Top Ten Catholic Movies

[MissScripture]

[quote name='MIkolbe' timestamp='1283866105' post='2169130']
The Matrix

Writer Orson Scott Card has observed that one of the few places in contemporary culture where serious theological and philosophical reflection is still practiced is within the realm of science fiction and fantasy. The Matrix hammers home the truth of that observation. From a Catholic perspective, The Matrix is one of the most surprisingly literate films of the past few decades. It is also one heck of an action flick pumped with adrenaline (and one well deserving its "R" rating for violence).

One does not normally hear the words "action flick" and "literate" in the same paragraph. How does the The Matrix do it?

Well, not by force of acting talent. Let's get the minuses out of the way right off the bat, Keanu Reeves (who plays a computer hacker named Thomas Anderson known by the alias "Neo") will not be on any Oscar lists. He does his patented "surfer nebbish in a crisis situation" schtick well enough, but (not that it matters much in a film like this) he simply doesn't have the range to portray the depths of anguish his character ought to be feeling when he discovers the Truth.

And what is the Truth?

Neo discovers it in a way curiously fraught with allusions to the Catholic Tradition. The very first words addressed to him come from his computer screen. They are "Wake up, Neo" (reminiscent of the baptismal exhortation, "Awake sleeper, and Christ will shine on you.") Indeed, Neo is to discover that he is being called to be nothing less than a Messiah for the human race. He is "The One" who is destined to liberate humankind from "The Matrix".

What's that? "The Matrix" is a vast cyber-reality built and maintained by artificially intelligent machines who rebelled against us, won the war, and now require the energy put out by the human body to power themselves. Humans are not born. They are grown, harvested, and plugged into the Matrix from their prenatal state onward, where neural impulses are fed into their brains to simulate their sensations and create a virtual world which exists only in the mind, yet which is so real that the vast majority of the human race (including Neo) has no idea that the "reality" is simply a colossal illusion. Everybody imagines they live in 1999, when in reality, it is about 2199 and the earth has been devastated and the last colony of free humans lives in "Zion", a subterranean city near the earth's core.

Some have managed to escape the Matrix, including the mysterious "Morpheus" (Lawrence Fishburne, in a nice performance) and "Trinity" (the sleek and impressive Carrie-Anne Moss). They have, with the crew of a futuristic hovercraft that zips through a network of subterranean tunnels, been fighting a guerilla war against the machines until Morpheus can find the One.

And how is this all so 'literate'? Because filmmakers Larry and Andy Wachowski have simply crammed the film with imagery and references, not only to Scripture, but to Greek myth, Alice in Wonderland, Japanese anime and Hong Kong-Fu, cyberpunk novels, theoretical mathematics, and a dash of Jungian psychology. True, this can be overwhelming, but it is also great fun and very interesting to watch and think about.

For instance, the film very deliberately incorporates basic elements of the Paschal mystery into the story, yet in a curiously mythic and fantastic way. Neo is introduced to Morpheus (who has, like John the Baptist, been looking for the One all his life). He is given a choice between taking two pills (like Alice's choice between the food labeled "Eat me" and the "Drink me"). The one will show him the Truth of his existence and Morpheus will show him "how deep the rabbit hole goes". The other will cause him to wake up tomorrow believing whatever he wants. Neo opts for truth and, in a harrowing scene, goes "through the looking glass" and finds himself for the first time awake in his own body, a body hooked up by terrifying plumbing to a vast cyber-network with millions of other people still attached to the Matrix. Assumed to be dead by the Matrix, he is promptly disposed of down a long pipe and into an underground river. The scene deliberately images birth, baptism, death and the River Styx and all at once. For the first time, Neo is in his real body, not an illusory one. It is a sort of Incarnation and baptism.

Morpheus tells Neo he is the One to defeat the Matrix and, in particular, the sinister "Agents" (sentient programs dressed like "Men in Black" played with a wonderfully sinister banality of evil by, in particular, Hugo Weaving). But Neo is still Thomas, the doubter, not the Deliverer Morpheus sees. So he begins his training (some terrific fight scenes here) and is at last led to meet the Oracle (another fun draw on Greek culture: the Oracle at Delphi). Like all Oracles, she is, of course, cryptic but says just what is needed. In Thomas' case, he is told he must either sacrifice his life for Morpheus or that Morpheus will die for him. Shortly thereafter, a member of Morpheus' crew betrays them (a la Judas Iscariot) and Neo is indeed forced to choose.

It is not the task of film reviews to spoil everybody's fun by telling how movies reach their climax, but I will point a few things out as I skirt about the edges of the story: namely, right smack in the middle of all this gadgetry, stunningly choreographed fight scenes, visual effects and, yes, appalling violence is hidden the essential paschal mystery of death, of the Christ figure Neo plunging into the very heart of hell and destroying it from the inside out, of resurrection and ascension. (Post-Columbine caveat: When I speak of a Neo as a "Christ figure" I do not mean that his moral behavior is Christian. There is, I stress again, a large amount of bloodshed in this film and much of it shed by Neo who is, disturbingly, dressed in a black trench coat as he guns down a large number of villains in the accomplishment of his "mission". However, the murderous behavior of Neo does not detract from the fact that the filmmakers do indeed intend to draw on the Paschal mystery and make him a Christ figure. In an analogous way, Catholic Tradition speaks of Joshua-who led Israel into the Promised Land [symbolizing heaven] through the River Jordan [a figure of baptism]-as a Christ figure, without meaning his genocidal campaign against the Canaanites was an expression of Christian morality. We must distinguish between shadow and reality.)

Another interesting note for a Catholic viewer. Where, in most Hollywood films, the "spiritual" person is typically the one (like Yoda in Star Wars or the Spirit Guide in What Dreams May Come) who exhorts us to abandon the body and look to disembodied spirituality as "ultimate reality", the curious and refreshing thing about The Matrix is that the whole point of Morpheus' quest is to awaken us from disembodiment and confront us with the fact that we are slaves until we can really live in the real world. Conversely, the evil Agents express their disgust with human beings as bodily creatures ("It's the smell," gags one with a hatred that any ancient gnostic would have been proud of.) It is just this gnostic hatred of the body and of creation that the heroes of the film, as much as any Catholic, disdain. They would rather be free in a harsh but real world than slaves in a false one. That is a choice many in our world are no longer willing to make.

In a culture like ours, so increasingly averse to traditional presentations of the Christian mystery and so increasingly unable to grasp even basic elements of the Paschal mystery, it is interesting to see those themes re-explored in such a quirky form of fiction. Would that the story might have been told without recourse to the violent images now inextricably bound up with Columbine High School. This film, like so much myth, is a mixture of real insight with moral dross, but is, on the whole, worth seeing.


- review by Mark Shea
[/quote]
Orson Scott Card wrote the Matrix? I totally didn't know that! COOL!

[MithLuin]

Haha, no, no, he didn't write it. He was writing about the genre, and Mark Shea quoted him, that's all.

[MissScripture]

[quote name='MithLuin' timestamp='1284604092' post='2173679']
Haha, no, no, he didn't write it. He was writing about the genre, and Mark Shea quoted him, that's all.
[/quote]
OOOOH! Hahaha! I read the "Writer" to mean the writer of the movie, not just a generic description of what he does.

[OnlySunshine]

The Passion of the Christ

Therese (2004 version)

John Paul II (CBS)

Chiara e Franceso (great Italian film with English subtitles)

Padre Pio: Miracle Man

Fishers of Men (Grassroots film)

God in the Streets of NYC (Grassroots)

The Exorcism of Emily Rose

Women of Mystery, Women of Hope (Grassroots)

Beloved: The Nashville Dominicans

Edited September 22, 2010 by MaterMisericordiae

[dominicansoul]

Beckett is pretty good...so is The Relunctant Saint...

check them out!

[Seven77]

The best Catholic films i've seen:&nbsp;<div><br></div><div>Beckett<br>Anno Domini<br>Song of Bernadette<br>The Mission<br>Babette's Feast<br>I Confess<br>Diary of a Country Priest<br>Monsieur Vincent<br>Jesus of Nazareth/The Passion of the Christ/Gospel of Matthew<br>Padre Pio: Miracle Man<br>Karol: A Man Who Became Pope<br>Faustyna<br>The Human Experience<br>On the Waterfront<br>Witness to Hope<br>Miracle of Marcellino<br>Romero<br>

<div>13th Day</div><div>Ninth Day</div><div>Passion of Joan of Arc</div></div><div>A Man for all Seasons</div><div>Miracle Maker</div><div>Prince of Egypt</div><div><br></div><div><div><br></div><div>I hope to add:&nbsp;</div><div></div><a href="http://therebedragonsfilm.com/"><div>There be Dragons</div></a><div></div><div><a href="http://www.cristiadafilm.com/blog/">Cristiada</a></div><div><br></div><div>Maybe someday:&nbsp;</div><div></div><div><a href="http://www.mosaiah.com/tepeyac/">Tepeyac Hill</a></div><div><br></div><div></div></div>

[Seven77]

[quote name='dominicansoul' timestamp='1292190962' post='2192388']
Beckett is pretty good...so is [b]The Relunctant Saint[/b]...

check them out!
[/quote]

it still hasn't made it to netflix for some reason!

[Papist]

The Passion of the Christ
Ben Hur
Becket
A Man for All Seasons
The Song of Bernadette
Les Miserables
The Mission
I Confess
On the Waterfront
The Keys of the Kingdom

[Cam42]

[quote name='dUSt' timestamp='1211912599' post='1545050']
What is your top ten list?
[/quote]

I may have posted this years ago, but we'll give an updated list. In this order, btw....

10. The Scarlet and the Black
9. The Mission
8. Going My Way
7. The Bells of St. Mary's
6. The Keys of the Kingdom
5. The Miracle of Fatima
4. Song of Bernadette
3. In This House of Brede
2. The Shoes of the Fisherman
1. The Cardinal

There are several honorable mentions, but there is my top 10.

[Sarah147]

[quote name='MithLuin' timestamp='1283142964' post='2165269']
'Jesus of Nazareth' (1977)

[media]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=a5g8wk70O7c[/media]


[/quote]





Wow, I'll have to watch that version. He is the most merciful, loving and kind that I have ever seen. What loving eyes he has.

Edited January 4, 2011 by JoyfulLife

[Shana]

"The Human Experience" (Grassroots)

[Lil'Monster]

I love [b][i]Clare and Francis[/i][/b]!

It's about St.Clare of Assisi and St. Francis of Assisi

[ameliabedelia]

In no order:
1. Beloved....[img]http://www.phatmass.com/phorum/public/style_emoticons/default/love.gif[/img]
2. Mother Theresa and Mother Theresa: The Legacy
3. Pope John Paul II
4. Molokai: The Story of Father Damien
5. I Confess
6. Bella
7. The Nativity Story
8. Chronicles of Narnia
9. Lord of the Rings
10. [font=arial, sans-serif]Teresa de los Andes[/font]
[font=arial, sans-serif]11. The Sound of Music!!![/font]
[font="arial, sans-serif"]
[/font]

[MarisStella]

[quote name='ameliabedelia' timestamp='1297491539' post='2211616']
In no order:
[b]1. Beloved....[img]http://www.phatmass.com/phorum/public/style_emoticons/default/love.gif[/img][/b]
2. Mother Theresa and Mother Theresa: The Legacy
3. Pope John Paul II
4. Molokai: The Story of Father Damien
5. I Confess
6. Bella
7. The Nativity Story
8. Chronicles of Narnia
9. Lord of the Rings
10. [font="arial, sans-serif"]Teresa de los Andes[/font]
[font="arial, sans-serif"]11. The Sound of Music!!![/font]
[font="arial, sans-serif"]
[/font]
[/quote]

[Hinter dem Horizont]

[quote name='JoyfulLife' timestamp='1294181158' post='2196665']



Wow, I'll have to watch that version. He is the most merciful, loving and kind that I have ever seen. What loving eyes he has.
[/quote]

Totally

and FISHERS OF MEN!

[Debra Little]

The Song of Bernadette,St. Therese
The Jesus Movie
The Passion of the Christ
The Bells of St. Mary's
[color=#595959][font=arial, verdana, sans-serif][size=4]Molokai:[/size][/font][/color] the story of Father Damien
The Robe
The Sound of Music

Edited February 24, 2011 by Debra Little

[Lil'Monster]

St. Patrick

[Not A Mallard]

Jesus of Nazareth

The Scarlet and the Black

Pope John Paul II (CBS)

Evan Almighty

[Don John of Austria]

In no particular order.

Becket

A Man for all Seasons

The Black Robe

THe Mission

Romero

I confess

Brother son Sister moon I don't know if it is one of my favorites but Brother son Sister moon is pretty good.... its just a bit too 70's for me.


Boondock saints both I and II--- yes its very violent, but well Catholics are not always supposed to be peaceful, think of them as modern Crusaders. Crusaders with foul mouths. When I get a good Cusader movie maybe I take it off the list.

I'll have to think about the other 2

[Lil Red]

[quote name='Don John of Austria' timestamp='1304925463' post='2238978']
Boondock saints both I and II--- yes its very violent, but well Catholics are not always supposed to be peaceful, think of them as modern Crusaders. Crusaders with foul mouths. When I get a good Cusader movie maybe I take it off the list.

I'll have to think about the other 2
[/quote]
i haven't seen II yet...is it better than the first or worse?