Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Posted

[quote name='cmotherofpirl' date='Jul 21 2005, 12:05 AM']But what you consider beautiful, sacred, dignified and prayerful might be different than someone else.
[right][snapback]652102[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]

There is an objectively more beautiful. It may not be recognized, but that's the fault of the person looking, their own blindness.

Just look at what Pope Benedict, or Pope St. Gregory the Great, or any Church document since, about how Gregorian chant is objectively more beautiful and better suited for the Liturgy. There is a reason that it is, and understanding why will help people understand why some music is objectively better than others, such as polyphony is such over praise and worship.

Posted

[quote name='cmotherofpirl' date='Jul 21 2005, 12:07 AM']Bell music is wonderful as long as you don't have to watch it ;)
[right][snapback]652105[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]

It is pretty, but (and I'm saying this because they did it at Bishop Vann's Consecration) it should not take over and become the primary source of music, whether through the hole Liturgy, or even in a single song. I don't care much for songs that are only instrumental, they're beautiful, and great to listen to, but I find them inappropriate for Mass, as has the Church for the most part. :)

Noel's angel
Posted

yeah well there isn't much Gregorian chant floating around Northern Ireland....

What we do have is a rich musical culture and if we can use that to aid the Mass, then all is good

Posted

[quote name='cmotherofpirl' date='Jul 21 2005, 12:10 AM']But that someone else could be right, and you could be wrong.
Are you trying to tell me music is objective????
Do you really believe having taste is a modern acquisition?
Do you think people in previous eras didn't have favorites as well?
[right][snapback]652109[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]

I'm saying that parts of music are subjective, such as the way that the music works. The fact that Dixit Maria has words makes infinately more suitable for Mass than Bach's Tocatta and Fugue in D Minor.

Favorites are fine, though. But I think more appropriate outside the Mass (in flavors of music that is).

Posted

[quote name='cmotherofpirl' date='Jul 21 2005, 12:29 AM']Sure its subjective.
What is sacred and reverent to you might not be to me.
[right][snapback]652140[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]

There is a set standard though for sacred, and all types of music cannot be considered, just as some are better suited (like Gregorian chant).

:) I'm sorry if you now feel like I'm picking apart your posts, four responses in a row, I'm not. :( I'm gonna respond to most posts as I go along. :)

Posted

[quote name='Philippe' date='Jul 21 2005, 04:27 AM']i happen to enjoy guitar playing and bass playing and drum playing and amazing singing at Mass. but then again to all of you that makes me a heretic. I really think there are many more things to worry about. We need to cool off a lil sometimes
[right][snapback]652225[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]

I don't think you're a heretic. :) In fact, I have yet to be upset with this thread. If I have offended you, I'm sorry. I'm just trying to point out that the Chruch has asked that certain music be used for Mass, and that others not be. This doesn't make that music bad, just a little inappropriate for Mass. :)

Posted

I haven't read thru all the answers so I don't know if this question has already been asked.

Is she the only one who chooses the songs? If she is then why is she? Who put her in charge of choosing the songs? That isn't sarcasm, it is a sincere question.

Does your parish have a "Liturgy Committee?" If so, where are they?

Have you attempted to speak to her yourself?

Posted

[quote name='Frankencow' date='Jul 21 2005, 04:29 AM']Be thankful you can understand daily mass....
[right][snapback]652227[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]

'Twould be easier for some if it were in Latin. :(

By the way, before I go further, I would like to mention that three years ago I asked my Priest if we could start a new choir with guitars and such, singing songs such as "Song of the Cross" for World Youth Day 2002. Since then I have joined a Gregorian chant schola and a polyphony choir. I have noticed since that point a difference in my heart and attitude at Mass, and sadly I have lost that since we only sing during the school year and I have no where I can now go for such music. :(

Posted (edited)

[quote name='cmotherofpirl' date='Jul 21 2005, 09:15 AM']What is wrong with joyfully praising God?
Did you ever read the psalms -"Praise the Lord for he is good, let his mercies endure forever"???
We are an EASTER people, not calvinists, or fire and brimstone people.
[right][snapback]652366[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]

We are singing joyfully. :) And I believe that our current Holy Father has said that it is fine to use various songs outside of Mass that are not meant for in Mass. That doesn't make them bad songs, just saying that there are many better and more appropriate. :)

Edit: Also, if you ever hear an Orlando di Lasso Mass, you might realize that it's more joyful in praising God than the Mass of Angels or Mass of Creation. :)

Edited by qfnol31
Posted

And lastly, kids are normally better at being joyful than adults. Their music tends to be such, as well as their attitude. Have any of you who know some Gregorian chant ever heard the tunes in them that sound like they belong to a young kid? There's a reason for that. ;)

voiciblanche
Posted

[quote name='qfnol31' date='Jul 21 2005, 04:01 PM']And lastly, kids are normally better at being joyful than adults.  Their music tends to be such, as well as their attitude.  Have any of you who know some Gregorian chant ever heard the tunes in them that sound like they belong to a young kid?  There's a reason for that.  ;)
[right][snapback]653070[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]

Um... what?

Posted

Gregorian chants = the songs of kids. :) (Sorta). :)

voiciblanche
Posted

[quote name='qfnol31' date='Jul 21 2005, 04:07 PM']Gregorian chants = the songs of kids.  :)  (Sorta).  :)
[right][snapback]653086[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]

I'm gonna sound nit-picky, but, I don't know any kids who could sing two notes of a Gregorian chant... for numerous reasons.

Posted

Yes, well, this was first brought to my attention by a Priest who's been singing them since he was about half your age. He's now eighty. :P

Posted

yeah, voici how much do you know about Gregorian Chant to be able to make that assessment?

Q, you rule.

voiciblanche
Posted

[quote name='qfnol31' date='Jul 21 2005, 04:14 PM']Yes, well, this was first brought to my attention by a Priest who's been singing them since he was about half your age.  He's now eighty.  :P
[right][snapback]653099[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]

We'll have to argue about this some other time; I'm about to miss the point and just be nit-picky.

Posted

LoL, uh, thanx. :)

Posted

[quote name='cmotherofpirl' date='Jul 21 2005, 04:35 PM']So these are the only hymns you find acceptable?
[right][snapback]652996[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]

Of course not! Those were merely examples of acceptable hymns!

Noel's angel
Posted

So a choir with guitars DOES sing acceptable hymns then...

Posted

I personally would think that they could be, but less so.

Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.
×
×
  • Create New...