Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

What You Don't Know Can Hurt You


Recommended Posts

Posted

Wait, I'm confused... am I supposed to be asking legitimate question to FH?  Or am I supposed to be discussing the AZ law?

 

I have no idea. Right now all people are doing is bickering intention for who said what and what it meant.

 

Besides, the AZ law is big news.

Posted

I have to say, my coming out thread was much more straightforward.

 

rimshot-gary.gif

The Bus Station
Posted

That is too perfect. Stolen.


 

IcePrincessKRS
Posted

I guess I am also curious about the need to "come out".  Because it seems these days with sports stars and movie stars it's just something popular to do.

 

 

 

I'm going to hazard a guess here. Given the other things I've seen Franny post here over the years I think she basically wanted to be honest with who she is and her worldview as a gay Catholic woman. I recall a thread she posted awhile back about being authentic. From what I've seen from the few gay people that I know not everyone comes to grips with it at the same time. There is no magical age where it clicks. Sure, she mentioned it before, and apparently it didn't impact anyone else here very much. But it's clearly impacting HER to admit to herself and others that she has these attractions and they're not going away, they're not minor, and if she wishes to remain a faithful Catholic she has a lot of sacrifices to make. That's HARD. I don't really feel like she should be expected to shoulder that in silence. I don't know what she was hoping for when she started this thread, but I do think it was a way of reaching out.

 

I'm not looking to argue, there are way too many combative posts in this thread already. I'm just trying to give some sort of answer to your question. I don't think it's a simple answer because it's so deeply entwined in emotions.

Posted

I really dont think the Catholic church is equipped to handle their gay members as of yet. Their methods as of right now are resist, resist, resist. I think it leads a lot of gay members to feel a little lost without resources to help them wade in the waters of reconciling the love of the faith with their orientation.

Posted (edited)

I'm going to hazard a guess here. Given the other things I've seen Franny post here over the years I think she basically wanted to be honest with who she is and her worldview as a gay Catholic woman. I recall a thread she posted awhile back about being authentic. From what I've seen from the few gay people that I know not everyone comes to grips with it at the same time. There is no magical age where it clicks. Sure, she mentioned it before, and apparently it didn't impact anyone else here very much. But it's clearly impacting HER to admit to herself and others that she has these attractions and they're not going away, they're not minor, and if she wishes to remain a faithful Catholic she has a lot of sacrifices to make. That's HARD. I don't really feel like she should be expected to shoulder that in silence. I don't know what she was hoping for when she started this thread, but I do think it was a way of reaching out.

 

I'm not looking to argue, there are way too many combative posts in this thread already. I'm just trying to give some sort of answer to your question. I don't think it's a simple answer because it's so deeply entwined in emotions.

 

adding onto Icey's awesome post:

 

and why shouldn't franny be able to come to phatmass with these struggles when this place has been a big part of her spiritual life over the years? we've all had struggles that we've shared with phatmass, about trying to live out our lives as faithful Catholics in the midst of huge crosses. franny should be able to do the same. and, honestly, it's no wonder that she lashed out. she's emotionally wounded, fragile, and someone she doesn't get along with poked her with (what seemed to be) a dismissive stick. 

 

just my two cents. 

Edited by Lil Red
Posted (edited)

 

I really dont think the Catholic church is equipped to handle their gay members as of yet. Their methods as of right now are resist, resist, resist

 

resist what?

Edited by Lilllabettt
Posted

Resist their homosexual feelings and thoughts, not to act on them etc.

Posted

wait hold on Lil Red, was it dismissive and it just seemed to be a stick, or was it a stick that just seemed to be dismissive?

 

I think the questions with FH are meant to be either/or, both/and, personal and/or general issues/topics of the day, as she mentioned both things in her original post.  the Arizona thing is something to talk about.  so are FP's questions.

Posted

Resist their homosexual feelings and thoughts, not to act on them etc.

 

um. yessssss......

Posted

are you suggesting a more comprehensive approach?

Posted (edited)

are you suggesting a more comprehensive approach?

 

I have no idea. I guess I would love to see us all restart our mentality...think about why homosexuality is wrong and how that influences our actions. I think there is a HUGE number of people who are extremely prejudice just not consciously. Their actions and how they interact etc show their feelings and its creating a world of resentment, anger, and fear.

 

I would love to see us all start from square one and maybe we CAN find a place for homosexual relationships in God's love.

 

But maybe its ust the kumbaya in me talking  :saint2:

Edited by CrossCuT
The Bus Station
Posted

... But it's clearly impacting HER to admit to herself and others that she has these attractions and they're not going away, they're not minor, and if she wishes to remain a faithful Catholic she has a lot of sacrifices to make. That's HARD. I don't really feel like she should be expected to shoulder that in silence. I don't know what she was hoping for when she started this thread, but I do think it was a way of reaching out ... I don't think it's a simple answer because it's so deeply entwined in emotions.

 

This is well said, thanks Ice.

Posted

wait hold on Lil Red, was it dismissive and it just seemed to be a stick, or was it a stick that just seemed to be dismissive?

 

 

i haven't had enough coffee for this conversation. 

tumblr_mctalko.gif

Posted (edited)

 

I would love to see us all start from square one and maybe we CAN find a place for homosexual relationships in God's love.

 

so what you are saying is the Church should ... change its teaching on the moral acceptability of homosexual relationships.

being careful not to take out my jump to conclusions mat.

Edited by Lilllabettt
Posted

so what you are saying is the Church should ... change its teaching on the moral acceptability of homosexual relationships.

being careful not to take out my jump to conclusions mat.

 

Relax. Those are just my thoughts. Obviously Im a minority in my thinking so you dont have to worry about any of that actually happening.

Posted

I think crosscut may be trying to suggest non-sexual same sex relationships based on those romantic attractions.  I don't think that's a good idea, I've known people who have tried to go that route, it just doesn't work out.  It really doesn't.  best case scenario it's a near occasion of sin.  might sound good to some but there's no way it works in practice and I don't think the Church should move towards accepting that.

 

there are a good deal of resources out there relating to homosexuality and chastity in the Church... but it's scattered to the point where the average person stepping into a Church is not likely to stumble upon the right response, generally they'll be met with the wrong kind of response, I think, the kind that ends up pushing them away.  

Posted

Relax. Those are just my thoughts. Obviously Im a minority in my thinking so you dont have to worry about any of that actually happening.

 

smells phishy is all.

 

stinks like phish.

Posted

 

I think crosscut may be trying to suggest non-sexual same sex relationships based on those romantic attractions.

 

 

is that what crosscut is suggesting, crosscut? or the other.

Posted

Im open to every possibility.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...