Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Posted

we wrote music for it that drew in the heights of the intellect and passions... I wanna see that in the guitar. not the lyrics, the instrumental.

Posted

[quote name='Aloysius' date='Oct 4 2005, 12:38 AM']that's happened more than once in the history of the Church.  the youth have been drawn to the mass without the introduction of modern music more than once in the history of the Church.  we didn't draw them in with the mass though... because the mass was never designed to be a tool of evanglization but a celebration and sacrifice among those who have already been won to the Lord.
[right][snapback]745492[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]

I'm not sure that's true. Music at mass has always been modern. Or more appropriately put, its been current. The pieces that you are advocating for were written on Monday and played the next Sunday because the composers were payed by particular churches to be their musician.

Posted

[quote name='Aloysius' date='Oct 4 2005, 12:42 AM']we wrote music for it that drew in the heights of the intellect and passions... I wanna see that in the guitar.  not the lyrics, the instrumental.
[right][snapback]745499[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]


We wrote the songs that make the young girls cry.

We wrote the songs, we wrote the songs...

Posted

replace where I said "modern" with "secular" and remember that I was talking about the instrumentals not the lyrics. I didn't intend to say "modern" there, obviously there should continue to be sacred music composed-- but it should be [i]sacred[/i] music. i'm not advocating being stuck by only that which is already written, but composing actual music designed for the heights of the intellect and the heart.

Posted

[quote name='Aloysius' date='Oct 3 2005, 10:42 PM']we wrote music for it that drew in the heights of the intellect and passions... I wanna see that in the guitar.  not the lyrics, the instrumental.
[right][snapback]745499[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]

why are you soooo anti-lyrics... lyrics are part of the song, the instruments are part of the song. They are put together to make something beautiful. Stop trying to solo either of them out because the two of them perform together to make the music.

Posted

I am not anti-lyrics. But we all agree that there should by lyrics that are in line with Catholic teaching and Christian et cetera. The disagreement is on instrumentals, and that is why I'm focusing on instrumentals. Some instrumentals are sacred and some are not. Some are proper to the roman liturgy, and some are not. Some draw more on emotions, some draw more on the intellect.

Posted

[quote name='Aloysius' date='Oct 4 2005, 12:47 AM']replace where I said "modern" with "secular" and remember that I was talking about the instrumentals not the lyrics.  I didn't intend to say "modern" there, obviously there should continue to be sacred music composed-- but it should be [i]sacred[/i] music.  i'm not advocating being stuck by only that which is already written, but composing actual music designed for the heights of the intellect and the heart.
[right][snapback]745505[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]

Give me the Church's guidelines for the composition of sacred music. What has to be followed to be liturgically correct and considered sacred?

And again, at one point the organ was a secular instrument.

Posted

it still is a secular instrument as you illustrated. it is the way it was played. play the guitar in such a way that the style of music played on it is distinct from the way the guitar is played in the secular world, and I'll be intrigued. I have yet to hear any such thing.

Posted

also, when talking about sacred music, the only thing I have been drawing on is the Second Vatican Concil which describes the distinct type of music that draws on both heart and mind and then promotes very strongly chant, polyphony, and organ.

the more apparent and emphasized the beat is made in music, the less it draws on the intellect and the more it draws on the emotions. when you get into the classical stuff that almosts seems to have been written by mathmeticians rather than artists it is obvious that it draws more on the intellect.

Posted

Al

All western music is borne from the Gregorian chant. Do re mi fa so la ti do are the the steps to western music. Do re mi fa so la ti do are also the beginning of seven lines of Gregorian chant. All western music comes from the sacred.

Posted

ok i think what i disagree with is that the idea that everything secular is evil... where does that come from, just because the way the secular world plays guitar means that, that style is anti-Catholic and not sacred. Can't they both go hand in hand?

Posted

I think the pro-modern music group is misunderstanding the anti-modern music group's point. Which is:

- Modern music (drums, guitars, etc) [b]is[/b] allowed
- Modern music can have a proper place in mass
- Modern music is bad when it completely replaces chant, etc (which it has in, dare I say, [b]most[/b] parishes)
- Modern music is bad when it detracts and overpowers other parts of the mass, and/or prohibits people from concentrating/worshipping in reverence

Please, argue for modern music, but don't feel like you have to be so extreme in your support of it that you look past the potential harm it brings--which I think we can all agree that it can do if not properly contained.

Posted

I know. That doesn't change the fact that there is a spectrum of what is emphasized. The sacred music really draws the intellect and passions in union into the heights of the music. Popular music has always swayed from intellectualism to emotionalism... and that's fine outside the liturgy.

Posted

we still are trying to define sacred music. What exactly makes music sacred

Posted

[quote name='Philippe' date='Oct 4 2005, 02:01 AM']ok i think what i disagree with is that the idea that everything secular is evil... where does that come from, just because the way the secular world plays guitar means that, that style is anti-Catholic and not sacred. Can't they both go hand in hand?
[right][snapback]745522[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]
I didn't say secular music was evil. I said it wasn't proper to the roman liturgy. emotional religious music is great outside the liturgy.

Posted

what makes secular music not proper for roman liturgy... what if gregorian chant became very popular in the secular world, would that make it innappropriate for liturgy?

Posted

nope. it doesn't have to do with its popularity.

anyway, I think in some way we all find the notion that gregorian chant will become popular in the secular world somewhat absurd. people five hundred years ago would find it absurd as well. the nature of the music, we can just tell it wouldn't be something played in the secular world.

[i]chant[/i] focuses solely on the human voice as the only instrument created directly by God.

but the polyphony and gregorian style are designed to focus the intellect and passions in union in the music. it challenges the intellect in a way that music with a strong obvious beat leading you never would. it draws in the emotion in its flow in a way that the intellectual classical music doesn't do either. it was designed for the roman liturgy and the roman liturgy was designed for it.

Posted (edited)

I think it is a fair issue to address because that is the underlying problem with the "modern" music. Some parishes are treating it like a concert, a recording session, or American Idol and the focus is no longer on the Eucharist. The sad part is when the parish can't see that the youth are attracted to to the music until it starts to smell of elderberries and all of a sudden the youth are no longer present. And this is the same for adults. You see them leave as well as soon as the music isn't "up to par". This particular problem was brought up by my parish council last year.

And we wonder why we are having a hard time bringing in the youth or adults for that matter. And instead of working together to fix the problem, we are quick to become defensive on both sides. The bottom line is, We are giving them a fish for a day instead of teaching them how to fish.

Edited by jmjtina
Posted

[quote]And we wonder why we are having a hard time bringing in the youth or adults for that matter. And instead of working together to fix the problem, we are quick to become defensive on both sides. The bottom line is, We are giving them a fish for a day instead of teaching them how to fish.[/quote]

Exactly

Our significant problem is in the fact that we have poorly catechized Catholics. Most cradle Catholics have a sixth grade understanding of the Church. The argument about music is simply a sympton to a greater problem. We have a lot of ignorant Catholics.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...