beatitude Posted January 27, 2015 Posted January 27, 2015 We have talked about this at length, actually -- this part you want to call attention to. Would it make you feel better if we all just shut up about it and didn't say anything and used no words to describe a difference because NOTHING TO SEE HERE? Already I am troubled by this thread. Perhaps I'll sit this one out and let the heterosexual, armchair theologians have it; I'm sure they're holier and more correct than I'll ever be. Me too. Reading that article was quite disturbing for me because I had a friend who used to write blog posts in a similar style to that, getting lots of approval and pats on the back from the particular Catholics she surrounded herself with (some of whom told her that her attraction to women was caused by demons). She was performing for an audience. Eventually it wore her out and didn't help her mental health at all. She doesn't believe in God any more. Such articles mostly seem to be written for the benefit of straight people who find the word 'gay' to be icky and want to be able to wave around a piece of paper going, "See! This gay person agrees with me!" I don't see any benefit to anyone in doing that, so I will join you in sitting out and hope that you have brought some cake. :)
Amppax Posted January 27, 2015 Posted January 27, 2015 (edited) Me too. Reading that article was quite disturbing for me because I had a friend who used to write blog posts in a similar style to that, getting lots of approval and pats on the back from the particular Catholics she surrounded herself with (some of whom told her that her attraction to women was caused by demons). She was performing for an audience. Eventually it wore her out and didn't help her mental health at all. She doesn't believe in God any more. Such articles mostly seem to be written for the benefit of straight people who find the word 'gay' to be icky and want to be able to wave around a piece of paper going, "See! This gay person agrees with me!" I don't see any benefit to anyone in doing that, so I will join you in sitting out and hope that you have brought some cake. :) I think you're making a pretty uncharitable assumption about the author. It's like the atheist who says theists don't ACTUALLY believe in all this God stuff, they're just lying to themselves, it's all an act. So your friend talked like this and has rejected faith, I don't think you need to project that onto the author. While I can see how you could read that into his piece, why not just take him at his word? Additionally, the assumption that everyone who reads the article is just looking for something saying that "icky" feeling they have about homosexuality is A-okay is about the same level of demeaning. Just speaking for myself, there are several people I'm close to who identify as gay. When I read on the topic my goal is to learn how to love these people I care about more. Not so I can sit back in self satisfaction and say "See? I knew it all along, to hell with teh gayz." Anyway, that's all I want to say about that. Edited January 27, 2015 by Amppax
beatitude Posted January 27, 2015 Posted January 27, 2015 I think you're making a pretty uncharitable assumption about the author. It's like the atheist who says theists don't ACTUALLY believe in all this God stuff, they're just lying to themselves, it's all an act. So your friend talked like this and has rejected faith, I don't think you need to project that onto the author. While I can see how you could read that into his piece, why not just take him at his word? Additionally, the assumption that everyone who reads the article is just looking for something saying that "icky" feeling they have about homosexuality is A-okay is about the same level of demeaning. Just speaking for myself, there are several people I'm close to who identify as gay. When I read on the topic my goal is to learn how to love these people I care about more. Not so I can sit back in self satisfaction and say "See? I knew it all along, to hell with teh gayz." Anyway, that's all I want to say about that. I'm not saying that I think the blog author is going to reject his faith. I mean that reading anything in that language or style is disturbing for me because it brings back memories of my friend (and what she had to do to herself in order to buy acceptance in a certain circle). I should have been clearer on that. But regarding the popularity of articles like this in certain Catholic circles, I stand by what I said. I have seen people doggedly referring to homosexuality as SSA, never mind that using an acronym with a quasi-medical feel might be quite hurtful to gay people, and when challenged on it (including by actual gay people) they go, "But I'm being loving, a person is always so much more than their sexuality, so I'm just trying to show that! I just don't want to reduce people to a label!" This has practically become a cliche. But when someone uses terms like SSA to describe their experience, they grab that writing and flourish it around as proof of their position - and what can the subtext of that be other than "Look, one of them agrees with me!"? This is reducing people to their sexuality despite all claims to the contrary, and it harms people. They might have the best intentions in the world but even the best intentions can still be damaging. Let's face it - the homosexuality discussions on Phatmass are rarely initiated by gay people (and on the few occasions that franciscanheart made threads about her experiences, there was a backlash from some users about how she was trying to put too much attention on herself and how she's gay). It's always seems to be straight people who love talking this to death and to be honest I don't think that this obsessive level of interest in anything is pure. I also don't think we need to read articles debating uses of terminology ad infinitum in order to learn how to love people better.
franciscanheart Posted January 27, 2015 Posted January 27, 2015 Of course we have talked about it. But nobody thinks we have solved it. And I do think there are issues with the (for lack of a non-icky term) "new homophiles'" narrative.I think it is easier to discuss these issues if we make an effort not to be hostile when we find disagreement. Like I said, it does not seem particularly to be an issue with anyone actually rejecting Church teaching.What would be icky? I ask with genuine curiosity.Here's the thing, Nihil: there is an effort being made. Whether you have the heart or mind enough to recognize that this is subdued is not a problem for which I wish to take responsibility, but I would suggest you now note, if you have not already, that this is restraint. If you are ignorant about the depth and weight of such issues, perhaps it would be more charitable of you to stay out of the discussion, or reserve your participation for such arenas as your dining room table with mom and pop. I've been told people often mold their young into something like themselves and that, even when they stray, most are uninclined to consume their young.
franciscanheart Posted January 27, 2015 Posted January 27, 2015 I'm not saying that I think the blog author is going to reject his faith. I mean that reading anything in that language or style is disturbing for me because it brings back memories of my friend (and what she had to do to herself in order to buy acceptance in a certain circle). I should have been clearer on that. But regarding the popularity of articles like this in certain Catholic circles, I stand by what I said. I have seen people doggedly referring to homosexuality as SSA, never mind that using an acronym with a quasi-medical feel might be quite hurtful to gay people, and when challenged on it (including by actual gay people) they go, "But I'm being loving, a person is always so much more than their sexuality, so I'm just trying to show that! I just don't want to reduce people to a label!" This has practically become a cliche. But when someone uses terms like SSA to describe their experience, they grab that writing and flourish it around as proof of their position - and what can the subtext of that be other than "Look, one of them agrees with me!"? This is reducing people to their sexuality despite all claims to the contrary, and it harms people. They might have the best intentions in the world but even the best intentions can still be damaging. Let's face it - the homosexuality discussions on Phatmass are rarely initiated by gay people (and on the few occasions that franciscanheart made threads about her experiences, there was a backlash from some users about how she was trying to put too much attention on herself and how she's gay). It's always seems to be straight people who love talking this to death and to be honest I don't think that this obsessive level of interest in anything is pure. I also don't think we need to read articles debating uses of terminology ad infinitum in order to learn how to love people better.You get the biggest slice. I'll eat the crumbs. :love:
Amppax Posted January 27, 2015 Posted January 27, 2015 I'm not saying that I think the blog author is going to reject his faith. I mean that reading anything in that language or style is disturbing for me because it brings back memories of my friend (and what she had to do to herself in order to buy acceptance in a certain circle). I should have been clearer on that. Thanks for the clarification. But regarding the popularity of articles like this in certain Catholic circles, I stand by what I said. I have seen people doggedly referring to homosexuality as SSA, never mind that using an acronym with a quasi-medical feel might be quite hurtful to gay people, and when challenged on it (including by actual gay people) they go, "But I'm being loving, a person is always so much more than their sexuality, so I'm just trying to show that! I just don't want to reduce people to a label!" This has practically become a cliche. But when someone uses terms like SSA to describe their experience, they grab that writing and flourish it around as proof of their position - and what can the subtext of that be other than "Look, one of them agrees with me!"? This is reducing people to their sexuality despite all claims to the contrary, and it harms people. They might have the best intentions in the world but even the best intentions can still be damaging. Let's face it - the homosexuality discussions on Phatmass are rarely initiated by gay people (and on the few occasions that franciscanheart made threads about her experiences, there was a backlash from some users about how she was trying to put too much attention on herself and how she's gay). It's always seems to be straight people who love talking this to death and to be honest I don't think that this obsessive level of interest in anything is pure. I also don't think we need to read articles debating uses of terminology ad infinitum in order to learn how to love people better. In my mind, the debate isn't about the terminology, it's the anthropology underlying (which, I think the author did a good job of highlighting). And, insofar as that anthropology relates to the truth, I think it does impact how we love. I'm actually fairly neutral in this particular debate ("New Homophiles" vs. Mattson et. al.; Crisis Magazine vs. Spiritual Friendship), I've read things from both sides that I found compelling. I think it's a discussion worth having. In terms of this article, while I found it interesting, I wouldn't say I agree with everything he said. I do agree with you, the focus on the terminology, if that is the center of the discussion, is misplaced. I should also be clear, I'm interested in this on more than one level, considering theology is more than just an armchair hobby for me, but my career/vocation/etc. Considering this has become maybe the most pressing social issue, I don't think the interest is necessarily out of place.
CrossCuT Posted January 27, 2015 Posted January 27, 2015 One thing I find interesting is that the author discusses his sexual identity as being a function of the other gender. I disagree. Being gay does not make you less of a man because you dont prefer vaginas....gay men are still men. Although later on he is like "IM A MAN LIKE JESUS AND ADAM CUZ THEY LOVE THEM CHICKS AND STUFF!" Oy oy oy I will be in the minority when I say the church really needs to straighten out (bad pun) their views on homosexuals because its just freaking convoluted at this point. The dude sounds like he is rambling about ways to convince himself that the church doesnt shun him as completely as it actually does. And then all us straight people can sit back and give ourselves a round of applause for finding a gay person who will denounce himself for the sake of his faith "See gay people get it!" His article might sound happy and like he has it all figured out, but he is most definitely denouncing himself...its sad to me.
CrossCuT Posted January 27, 2015 Posted January 27, 2015 Such articles mostly seem to be written for the benefit of straight people who find the word 'gay' to be icky and want to be able to wave around a piece of paper going, "See! This gay person agrees with me!" I don't see any benefit to anyone in doing that, so I will join you in sitting out and hope that you have brought some cake. :) Im glad Im not the only person with this thought.
Amppax Posted January 27, 2015 Posted January 27, 2015 If anyone's interested, there's a debate between the author of the article and Eve Tushnet, author of the book "Gay and Catholic." You can find it here, skip ahead to 8:25 to hear the beginning of the discussion.
Not The Philosopher Posted January 27, 2015 Posted January 27, 2015 If anyone's interested, there's a debate between the author of the article and Eve Tushnet, author of the book "Gay and Catholic." You can find it here, skip ahead to 8:25 to hear the beginning of the discussion. I'd like to check it out when I have the time. I've been following Tushnet and Mattson for the past couple of years, so it'll be interesting to hear them sparring with each other.
Nihil Obstat Posted January 27, 2015 Author Posted January 27, 2015 My perspective is this: Do gay Catholics, or whatever term you prefer, actually identify with homosexuality? In other words, do they believe homosexuality forms part of their identity as human beings? Do they agree with the Church that homosexual attraction is, in and of itself, an inherent disorder. I.e. homosexual attraction cannot in itself be oriented to the good? So, how does a Catholic reconcile treating an inherent disorder as a part of their deepest identity? Do they then wish to treat homosexuality as a good to be celebrated? If so I wish to hear the rationale. And if my line of questions misses the point, I would like to know precisely where, because this is a subject in which I will not tolerate a lack of clarity. The stakes are far too high. So Fran, with all due respect, I am not going anywhere. I have a stake in this too, and I intend to be thorough.
franciscanheart Posted January 27, 2015 Posted January 27, 2015 My perspective is this:Do gay Catholics, or whatever term you prefer, actually identify with homosexuality? In other words, do they believe homosexuality forms part of their identity as human beings?Do they agree with the Church that homosexual attraction is, in and of itself, an inherent disorder. I.e. homosexual attraction cannot in itself be oriented to the good?So, how does a Catholic reconcile treating an inherent disorder as a part of their deepest identity?Do they then wish to treat homosexuality as a good to be celebrated? If so I wish to hear the rationale.And if my line of questions misses the point, I would like to know precisely where, because this is a subject in which I will not tolerate a lack of clarity. The stakes are far too high.So Fran, with all due respect, I am not going anywhere. I have a stake in this too, and I intend to be thorough.Before anyone attempts to answer the questions we have already answered in a number of other threads on phatmass preceding this one, let me ask you this:Do heterosexual Catholics view sexuality as a piece of their identity? Is sexuality part of who we are as humans -- errrrr... part of who they are as heterosexual people?
CrossCuT Posted January 27, 2015 Posted January 27, 2015 My perspective is this: Do gay Catholics, or whatever term you prefer, actually identify with homosexuality? In other words, do they believe homosexuality forms part of their identity as human beings? Do they agree with the Church that homosexual attraction is, in and of itself, an inherent disorder. I.e. homosexual attraction cannot in itself be oriented to the good? So, how does a Catholic reconcile treating an inherent disorder as a part of their deepest identity? Do they then wish to treat homosexuality as a good to be celebrated? If so I wish to hear the rationale. And if my line of questions misses the point, I would like to know precisely where, because this is a subject in which I will not tolerate a lack of clarity. The stakes are far too high. So Fran, with all due respect, I am not going anywhere. I have a stake in this too, and I intend to be thorough. Honestly, I think there are a lot of homosexuals who do not identify as such because of the incredible amount of pressure and negativity from the church and certain parts of society (which are influenced by the church). They find a way to cope with that blatant bigotry by enveloping themselves in the churchs discrimination and turning into a coat of honor instead of a coat of shame. I think this author is a prime example. Most of society is cool beans with homosexuality, however the seed of discrimination is still planted through the church because they continually preach that it is inherently disordered, disgusting, and something homosexuals need to repress, deny, or ignore. If they dont do this, they have no place in the Catholic society; they are effectively shunned and looked upon with different eyes. Honestly (and this might sound terrible) but I dont understand how any Catholic homosexual can feel totally ok with giving up any sort life of love with a partner simply because their faith doesnt know what the eff to do with them anymore. Its so depressing for me to think that people willingly subject themselves to a partnerless future because the church has taught them they are damaged and twisted. But again, maybe I just dont get the religion thing...maybe they are fulfilled with their spiritual life and love for God so much that its not a struggle...or maybe it is a struggle and they are cool with it. I dunno. I try to put myself in that position as best as I can (for being a straight person who wont ever have to deal with the same struggles) and it still sucks. But I think you raise a good question. How do you have both? How do you maintain your Catholic faith that calls for you to view the desire as evil, disorders, and sick but still treat the people lovingly? I think thats the key; it doesnt happen...or at least very rarely. You might have the best intentions, but your core belief is that this is wrong/bad/sick etc....and its hard to wade through those feelings to come out the other side unscathed as far as how you treat people. Its the ripple effect.
Nihil Obstat Posted January 27, 2015 Author Posted January 27, 2015 (edited) Before anyone attempts to answer the questions we have already answered in a number of other threads on phatmass preceding this one, let me ask you this: Do heterosexual Catholics view sexuality as a piece of their identity? Is sexuality part of who we are as humans -- errrrr... part of who they are as heterosexual people? I will not speak for anyone else, but I view heterosexuality as being explicitly ordained by God to be directed towards marriage, then ultimately for the purpose of 一 procreation, 二 mutual love, support, sanctification. Inasmuch as homosexuality cannot be oriented towards the purpose of human sexuality I likewise cannot consider it oriented towards the ultimate good. Therefore I would consider it misguided to accept it as an inherent part of human identity. Therefore, I would not consider heterosexuality as such to be part of my identity. Rather I consider it to be a manifestation of natural law and orientation towards God's intentions for man. Heterosexuality is prescriptively normative, and homosexuality is an unfortunate consequence of man's broken nature and an inclination which is to be overcome in a way that leads to sanctification. Edit for further clarity: heterosexuality, then, is the proper ordering of human sexuality. Homosexuality is a disordered (not sinful, disordered) orientation of human sexuality. Edited January 27, 2015 by Nihil Obstat
franciscanheart Posted January 27, 2015 Posted January 27, 2015 I will not speak for anyone else, but I view heterosexuality as being explicitly ordained by God to be directed towards marriage, then ultimately for the purpose of 一 procreation, 二 mutual love, support, sanctification.Inasmuch as homosexuality cannot be oriented towards the purpose of human sexuality I likewise cannot consider it oriented towards the ultimate good. Therefore I would consider it misguided to accept it as an inherent part of human identity. Therefore, I would not consider heterosexuality as such to be part of my identity. Rather I consider it to be a manifestation of natural law and orientation towards God's intentions for man. Heterosexuality is prescriptively normative, and homosexuality is an unfortunate consequence of man's broken nature and an inclination which is to be overcome in a way that leads to sanctification. Edit for further clarity: heterosexuality, then, is the proper ordering of human sexuality. Homosexuality is a disordered (not sinful, disordered) orientation of human sexuality.Why then do you ask for any of us to speak for all others?
Nihil Obstat Posted January 27, 2015 Author Posted January 27, 2015 (edited) Why then do you ask for any of us to speak for all others? Speak for yourself, and if you feel inclined then attempt to speak for others. While I said that I speak for myself, I should have added the caveat that I think what I said is true for everyone, but I do not think that many people have explicitly thought of it in such terms. Many 'average Catholics' do not always think in philosophical terms, which is fine, but for the sake of clarity I think it is necessary here. Edited January 27, 2015 by Nihil Obstat
PhuturePriest Posted January 27, 2015 Posted January 27, 2015 I see no reason why we can't or shouldn't talk about such matters, especially since they are more important than ever in this age. Many Catholics identify with being gay to the point that they disagree with Church doctrine. Obviously, we all agree that is wrong and is taking it too far. But is that the only way to take it too far? How do we know if we haven't spoken about it in length and discussed it philosophically and theologically?
An Historian Posted January 27, 2015 Posted January 27, 2015 I will not speak for anyone else, but I view heterosexuality as being explicitly ordained by God to be directed towards marriage, then ultimately for the purpose of 一 procreation, 二 mutual love, support, sanctification. Inasmuch as homosexuality cannot be oriented towards the purpose of human sexuality I likewise cannot consider it oriented towards the ultimate good. Therefore I would consider it misguided to accept it as an inherent part of human identity. Therefore, I would not consider heterosexuality as such to be part of my identity. Rather I consider it to be a manifestation of natural law and orientation towards God's intentions for man. Heterosexuality is prescriptively normative, and homosexuality is an unfortunate consequence of man's broken nature and an inclination which is to be overcome in a way that leads to sanctification. Edit for further clarity: heterosexuality, then, is the proper ordering of human sexuality. Homosexuality is a disordered (not sinful, disordered) orientation of human sexuality. Fantastic post, Nihil.
Nihil Obstat Posted January 27, 2015 Author Posted January 27, 2015 Fantastic post, Nihil. Thank you. I am putting a lot of effort into this.
An Historian Posted January 27, 2015 Posted January 27, 2015 Thank you. I am putting a lot of effort into this. Reading your posts in this thread have been a great help. As you said, most Catholics don't think in philosophical terms. And while I lament the fact that I am more educated than most Catholics—it should not be so, as I am not even remotely theologically or philosophically trained—I still lack the aid of systematiic thought and expression on matters of the Catholic faith whch philosophy provides. You've adequately expressed my own thoughts on human sexuality better than I have been able to myself up until now.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now