Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

The Strange Notion Of "gay Celibacy"


Recommended Posts

Posted

I dont understand how any Catholic homosexual can feel  totally ok with giving up any sort life of love with a partner simply because their faith doesnt know what the eff to do with them anymore. Its so depressing for me to think that people willingly subject themselves to a partnerless future because the church has taught them they are damaged and twisted. But again, maybe I just dont get the religion thing...maybe they are fulfilled with their spiritual life and love for God so much that its not a struggle...or maybe it is a struggle and they are cool with it. I dunno. I try to put myself in that position as best as I can (for being a straight person who wont ever have to deal with the same struggles) and it still smells of elderberries.

 

But I think you raise a good question. How do you have both? How do you maintain your Catholic faith that calls for you to view the desire as evil, disorders, and sick but still treat the people lovingly? I think thats the key; it doesnt happen...or at least very rarely. You might have the best intentions, but your core belief is that this is wrong/bad/sick etc....and its hard to wade through those feelings to come out the other side unscathed as far as how you treat people. Its the ripple effect. 

 

I'm not gay, but I am celibate, and a celibate life can still be loving and enriching. I have had people assuming that I must be miserable and that there's something 'wrong' with me because I don't want to date (this is one reason why I rarely talk about it) but I and others are living proof that you don't need a romantic partner to be happy in life. That much is true.

 

It's also not required by Catholic teaching to view gay people as sick. I certainly don't. However, this doesn't change the fact that many people do treat them as sick, even going so far as to claim that by medicalising people's experiences they're being compassionate ("I love them, it's not their fault they have a disorder..."). And to be honest I don't know how gay Catholics cope with that either. It may not be integral to Catholicism, but the unfortunate fact is that this is what many gay people are experiencing, and a beautiful theory is poor comfort when you're surrounded by people whose practice puts you in pain. I just try to make sure my practice is different. It's the only thing I can do.

PhuturePriest
Posted (edited)

I don't understand why proponents of the gay movement are clearly incapable of speaking about the Church and its beliefs without falling into calling us names. It seems disingenuous, like they haven't really refined their argument beyond "This is morally good simply because I/others want it."

Edited by PhuturePriest
Posted

Such articles mostly seem to be written for the benefit of straight people who find the word 'gay' to be icky and want to be able to wave around a piece of paper going, "See! This gay person agrees with me!" I don't see any benefit to anyone in doing that, so I will join you in sitting out and hope that you have brought some cake. :)

 

I kinda get that vibe too. Similar to when there are racial issues and a black guy comes out and says "come on black people we need to be responsible and stop blaming the cops,: that spreads like wild-fire with a certain segment of white folk because it confirms their own biases and such.

 

I don't have the energy to adequately address your post nihil. I will just say that you can be charitable and sanctimonious at the same time. By saying something along the lines of "calling myself gay is a rejection of God" then you are in a way saying everyone who calls themselves gay is rejecting God or God's design or whatever.

Posted

And to be honest I don't know how gay Catholics cope with that either. It may not be integral to Catholicism, but the unfortunate fact is that this is what many gay people are experiencing, and a beautiful theory is poor comfort when you're surrounded by people whose practice puts you in pain. I just try to make sure my practice is different. It's the only thing I can do.

 

giphy.giftumblr_mypc3hZpZo1to6gr2o1_500.gif

Posted

 

I don't have the energy to adequately address your post nihil. I will just say that you can be charitable and sanctimonious at the same time. By saying something along the lines of "calling myself gay is a rejection of God" then you are in a way saying everyone who calls themselves gay is rejecting God or God's design or whatever.

I hope that is not what you took away from my post. You would really seriously be missing the point of what I was saying.

PhuturePriest
Posted

Hopefully you guys can help me out, because I am legitimately and sincerely curious, but I simply can't wrap this around my head.

 

You all admirably and unwaveringly assent with Church teaching that being gay (Or having same-sex attraction, as the Church prefers to call it) is inherently ordered towards a moral evil. So why do you identify with that? Why would you identify with something which orders you towards a moral evil? It's logically and theologically inconsistent. As the Church itself has very clearly said, we all have inherent disorders, because we are all prone to one sin or another. But you don't see people identifying with other disordered desires. When I used to watch pornography, I never identified myself as a pornosexual, or identified it as something that was a major part of me simply because it directly involved my sexuality. So why do you do that with same-sex attraction? It's something you struggle with, yes. It's something you will always likely struggle with. But that does not mean you should therefore identify yourself with a disordered desire.

 

Again, these are simply my thoughts. If one of you could explain to me why you do this and why you think it's logically consistent and/or helpful to you in your spiritual life, I would sincerely appreciate it.

Posted

The problem with Mattson is that he reduces sexuality to the biological. This is a huge emphasis of Tushnet and others, that there is a difference in how one relates with the world. I think it's a fair critique in some senses.

Posted

Phuture I think it's because sexuality is a very deep seated part of human beings. It strongly influences everything else - vocation, family, etc. it would be very challenging to go a day and not be reminded that you are gay, if only by the circumstance that you aren't partnered.

It's not something you can put in a box and and put to the side. Pornagraphy is disordered but you were still a straight person the whole time you were watching porn. You can wake up one day and not watch porn, a gay person is going to be gay every day they wake up.

Posted (edited)

Hopefully you guys can help me out, because I am legitimately and sincerely curious, but I simply can't wrap this around my head.

 

You all admirably and unwaveringly assent with Church teaching that being gay (Or having same-sex attraction, as the Church prefers to call it) is inherently ordered towards a moral evil. So why do you identify with that? Why would you identify with something which orders you towards a moral evil? It's logically and theologically inconsistent. As the Church itself has very clearly said, we all have inherent disorders, because we are all prone to one sin or another. But you don't see people identifying with other disordered desires. When I used to watch pornography, I never identified myself as a pornosexual, or identified it as something that was a major part of me simply because it directly involved my sexuality. So why do you do that with same-sex attraction? It's something you struggle with, yes. It's something you will always likely struggle with. But that does not mean you should therefore identify yourself with a disordered desire.

 

Again, these are simply my thoughts. If one of you could explain to me why you do this and why you think it's logically consistent and/or helpful to you in your spiritual life, I would sincerely appreciate it.

 

I know that franny AND OTHERS (oh my gosh!) has addressed this, multiple times in multiple threads. Do you think they want to explain it again? 

Edited by Lil Red
PhuturePriest
Posted

I know that franny has addressed this, multiple times in multiple threads. Do you think she wants to explain it again? 

 

Who said I was talking to Frannie? She doesn't have a sole claim on being the only Catholic with same-sex attraction on this website.

Posted

HeadDesk.gif

 

I'm sure those same threads have other people's experiences as well. 

Posted (edited)

Hopefully you guys can help me out, because I am legitimately and sincerely curious, but I simply can't wrap this around my head.

You all admirably and unwaveringly assent with Church teaching that being gay (Or having same-sex attraction, as the Church prefers to call it) is inherently ordered towards a moral evil. So why do you identify with that? Why would you identify with something which orders you towards a moral evil? It's logically and theologically inconsistent. As the Church itself has very clearly said, we all have inherent disorders, because we are all prone to one sin or another. But you don't see people identifying with other disordered desires. When I used to watch pornography, I never identified myself as a pornosexual, or identified it as something that was a major part of me simply because it directly involved my sexuality. So why do you do that with same-sex attraction? It's something you struggle with, yes. It's something you will always likely struggle with. But that does not mean you should therefore identify yourself with a disordered desire.

Again, these are simply my thoughts. If one of you could explain to me why you do this and why you think it's logically consistent and/or helpful to you in your spiritual life, I would sincerely appreciate it.

PP,
The difference is the attraction as a human toward another as a fundamental human need. We couple to become one that is greater then two individuals. A SSA person as a Catholic has to eliminate any possibility if an intimate life partner and have to chose forever single hood. A Hetero has the choice to do so or not.
That's different from just avoiding specific sexual behaviors. The sexual attraction is only part of a fundamental need to love and be loved in human experience. Not all heterosexuals can be happy being single, but a homosexual must be single all their life, despite their need for a life mate. Edited by Anomaly
Posted

PP,
The difference is the attraction as a human toward another as a fundamental human need. We couple to become one that is greater then two individuals. A SSA person as a Catholic has to eliminate any possibility if an intimate life partner and have to chose forever single hood. A Hetero has the choice to do so or not.
That's different from just avoiding specific sexual behaviors. The sexual attraction is only part of a fundamental need to love and be loved in human experience. Not all heterosexuals can be happy being single, but a homosexual must be single all their life, despite their need for a life mate.

Yeah, sometimes life sucks. Nobody denies that. It is a consequence of living in a world marked and broken by sin.

A man who is totally impotent can also never get married, no matter how heterosexual he is. It could be very difficult and very lonely for him. But his circumstance is a call to embrace God's plan in his life, even if it is not what he might have preferred.

PhuturePriest
Posted (edited)

PP,
The difference is the attraction as a human toward another as a fundamental human need. We couple to become one that is greater then two individuals. A SSA person as a Catholic has to eliminate any possibility if an intimate life partner and have to chose forever single hood. A Hetero has the choice to do so or not.
That's different from just avoiding specific sexual behaviors. The sexual attraction is only part of a fundamental need to love and be loved in human experience. Not all heterosexuals can be happy being single, but a homosexual must be single all their life, despite their need for a life mate.

 

I would disagree with you on a few nuanced points of your post.

 

Though I reject the idea that God purposefully makes people have SSA, I also believe that God gives us the grace and strength to overcome anything and fulfill us despite what we don't have (Note: I don't mean "overcome" as in "overcome your SSA"). If you are to be single the rest of your life, God will give you the grace and fulfillment necessary to do that. God will always give us everything we need to overcome anything that might be detrimental to our spiritual lives, including SSA. SSA isn't its own special entity that not even God can touch.

 

I agree that, as humans, we have a fundamental need for love between us. But I (Like the Church) disagree that our fundamental need for love means romance and eros in particular. In fact, I quite agree with C.S. Lewis that agape is the greatest of the four types of love, and people with SSA have a unique means to develop agape in its purest form.

Edited by PhuturePriest
Posted

Yeah, sometimes life sucks. Nobody denies that.


Yah. But what you are missing is that sometimes life sucks in life altering, identity altering ways. I imagine this has never happened to you.

Impotent man is a great example. his inability to have an erection (which has nothing to do with his capacity to form lasting emotional bonds and in every other way fulfill the role of spouse) means he is robbed of the opportunity to fall in love, live with a partner, parent children etc. I imagine he would wake up every day pretty aware of his impotence and how this affects his sexuality.
PhuturePriest
Posted

Yah. But what you are missing is that sometimes life smells of elderberries in life altering, identity altering ways. I imagine this has never happened to you.

Impotent man is a great example. his inability to have an erection (which has nothing to do with his capacity to form lasting emotional bonds and in every other way fulfill the role of spouse) means he is robbed of the opportunity to fall in love, live with a partner, parent children etc. I imagine he would wake up every day pretty aware of his impotence and how this affects his sexuality.

 

But again, this goes down a line of thinking the Church disagrees with, because it implicitly says we need eros in order to be properly happy and fulfilled.

Posted (edited)

Yah. But what you are missing is that sometimes life smells of elderberries in life altering, identity altering ways. I imagine this has never happened to you.

Impotent man is a great example. his inability to have an erection (which has nothing to do with his capacity to form lasting emotional bonds and in every other way fulfill the role of spouse) means he is robbed of the opportunity to fall in love, live with a partner, parent children etc. I imagine he would wake up every day pretty aware of his impotence and how this affects his sexuality.

I have no doubt that it is awful. But the real question is how do we respond? We cannot change reality; we can only respond to it.

Obviously, for a Catholic, we have to respond in a way that is open to grace and allows for our sanctification. Resignation to the Divine Will.

No, it is not easy. It is the hardest thing in the world, doubly so for those people who suffer from major disorders or tragedies through no fault of their own. But sometimes reality imposes on us obligations that we did not ask for and do not want.

Edited by Nihil Obstat
Posted

. But sometimes reality imposes on us obligations that we did not ask for and do not want.

 

Sometimes. But sometimes we can ignore reality and just keep chugging along.

Posted

But again, this goes down a line of thinking the Church disagrees with, because it implicitly says we need eros in order to be properly happy and fulfilled.


DUDE! Yeah yeah you don't need eros. Do we tell young people who want to get married "now remember you don't need romance to be fulfilled"? No. That's because most people in spite of knowing you can be fulfilled with other things nevertheless want to get married and have a family. Because it's part of being human.

I bet you would be the person who tells infertile women "you can be fulfilled by mentoring others and being involved in your parish and blah blah blah" none of which addresses the MATERNAL instinct inscribed on a woman's heart. Even if it's true.
Posted

I don't label myself as gay just because I really, really want to have sex with men and have no desire to have sex with women. TAKE THAT MODERN WORLD!!!!

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...