Benedictus Posted November 7, 2014 Posted November 7, 2014 (edited) When a person says somethings funny they don't always mean it's funny haha or hoho. For example if someone says something smells funny it doesn't mean they smell laughter, it means something stinks. I believe Credo implied your position smells funny. Yeah, I know. But it's neither amusing or stinky, and it isn't to those affected. I expect some to think it is though. If not this thread wouldn't be happening. Edited November 7, 2014 by Benedictus
Credo in Deum Posted November 7, 2014 Posted November 7, 2014 The "I'll say a Rosary for you" fighting is the Catholic version of "bless your heart".
PhuturePriest Posted November 7, 2014 Posted November 7, 2014 Yeah, I know. But it's neither amusing or stinky, and it isn't to those affected. I expect some to think it is though. If not this thread wouldn't be happening. There is certainly something very smelly about you, Benedictus. Quite recently, you wrote the following: I'm not sure you'll ever get the affirmation you may seek from the church at this point in space and time. But you will find voices and many examples of people who are living out a Christian faith as best they can, even though their response to those challenges is different. There have been cases of transgendered people becoming clergy and or transitioning when they are clergy. The Anglican church has examples, such as Rev Dr Cameron Partridge, Rev Dr Christina Beardsley and others. There have been Catholic clergy and religious who have joined the Epicopalians during/after their transitions because they have been pushed out of the Catholic church, although not always with the wishes of the congregation/institute where they lived. This isn't something the Catholic church puts in the weekly news but I'd say it's not an insignificant number. Disregarding all the other phishy things you've said, that quote alone merits either some very convincing clarifications, or a phishy tag.
Benedictus Posted November 7, 2014 Posted November 7, 2014 Being tempted to abandon the Faith does seem to reveal some type of personal crisis. I didn't see that written. Do you think all Christians who aren't Catholics, and don't want to be affiliated to the institution, lack faith? I don't remember Pope Benedict saying this when he sat through a service in Westminster Abbey. I didn't see Pope Francis say this when he sent a video message to Evangelical leaders. Do you think Jesus, the God of love, gets flustered because people go to an Episcopal church instead of a Catholic one?
Benedictus Posted November 7, 2014 Posted November 7, 2014 (edited) There is certainly something very smelly about you, Benedictus. Quite recently, you wrote the following: Disregarding all the other phishy things you've said, that quote alone merits either some very convincing clarifications, or a phishy tag. What I said in those comments, which you dug out, were true. It wasn't a matter of opinion. Tell me they are not. Edited November 7, 2014 by Benedictus
PhuturePriest Posted November 7, 2014 Posted November 7, 2014 What I said is true. It wasn't a matter of opinion. It's phishy and wreaks of dissent.
PhuturePriest Posted November 7, 2014 Posted November 7, 2014 What I said is true. It wasn't a matter of opinion. Quote I think it's also worth looking into some of the views currently at work in Psychology, Sociology, Gender Theory. This overlaps into Gender theology, check out Marcella Althaus-Reid and Robert Goss. A friend of mine looked those people up. Marcella Althaus-Reid is not Catholic, and was described as a "quee.r god" (literal quote form the google search). Fr Robert Goss is a 70's Jesuit and wrote a book called "Queering Christ" and a q.ueer bible and is very pro-gay. Both are anti-Catholic, and their works should most certainly not be recommended to anyone on a Catholic website.
KnightofChrist Posted November 7, 2014 Posted November 7, 2014 (edited) Yeah, I know. But it's neither amusing or stinky, and it isn't to those affected. I expect some to think it is though. If not this thread wouldn't be happening. Soylent Green is people, the erroneous arguments you've offered which are odd are not people. It seems the greater part of what you argue here seems to be heavily based upon attempting to paint those that disagree with you as uncharitable and mean spirited to marginalize, rather than on a solid and reasoned position. Edited November 7, 2014 by KnightofChrist
Benedictus Posted November 7, 2014 Posted November 7, 2014 It's phishy and wreaks of dissent. Tell me in that selected quote where what I said hasn't happened. There are transgender clergy in the Anglican church. Titles, on here or elsewhere, probably matter more to you than me. It seems like a way to express frustration, whatever.. I'll be joining a religious institute in the new year. I follow all the church requires of me on sexual morality, and there's no major issues raised over what I've said I struggle with. I'm open about it and develop by discussing it. I'm not a robot. You can think what you like.
PhuturePriest Posted November 7, 2014 Posted November 7, 2014 Tell me in that selected quote where what I said hasn't happened. There are transgender clergy in the Anglican church. Titles, on here or elsewhere, probably matter more to you than me. It seems like a way to express frustration, whatever.. I'll be joining a religious institute in the new year. I follow all the church requires of me on sexual morality, and there's no major issues raised over what I've said I struggle with. I'm open about it and develop by discussing it. I'm not a robot. You can think what you like. There are people doing that. But that doesn't make it right, as you seem to be suggesting in the post. I'll be entering seminary in the next year. I'm not sure what that has to do with anything. As I pointed out with the author of that book you recommended, there are priests who are against Church teaching.
Nihil Obstat Posted November 7, 2014 Author Posted November 7, 2014 Tell me in that selected quote where what I said hasn't happened. There are transgender clergy in the Anglican church. Titles, on here or elsewhere, probably matter more to you than me. It seems like a way to express frustration, whatever.. Anglicans and Episcopalians have no true clergy. :|
Benedictus Posted November 7, 2014 Posted November 7, 2014 Quote A friend of mine looked those people up. Marcella Althaus-Reid is not Catholic, and was described as a "quee.r god" (literal quote form the google search). Fr Robert Goss is a 70's Jesuit and wrote a book called "Queering Christ" and a q.ueer bible and is very pro-gay. Both are anti-Catholic, and their works should most certainly not be recommended to anyone on a Catholic website. You choose now to cross thread and not discuss this at the time, OK. So it wasn't what I said, but the author I mentioned? Those people are leading writers in their fields, which is why I gave them as examples. They were relevant to the topic. The areas they write on are contentious to some, less to others. I never said I agree with them on everything or that I've read everything about them. People can look, if they choose, and reflect on this for themselves. In all areas, even Catholic seminary, you'll need to read books that are seen as anti catholic. I don't think you'll understand all the theological developments and situations if you didn't. Most will need to do units, or parts, on LGBT, Feminist and Process theology at some point etc. Much would be contrary to what the church sees as valid. But it is often studied nevertheless. I'm not clear why you take the view that's it 's better to ignore and not read subjects, or people, simply because they disagree with beliefs you hold. Reading people who disagree with you should help make your beliefs, and why you hold them, stronger and clearer. Not everything a person says, even if they are anti Catholic, is tainted by that position either There are people doing that. But that doesn't make it right, as you seem to be suggesting in the post. I'll be entering seminary in the next year. I'm not sure what that has to do with anything. As I pointed out with the author of that book you recommended, there are priests who are against Church teaching. I didn't say it was right. I also don't tend to tell people what they have to do either, and especially not on forums. I'm not a control freak. A book is just a book, all sorts of books can be helpful. Not all answers are found in theological books. I thought it amusing you'd desire someone to have a religious and phishy label at the same time. Plus I actually do follow the church teaching myself on core matters, despite people probably assuming I don't. So I was simply clarifying as people can be quick to anger and judge.
PhuturePriest Posted November 7, 2014 Posted November 7, 2014 (edited) You choose now to cross thread and not discuss this at the time, OK. So it wasn't what I said, but the author I mentioned? Those people are leading writers in their fields, which is why I gave them as examples. They were relevant to the topic. The areas they write on are contentious to some, less to others. I never said I agree with them on everything or that I've read everything about them. People can look, if they choose, and reflect on this for themselves. In all areas, even Catholic seminary, you'll need to read books that are seen as anti catholic. I don't think you'll understand all the theological developments and situations if you didn't. Most will need to do units, or parts, on LGBT, Feminist and Process theology at some point etc. Much would be contrary to what the church sees as valid. But it is often studied nevertheless. I'm not clear why you take the view that's it 's better to ignore and not read subjects, or people, simply because they disagree with beliefs you hold. Reading people who disagree with you should help make your beliefs, and why you hold them, stronger and clearer. Not everything a person says, even if they are anti Catholic, is tainted by that position either I didn't say it was right. I also don't tend to tell people what they have to do either, and especially not on forums. I'm not a control freak. A book is just a book, all sorts of books can be helpful. Not all answers are found in theological books. I thought it amusing you'd desire someone to have a religious and phishy label at the same time. Plus I actually do follow the church teaching myself on core matters, despite people probably assuming I don't. So I was simply clarifying as people can be quick to anger and judge. There is nothing wrong with reading a book that has a core message which is against Church teaching. There is something wrong with recommending someone who is struggling with something to read a book that will recommend him to disobey Church teaching. I don't care if you're religious, clergy, laymen, or even the Pope. If you're phishy, you're phishy, and you deserve a phishy tag regardless of your vocation if you are not in accordance with Church teaching. I find it amusing that you think being a religious and/or clergymen makes someone above such a tedious thing as being labeled a heretic. Edited November 7, 2014 by FuturePacker
Benedictus Posted November 7, 2014 Posted November 7, 2014 Anglicans and Episcopalians have no true clergy. :| Valid, but illicit. Indeed.
Benedictus Posted November 7, 2014 Posted November 7, 2014 (edited) There is nothing wrong with reading a book that has a core message which is against Church teaching. There is something wrong with recommending someone who is struggling with something to read a book that will recommend him to disobey Church teaching. I don't care if you're religious, clergy, laymen, or even the Pope. If you're phishy, you're phishy, and you deserve a phishy tag regardless of your vocation if you are not in accordance with Church teaching. I find it amusing that you think being a religious and/or clergymen makes someone above such a tedious thing as being labeled a heretic. Reading a book will make someone a heretic? OK. Don't read any books, esp on topics that you find hard. Where does the author say to not follow church teaching in their books? Why would someone listen anyway? I don't think that about clergy at all. It's more funny you think forum titles make a difference either way. You decide what someone needs and deserves because you say so? Give me a break. First you posted I made claims of something in another thread, which you quoted. Then you moved onto saying I shouldn't have mentioned that author, although you said nothing at the time within that thread. Despite the fact that to understand that area of thought you need to read some of those books. You seem to be getting flustered because I'm not jumping as high as you expect. That's just too bad. Edited November 7, 2014 by Benedictus
Amppax Posted November 7, 2014 Posted November 7, 2014 Valid, but illicit. Indeed. No actually. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Apostolicae_Curae
PhuturePriest Posted November 7, 2014 Posted November 7, 2014 Reading a book will make someone a heretic? OK. Don't read any books, esp on topics that you find hard. Where does the author say to not follow church teaching in their books? Why would someone listen anyway? I don't think that about clergy at all. It's more funny you think forum titles make a difference either way. You decide what someone needs and deserves because you say so? Give me a break. First you posted I made claims of something in another thread, which you quoted. Then you moved onto saying I shouldn't have mentioned that author, although you said nothing at the time within that thread. Despite the fact that to understand that area of thought you need to read some of those books. You seem to be getting flustered because I'm not jumping as high as you expect. That's just too bad. That's not what I said and you know it. Or, at least, I hope you do, as I was quite clear. Reading a book doesn't make you a heretic. Recommending a book which is contrary to Church teaching and praising it makes your theological loyalties questionable at best. The importance of the tags is letting other people know if they can trust the person to be solidly in line with Church teaching or not. You are questionable at best, and are riding the phishy line really hard at worst. I'm not the only one who thinks this, and I know a Mediator of Meh who agrees with me. I didn't read it at the time it was done, it was reported to me by another member. I gave my support to penguin in that thread and then left it at that. I was unaware such books were being recommended.
veritasluxmea Posted November 7, 2014 Posted November 7, 2014 In all areas, even Catholic seminary, you'll need to read books that are seen as anti catholic. I don't think you'll understand all the theological developments and situations if you didn't. Most will need to do units, or parts, on LGBT, Feminist and Process theology at some point etc. Much would be contrary to what the church sees as valid. But it is often studied nevertheless. I'm not clear why you take the view that's it 's better to ignore and not read subjects, or people, simply because they disagree with beliefs you hold. Reading people who disagree with you should help make your beliefs, and why you hold them, stronger and clearer. Not everything a person says, even if they are anti Catholic, is tainted by that position either The way the books were presented, to an average reader (me) it sounds as though you were recommending the books as examples of how to think about transgender issues. Instead of saying, "here are some books that present a worldview contrary to Church Teaching, let's study them to understand it" the post read as "You're not going to find the affirmation to live as you want from the Catholic Church, read these books to find it instead." Obviously, that's wrong. I didn't say it was right. I also don't tend to tell people what they have to do either, and especially not on forums. I'm not a control freak. There are a lot of gray areas in the Church, but Church doctrine isn't one of them. It is right, and anything against it is wrong and should be presented as such. You don't need to tell people what they need to do. We have Jesus for that. I thought it amusing you'd desire someone to have a religious and phishy label at the same time. I hope no religious would ever need a phishy label, in the forums or real life, but if they did, and it's perfectly possible as in the example of Fr Robert Goss, I also hope it would be dealt with swiftly and severely. Plus I actually do follow the church teaching myself on core matters, despite people probably assuming I don't. So I was simply clarifying as people can be quick to anger and judge. I believe you do. It's just hard to tell from the way the post was written. Whether you disagree or agree with the Church, clarification and honesty from the start is good, for all of us. And yes, Anglican orders are invalid because they do not have apostolic succession. Shortly after their break from the Church they changed the form and words of ordination and lost succession.
Benedictus Posted November 7, 2014 Posted November 7, 2014 No actually. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Apostolicae_Curae No I mean the sacraments they give maybe valid, but illicit. The Catholic church can't say Anglican ordinations are valid (even if there is apostolic succession), and also because Anglicans ordain women. I think the situation is similar for the Orthodox, but I'm not sure. I think there is some debate over the validity of Catholic priests who become Anglicans. Likewise if a Catholic Bishop ordains people not sanctioned by the church. But I think it's a complicated area, Canon lawyers terrain.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now