veritasluxmea Posted April 30, 2015 Posted April 30, 2015 Fran, To be fair, NO started the thread with the article that dismissed sexual orientation as being superfluous to Catholics. Either you are celibate, or have sex with a spouse that is open to life. Any other nuance or flavoring to the conversation is unwanted adulteration to the ideal. IOW, shut up about who you would prefer to touch, it's no touch unless conception can occur with your spouse within a sacramental marriage. Simple black and white Church ministry to all humans. "There is no getting away from it; the Christian rule is, 'Either marriage, with complete faithfulness to your partner, or else total abstinence.' Now this is so difficult and so contrary to our instincts, that obviously either Christianity is wrong or our sexual instinct, as it now is, has gone wrong. One or the other. Of course, being a Christian, I think it is the instinct which has gone wrong. But I have other reasons for thinking so." C.S. Lewis in Mere Christianity
Anomaly Posted April 30, 2015 Posted April 30, 2015 "There is no getting away from it; the Christian rule is, 'Either marriage, with complete faithfulness to your partner, or else total abstinence.' Now this is so difficult and so contrary to our instincts, that obviously either Christianity is wrong or our sexual instinct, as it now is, has gone wrong. One or the other. Of course, being a Christian, I think it is the instinct which has gone wrong. But I have other reasons for thinking so." C.S. Lewis in Mere Christianity I don't think any one proposed out of marriage sex anywhere in this thread. Fran's points in how the Church can help people with SSA achieve this. The entire point is it's different for someone living 'haven't met a compatible person to be a spouse' and living with 'my sexual attraction condemns me to never having or being a spouse'. Some are blissfully satisfied with the "Just Say No" ministry. Others think the can be something more. Like recognizing all crosses don't weigh the same, especially if you've never carried it. I want to say something about compassion vs empathy vs sympathy vs kindness here but suitable nuance eludes me.
Norseman82 Posted May 1, 2015 Posted May 1, 2015 Consider that you (that is, our hypothetical person doing everything right [let's just ignore the problems here]) still have the hope that someday, maybe, you will be able to fulfill that desire. How exactly is that harder than knowing you'll never have that sort of intimacy? Right, but again, see above. They still could. Which is very different than can't. The point is that I don't use it as an argument to create a protected class to give me permission to live an immoral lifestyle, which is what the examples Aragon cited are used by the secular media to gain sympathy for the "agenda". At least people with SSA can identify what is causing their inability to find an opposite-gender spouse (however, who says they cannot change?) as opposed to the non-impedimented people who get uncalled for opposition from their fellow Catholics (see Frannie's manipulative "you know better than God" statement).
Norseman82 Posted May 1, 2015 Posted May 1, 2015 Considering such a state (wanting marriage but not getting it) an injustice is saying that you know better than God what is good for your life. Do you have a private 1-800 line to God? If so, there's a certain Argentinian in Rome that I'm sure would like to have you on his staff. You do not speak for what God thinks is good in my life. I, on the other hand, have read what God has publicly stated about how it is not good for man to be alone. God has clearly indicated in Scripture that for those that (for whatever reason) cannot handle lifelong celibacy, heterosexual mariage IS what is good for his/her life. So, if anyone is off-base here, it certainly isn't me.
Norseman82 Posted May 1, 2015 Posted May 1, 2015 (edited) -- you're probably attracted to the toaster." With which you can make a turkey sandwich for Lilllabettt... Edited May 1, 2015 by Norseman82
Credo in Deum Posted May 1, 2015 Posted May 1, 2015 Fran, To be fair, NO started the thread with the article that dismissed sexual orientation as being superfluous to Catholics. Either you are celibate, or have sex with a spouse that is open to life. Any other nuance or flavoring to the conversation is unwanted adulteration to the ideal. IOW, shut up about who you would prefer to touch, it's no touch unless conception can occur with your spouse within a sacramental marriage. Simple black and white Church ministry to all humans. It's sad that you look at it in such a cold way. The reality is the Church, Christ, calls all of us to a higher love for one another; a Supernatural Charity. This is a love for the salvation of souls, the image of God found in all human persons! I know this means little to an atheist, but, to a Catholic it is a form a love the world does not teach or provide. As Christ said, "no greater love than this, that a man lay down his life for his friends." When I do not act on my attraction I lay down my life. When I get an attraction and move my thoughts to the things which are above, I lay down my life. Sure there is a difference between couldn't and can't but it is not so big that I have to become depressed about it. There are plenty of people who can't have things I can and so where I struggle they do not, but where they struggle I do not. I don't ask that others minimize my struggle, but I also don't minimize the struggles of others just because they haven't or don't experience the same things as me. It's not really fair for me to use the "you don't know what I go through" defense to minimize someone else's struggle by saying mine are heavier, when I do not know how heavy the other persons struggles are with the things in their life. Sure all crosses aren't the same weight but they all lead to the same thing and that is our sanctification which means they're heavy enough to cause a death to self. No Catholic should ever compare crosses, since it is uncharitable. Regardless in the end I reflect on why was I created? Was it so I could have everything I desire? Was I created for myself? No, as a Catholic I believe I was made to love, honor, and serve God and my neighbor as myself; a child made in the image of God, purchased with a high price the Blood of Jesus Christ. This is my purpose and my greatest peace amidst all sufferings. Sure I still struggle with being too focused on myself and my desires, but through the sacramental life, a great confessor, and prayers and mortifications, I have been blessed to see that my desires, regardless of what or who they are for, are the highest expressions of love only when they are ordered toward God. It is because of this I am thankful for my Cross and blessed that God has permitted me to have it since it is an opportunity for me to give everything to Him, which is the very reality of Heaven where God posses my entire being! I want to be in Heaven so God can have all of me, so why shouldn't my life on earth reflect the eternity I'm moving towards and why should I waste my time upset because I can't have something which would move me in the opposite direction? Dear Jesus, bless our social and cultural climate. Grant that that our society may be purified of everything contrary to chastity, and that we may have the strength to resist the pressures of prevailing distortions of human sexuality. “In the world you have tribulation; but be of good cheer, I have conquered the world” (Jn. 16:33). “In all these things we are more than conquerors through him who loved us” (Rom. 8:37).Hail Mary... Dear Jesus, bless our relationships. Grant that they will be holy, healthy, and honorable at all times. “Having purified your souls by your obedience to the truth for a sincere love of the brethren, love one another earnestly from the heart” (1 Pet. 1:22).Hail Mary... Dear Jesus, bless our efforts at modesty. Grant that how we dress and carry ourselves may veil what should be veiled, and give us the strength to resist evil fashions and the glamor of sin. “Do not be conformed to this age, but be transformed by the renewal of your mind” (Rom. 12:2).Hail Mary... Dear Jesus, bless our five senses. Grant that the things we see, the music and jokes we hear, our food and drink, and the encounters we have through touch may all be pure and holy. “Seek the things that are above” (Col. 3:1).Hail Mary... Dear Jesus, bless our sensuality. Grant that our impulses may not go after base pleasures, but will be freed by wisdom and inflamed for what is good. “In your struggle against sin you have not yet resisted to the point of shedding your blood” (Heb. 12:4).Hail Mary... Dear Jesus, bless our memory. Grant that no dark memories from our past may haunt us, but let your light shine within us to fill us with a healing hope in you. “And every one who thus hopes in him purifies himself as he is pure” (1 Jn. 3:1). Hail Mary.... Dear Jesus, bless our power of estimation. Grant that we may quickly sense dangers to chastity, instinctively flee from them, and that we may never turn away from higher and more difficult goods for the sake of sinful self- indulgence. “For what shall it profit a man to gain the whole world and lose his soul?” (Mk. 8:36)Hail Mary... Dear Jesus, bless our affectivity. Grant that we may love chastity and rejoice in it, that all of our emotions may be in harmony with what is right, and that no sadness, discouragement, fear, insecurity, or loneliness may afflict us unto sexual sin. “For the grace of God has appeared, saving all and training us to reject godless ways and worldly passions and to live temperately, justly, and devoutly in this age...” (Titus 2:11-12).Hail Mary... Dear Jesus, bless our hearts. Grant that the place where Christ abides in us with the Father and the Spirit may become the place where we live with the Holy Trinity in friendship. “Jesus answered him, ‘If a man loves me, he will keep my word, and my Father will love him, and we will come to him and make our home with him.’” (Jn. 14:23). Dear Jesus, bless our will. Grant that it may never be opposed by our sensuality, that it may never be conflicted in the moment, but that it may hold fast to chastity no matter how difficult it may be. “For the Son of God, Jesus Christ... was not Yes and No; but in him it is always Yes. For all the promises of God find their Yes in him” (2 Cor. 1:19-20).Hail Mary... Dear Jesus, grant us the grace of self- surrender. Grant that we may hand over to God nothing less than our whole lives. “Father, into your hands I commend my spirit” (Lk. 23:46).Hail Mary... PAX
veritasluxmea Posted May 1, 2015 Posted May 1, 2015 I don't think any one proposed out of marriage sex anywhere in this thread. Fran's points in how the Church can help people with SSA achieve this. The entire point is it's different for someone living 'haven't met a compatible person to be a spouse' and living with 'my sexual attraction condemns me to never having or being a spouse'. Some are blissfully satisfied with the "Just Say No" ministry. Others think the can be something more. Like recognizing all crosses don't weigh the same, especially if you've never carried it. I want to say something about compassion vs empathy vs sympathy vs kindness here but suitable nuance eludes me. No, it was more that your original post reminded me of the quote. Honestly the best place to start... Courage should be more widely promoted, every diocese should have a solid branch. It should be more open that this is a problem and there's an option, like maybe having advertisements in the bulletin or little cards in the confessional. Churches should again, like NO stated, offer sacraments, spiritual direction, incorporate into parish life like they do for everyone else, but with more focus on support for homosexuality. The rest is just making sure people are focused on community and building up other disciples. For teens, when youth groups have TOB night, cover homosexuality with something like Jason Evert on it. If a teen thinks they're gay, I'd think the best thing to do is just affirm and reassure them and their experiences and also give them space/time and no pressure to figure it out. Actually, the better parishes already do this. Other parishes can barely get their music program and religious education together, so don't expect anything special for SSA. I think an individual, local approach like that is best. What else needs to be done?
Anomaly Posted May 1, 2015 Posted May 1, 2015 It's sad that you look at it in such a cold way. The reality is the Church, Christ, calls all of us to a higher love for one another; a Supernatural Charity. This is a love for the salvation of souls, the image of God found in all human persons! I know this means little to an atheist, but, to a Catholic it is a form a love the world does not teach or provide. As Christ said, "no greater love than this, that a man lay down his life for his friends." When I do not act on my attraction I lay down my life. When I get an attraction and move my thoughts to the things which are above, I lay down my life. Sure there is a difference between couldn't and can't but it is not so big that I have to become depressed about it. There are plenty of people who can't have things I can and so where I struggle they do not, but where they struggle I do not. I don't ask that others minimize my struggle, but I also don't minimize the struggles of others just because they haven't or don't experience the same things as me. It's not really fair for me to use the "you don't know what I go through" defense to minimize someone else's struggle by saying mine are heavier, when I do not know how heavy the other persons struggles are with the things in their life. Sure all crosses aren't the same weight but they all lead to the same thing and that is our sanctification which means they're heavy enough to cause a death to self. No Catholic should ever compare crosses, since it is uncharitable. PAX I apologize that I didn't convey pointed sarcasm against tone deaf "instruction" and instead led you to mistakenly believe that was my personal opinion. Empathy and kindness is not necessarily excluded from atheistic or theist philosophies. Atheists are just limited to fostering it within this lifetime. Neither claim to be perfect or always good at it. Kinda what puts the thrill in living and a reason for good conversation. Peace and contentment to you as well.
Amppax Posted May 1, 2015 Posted May 1, 2015 (edited) This is definitely a first, but I was doing some reading inspired by this thread and came across this video by Michael Voris. As most probably know, I'm not a fan of his, but I thought this was very interesting and well said. I'm interested to see what others think, especially Frannie. Anyway, here is the video: Edited May 1, 2015 by Amppax
Ark Posted May 2, 2015 Posted May 2, 2015 (edited) Does anyone feel there's too much openness on this topic? I think some things should be kept private with a spiritual director. Edited May 2, 2015 by Ark
franciscanheart Posted May 4, 2015 Posted May 4, 2015 This is definitely a first, but I was doing some reading inspired by this thread and came across this video by Michael Voris. As most probably know, I'm not a fan of his, but I thought this was very interesting and well said. I'm interested to see what others think, especially Frannie. Anyway, here is the video: I think it's interesting. I was apprehensive for obvious reason, but he makes some good points. I take no issue (from what I remember).
franciscanheart Posted May 4, 2015 Posted May 4, 2015 Does anyone feel there's too much openness on this topic? I think some things should be kept private with a spiritual director. If I were sharing the details of some kind of perverted sexual desire publicly, I would imagine that would be too open. If I was talking constantly about lustful thoughts about people, I could see where that would be questionable. As for being open about being gay, no, I don't. Since coming out at phatmass, I have had numerous people write to me to talk, to commiserate, and to find support, comfort, and strength. We lean on each other when the going gets tough, and we wouldn't be able to do that if we didn't know who each of the others were. We only know because we weren't afraid to say something outside of spiritual direction. I don't discuss the details of my struggles with the general public. That would be ridiculous. But in the same way I see it beneficial for people who have lost children or spouses to seek comfort and support with others, I see the benefit of gay Catholics having people like them to talk to. I imagine the same is true for divorced Catholics and others.
Ark Posted May 5, 2015 Posted May 5, 2015 If I were sharing the details of some kind of perverted sexual desire publicly, I would imagine that would be too open. If I was talking constantly about lustful thoughts about people, I could see where that would be questionable. As for being open about being gay, no, I don't. Since coming out at phatmass, I have had numerous people write to me to talk, to commiserate, and to find support, comfort, and strength. We lean on each other when the going gets tough, and we wouldn't be able to do that if we didn't know who each of the others were. We only know because we weren't afraid to say something outside of spiritual direction. I don't discuss the details of my struggles with the general public. That would be ridiculous. But in the same way I see it beneficial for people who have lost children or spouses to seek comfort and support with others, I see the benefit of gay Catholics having people like them to talk to. I imagine the same is true for divorced Catholics and others. Well I thank you for sharing that. I can see where a benefit may be derived from some openness, but conversely I don't see people habituated to the sin of self-abuse and porn addiction really discussing their disordered sin in the open, and their sin is far more common than homosexuality. I think there is a danger with being too open and causing scandal by making homosexuality seem acceptable -- 'acceptable' meaning "ok" -- I do not mean to suggest that homosexuals should face abuse or any bigotry.
Amppax Posted May 5, 2015 Posted May 5, 2015 Well I thank you for sharing that. I can see where a benefit may be derived from some openness, but conversely I don't see people habituated to the sin of self-abuse and porn addiction really discussing their disordered sin in the open, and their sin is far more common than homosexuality. I think there is a danger with being too open and causing scandal by making homosexuality seem acceptable -- 'acceptable' meaning "ok" -- I do not mean to suggest that homosexuals should face abuse or any bigotry. You're wrong on that count, there've been quite a few threads on the topic of pornography before. However, you're missing an important distinction, between homosexual inclinations and actions. The actions are sinful, the inclination is not. I think when this distinction is made (and it's been made ad nauseum on this forum), scandal shouldn't be an issue.
franciscanheart Posted May 5, 2015 Posted May 5, 2015 Well I thank you for sharing that. I can see where a benefit may be derived from some openness, but conversely I don't see people habituated to the sin of self-abuse and porn addiction really discussing their disordered sin in the open, and their sin is far more common than homosexuality. I think there is a danger with being too open and causing scandal by making homosexuality seem acceptable -- 'acceptable' meaning "ok" -- I do not mean to suggest that homosexuals should face abuse or any bigotry. I second what Amp said below, though I understand and appreciate your line of thought. The distinction Amp mentions is incredibly important and I think invalidates any idea that we're discussing sinful behavior as if it's acceptable or "bound to happen". Make sense? Self-abuse or masturbation or viewing pornography -- those are all sins. Being gay isn't sinful. The tendency toward homosexual desire is not, in and of itself, a sin. Homosexual actions are sinful, and I would not talk about those things "openly" in the way I talk about just being gay. So to compare being gay to, as you offered up, watching pornography, isn't really fair -- though, again, I understand how you arrived at that comparison and appreciate the point you were attempting to make. You're wrong on that count, there've been quite a few threads on the topic of pornography before. However, you're missing an important distinction, between homosexual inclinations and actions. The actions are sinful, the inclination is not. I think when this distinction is made (and it's been made ad nauseum on this forum), scandal shouldn't be an issue. Agreed.
Ark Posted May 8, 2015 Posted May 8, 2015 I second what Amp said below, though I understand and appreciate your line of thought. The distinction Amp mentions is incredibly important and I think invalidates any idea that we're discussing sinful behavior as if it's acceptable or "bound to happen". Make sense? Self-abuse or masturbation or viewing pornography -- those are all sins. Being gay isn't sinful. The tendency toward homosexual desire is not, in and of itself, a sin. Homosexual actions are sinful, and I would not talk about those things "openly" in the way I talk about just being gay. So to compare being gay to, as you offered up, watching pornography, isn't really fair -- though, again, I understand how you arrived at that comparison and appreciate the point you were attempting to make. Hmm. Well desire can certainly be sinful for a heterosexual so it can certainly be sinful for a homosexual. Our Lord said that a man who thinks of committing adultery has already become guilty of it. I guess what seems to be changing is this idea of homosexuality being acceptable in the sense that it's just another sexual orientation alongside heterosexuality. As if God ordained both as different valid paths for people to take. It's hard for me, because I don't mean to offend but I don't know how else to put this, but homosexuality is intrinsically disordered. I don't think a person should be content with experiencing such desires, but like a heterosexual, should control their passions and subdue them. Now the point about addicts to self abuse is poignant because if you ask any addict there is a point where the appearance of self-control is lost. Many people are exposed to porn at a very young age, some as young as 10 years old, so you'll hear people masturbating compulsively daily (or more) for years. The sin becomes so ingrained that it seems impossible to overcome, and arguably, it becomes a part of them in some apparent way, yet I don't see the same openness concerning this sin. I feel some caution is necessary, and that ordinarily this is something that should only be shared with a confessor. We don't need to know eachother's sins, falls, and struggles. In fact, we should be very similar to one another if we are living a virtuous life. Very little should differentiate us as our sins and passions would be under control. These are just some thoughts, I mean no offense here, I myself was a very big sinner and lived a debauched life. You probably are a holier person than myself, so I mean no judgement against you. I don't share my sins so as not to cause scandal. Oremus pro invicem.
franciscanheart Posted May 8, 2015 Posted May 8, 2015 Hmm. Well desire can certainly be sinful for a heterosexual so it can certainly be sinful for a homosexual. Our Lord said that a man who thinks of committing adultery has already become guilty of it. I guess what seems to be changing is this idea of homosexuality being acceptable in the sense that it's just another sexual orientation alongside heterosexuality. As if God ordained both as different valid paths for people to take. It's hard for me, because I don't mean to offend but I don't know how else to put this, but homosexuality is intrinsically disordered. I don't think a person should be content with experiencing such desires, but like a heterosexual, should control their passions and subdue them. Now the point about addicts to self abuse is poignant because if you ask any addict there is a point where the appearance of self-control is lost. Many people are exposed to porn at a very young age, some as young as 10 years old, so you'll hear people masturbating compulsively daily (or more) for years. The sin becomes so ingrained that it seems impossible to overcome, and arguably, it becomes a part of them in some apparent way, yet I don't see the same openness concerning this sin. I feel some caution is necessary, and that ordinarily this is something that should only be shared with a confessor. We don't need to know eachother's sins, falls, and struggles. In fact, we should be very similar to one another if we are living a virtuous life. Very little should differentiate us as our sins and passions would be under control. These are just some thoughts, I mean no offense here, I myself was a very big sinner and lived a debauched life. You probably are a holier person than myself, so I mean no judgement against you. I don't share my sins so as not to cause scandal. Oremus pro invicem. Well. Hmmm. Okay. Before I begin, let me thank you for your honesty, frankness, and kindness. I don't take offense to anything you said. Often, the way a belief or ultimate difference of opinion is expressed makes all the difference between offense and frustration -- and I haven't even reached frustration yet. [thumbs up] I'm going to start at the beginning and work my way through. I think in this instance, working through on a point by point basis will be helpful. Hmm. Well desire can certainly be sinful for a heterosexual so it can certainly be sinful for a homosexual. Of course. Desire can always cross the threshold into lust and thus becomes sinful. Our sexual desire as given to us by God, however, is not, in and of itself, sinful. This is an important and necessary distinction if we're going to talk about the Church's teaching on homosexuality. Our Lord said that a man who thinks of committing adultery has already become guilty of it. We're talking about lust in this case, not base heterosexuality or base homosexuality. Entertaining the thoughts of having sexual relations is much different than the inherent desire to be sexually intimate with a partner. I guess what seems to be changing is this idea of homosexuality being acceptable in the sense that it's just another sexual orientation alongside heterosexuality. As if God ordained both as different valid paths for people to take. So this one is difficult to discuss in writing but I'm going to do my best. I think the perception in the church is often that, if we accept homosexuality as being a thing that happens, then we're condoning people being gay. Further, if we condone them being gay, then we're saying it's okay for them to think about sexual relations in that context. We're giving them too much rope and they're going to spiritually hang themselves if we let them think about any of this. So we need to tell them to deny this part of themselves and realize that God wants much more for them (because obviously they don't understand this if they want to claim that they are gay). Now, I often exaggerate to make a point. But basically, this is the feeling I get from many -- you included. It's the idea many have, I think, that because I say I am gay and I am open about that in certain places and with certain people, that I think about having sex with women or that I want to live a lesbian lifestyle in the Church. Or like, I want to "play a lesbian" and just not have sex. What does that look like to you? What is your schema about people who identify as gay? I know for certain that I have never said in this thread or anywhere else we've talked about this on phatmass that I think it's okay for people to explore their homosexuality in the bedroom. I've never said here or elsewhere that it is or should be acceptable in the Church to practice homosexuality, or that it's physical expression is a valid expression of God's love for humanity. I have not said at any point that God ordained these both as "valid paths" for His children to take. But then, I think we're talking about two different things again if we are talking about paths. Does God have children who are heterosexual -- some of whom He calls to sexual intimacy and procreation? Yep. Does he want them to remain chaste? Yep. Does he also have children who are heterosexual who are meant to remain celibate and chaste? Yep. What about gays? Does God have homosexual children He calls to be celibate and chaste? Yep. We are all called to the same chastity, but not all of us are called to sexual intimacy. Recognizing the difference between heterosexuality and homosexuality is not condoning the practice of both. It's simply acknowledging that there exists, in some of God's children, a desire for the same sex and not the opposite. But we're all called to chastity. It's hard for me, because I don't mean to offend but I don't know how else to put this, but homosexuality is intrinsically disordered. In the context of Catholic teaching, we are absolutely agreed. You do mean that in the context of Catholic teaching, correct? I don't think a person should be content with experiencing such desires, but like a heterosexual, should control their passions and subdue them. There's a difference between experiencing the desire and letting it run rampant. I like to think of my sexuality a lot like that of professed religious. Do you think religious walk around every day thinking about all the sex they don't get to have? Probably not. Does it cross their minds from time to time -- the idea of sexual desire? Perhaps. But we don't assume that they don't subdue their passions. I experience the initial knee-jerk reaction of sexual desire the same way you or any other non-asexual person experiences desire. But I think your assumption is that because I say that I am gay, and I am not ashamed or "discontent" with that, that I am essentially saying that I allow myself to think in sexual terms about other women. I don't. As far as asking homosexuals to be discontent with themselves in that regard, I don't know how to respond yet. Do you mean that homosexuals should feel discontent about their natural (read: inborn) desire to be intimate with the same sex for all of their lives, should pray in some kind of sorrow, or should hope to be "freed" of the "cross they've been asked to carry"? I'm not exactly sure I follow and I hesitate to make too many assumptions. Now the point about addicts to self abuse is poignant because if you ask any addict there is a point where the appearance of self-control is lost. Many people are exposed to porn at a very young age, some as young as 10 years old, so you'll hear people masturbating compulsively daily (or more) for years. The sin becomes so ingrained that it seems impossible to overcome, and arguably, it becomes a part of them in some apparent way, yet I don't see the same openness concerning this sin. Your mistake, in my opinion, is comparing homosexuals to addicts at all. It is the same mistake people make when trying to compare homosexuality to pedophilia. It isn't a just or logical comparison. Masturbation is the same for everyone -- gay or straight. Homosexuals are what they are; there isn't any changing that. If I went really far out on a limb (which I had to do several times to try to bend myself into the pretzel necessary to follow your logic), I would think you're suggesting that homosexuals should never think of themselves as being gay because if they do they are likely to sin and then they will accept that sexual sin of lust as being an acceptable part of their person. That's not what you meant is it? (And before I get too far, please know that the pretzel comment was a lighthearted joke about each of us trying to understand what the other is saying. I think we're taking two different approaches to meet the same end goal and it feels a bit like the Batman but going the length of Titan and the speed of Mr. Freeze. Ahem, Six Flags anyone?) All that said, I think this is a faulty comparison. Homosexuals are not, by their nature, sinful. They have the same chances of falling prey to any number of sexual sins as a heterosexual -- with the added complexity of often desiring those things with a person of the same sex. (You can see, I'm sure, where the issue of something like porn or masturbation becomes a little more confusing and complicated when it's a person of the same sex. Though, I think we can agree that the sin is the same; it's a sin against the flesh and against God's love for us. It's a sin against a beautiful gift God gave to us, a perversion of the beauty of sexual relations.) I feel some caution is necessary, and that ordinarily this is something that should only be shared with a confessor. We don't need to know eachother's sins, falls, and struggles. In fact, we should be very similar to one another if we are living a virtuous life. Very little should differentiate us as our sins and passions would be under control. Caution is absolutely necessary, as it is with everything. But I don't see where my sharing that I am gay is reason to lock the door and turn off the lights. My telling you that I am gay is not admitting to you a sin, a fall, or even a struggle, really. When I tell you that I am gay, what I am telling you is that I am predominantly attracted to women. This means I am attracted to women over men in most forms of intimacy -- up to and including sex. What I am not telling you is that I have lustful thoughts about women, that I dwell on lustful thoughts about women, that I definitely want to have sex with women, that I do have sex with women, and so on. Does that make sense? When I say I am gay, the tendency, it would seem, is to think, "GAY SEX." Often I find that when someone thinks about me being gay, they go immediately to what they think I want to do in the bedroom. That seems very shortsighted and even ignorant, don't you think? These are just some thoughts, I mean no offense here, I myself was a very big sinner and lived a debauched life. You probably are a holier person than myself, so I mean no judgement against you. I don't share my sins so as not to cause scandal. I have not shared any of mine, either. I hope I've made that clear with this post. My telling you that I am gay is not revealing anything about my sinfulness. The person who hears my confession is the one who knows my sin. My Lord knows my sin. Several close friends know my struggles, but not my sin. I imagine that's the truth for many -- gay or straight.
Ark Posted May 9, 2015 Posted May 9, 2015 Well. Hmmm. Okay. Before I begin, let me thank you for your honesty, frankness, and kindness. I don't take offense to anything you said. Often, the way a belief or ultimate difference of opinion is expressed makes all the difference between offense and frustration -- and I haven't even reached frustration yet. [thumbs up] I appreciate that, despite our differences you probably are a holier person than me, and I say that with all sincerity. I agree that desires in and of themselves are not sinful but I think it's important to remember that God ordained one sexual orientation, that of a man towards a woman and vice versa. Anything else is not another sexual orientation per se but a malformation of what God originally made. For example there are scientists that say some people are genetically predisposed to pedophilia but I wouldn't describe this as another orientation. I also wouldn't say this is a "God given" desire, at least not in the sense that God positively ordained a person to have such a disordered inclination, rather God permitted it, the actual cause if it's genetic is to be ascribed to a flaw in nature. I think this is where we fundamentally differ. I don't think the issue is over whether homosexuality occurs, it does and has been occurring since time immemorial. What is changing is that people identify with homosexuality and are open about it. "I am Gay" vs "I have SSA". "Coming out" vs private spiritual direction. Christians with SSA have always been around but how they behave in public has changed, and in my opinion it is causing scandal, confusion, and divisiveness in our community. I'm sorry if I gave you that impression but I know by identifying as Gay you don't mean that that you just want to have sexual thoughts. I do think by identifying with it and being public about it you are diminishing SSA's reality of being disordered and possibly contributing to scandal. I would say this not just for people with SSA but any other sinful or disordered tendency, whether they people who developed a tendency by their own actions, or those who perhaps are genetically predisposed but are not yet accepted by greater society. My judgement is meaningless but as I mentioned earlier you're probably much holier than myself. I don't think we're at issue over whether a person can have SSA and live chaste, or be holy, or is loved by God. I think identifying with and and being public about it can have some negative effects even if it be unintentional. Yes, I agree with you. I'm not sure what you mean here, what is the meaning in a non-Catholic context? That is not my assumption and I apologize if that is the impression I gave. For me it's more an issue of diminishing the reality of SSA being disordered but it can potentially be promoting a Gay lifestyle. Again, I think you are holier than and I'm sure to some degree you recognize as a person that identifies with being Gay you are exceptional in many respects. May question to you is, ought a person be "Gay and proud"? Let me clarify this a bit. We should be ashamed and discontent over our sins and any disordered inclinations. I want to emphasize I'm not singling out people with SSA but would also apply the same to habitual self-abusers that act out of compulsion, people with an inordinate sexual desire for children, adulterers, etc. We all have things to be ashamed of, and this especially includes myself, and this relates to the horror that is sin and the abominable nature of some of the sins we commit or are inclined to. We ought to strive to the best of our ability to heal ourselves, regardless of what which dispositions we either developed in ourselves or may be genetically predisposed to. This is what I mean by being discontented. I don't mean a denial of one self as the disorders we posses are not a part of ourselves. We are attempting to be healed so that we be restored as we were meant to be. Now I do believe that despite arduous effort at self mastery and healing an inclination may still remain, and any further attempt at healing is unreasonable and perhaps damaging, I think in such a state a person can be "content" relatively. I certainly am not at this state. I am very discontented. Habitual sin can so harden a soul towards a particular act that it becomes virtually compulsive. The habitual self-abuser who is attempting to free themselves from the sin finds themselves in a very challenging position, and at times a sense of hopelessness. Overcoming their sin is painful and certainly feels like "self denial." All I meant here is that the struggle is really not that different. Now pedophilia is interesting because apparently there may be a genetic predisposition, in other words people are born with it. I sometimes wonder if the Gay-rights movement is really an interim step for making pederasty acceptable. NAMBLA is already using the same arguments that Gay groups are and I don't see how in a secular Western context these relationships can be denied. I think society will always abhor acts against he very young but I think it will reconsider age restrictions and condone mid-aged catamites and pederasts. Frightening, but such is the state we find ourselves in. Not exactly but it's not that controversial that once we identify with something we subconsciously play the part, a great example of this is with alcoholics. AA is terribly unsuccessful and one of the arguments why it's so unsuccessful is that it teaches people to accept that they are Alcoholics, "once an addict always an addict," and so in their minds they program themselves to believe that what they have is inescapable and incurable. Are we then surprised that so many people relapse? Why would this principle not apply to people who identify with any other tendency? I think we're probably more in agreement than in disagreement and at points we've talked over each-other. I never meant to suggest a person with SSA can't be holy and still have SSA. We're in agreement here. Like I said before you are an exceptional Catholic as well as an exceptional person who identifies as Gay. For most "being Gay" refers to a lifestyle, in your case it sounds like you simply accept having SSA but continue to live a virtuous and chaste life, excelling in nearness to our Lord, which no one (let alone myself) could fault you for. The terminology is weird because being something usually does denote some sort of action, and so it's unusual for a person to speak of "being heterosexual" but I see what you are getting at.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now