Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Posted

Hi Selah! :)

  • 2 weeks later...
Posted

Let's talk about this more!

Posted

xD Okay!

 

Wanna talk about the essence-energies distinction? That's my favorite thing ever about Byzantine Christianity. 

Credo in Deum
Posted

I think you scared off, Eliakim.  :hehe2:

Posted

I think you scared off, Eliakim.  :hehe2:

 

xD 

Posted

xD Okay!

Wanna talk about the essence-energies distinction? That's my favorite thing ever about Byzantine Christianity.


It's not mine, but if I remember to tell myself 'It's a mystery'*** before I read anything about it, then I can get really interested. This post is a nice readable place to start http://forums.catholic.com/showpost.php?p=7156231&postcount=6

For myself, I'm much more interested in comparisons of practices and how they have come about. And what they imply theologically. I love reading and talking about what practices imply theologically and it's all my spiritual father's fault.

*** In the Orthodox sense of something that you come to understand as you are led deeper into it.
Posted

That is lovely. St. Palamas is one of my favorite saints. He was such a humble man, and his writings and homilies are wonderful. He also defended Hesychasm, which uses the Jesus Prayer. I started praying it, and it's really amazing. I have a small wrist chotki, but now can't find it. grr. 

CatholicsAreKewl
Posted (edited)

Lulz My dads side of the family is Melkite and my mom's is Maronite. I asked my mom and she said she believes in the immaculate conception. Explain that, salad. Edited by CatholicsAreKewl
Posted

Eastern Catholics are allowed to keep their traditions and customs, but are they required to submit to dogmas that the Magisterium pronounces, such as ex-cathedra pronouncements like Immaculate Conception?  Also no more divorce? 

 

E

Simply put, yes.

Posted

Someone needs to write Eastern Christianity for Dummies so that those of us of the West can understand the other lung.

Except that it would cause a schism because no one can agree just what the Eastern tradition on anything actually is. One camp will say one thing and another will say something else.

 

Also, the Melkites are not the end all and be all of Byzantine-rite Catholicism.

Posted (edited)

I know that, but I was specifically asking Eliakim to go ask a Melkite Bishop.

 

He went to a Maronite instead.

 

One cannot, unless they delude themselves, deny that the Melkites and the Orthodox agree on doctrinal ideas (dormition, theosis, ancestral sin, etc).

 

There is no submitting to Rome. Eastern Catholics do not submit to Rome. They submit to their Patriarchs, who are in communion with Rome. 

 

 

Edited by Selah
Posted

Lulz My dads side of the family is Melkite and my mom's is Maronite. I asked my mom and she said she believes in the immaculate conception. Explain that, salad.

 

*facepalm*

 

you said your mom is a Maronite. Maronites believe in the Immaculate Conception. Melkites do not. 

 

Maronites used to reject the Immaculate Conception, but after the Latinization, they were forced to accept it.

 

/repeatsherselffortheeleventyethtime

Posted

*facepalm*

 

you said your mom is a Maronite. Maronites believe in the Immaculate Conception. Melkites do not. 

 

Maronites used to reject the Immaculate Conception, but after the Latinization, they were forced to accept it.

 

/repeatsherselffortheeleventyethtime

 

Now, is this the official position of the Melkite Church, with the Patriarch's approval, or is it what some Melkites say (or worse, is it what the Melkite blogosphere says :) )?

Posted

Simply put, yes.

 

There is no require. Rome doesn't get to tell the East what to do. It's not the big brother of Catholicism. There is no allow, no require. The East has its traditions, and the West has theirs. 

Posted

Now, is this the official position of the Melkite Church, with the Patriarch's approval, or is it what some Melkites say (or worse, is it what the Melkite blogosphere says :) )?

 

This is getting tiring. And I am losing what little patience I have left.

 

Go through the thread and read what I have wrote, as well as the links I have posted. Go talk to Melkites, go ask questions of their Bishops. 

Posted

There is no require. Rome doesn't get to tell the East what to do. It's not the big brother of Catholicism. There is no allow, no require. The East has its traditions, and the West has theirs. 

But does it get more "primus inter pares" than a big brother? :)

Posted

http://www.mliles.com/melkite/theotokosminorconception.shtml

From the site:

Melkite Greek Catholic Church Information Center is an unofficial Melkite Greek Catholic Web site and has not been reviewed or approved by any Melkite clergy person.

 

 https://melkite.org/tag/conception-of-the-theotokos

Hardly a rejection of the Immaculate Conception. More an explanation of why it's not mentioned in Byzantine theology.

 

Posted

But does it get more "primus inter pares" than a big brother? :)

 

The Pope is not viewed the same in the Melkite Church. He is the first among equals, but infallibility and supremecy are rejected. 

 

I honestly would have thought that you, being an Eastern Catholic, would be a little more aware of what the Eastern Churches taught. Even though Melkite does not equal Byzantine, and you may not be Melkite yourself, I would have thought you would have done at least a little research into the matter. 

Posted

 

 

Being unofficial does not change it from being what is taught. The Melkites do not accept the Immaculate conception because their view on sin is different from the West's view. 

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...