Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

The Strange Notion Of "gay Celibacy"


Recommended Posts

PhuturePriest
Posted

There's a big difference between saying, in a variety of ways, 'look, I'm empathetic' versus actually demonstrating empathy. 

 

I don't see how claiming he (and, I assume since I agree with him, I) has a lack of empathy simply because he believes we can overcome our struggles through grace. It's disingenuous.

Posted (edited)

What do you want, exactly?

 

When you talk so clinically and detached, it hurts this community and people personally. I don't think you are the type of person, in real life, to say something so hurtful to someone who is suffering, but you post seemingly without empathy. 

 

What about sitting with people in their brokenness, in their suffering? As a Christian, I do not respond to someone's hurt, sorrow, brokenness, or suffering by saying "Life smells of elderberries sometimes". I respond by being with them in their sorrow, to let them pour it out to me, to cry with them, to hurt with them, to say to them "I don't understand your pain, but I am here for you to rage to, to cry to, to unburden yourself to." I don't say "All you need is Jesus and to accept your life!" Or "That's the way your life is going to go, just buck up and accept it!" Is that really a Christian response? That has *never* been my response to see someone struggling (with their vocation, their life, their sexuality, whatever). I'm not trying to say that you don't respond in similar ways in real life, but online it doesn't not seem so. 

 

When you posted what you did, I feel like that was not an authentic engagement with where real Catholic people (not just anonymous screen names) are at in their lives and their struggles. Sarcasm is generally my first response in situations like these. 

 

 

With that, I'm out of this thread. I'm being too impatient with this today, and honestly don't need this kind of engagement in my life right now. Peace. 

Edited by Lil Red
Posted

There it is

 

And how, pray tell, does my statement lack empathy?

Posted

 

1,833 people died in the wake of Hurricane Katina.  The 2011 earthquake and resulting tsunamai off the coast of Japan killed 15,889 people.  In the past month Boko Haram has kidnapped and sold hundreds of young girls into sexual slavery, and killed hundreds more men.

 

Yeah, life smells of elderberries sometimes.

 

Nihil's presented the Catholic response to suffering.  A response of courage and trust in God's providence.  The effiminate spirituality some people peddle will do nothing more than breed more milquetoasts who will cower and wilt at the first confrontation with humanity's broken state.

 

Or perhaps you're one of those propserity gospel folks?

 

I disagree with Nihil a lot and think he has lots of blinders but I also believe that he means well. I think you just revel in it. 

Posted

 

1,833 people died in the wake of Hurricane Katina.  The 2011 earthquake and resulting tsunamai off the coast of Japan killed 15,889 people.  In the past month Boko Haram has kidnapped and sold hundreds of young girls into sexual slavery, and killed hundreds more men.

 

Yeah, life smells of elderberries sometimes.

 

Nihil's presented the Catholic response to suffering.  A response of courage and trust in God's providence.  The effiminate spirituality some people peddle will do nothing more than breed more milquetoasts who will cower and wilt at the first confrontation with humanity's broken state.

 

Or perhaps you're one of those propserity gospel folks?

 

Peace be with you. 

PhuturePriest
Posted

When you talk so clinically and detached, it hurts this community and people personally. I don't think you are the type of person, in real life, to say something so hurtful to someone who is suffering, but you post seemingly without empathy. 

 

What about sitting with people in their brokenness, in their suffering? As a Christian, I do not respond to someone's hurt, sorrow, brokenness, or suffering by saying "Life smells of elderberries sometimes". I respond by being with them in their sorrow, to let them pour it out to me, to cry with them, to hurt with them, to say to them "I don't understand your pain, but I am here for you to rage to, to cry to, to unburden yourself to." We don't say "All you need is Jesus and to accept your life!" Or "That's the way your life is going to go, just buck up and accept it!" Is that really a Christian response? That has *never* been my response to see someone struggling (with their vocation, their life, their sexuality, whatever). I'm not trying to say that you don't respond in similar ways in real life, but online it doesn't not seem so. 

 

When you posted what you did, I feel like that was not an authentic engagement with where real Catholic people (not just anonymous screen names) are at in their lives and their struggles. Sarcasm is generally my first response in situations like these. 

 

 

With that, I'm out of this thread. I'm being too impatient with this today, and honestly don't need this kind of engagement in my life right now. Peace. 

 

Emotions are important. We should always be empathetic. However, you seem to only be content with purely emotional responses to things, and disregard completely intellectual and philosophical approaches to issues. It seems rather unbalanced.

Posted

I disagree with Nihil a lot and think he has lots of blinders but I also believe that he means well. I think you just revel in it. 

 

You think I revel in what, exactly?

PhuturePriest
Posted

You think I revel in what, exactly?

 

Revelness. You're practically covered in it, really.

Posted

Emotions are important. We should always be empathetic. However, you seem to only be content with purely emotional responses to things, and disregard completely intellectual and philosophical approaches to issues. It seems rather unbalanced.

 

ohhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhh fpppppppppppppppppp

Posted

Revelness. You're practically covered in it, really.

 

YORO.

Not The Philosopher
Posted

Fun anecdote: One of my ordained profs recently started helping out in a youth ministry. He described the experience of having to deal with a bunch of teenagers for several hours as a "celibacy booster." Being married with kids ain't exactly a bed of roses either.

 

Anyhow, I think there's a bit of a line between acknowledging and empathizing with peoples' crosses, and going into, "oh, poor you" territory, which can get a bit patronizing, I find. Dealing with same-sex attraction/teh gays/whatever doesn't really put me on par with the Littlest Cancer Survivor.

Posted

For anyone who would like me to be highly empathetic and prayerful and charitable and understanding, that sounds great. Please start a thread. I will post in it, and anyone who would like to talk about that should do so. If you want to rake me over the coals, please do. If you would like to call me out for lacking charity and understanding, please do so. I will welcome it and participate to the best of my ability.

 

But this thread was not intended for that. It was not intended to be an investigation of anyone's relationship with the Church. I had hoped to discuss seriously and reasonably the authentic Catholic response to homosexuality and those affected by it. There is a place for such discussions, and I had hoped this thread might be one of those appropriate contexts. Like all subjects, we speak differently when we discuss on a theoretical level than we do on a personal level, and I intended from the start for this thread to address the theoretical. I have tried to do that in my own posts, and I apologize for anything I said that was 'clinical' or 'detached'. But I had intended for a specific subject for this thread which was not meant to be personal or condemnatory.

Posted

I am not and never have been a particularly emotive person. I will not apologize for that, but I will apologize for any time I have inadvertently been disrespectful or uncharitable. I have nothing but respect for everyone in this thread and have always tried to demonstrate that according to my abilities.
That is the last I will say on that topic in this thread.

Posted

I would disagree with you on a few nuanced points of your post.

Though I reject the idea that God purposefully makes people have SSA, I also believe that God gives us the grace and strength to overcome anything and fulfill us despite what we don't have (Note: I don't mean "overcome" as in "overcome your SSA"). If you are to be single the rest of your life, God will give you the grace and fulfillment necessary to do that. God will always give us everything we need to overcome anything that might be detrimental to our spiritual lives, including SSA. SSA isn't its own special entity that not even God can touch.

I agree that, as humans, we have a fundamental need for love between us. But I (Like the Church) disagree that our fundamental need for love means romance and eros in particular. In fact, I quite agree with C.S. Lewis that agape is the greatest of the four types of love, and people with SSA have a unique means to develop agape in its purest form.


Weves.

People sincerely believe in Xenu too. It's valid to believe God gives magic strength to endure pain. I'm not arguing that. But it's disengenous to use that as an argument for others to sit back and endure it.
franciscanheart
Posted

For anyone who would like me to be highly empathetic and prayerful and charitable and understanding, that sounds great. Please start a thread. I will post in it, and anyone who would like to talk about that should do so. If you want to rake me over the coals, please do. If you would like to call me out for lacking charity and understanding, please do so. I will welcome it and participate to the best of my ability.
 
But this thread was not intended for that. It was not intended to be an investigation of anyone's relationship with the Church. I had hoped to discuss seriously and reasonably the authentic Catholic response to homosexuality and those affected by it. There is a place for such discussions, and I had hoped this thread might be one of those appropriate contexts. Like all subjects, we speak differently when we discuss on a theoretical level than we do on a personal level, and I intended from the start for this thread to address the theoretical. I have tried to do that in my own posts, and I apologize for anything I said that was 'clinical' or 'detached'. But I had intended for a specific subject for this thread which was not meant to be personal or condemnatory.

You can't be serious.

Haven't you been at phatmass long enough to know that if you're going to post donkey poop, you're going to get called on it? Sorry, but no. Take it like a woman and move on.
PhuturePriest
Posted

Perhaps your position might be taken more seriously if your reasoning went beyond "Ermagerd, I am so enraged that you have the gall to think differently than I do."

PhuturePriest
Posted

You can't be serious.

Haven't you been at phatmass long enough to know that if you're going to post donkey poop, you're going to get called on it? Sorry, but no. Take it like a woman and move on.

 

What about it qualifies as "donkey poop"? You've given no reason as to why it is other than outrage that he disagrees with you. If this were a college paper, you'd be given an F and probably put on academic probation. If you want your position taken seriously, make the first move and take it seriously yourself. "Ermagerd, this is donkey poop" is not a genuine rebuttal to something, and you know that.

puellapaschalis
Posted (edited)

For anyone who would like me to be highly empathetic and prayerful and charitable and understanding, that sounds great. Please start a thread. I will post in it, and anyone who would like to talk about that should do so. If you want to rake me over the coals, please do. If you would like to call me out for lacking charity and understanding, please do so. I will welcome it and participate to the best of my ability.

 

But this thread was not intended for that. It was not intended to be an investigation of anyone's relationship with the Church. I had hoped to discuss seriously and reasonably the authentic Catholic response to homosexuality and those affected by it. There is a place for such discussions, and I had hoped this thread might be one of those appropriate contexts. Like all subjects, we speak differently when we discuss on a theoretical level than we do on a personal level, and I intended from the start for this thread to address the theoretical. I have tried to do that in my own posts, and I apologize for anything I said that was 'clinical' or 'detached'. But I had intended for a specific subject for this thread which was not meant to be personal or condemnatory.

 

It is precisely because issues like human sexuality and issues like it are so personally experienced by just about everyone that a dispassionate, 'clinical' if you like, discussion must be allowed to take place. Surgeons talking amongst themselves will discuss a condition without wearing their heart on their sleeves, so surely all of us (because as humans we all deal with our sexuality) should be able to do something similar. There is a place for an outwardly emotional empathy in this discussion, but also a need to not be clouded by the same. Past threads have been coloured by that emotional side of things - it's time for one without.
 

Edited by puellapaschalis
Posted

Ok, thank you.

PhuturePriest
Posted

It is precisely because issues like human sexuality and issues like it are so personally experienced by just about everyone that a dispassionate, 'clinical' if you like, discussion must be allowed to take place. Surgeons talking amongst themselves will discuss a condition without wearing their heart on their sleeves, so surely all of us (because as humans we all deal with our sexuality) should be able to do something similar. There is a place for an outwardly emotional empathy in this discussion, but also a need to not be clouded by the same. Past threads have been coloured by that emotional side of things - it's time for one without.
 

 

This should be stapled on the front page of Phatmass.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...