Nihil Obstat Posted January 26, 2015 Posted January 26, 2015 We have talked a lot on the forums recently about homosexuality, especially the authentic Catholic witness that could be provided by those Catholics who struggle with homosexual attraction. I think this article gives an interesting perspective that perhaps has not been addressed lately. Very Aristotelian and teleological, if I might speculate a bit. Link to an article on Crisis Magazine: http://www.crisismagazine.com/2015/strange-notion-gay-celibacy "Why would I call myself a gay man, then, simply because I find men sexually attractive? This is in opposition to the way God made me and the nature he gave me. Regardless of what my feelings might tell me, my body reveals to me the truth that I am not gay, but rather a male made for a female. The Catechism is clear about our sexual identity: “Everyone, man and woman, should acknowledge and accept his sexual identity. Physical, moral, and spiritual difference and complementarity are oriented toward the goods of marriage and the flourishing of family life. The harmony of the couple and of society depends in part on the way in which the complementarity, needs, and mutual support between the sexes are lived out.” Accepting myself as I truly am requires that I reject a belief that I have a sexual identity other than being a man made for women. Recognizing this truth of who I am, as a sexual creature, is fundamental to the virtue of chastity. When it comes to homosexuality, however, many seem to believe that sexual continence is the earmark of chastity. But this is not so. Rather, continence, in any single person’s life, is a necessary sign of chastity, but it does not express the fullness or breadth of the beauty of the virtue. Chastity is far more than what we do or don’t do with our sexual organs. The Catechism tells us that “chastity means the successful integration of sexuality within the person and thus the inner unity of man in his bodily and spiritual being.” [...] This truth about my sexual identity is the reason I also refuse to call myself celibate. Though I am living a single life, I am no different than all of my other single friends who have yet to be married. They do not speak of themselves as celibate, nor should I. They and I are single. Nor am I a part of a “sexual minority,” as some would say of a man like me. I am a male, just as Adam was, just as Christ was, just like all of my other male friends. As the 1986 Letter On The Pastoral Care of the Homosexual Person wisely tells me, “every one living on the face of the earth has personal problems and difficulties, but challenges to growth, strengths, talents and gifts as well.” One of my challenges is that I suffer from the privation of the good of seeing women as sexually desirable—but that fact doesn’t make me a different sort of man than all of the other men in the world around me. The virtue of chastity teaches me this truth." Thoughts?
Ark Posted January 26, 2015 Posted January 26, 2015 This man is a great Catholic and witness to the truth. May God reward him handsomely!
Ark Posted January 26, 2015 Posted January 26, 2015 The author is linked to this documentary which looks awesome: http://everlastinghills.org/movie/
PhuturePriest Posted January 26, 2015 Posted January 26, 2015 The author is linked to this documentary which looks amesome: http://everlastinghills.org/movie/ I can vouch for the goodness of this movie. One I recommend even more, however, is The Third Way, which is also free online.
CatherineM Posted January 26, 2015 Posted January 26, 2015 I met some celibate gay men through some volunteer work with Courage. They are incredible witnesses.
Not The Philosopher Posted January 26, 2015 Posted January 26, 2015 I find that some of the thinking that goes on in the side-b community, so to speak, blurs the lines a bit, and hence is worth evaluating critically in light of Church teaching. The sexual anthropology Mr. Mattson describes is correct. You're not a special snowflake, etc. However, I do find a lot of these debates over what terms you should refer to yourself with to be a tad bit on the pedantic side. It makes the PC alarms go off in my head.
Nihil Obstat Posted January 26, 2015 Author Posted January 26, 2015 Oh, I had meant to properly attribute this as well. The author is Daniel Mattson. I find that some of the thinking that goes on in the side-b community, so to speak, blurs the lines a bit, and hence is worth evaluating critically in light of Church teaching. The sexual anthropology Mr. Mattson describes is correct. You're not a special snowflake, etc. However, I do find a lot of these debates over what terms you should refer to yourself with to be a tad bit on the pedantic side. It makes the PC alarms go off in my head. I see where you are coming from with that. I think this article could be a useful caution against excess. There has been the whole debate surrounding the so-called "new homophiles". Personally I find the label kind of weird. Sounds like a word that should be borderline obscene, even though it is not. Anyway, whatever. There was an article recently on how the term itself is insufficient and misleading. That controversy in particular seems to be marked not necessarily by one side having issues with Church teaching, but rather in both sides disagreeing on how best to think with the mind of the Church. In that context I think it seems to make more sense. If I might be rather bold, I think that the so-called 'new homophiles' have, at times, gone a bit too far in identifying with homosexuality. I think that among some there has been a sort of subconscious effort to downplay the fact that homosexual attraction is, in itself, inherently disordered. And when such persons downplay the inherent disorder of the condition, it can then in some ways be accepted as "part of who we are", in a way beyond that in which concupiscence is a part of the human condition. Without caution some people could be led to forget that homosexual attraction is inherently disordered, and instead treat it as an ordinary temptation which finds its proper end in some related good. So the way I am seeing this is not exactly that people are getting wound up by minutiae. Rather, that this is an emotionally charged and complex subject in which we seem to be having some trouble in conforming ourselves to the mind of the Church. I think this also touches on the debates we have had on whether or not a gay Catholic should 'come out'. Sometimes it has been overly reduced to the idea that Catholics are just plain uncomfortable with gay people, but I think that misses the point, and I think this article touches on part of the reason.
franciscanheart Posted January 26, 2015 Posted January 26, 2015 We have talked about this at length, actually -- this part you want to call attention to. Would it make you feel better if we all just shut up about it and didn't say anything and used no words to describe a difference because NOTHING TO SEE HERE?Already I am troubled by this thread. Perhaps I'll sit this one out and let the heterosexual, armchair theologians have it; I'm sure they're holier and more correct than I'll ever be.
dUSt Posted January 26, 2015 Posted January 26, 2015 We have talked about this at length, actually -- this part you want to call attention to. Would it make you feel better if we all just shut up about it and didn't say anything and used no words to describe a difference because NOTHING TO SEE HERE? Already I am troubled by this thread. Perhaps I'll sit this one out and let the heterosexual, armchair theologians have it; I'm sure they're holier and more correct than I'll ever be. I like heterosexual armchairs.
Nihil Obstat Posted January 26, 2015 Author Posted January 26, 2015 We have talked about this at length, actually -- this part you want to call attention to. Would it make you feel better if we all just shut up about it and didn't say anything and used no words to describe a difference because NOTHING TO SEE HERE? Already I am troubled by this thread. Perhaps I'll sit this one out and let the heterosexual, armchair theologians have it; I'm sure they're holier and more correct than I'll ever be. Of course we have talked about it. But nobody thinks we have solved it. And I do think there are issues with the (for lack of a non-icky term) "new homophiles'" narrative. I think it is easier to discuss these issues if we make an effort not to be hostile when we find disagreement. Like I said, it does not seem particularly to be an issue with anyone actually rejecting Church teaching.
Not The Philosopher Posted January 26, 2015 Posted January 26, 2015 Of course we have talked about it. But nobody thinks we have solved it. And I do think there are issues with the (for lack of a non-icky term) "new homophiles'" narrative. I think it is easier to discuss these issues if we make an effort not to be hostile when we find disagreement. Like I said, it does not seem particularly to be an issue with anyone actually rejecting Church teaching. Well, that, or we could spend 10+ pages making "heterosexual armchair" jokes and memes.
Nihil Obstat Posted January 26, 2015 Author Posted January 26, 2015 Well, that, or we could spend 10+ pages making "heterosexual armchair" jokes and memes. I can do that.
Nihil Obstat Posted January 27, 2015 Author Posted January 27, 2015 Here is one perspective on them: http://www.crisismagazine.com/2013/the-new-homophiles
Ice_nine Posted January 27, 2015 Posted January 27, 2015 I've seen people who are very adamant about "coming out" and those who refuse to accept the label. Fine. What about this: Let people deal with their sexuality how they want to. They're trying to follow church teaching, if the feel the need to claim, or conversely,reject, a label then for God's sake just let them. The problem is with people thinking their way is the right/only proper way to deal with it. I know I'm not the only phatmasser who has had to negotiate a non-heteronormative psychosexual er, history. I've gotten comfortable with how I've reconciled my sexuality with my faith but there's always someone to say I'm doing it the wrong way. And for the record I mostly agree with the author I think it's a reasoning smiliar to my own but WHY oh WHY must his line of reasoning be foisted upon everyone who struggles with this issue. Pardon if I come off as a bit touchy. I used to think my way of dealing with **** was the best way for a faithful Catholic to deal with it. Talk about hubris. I've come to see that there are different approaches that fit different people and it can be so hard and such a cross to bear, leave the poor people who are trying alone.
Nihil Obstat Posted January 27, 2015 Author Posted January 27, 2015 I've seen people who are very adamant about "coming out" and those who refuse to accept the label. Fine. What about this: Let people deal with their sexuality how they want to. They're trying to follow church teaching, if the feel the need to claim, or conversely,reject, a label then for God's sake just let them. The problem is with people thinking their way is the right/only proper way to deal with it. I know I'm not the only phatmasser who has had to negotiate a non-heteronormative psychosexual er, history. I've gotten comfortable with how I've reconciled my sexuality with my faith but there's always someone to say I'm doing it the wrong way. And for the record I mostly agree with the author I think it's a reasoning smiliar to my own but WHY oh WHY must his line of reasoning be foisted upon everyone who struggles with this issue. Pardon if I come off as a bit touchy. I used to think my way of dealing with **** was the best way for a faithful Catholic to deal with it. Talk about hubris. I've come to see that there are different approaches that fit different people and it can be so hard and such a cross to bear, leave the poor people who are trying alone. Does it have to be about forcing though? I mean, I did not read much aggressiveness into the article, so I am not reading it with much of an impression that he wants to force or browbeat Catholics into accepting his way of thinking. I do think he author thinks what he is talking about is the best way, the most authentic way to address this as a Catholic. I think that is to be expected. Otherwise I doubt he would have bothered to write it. But that is how we do things as Catholics, right? We are always going to be falling short on something, and there is always going to be someone else out there who can help us do better. And sometimes we also need help even just to see where we can be improving. I mean... here is a somewhat-related example. I was gently scolded in the confessional once because it had been four weeks since I went last. My confessor said four weeks was too long to really do a thorough examination of conscience. And he is right. He recommended that I make an effort for at least every three weeks, better yet every two. For a Catholic who is just returning to a serious practice of the faith, confession every two weeks might seem absolutely insane. Maybe getting there every couple of months is really huge progress for them. That is great, but we would still gently lead them towards more frequent confessions too. And they may need encouragement to do so. It is a both/and thing. We are happy they are making such great progress, and when it is appropriate we might try to help them do better. So yeah, even if someone is doing pretty ok with something, sometimes they still need help. Sometimes it is our place to offer that help, and sometimes it is not. I would rather see it as an expression of genuine concern and charity rather than self-righteousness.
superblue Posted January 27, 2015 Posted January 27, 2015 This topic in general seems way too sensitive for most, not all people, but most people to try and bridge the gap on..... most of us can grasp the idea of celibacy , no sex before marriage, and then the reality of teenagers, hormones that are out of control , the lack of discussion and guidance by clergy and parents on how to help young teens in understanding the importance of celibacy/marriage/ why they are important... and to make things even harder, we have a society that is non stop pumping promiscuity and sex into our lives in some form or another at some level or another..... and then to tack this onto homosexuals becomes odd, it seems the focus shouldn't be so much at the beginning of hey this or that is considered a sin, or this or that is considered a disorder, but the focus should be is how do we welcome / evangelize / convert / anyone but in this case homosexuals to Christ and the Church... Just to get that person past the door an to simply sit in a pew. Forget preaching or lecturing to the person. IF people find a good, and honest way to encourage others be it homosexual, atheist, whatever, to encounter Christ, then there is something to go from... but to just pop open the catechism and point to a certain page, and to quote theology and scripture, who is that helping, how is it not just opening up a debate and nothing more, and at the end to just hope the person can no longer continue the debate, concede and then what convert ? I don't see the need for the discussion any more, what I do see the need for is more books for those who are homosexual, and want to be Catholic, or do not understand certain things,,,,,,, I don't know if Scott Haan has ever written such a book, but I think he is a good author and might come up with something really good for a start. I think that is something I would find more helpful is a pinned thread, on educational books, or some kind of book in general on evangelizing that spans the range from Homosexuals and other religions.... I could have used such information before bringing it up in my 8th grade class half hazardly out of the blue just to get the class talking and see what they think, biggest mistake ever and got a slap on the wrist for even trying. live an learn. Had I been really wanting to talk about it I would have researched material first and sought advise first, but it was just getting really slow in class lol so threw a grenade and it blew up on me go figure.
4588686 Posted January 27, 2015 Posted January 27, 2015 We have talked a lot on the forums recently about homosexuality, especially the authentic Catholic witness that could be provided by those Catholics who struggle with homosexual attraction. I think this article gives an interesting perspective that perhaps has not been addressed lately. Very Aristotelian and teleological, if I might speculate a bit. Link to an article on Crisis Magazine: http://www.crisismagazine.com/2015/strange-notion-gay-celibacy "Why would I call myself a gay man, then, simply because I find men sexually attractive? This is in opposition to the way God made me and the nature he gave me. Regardless of what my feelings might tell me, my body reveals to me the truth that I am not gay, but rather a male made for a female. The Catechism is clear about our sexual identity: “Everyone, man and woman, should acknowledge and accept his sexual identity. Physical, moral, and spiritual difference and complementarity are oriented toward the goods of marriage and the flourishing of family life. The harmony of the couple and of society depends in part on the way in which the complementarity, needs, and mutual support between the sexes are lived out.” Accepting myself as I truly am requires that I reject a belief that I have a sexual identity other than being a man made for women. Recognizing this truth of who I am, as a sexual creature, is fundamental to the virtue of chastity. When it comes to homosexuality, however, many seem to believe that sexual continence is the earmark of chastity. But this is not so. Rather, continence, in any single person’s life, is a necessary sign of chastity, but it does not express the fullness or breadth of the beauty of the virtue. Chastity is far more than what we do or don’t do with our sexual organs. The Catechism tells us that “chastity means the successful integration of sexuality within the person and thus the inner unity of man in his bodily and spiritual being.” [...] This truth about my sexual identity is the reason I also refuse to call myself celibate. Though I am living a single life, I am no different than all of my other single friends who have yet to be married. They do not speak of themselves as celibate, nor should I. They and I are single. Nor am I a part of a “sexual minority,” as some would say of a man like me. I am a male, just as Adam was, just as Christ was, just like all of my other male friends. As the 1986 Letter On The Pastoral Care of the Homosexual Person wisely tells me, “every one living on the face of the earth has personal problems and difficulties, but challenges to growth, strengths, talents and gifts as well.” One of my challenges is that I suffer from the privation of the good of seeing women as sexually desirable—but that fact doesn’t make me a different sort of man than all of the other men in the world around me. The virtue of chastity teaches me this truth." Thoughts? That's bleak.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now