Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Nihil Obstat
Posted

 

 

 

I'm not sure what definition you're going by.  That's certainly music.  It's not spoken.

 

How does one precisely define the difference between speaking and singing? Is it the simple ability to define what notes are present? Because many forms of rap, as I understand it, change pitches even while it maintains what is perceived as a spoken 'feeling'. At the same time, many simple chanted tones have very little in terms of pitch changes. The main difference, besides the very regular nature of the simple chants, seems to be that the notes themselves are in a tone more easily perceived as sung. But they are still notes, and when one pays attention there are still changes in pitch. It's a stylistic difference.

Frankly, I do not think there is much difference between simple chant tones, and some forms of rap, except primarily stylistic differences. The tones are rather differently, but I think it is primary a stylistic choice. And in that sense I see no way to exclude rap as music while still including chant. 

Anastasia13
Posted (edited)

I always thought there was something attractive about Mark Wahlberg. Now it finally makes sense.

Edited by Light and Truth
fides' Jack
Posted

What grammar problems ? lol Yea they had an official music play list awhile back and Tupac's song Changes made it on the list. I doubt Tupac will be in the liturgical music anytime soon. lol

 

Play list for what?  I don't understand.  Was it playing at the Vatican or something?

 

Or an approved list of music for Catholics to listen to?  (meaning without content that's too questionable)  - this I can see.  I remember they did that with movies.

Credo in Deum
Posted

I always thought there was something attractive about Mark Wahlberg. Now it finally makes sense.

putersmash.gif

fides' Jack
Posted (edited)

How does one precisely define the difference between speaking and singing? Is it the simple ability to define what notes are present? Because many forms of rap, as I understand it, change pitches even while it maintains what is perceived as a spoken 'feeling'. At the same time, many simple chanted tones have very little in terms of pitch changes. The main difference, besides the very regular nature of the simple chants, seems to be that the notes themselves are in a tone more easily perceived as sung. But they are still notes, and when one pays attention there are still changes in pitch. It's a stylistic difference.

Frankly, I do not think there is much difference between simple chant tones, and some forms of rap, except primarily stylistic differences. The tones are rather differently, but I think it is primary a stylistic choice. And in that sense I see no way to exclude rap as music while still including chant. 

 

Well, try singing something in your normal voice, on the same note.  Maybe this post.  Then, try saying it.  You'll notice there is a difference, though I'm not sure I could easily put it into words.  

 

Maybe something about how when you're singing you're carrying your voice between syllables, while speaking each syllable starts and ends itself somehow??  

 

Of course, when you speak you can also change tone & pitch (& certainly volume) to express emotion, etc..., but there's still a definite difference between singing and speaking.

Edited by fides' Jack
Posted (edited)

Alot of the most talented rappers deliver in a "singing" type delivery. An old friend never liked Jay-Z because as my friend put it he "talked" over the beats. He preferred artist like Nelly who had more melody in their delivery when they rapped.

Edited by Guest
Credo in Deum
Posted
music  noun    (Concise Encyclopedia)

Art concerned with combining vocal or instrumental sounds for beauty of form or emotional expression, usually according to cultural standards of rhythm, melody, and, in most Western music, harmony. Music most often implies sounds with distinct pitches that are arranged into melodies and organized into patterns of rhythm and metre. The melody will usually be in a certain key or mode, and in Western music it will often suggest harmony that may be made explicit as accompanying chords or counterpoint. Music is an art that, in one guise or another, permeates every human society. It is used for such varied social purposes as ritual, worship, coordination of movement, communication, and entertainment.

 
mu·sic  noun, often attributive \ˈmyü-zik\
 
 
1
a :  the science or art of ordering tones or sounds in succession, in combination, and in temporal relationships to produce a composition having unity and continuity
 
b :  vocal, instrumental, or mechanical sounds having rhythm, melody, or harmony
2
a :  an agreeable sound :  euphony <her voice was music to my ears>
 
b :  musical quality <the music of verse>
3
:  a musical accompaniment <a play set to music>
4
:  the score of a musical composition set down on paper
5
:  a distinctive type or category of music <there is a musicfor everybody — Eric Salzman>
 
 
 
 

 

Posted

Play list for what? I don't understand. Was it playing at the Vatican or something?

Or an approved list of music for Catholics to listen to? (meaning without content that's too questionable) - this I can see. I remember they did that with movies.

My bad I see what you're saying. It was on their official MySpace page back in the day.
Posted

The late rapper Tupac Shakur has been included as part of the Vatican's official MySpace Music playlist.

The seat of the Catholic Church released a list of 12 songs onto the social networking Web site's streaming music service this week when the site launched in the United Kingdom.

Among selections from Mozart, Muse and Dame Shirley Bassey is the slain rapper's song "Changes," which was released two years after his shooting death on a greatest hits album in 1998.

"The genres are very different from each other, but all these artists share the aim to reach the heart of good minded people," the Vatican wrote on its official MySpace Music page.

As of Thursday night, "Changes" had been played more than 4.6 million times on the Web site.

The list was compiled by Father Giulio Neroni, artistic director of church publisher St Paul's Multimedia. He was also responsible for compiling the Vatican's recent Alma Mater album, which combined Gregorian chants and prayers with classical music and the voice of Pope Benedict XVI speaking in five languages.

Shakur, who spent time in prison for sexual assault, was gunned down in a drive-by shooting in Nevada in 1996.

The lyrics of "Changes" describe Shakur's desire to change a grim life of drugs, crime and violence on the streets.

Lyrics of the song, which is labeled as "explicit," include 'Is life worth living, should I blast myself?" "Give the crack to the kids, who the hell cares, one less hungry mouth on the welfare," and "My stomach hurts, so I'm looking for a purse to snatch."

At another point, Tupac sings: "Cause both black and white are smokin' crack tonight."

In contrast, the playlist also contains selections from the album "Music of the Vatican" such as "Advocata Nostra" and "Causa Nostrae Laetitiae."

Other contemporary tracks on the mix include Muse's "Uprising" from their new album "The Resistance" and "He Doesn't Know Why" by the folk group Fleet Foxes.

fides' Jack
Posted

What grammar problems ? lol Yea they had an official music play list awhile back and Tupac's song Changes made it on the list. I doubt Tupac will be in the liturgical music anytime soon. lol

 

Well, this is a good example. I'll rewrite the post for you:

 

What grammar problems? lol!  Yeah, they had an official music play list a while back and Tupac's song 'Changes' made it on the list. I doubt Tupac will be in the liturgical music anytime soon. lol

 

There is a lot of missing punctuation and a tendency toward a run-on feel in your sentences.  "lol" is very common and easy to understand, but taking it out helps the sentences be more understandable (that's a nit-pick).  A couple of times I've seen strange spaces before your question marks, including here, which is somewhat distracting.  The quotation marks around the song title probably aren't necessary, but they do help separate it as a song title.  I had to remove the extra "the" in my mind before I could make sense of that sentence.  Then there's the misuse of the word "awhile", which you can read about here: http://www.quickanddirtytips.com/education/grammar/while-versus-awhile

 

Sorry - I'm not trying to be a jerk about it - it's just much easier to understand someone when they express themselves clearly in written form.  And you asked.

Posted

Well, this is a good example. I'll rewrite the post for you:

What grammar problems? lol! Yeah, they had an official music play list a while back and Tupac's song 'Changes' made it on the list. I doubt Tupac will be in the liturgical music anytime soon. lol

There is a lot of missing punctuation and a tendency toward a run-on feel in your sentences. "lol" is very common and easy to understand, but taking it out helps the sentences be more understandable (that's a nit-pick). A couple of times I've seen strange spaces before your question marks, including here, which is somewhat distracting. The quotation marks around the song title probably aren't necessary, but they do help separate it as a song title. I had to remove the extra "the" in my mind before I could make sense of that sentence. Then there's the misuse of the word "awhile", which you can read about here: http://www.quickanddirtytips.com/education/grammar/while-versus-awhile

Sorry - I'm not trying to be a jerk about it - it's just much easier to understand someone when they express themselves clearly in written form. And you asked.

hahaha that was awesome and I did ask. I don't think you're being a jerk. Thanks.
fides' Jack
Posted

The late rapper Tupac Shakur has been included as part of the Vatican's official MySpace Music playlist.

The seat of the Catholic Church released a list of 12 songs onto the social networking Web site's streaming music service this week when the site launched in the United Kingdom.

Among selections from Mozart, Muse and Dame Shirley Bassey is the slain rapper's song "Changes," which was released two years after his shooting death on a greatest hits album in 1998.

"The genres are very different from each other, but all these artists share the aim to reach the heart of good minded people," the Vatican wrote on its official MySpace Music page.

As of Thursday night, "Changes" had been played more than 4.6 million times on the Web site.

The list was compiled by Father Giulio Neroni, artistic director of church publisher St Paul's Multimedia. He was also responsible for compiling the Vatican's recent Alma Mater album, which combined Gregorian chants and prayers with classical music and the voice of Pope Benedict XVI speaking in five languages.

Shakur, who spent time in prison for sexual assault, was gunned down in a drive-by shooting in Nevada in 1996.

The lyrics of "Changes" describe Shakur's desire to change a grim life of drugs, crime and violence on the streets.

Lyrics of the song, which is labeled as "explicit," include 'Is life worth living, should I blast myself?" "Give the crack to the kids, who the hell cares, one less hungry mouth on the welfare," and "My stomach hurts, so I'm looking for a purse to snatch."

At another point, Tupac sings: "Cause both black and white are smokin' crack tonight."

In contrast, the playlist also contains selections from the album "Music of the Vatican" such as "Advocata Nostra" and "Causa Nostrae Laetitiae."

Other contemporary tracks on the mix include Muse's "Uprising" from their new album "The Resistance" and "He Doesn't Know Why" by the folk group Fleet Foxes.

 

Interesting...

 

Thanks for the copy/paste.

Nihil Obstat
Posted (edited)

Well, try singing something in your normal voice, on the same note.  Maybe this post.  Then, try saying it.  You'll notice there is a difference, though I'm not sure I could easily put it into words.  

 

Maybe something about how when you're singing you're carrying your voice between syllables, while speaking each syllable starts and ends itself somehow??  

 

Of course, when you speak you can also change tone & pitch (& certainly volume) to express emotion, etc..., but there's still a definite difference between singing and speaking.

But rap, even the most 'spoken sounding' of styles, still produces clear pitches and I think if you were to check it would also clearly fit into a definitive key signature. It is clearly possible to change the key in a rap song. It is certainly eminently possible to hit a 'wrong note' in a rap. Yet, it is not music? Why not? The two biggest differences, when we ignore lyrical content, between chant and rap that I can perceive is that rap has an infinitely stricter set of conventions regarding rhythm, and rap is tonally closer to a regular speaking voice. I simply cannot see how this disqualifies it as music.

It has rhythm, it has melody, and it can have harmony. It is just that the melody and possibly harmonies are rather strange and foreign to a musical palette that is accustomed to more historic forms of western music.

Edited by Nihil Obstat
Anastasia13
Posted

 

I always thought there was something attractive about Mark Wahlberg. Now it finally makes sense.

putersmash.gif

 

I loved that movie, and how his character learned ballet and harp "ironically". 

fides' Jack
Posted

But rap, even the most 'spoken sounding' of styles, still produces clear pitches and I think if you were to check it would also clearly fit into a definitive key signature. It is clearly possible to change the key in a rap song. It is certainly eminently possible to hit a 'wrong note' in a rap. Yet, it is not music? Why not? The two biggest differences, when we ignore lyrical content, between chant and rap that I can perceive is that rap has an infinitely stricter set of conventions regarding rhythm, and rap is tonally closer to a regular speaking voice. I simply cannot see how this disqualifies it as music.

It has rhythm, it has melody, and it can have harmony. It is just that the melody and possibly harmonies are rather strange and foreign to a musical palette that is accustomed to more historic forms of western music.

 

I can agree with most of this.

 

Maybe there is some rap that does inch toward crossing the line between speaking and singing.  But I think if it did cross that line, it would cease being 'rap'.  I think that's the quality that makes it 'rap'.  

Nihil Obstat
Posted

I can agree with most of this.

 

Maybe there is some rap that does inch toward crossing the line between speaking and singing.  But I think if it did cross that line, it would cease being 'rap'.  I think that's the quality that makes it 'rap'.  

I would be fine with not calling rapping "singing" in a traditional sense of the word.

So, music or not music after all?

Credo in Deum
Posted

It's music!

http://youtu.be/v1PBptSDIh8

fides' Jack
Posted

I would be fine with not calling rapping "singing" in a traditional sense of the word.

So, music or not music after all?

 

I think it's speaking, often to a musical background.  

 

Call my cynical.  :)

KnightofChrist
Posted (edited)

Yea I agree with all of this. How do you feel about someone like Mark Wahlberg who practices and speaks out about his Faith but yet still produces and acts in movies with blasphemy, nudity, ect ?


Outside of using an example of blasphemy to teach that it is wrong, blasphemy is never acceptable. While I agree that some forms of art can use nudity in a non-perverse manner, I cannot recall ever seeing it used in a artful manner in movies. Edited by KnightofChrist
Nihil Obstat
Posted

I think it's speaking, often to a musical background.  

 

Call my cynical.   :)

Y-U-NO-Guy-Meme-Face-300x300.jpg

 

Outside of using an example of blasphemy to teach that it is wrong, blasphemy is never acceptable. While I agree that some forms of art can use nudity in a non-perverse manner, I cannot recall ever seeing it selected in a artful manner in movies.

That is why I have minor reservations about The Exorcist. I think it is rather a good example in popular media of the Catholic understanding of possession - with some qualifications - but I think it may have been technically blasphemous to film a couple of the more 'intense' scenes of possession. I have not yet decided what the implications of this might be.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...