Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Church/saint Teaching And Modesty


Recommended Posts

Posted

The sisters are tagteaming. I love it!

Lilllabettt
Posted

no one can withstand los luchadores

 

dominicansoul
Posted

Mary's Little Flower,

 

I respect the fact that you are a recent convert who has been affected by your conversion in such a way that modesty is very important to you.  You recognize that you had not dressed modestly in the past and are struggling to do that now, and for that I commend you.  I believe the Holy Spirit is guiding you in this area.  Continue to look towards the Church and Her Saints, because they will not fail you.

 

Do avoid the extremes, though.  Pray to recognize what true modesty is.  You dont' want to listen to the opinions of those who are very scrupulous when it comes to modesty.  (They believe every modern style is wrong, and immoral.)  You definitely don't want to listen to the opinions of those who think modesty is relative.  (They believe there are no such things as immodest dress.)  The Church is not extreme, but very balanced in this matter.

 

I will keep you in my prayers as I have been.  I love converts :)  the zeal you all have remind me to never take our Faith for granted.  :) 

 

 

Nihil Obstat
Posted

It is not strictly relevant to this conversation, but I have mentioned this before. Few things warm my cold traddy heart so much as the sight of a bunch of young girls in white dresses. We had our Corpus Christi procession today, and the young girls of the parish were spreading rose petals. :)

I think that must be the archetype of modesty.

Lilllabettt
Posted

94c470cf-fc63-4312-bc5f-156a3c8de400_zps

fc8f7e2b-1474-459e-95ca-991770b4cee3_zps

See the difference? I would like to point out that the non-modest picture features a person wearing a long sleeved, long-hemmed dress. More coverage does not equal modesty.  The native people below are wearing next to nothing, but their bearing is very modest.

 

Modesty is relative to time,place, body, and situation.  Modesty in the 1600s is different from modesty in the 21st century.  A particular dress might be fine on a smaller girl but immodest on a larger one. What is modest in Menlo Park, CA is different from what is modest in Ethiopia. A swimsuit would be immodest at the grocery store, but not at the pool.

Posted

94c470cf-fc63-4312-bc5f-156a3c8de400_zps

fc8f7e2b-1474-459e-95ca-991770b4cee3_zps

See the difference? I would like to point out that the non-modest picture features a person wearing a long sleeved, long-hemmed dress. More coverage does not equal modesty.  The native people below are wearing next to nothing, but their bearing is very modest.

 

Modesty is relative to time,place, body, and situation.  Modesty in the 1600s is different from modesty in the 21st century.  A particular dress might be fine on a smaller girl but immodest on a larger one. What is modest in Menlo Park, CA is different from what is modest in Ethiopia. A swimsuit would be immodest at the grocery store, but not at the pool.

 

Why?

Lilllabettt
Posted

Well ... the reason there are different standards for modesty in different times and places because culture develops in different ways.

 

If I had to speculate I would say the native people pictured wore less clothing from the beginning because of the temperature. So because women's breasts were never concealed and they never came to think of them as private or sexual; they serve a functional purpose of feeding babies.

 

The reason a shirt might be modest on a smaller girl and not on a larger girl is because women have breasts, and in our culture breasts are sexualized.

The reason a swimsuit is modest at the pool and not at the grocery store ... well, if common sense  doesn't tell you that I'm not sure what to tell you. Pray to St. John Paul to help you understand what he meant when he said that.

 

Posted

So, you really don't know.

Lilllabettt
Posted

Ummmm well, no, no one "knows" why it is, just that it is.  Anthropologists have written dissertations trying to answer that question since before their discipline was created. Its one of those huge questions human beings can hardly get their arms around. The word "why" is like that a lot.

Posted

http://www.wholesomewear.com/page-4.html

 

So folks, do you think these swimsuits are modest in our culture?

What's your point? Those being modest does not imply that they are the only form of modest swimwear. 

Posted

Why?

 

Papist, do you think the native people pictured are exhibitionists? Do you think the man pictured chooses to wear a loincloth instead of something else he could wear, because the loincloth is sexually provocative?

 

On the other hand, do you think the Hollywood starlet pictured is an exhibitionist? Do you think she chooses to wear a long-sleeved, long-hemmed dress slit up her thigh because it is sexually provocative?

 

That's why.

Guest Allie
Posted (edited)

What's your point? Those being modest does not imply that they are the only form of modest swimwear. 

 

 Just wondering if something that draws so much attention is modest?

Edited by Allie
Posted

 Just wondering if something that draws so much attention is modest?

 

Drawing attention is not in and of itself immodest. 

Posted

I wouldn't wear it. I'm all for modesty, but I would also like to wear something that is cute. IMHO that isn't the cutest.

Posted

Papist, do you think the native people pictured are exhibitionists? Do you think the man pictured chooses to wear a loincloth instead of something else he could wear, because the loincloth is sexually provocative?

 

On the other hand, do you think the Hollywood starlet pictured is an exhibitionist? Do you think she chooses to wear a long-sleeved, long-hemmed dress slit up her thigh because it is sexually provocative?

 

That's why.

 

Why other cultures wear what they wear, I don't know. I don't see it relevant to the culture we live in. Hence, the why. No one is saying the less you wear the more immodest you are, and the more you wear the more modest you are.

 

And to say it is common sense is not much. I am sure most people think their thinking is common sense. 

Posted

Why other cultures wear what they wear, I don't know. I don't see it relevant to the culture we live in. Hence, the why. No one is saying the less you wear the more immodest you are, and the more you wear the more modest you are.

 

And to say it is common sense is not much. I am sure most people think their thinking is common sense. 

I think the point that is being made is that what constitutes "modest dress" is not concrete and you cannot break it down to "this is what is modest across all time and context". 

Posted

I think the point that is being made is that what constitutes "modest dress" is not concrete and you cannot break it down to "this is what is modest across all time and context". 

 

And that is what I am trying to understand. How did it go from totally covered suits (men and women) to dental floss bikinis. 

Posted

No one here is advocating for bikinis.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...