another man to death after finding out that they visited a strip club, in contradiction to Islamic values. 12/4/2009 - Binghamton, NY -A non-Muslim Islamic studies professor is stabbed to death by a Muslim grad student in revenge for 'persecuted' Muslims. In total, there have been over 70 attacks in the US by muslims resulting in the death of over 3100 people and 1,000's more who have been maimed, injured, etc. At what point do we not hold this "faith" responsible? Well, I am not saying we shouldn't place blame on religious beliefs but we cannot generalize a whole religion. I am not trying to be a hippy dippy liberal by saying this. It's actually inaccurate. The traditional versions of Islam that seek to conquer the world, allow for sex slaves, and call for attempts to invade a non-muslim nation at least once a year are to blame. We have to be careful not to group all Muslims with those that hold these beliefs. Edited April 22, 2013 by CatholicsAreKewl
EmilyAnn Posted April 22, 2013 Posted April 22, 2013 On 9/11, on 5th avenue in Brooklyn, after the towers fell, the islamic residents were in the streets handing out candy. The firehouse that was right around the corner, half the men from that house were killed. I am sorry, if the majority are not jihadists, they celebrate it, if they don't celebrate it, they say nothing to stop it. What happened after Mehmet Ali AÄŸca was almost successful in murdering the leader of the Roman Catholic Church? Nothing. Other faiths, be it Christian, Jewish, Jehovah Witness, etc. have done what to these people? In the US alone, there has been 4 deadly attacks in just over 2 months: 2/7/13 - Buena Vista, NJ - A Muslim targets and beheads two Christian Coptic immigrants. 3/24/13 - Ashtabula, OH - A Muslim convert walks into a church service with a Quran and guns down his Christian father while praising Allah. 4/15/13 - Boston, MA - Foreign-born Muslims describing themselves as 'very religious' detonate two bombs packed with ball bearings at the Boston Marathon, killing three people and causing several more to lose limbs. 4/19/13 - Boston, MA - Jihadists gun down a university police officer sitting in his car. Various others: 8/6/2003 - Houston, TX - After undergoing a 'religious revival', a Saudi college student slashes the throat of a Jewish student with a 4" butterfly knife, nearly decapitating the young man. 6/16/2006 - Baltimore, MD - A 62-year-old Jewish moviegoer is shot to death by a Muslim gunman in an unprovoked terror attack. 6/25/2006 - Denver, CO - Saying that it was 'Allah's choice', a Muslim shoots four of his co-workers and a police officer. 7/28/2006 - Seattle, WA - An 'angry' Muslim-American uses a young girl as hostage to enter a local Jewish center, where he shoots six women, one of whom dies. 2/13/2007 - Salt Lake City, UT - A Muslim immigrant goes on a shooting rampage at a mall, targeting people buying Valentine's Day cards at a gift shop and killing five. 2/12/2009 - Buffalo, NY - The founder of a Muslim TV station beheads his wife in the hallway for seeking a divorce. 4/12/2009 - Phoenix, AZ - A man shoots his brother-in-law and another man to death after finding out that they visited a strip club, in contradiction to Islamic values. 12/4/2009 - Binghamton, NY -A non-Muslim Islamic studies professor is stabbed to death by a Muslim grad student in revenge for 'persecuted' Muslims. In total, there have been over 70 attacks in the US by muslims resulting in the death of over 3100 people and 1,000's more who have been maimed, injured, etc. At what point do we not hold this "faith" responsible? Is the Christian faith responsible for the evil that has been committed in its name? I know a great many Muslims who are just as horrified and upset by those events as you are and fully condemn them. Would you blame the whole Christian faith if those crimes were committed by Christians? Should all Christians be judged by the Westboro Baptist church? You cannot assume that all members of a faith are the same. I grew up in the Middle East during the start of the Iraq War. I am well aware of the evils that have been committed in the name of Islam. But I also know that there are a great many Muslims who work to stop these evils. You cannot just look at one side of the picture.
CatholicsAreKewl Posted April 22, 2013 Posted April 22, 2013 Is the Christian faith responsible for the evil that has been committed in its name? I know a great many Muslims who are just as horrified and upset by those events as you are and fully condemn them. Would you blame the whole Christian faith if those crimes were committed by Christians? Should all Christians be judged by the Westboro Baptist church? You cannot assume that all members of a faith are the same. I grew up in the Middle East during the start of the Iraq War. I am well aware of the evils that have been committed in the name of Islam. But I also know that there are a great many Muslims who work to stop these evils. You cannot just look at one side of the picture. True, or the whole drone strike video game kill machine we have in foreign countries that have been killing innocent people.
Anastasia13 Posted April 23, 2013 Posted April 23, 2013 But I also know that there are a great many Muslims who work to stop these evils. You cannot just look at one side of the picture. Muslims killed my great grandparents' families, and a Muslim saved my great grandfather's life.
Guest Posted April 27, 2013 Posted April 27, 2013 (edited) Future Priest....I agree with everything the Church teaches...Every single thing...Lately I have doubts about the old testement being actually real history...And I don't think God really wanted children and women to be killed...And also ok'd women to be raped...If you can show me in the Catholic Rule Book where having these views put me at odds with the Church please do...Because if I agree with everything else the Church teaches then I will work out these issues too...And no I don't like religion...Not at all...But if Catholicism is the only true religion then it shouldn't matter that I don't like the false ones...If not liking religion is against the rules in the Catholic Rule Book again please show me where...And I have no problem with muslims who are peacefull...I never stated I did...I do have a problem with islam though....I pray for the day it doesn't exist... Edited April 27, 2013 by Guest
Adrestia Posted April 27, 2013 Posted April 27, 2013 (edited) One of my very good friends here in Texas is a Sunni Muslim. I recently asked her about the hierarchy in Islam. Apparently, there is none. There is no system in place to remove an Imam who is distorting their teachings for political or violent motives. When I told her (and another Sunni Muslim friend of hers) that Catholic Bishops can discipline or remove a priest who has distorted our teachings, her response was, "Can we borrow him?" I have many Muslim friends. They more disgusted with the terrorists than we can comprehend. Think about the Westboro Baptist Church - pretend for a moment that they claimed to be Catholic and were killing people - now add on the fact that there is no official hierarchy to refute their affiliation with our church - that's how they feel. By the way, it was a Muslim Imam and members of a Muslim community that tipped off the Canadians to stop the al Qaeda train attack. Edited April 27, 2013 by Adrestia
Adrestia Posted April 27, 2013 Posted April 27, 2013 Another thing that I found interesting was that she said she didn't feel she should have to apologize for the actions of other people just because those other people claim to be Muslim. From her point of view, the person committing the sin as accountable to God. If the person is an Imam who leads others to sin, that Imam is accountable for all the sins of those he has led astray. I have no idea how common this type of thought is in Muslim communities. But, if it is widespread, it might explain why many of the rational Muslims don't speak out more loudly against the terrorists.
PhuturePriest Posted April 27, 2013 Posted April 27, 2013 Future Priest....I agree with everything the Church teaches...Every single thing...Lately I have doubts about the old testement being actually real history...And I don't think God really wanted children and women to be killed...And also ok'd women to be raped...If you can show me in the Catholic Rule Book where having these views put me at odds with the Church please do...Because if I agree with everything else the Church teaches then I will work out these issues too...And no I don't like religion...Not at all...But if Catholicism is the only true religion then it shouldn't matter that I don't like the false ones...If not liking religion is against the rules in the Catholic Rule Book again please show me where...And I have no problem with muslims who are peacefull...I never stated I did...I do have a problem with islam though....I pray for the day it doesn't exist... I was very harsh to you at first and I apologize. I wish I hadn't said those things. As for this post, I can't answer the first few questions. However, being at odds with religion and being Catholic is contradictory. Catholicism IS a religion. In fact, it's THE religion. So saying you don't like religion is contradictory, because if you don't like religion, you don't like Catholicism. Now, if you want to say you don't like false religions, join the club. I'm pretty sure you're supposed to not like lies and falsehoods that have led people away from God's Church.
CatholicsAreKewl Posted April 27, 2013 Posted April 27, 2013 (edited) One of my very good friends here in Texas is a Sunni Muslim. I recently asked her about the hierarchy in Islam. Apparently, there is none. There is no system in place to remove an Imam who is distorting their teachings for political or violent motives. When I told her (and another Sunni Muslim friend of hers) that Catholic Bishops can discipline or remove a priest who has distorted our teachings, her response was, "Can we borrow him?" I have many Muslim friends. They more disgusted with the terrorists than we can comprehend. Think about the Westboro Baptist Church - pretend for a moment that they claimed to be Catholic and were killing people - now add on the fact that there is no official hierarchy to refute their affiliation with our church - that's how they feel. By the way, it was a Muslim Imam and members of a Muslim community that tipped off the Canadians to stop the al Qaeda train attack. You're right. Muslims don't really have a hierarchy, unless we're talking about Shi'ite Islam, which is a parody of the Catholic Church. Edited April 27, 2013 by CatholicsAreKewl
4588686 Posted April 27, 2013 Posted April 27, 2013 . At what point do we not hold this "faith" responsible? That's a great point. I also hold Christianity responsible for ted Haggard holding meth for a friend and getting sensual massages from a male callboy
CatholicsAreKewl Posted April 27, 2013 Posted April 27, 2013 (edited) Another thing that I found interesting was that she said she didn't feel she should have to apologize for the actions of other people just because those other people claim to be Muslim. From her point of view, the person committing the sin as accountable to God. If the person is an Imam who leads others to sin, that Imam is accountable for all the sins of those he has led astray. I have no idea how common this type of thought is in Muslim communities. But, if it is widespread, it might explain why many of the rational Muslims don't speak out more loudly against the terrorists. I was going to post about this exact thing. Many Muslims don't feel obligated to speak out against certain groups because they feel these groups are a minority that they can't control. However, I can't ignore the fact that Islam DOES have problems. Muftis can interpret certain scriptures as violent or passive depending on what their goals are. The fact that this can occur is alarming. The overwhelming majority of Muslims are not bad people. However, that doesn't mean that religious leaders in Sunni Islam cannot make a strong argument for the extreme interpretation of the Qur'an and the Hadiths if they so wish to. Edited April 27, 2013 by CatholicsAreKewl
4588686 Posted April 27, 2013 Posted April 27, 2013 Another thing that I found interesting was that she said she didn't feel she should have to apologize for the actions of other people just because those other people claim to be Muslim. From her point of view, the person committing the sin as accountable to God. If the person is an Imam who leads others to sin, that Imam is accountable for all the sins of those he has led astray. I have no idea how common this type of thought is in Muslim communities. But, if it is widespread, it might explain why many of the rational Muslims don't speak out more loudly against the terrorists. How many times have you publicly denounced the Serbian Orthodox Church for it's support of the Bosnian Serb army during the Bosnian civil war? Or the Russian Orthodox Church for it's support of the Russian army's criminal campaign in Chechnya? I don't see why 'more Muslims not speaking out' is viewed as something puzzling. Do you apologize for everything bad done in the name of Christianity or by Christians? More importantly, how are 'average Muslims' supposed to speak out? I just don't get this idea. Is the idea that Fox is going to run an hour long special on Ahmed the Arab guy who runs a regionally themed grocery down the street's opinion of the September 11th attacks? Most Muslim organizations do release statements but they usually don't get published. Nor should it. The opinion of x school's MSA on event y isn't really an valid news story. Unless you're talking about my school where there was a terrorist attack.
Gabriela Posted April 28, 2013 Posted April 28, 2013 I'd like to know what all those bashing Islam/Muslims would propose we do about Islam/Muslims.
Adrestia Posted April 28, 2013 Posted April 28, 2013 How many times have you publicly denounced the Serbian Orthodox Church for it's support of the Bosnian Serb army during the Bosnian civil war? Or the Russian Orthodox Church for it's support of the Russian army's criminal campaign in Chechnya? I don't see why 'more Muslims not speaking out' is viewed as something puzzling. Do you apologize for everything bad done in the name of Christianity or by Christians? More importantly, how are 'average Muslims' supposed to speak out? I just don't get this idea. Is the idea that Fox is going to run an hour long special on Ahmed the Arab guy who runs a regionally themed grocery down the street's opinion of the September 11th attacks? Most Muslim organizations do release statements but they usually don't get published. Nor should it. The opinion of x school's MSA on event y isn't really an valid news story. Unless you're talking about my school where there was a terrorist attack. Yes. When someone who claims to be Catholic twists sacred scripture for evil ends, I apologize.
Guest Posted April 28, 2013 Posted April 28, 2013 Future Priest you should of said those things...No need to say sorry...I actually agree with you...I was very angry when I wrote that post...And a lot of my post lately have been filled with doubt and questioning things...If God is real which I believe He is He will pull me through this and my faith will be even stronger...I see what you are saying about Catholicism being a religion...So I agree with you there...I just don't like how religion can become all rules and regulations and love can seem to be left out...To me that is what the early church looked like to me looking back on it...Just my opinion...Not saying I'm right...And that's what most other religions look like to me now...Rules and regulations and men telling everyone else what God wants and expects...And in the worse cases killing other people because they don't agree.
Guest Posted April 28, 2013 Posted April 28, 2013 (edited) Todays reading and Homily was about Love...Jesus said I give you a new commandment and that is to love one another as I have loved you...That's the only real religion to me...Love....And I have found love in Catholicism...On the other hand I don't see how one could find love in islam...I really don't... Edited April 28, 2013 by Guest
Guest Posted April 28, 2013 Posted April 28, 2013 You can't leave islam and if you do you're put to death....That isn't love...That's the farthest thing from love there is...
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now