jim111 Posted May 12, 2013 Posted May 12, 2013 (edited) No, I am not. You have not quoted doctrinal or dogmatic statements. And I'm not going to respond to this topic anymore. I know a lost cause when I see one. Then lets change topics and determine, whats a doctrine? Edited May 13, 2013 by jim111
MarysLittleFlower Posted May 13, 2013 Author Posted May 13, 2013 While your underlining is very interesting Fatima is not part of the Church's teaching. Fatima is accepted by the Church... it has much more authority than our own opinions. I read that it's wise and prudent to accept true revelations and take them seriously.
MarysLittleFlower Posted May 13, 2013 Author Posted May 13, 2013 I think the issue is that people are defining modesty very differently. MLF highlighted the statement, 'Modesty protects the intimate centre of the person', and I would absolutely agree with that - but I don't take that sentence to be referring to sleeve and skirt lengths. For me it's about an attitude of the heart. When I read that sentence, I always think of Jesus' teaching that we should not pray to be seen on street corners, but retreat to our rooms and shut the door. This is a beautiful metaphor for the 'intimate centre', and how to protect it and draw strength from it without showing off. Modesty colours all areas of life, and to reduce it just to clothing (and, let's be honest, women's clothing - people who support the fraudulent 'Mary-like standards' may declare that they support modesty for men, but they spend hardly any time talking about it) does it a disservice. It's also inimical to the idea of modesty, which is about the interior. The hyper-focus on clothing makes it all about externals, and can sometimes verge on the immodest because of all the attention people give it - public sighs on how hard it is to find appropriate clothes, etc. I am reminded of Jesus' statement on longer tassels and broader phylacteries, also from that gospel, only here it's about longer skirts and lacier mantillas. The irony is that my usual clothing consists of long skirts (lengths ranging from knee to ankle). I do wear trousers sometimes, and T-shirts (gosh, my salacious elbows...), but nothing that would raise eyebrows. I am not sitting in a miniskirt or a bikini as I write this. But my clothing is not the central thing when it comes to modest living. It's a consequence of other, more important things. As a younger Catholic (aged about twenty, twenty-one) I just couldn't see that. I went through a phase of being obsessed with the 'modesty' externals, and I did look seriously at those 'Mary-like standards' (although thankfully even then I could smell the fish). Anyone who thought I was doing it wrong had to be prayed for, very sweetly and very charitably, because they just didn't understand. I think we all have it at some time or another. You're lucky if you escaped it entirely. :P Beatitude, I see what you are saying, but the way I understand, for me the skirt length etc is significant not just because it's listed on the website, but because it makes sense that a skirt beyond a certain point is no longer modest. It doesn't make sense to think that anything is modest... so then the question is: how long is modest enough. To me, if it covers my knees well enough when I'm sitting, that's modest, so the skirt length I choose is mid calf to floor length, not shorter. I don't think it's reducing it to clothing to think about clothing at all.... we can think about the internal attitude *and* the clothing too :) the reason I don't talk too much about modesty for men, is because I'm trying to figure out how to be modest myself, and I'm a woman so I think mostly about modesty for women. In the end, the way I see it is that people who are much holier than me did talk about specifics in modest clothing. Like skirt length. I'd rather trust their opinion than the world or what the fashions are. Some might disagree with them and say that these are not infallible statements, but even if not infallible dogmas - they were still said by people who lived holy lives, so they must have put thought and prayer into it.
EmilyAnn Posted May 13, 2013 Posted May 13, 2013 Fatima is accepted by the Church... it has much more authority than our own opinions. I read that it's wise and prudent to accept true revelations and take them seriously. Breaking my thing about not replying, but we are not bound to believe in Marian apparitions. The Church may deem an apparition "worthy of belief" but they are still private revelations and as I have said, we are not bound to believe in them.
dominicansoul Posted May 13, 2013 Posted May 13, 2013 I love Our Lady of Fatima. Her feast day is today!
MarysLittleFlower Posted May 13, 2013 Author Posted May 13, 2013 (edited) Breaking my thing about not replying, but we are not bound to believe in Marian apparitions. The Church may deem an apparition "worthy of belief" but they are still private revelations and as I have said, we are not bound to believe in them. The way I understand it, - the Church only binds us to believe to the essentials. Often they show a truth about God, like the Holy Trinity, - or about Mother Mary, the truth about what happens after death, etc. However - the way I've come to see it is that just because we aren't bound to believe in something else, doesn't mean that we should just ignore it... for example if it comes to my own opinion vs a true private revelation, - the true private revelation is still WAY more authoritative than my own opinion based on the culture, etc. If Mary says that there would be immodest fashions, - if I disagree, it's my word against Mary's. I think Mary knows the truth more than me and has much more authority :) and true private revelations don't clash with the Bible and other truths, but they might be different than our opinions or the world's truths. If we only stick with the dogmas but ignore everything else.... that doesn't seem to be so great because God gives us private revelations to remind us of things to give us advice on how to live out our faith in our age. It's better to listen to this than to other sources like human opinion. If we ignore everything we don't strictly "have" to believe, we would not pray the Rosary, not go to Adoration, no one would do the Sacred Heart devotion though there are such great promises attached to it, bad things would happen to the world cause we would ignore Mary's requests on how to help bring peace, etc, people would ignore miracles happening and even experiences of God's presence in their own lives - but all these things can help us to follow public revelation better.. In the end I think it's more simple to just accept everything that is true. St Louis de Montfort talked about this: "Everyone knows that there are three different kinds of faith by which we believe different kinds of stories: To stories of Holy Scripture we own DIVINE FAITH; To stories concerning other than religious subjects, which do not militate against common sense and which are written by trustworthy authors, we pay the tribute of HUMAN FAITH; whereas To stories about holy subjects which are told by good authors and are not in the slightest degree contrary to reason, faith, or morals (even though they may sometimes deal with happenings which are above the ordinary run of events) we pay the tribute of PIOUS FAITH. I agree that we must be neither too credulous nor too critical and that we should remember that "virtue takes the middle course" - keeping a happy medium in all things in order to find just where truth and virtue lie. But on the other hand I know equally well that charity easily leads us to believe all that is not contrary to faith or morals: "Charity ....believeth all things;" *1* in the same way pride induces us to doubt even well authenticated stories on the plea that they are not to be found in the Bible." (Secret of the Rosary, St Louis de Montfort) Fatima is not contrary to faith and morals, it's made clear in the apparitions that it's very important for our times, - all these and more are reasons to take it seriously, I think, and it's just simpler to do that, instead of being doubtful :) Edited May 13, 2013 by MarysLittleFlower
MarysLittleFlower Posted May 13, 2013 Author Posted May 13, 2013 (edited) If someone is unsure about Fatima, or something else, they could pray about it and ask God to help them see the truth on it... God is giving us the choice, but these revelations can help us in our lives and God can give us understanding on them. After all if Mary came to give a message, it must have been important... she wouldn't come and give a message just so that we can forget about it. That would be sad, even though the Church doesn't bind us to accept private revelation. Dogmas are found in public revelation that have been given to us - and private revelation corresponds with public revelation and shows us ways to live it out or apply it, or gives certain helpful points etc.. the Church binds us to public revelation because if we ignore that, we would be ignoring a dogma that is necessary to be Catholic. However, if we ignore private revelation, even though we'll still have the dogmas, we might not receive that advice we need for our times or benefit from a special grace given to the world. Revelations also give us ways to help convert other souls, like often they give us prayers, and just through reading them, people might be converted. It's like if we could see Jesus now and He would be saying something to us, wouldn't we listen? :) we wouldn't turn away and say "I don't care about this, it's not a dogma of public revelation". of course we wouldn't do that. So it's unwise to do that with others' true revelations either. We are not bound to them, but it's wise to follow them, because God is offering us more help for our lives. :) if Mary spoke to us, we would listen, so it's good to listen when she spoke to Lucia, Jacinta, and Francisco, too. Edited May 13, 2013 by MarysLittleFlower
EmilyAnn Posted May 13, 2013 Posted May 13, 2013 The way I understand it, - the Church only binds us to believe to the essentials. Often they show a truth about God, like the Holy Trinity, - or about Mother Mary, the truth about what happens after death, etc. However - the way I've come to see it is that just because we aren't bound to believe in something else, doesn't mean that we should just ignore it... for example if it comes to my own opinion vs a true private revelation, - the true private revelation is still WAY more authoritative than my own opinion based on the culture, etc. If Mary says that there would be immodest fashions, - if I disagree, it's my word against Mary's. I think Mary knows the truth more than me and has much more authority :) and true private revelations don't clash with the Bible and other truths, but they might be different than our opinions or the world's truths. If we only stick with the dogmas but ignore everything else.... that doesn't seem to be so great because God gives us private revelations to remind us of things to give us advice on how to live out our faith in our age. It's better to listen to this than to other sources like human opinion. If we ignore everything we don't strictly "have" to believe, we would not pray the Rosary, not go to Adoration, no one would do the Sacred Heart devotion though there are such great promises attached to it, bad things would happen to the world cause we would ignore Mary's requests on how to help bring peace, etc, people would ignore miracles happening and even experiences of God's presence in their own lives - but all these things can help us to follow public revelation better.. In the end I think it's more simple to just accept everything that is true. St Louis de Montfort talked about this: "Everyone knows that there are three different kinds of faith by which we believe different kinds of stories: To stories of Holy Scripture we own DIVINE FAITH; To stories concerning other than religious subjects, which do not militate against common sense and which are written by trustworthy authors, we pay the tribute of HUMAN FAITH; whereas To stories about holy subjects which are told by good authors and are not in the slightest degree contrary to reason, faith, or morals (even though they may sometimes deal with happenings which are above the ordinary run of events) we pay the tribute of PIOUS FAITH. I agree that we must be neither too credulous nor too critical and that we should remember that "virtue takes the middle course" - keeping a happy medium in all things in order to find just where truth and virtue lie. But on the other hand I know equally well that charity easily leads us to believe all that is not contrary to faith or morals: "Charity ....believeth all things;" *1* in the same way pride induces us to doubt even well authenticated stories on the plea that they are not to be found in the Bible." (Secret of the Rosary, St Louis de Montfort) Fatima is not contrary to faith and morals, it's made clear in the apparitions that it's very important for our times, - all these and more are reasons to take it seriously, I think, and it's just simpler to do that, instead of being doubtful :) I am not saying we should ignore them, I am saying we are not bound to them. There is a difference. And I was saying quote dogma/doctrine because another person was trying to hold me to that but not doing it themselves.
Papist Posted May 13, 2013 Posted May 13, 2013 Breaking my thing about not replying, but we are not bound to believe in Marian apparitions. The Church may deem an apparition "worthy of belief" but they are still private revelations and as I have said, we are not bound to believe in them. Are you saying you do not believe in the Fatima apparitions?
EmilyAnn Posted May 13, 2013 Posted May 13, 2013 Are you saying you do not believe in the Fatima apparitions? Not at all. Personally, if the Church has declared something worthy of belief then I trust that.
Papist Posted May 13, 2013 Posted May 13, 2013 Could this be moved to the debate table? I think the point it being here is not to debate, but to discuss Church/Saints teachings/wisdom and share thoughts on modesty. No one should be telling anyone he/she is wrong. We all should talk about ourselves and why we choose our modesty lifestyle, whatever that is. Also, we all should not misinterpret someone's modesty philosophy as a condemnation of ours.
MarysLittleFlower Posted May 13, 2013 Author Posted May 13, 2013 (edited) I am not saying we should ignore them, I am saying we are not bound to them. There is a difference. And I was saying quote dogma/doctrine because another person was trying to hold me to that but not doing it themselves. I read through those posts to understand what you mean. It seems like the poster was saying that there are dogmas and doctrines (2 different things) and he was talking about some doctrines, and Fatima is related because it doesn't contradict doctrines. You were disagreeing and saying that he did not say any doctrine. Am I correct? I don't know if we are over complicating it or what... I think - if Mary said something at Fatima, - it's good to just believe it and it doesn't contradict doctrine anyway. That's why I brought up the whole point, that private revelations are helpful to understand/live out public revelation more deeply. (I just listened to a sermon where a priest said that - private revelation helps us to enter more deeply into public revelation). So Fatima helps us to understand more about the Church's doctrines on - let's say modesty, along with many other things (like the reality of hell, or sin, or chastity, or prayer, the Rosary, conversions) - so we can listen to Fatima's message about modesty and follow it :) Edited May 13, 2013 by MarysLittleFlower
EmilyAnn Posted May 13, 2013 Posted May 13, 2013 I read through those posts to understand what you mean. It seems like the poster was saying that there are dogmas and doctrines (2 different things) and he was talking about some doctrines, and Fatima is related because it doesn't contradict doctrines. You were disagreeing and saying that he did not say any doctrine. Am I correct? I don't know if we are over complicating it or what... I think - if Mary said something at Fatima, - it's good to just believe it and it doesn't contradict doctrine anyway. That's why I brought up the whole point, that private revelations are helpful to understand/live out public revelation more deeply. (I just listened to a sermon where a priest said that - private revelation helps us to enter more deeply into public revelation). So Fatima helps us to understand more about the Church's doctrines on - let's say modesty, along with many other things (like the reality of hell, or sin, or chastity, or prayer, the Rosary, conversions) - so we can listen to Fatima's message about modesty and follow it :) The poster tried to demand that I argue my point using only dogma/doctrine. While I do not object to doing so on principle, my objection was to doing so when they were not. Just because something does not contradict doctrine does not make it doctrine.
MarysLittleFlower Posted May 13, 2013 Author Posted May 13, 2013 (edited) I'm just reading through the quote: "the sins which bring most souls to hell are the sins of the flesh. Certain fashions are going to be introduced which will offend Our Lord very much... the Church has no fashions; Our Lord is always the same..." http://www.catholicmodesty.com/Jacintamodesty.html So we can reflect/pray on that perhaps :) Edited May 13, 2013 by MarysLittleFlower
dominicansoul Posted May 13, 2013 Posted May 13, 2013 Our Lady stated the obvious: "there will be fashions introduced that will offend God." And if you don't agree and instead believe that in all cultures, and in every single corner of the world there are absolutely no such things as immodest fashions...then, there's nothing else to discuss... This thread are for those who believe there are immodest fashions (we're not debating that in this thread.) It's also a thread to discuss what the Saints have taught us and how do we apply their advice to our own fashions and dress.
MarysLittleFlower Posted May 13, 2013 Author Posted May 13, 2013 The poster tried to demand that I argue my point using only dogma/doctrine. While I do not object to doing so on principle, my objection was to doing so when they were not. Just because something does not contradict doctrine does not make it doctrine. I understand what you mean now. Maybe Jim111 can clarify if he was trying to use doctrine or not :) I see he included this quote, - but I'm not sure where it's from.... Jim111: could you explain to us maybe the source of this quote? There are two aspects to Christian modesty. The first is to avoid being an occasion of sin. The second, more positively speaking, is to be instilled with the spirit of modesty inspired by a deep love for the virtue of chastity, and also by the proper understanding that our clothing is meant to enhance the dignity of the human body and to be a symbol of our state in life. Both aspects, while in no way excluding men, are much more important for women. Because of the natural differences in the genders, women are both far more prone to be occasions of sin, and, being "the weaker vessel" (1Pet. 3:7),to be treated with less dignity or respect. Proper dress does much to overcome this, and this is why St. Paul wrote in the New Testament that women should appear "in decent apparel; adorning themselves with modesty and sobriety."
Papist Posted May 13, 2013 Posted May 13, 2013 Not at all. Personally, if the Church has declared something worthy of belief then I trust that. I understand the point you are making. It is very similar to a conversation I had with my sis-in-law re JPII theology of the body. I was encouraging her to read some of it. She did some, but told me that it was not infallible teaching, implying she was not bound to adhere to. This is true, but I told her we would be doing ourselves a disservice if we dismissed things on the basis that we are not bound by Church law to believe. I think perhaps the message of Fatima may fit into this category. Just something to think about. I do not mean to say you do not believe the message of Fatima. That I do not know.
EmilyAnn Posted May 13, 2013 Posted May 13, 2013 I understand what you mean now. Maybe Jim111 can clarify if he was trying to use doctrine or not :) I see he included this quote, - but I'm not sure where it's from.... Jim111: could you explain to us maybe the source of this quote? There are two aspects to Christian modesty. The first is to avoid being an occasion of sin. The second, more positively speaking, is to be instilled with the spirit of modesty inspired by a deep love for the virtue of chastity, and also by the proper understanding that our clothing is meant to enhance the dignity of the human body and to be a symbol of our state in life. Both aspects, while in no way excluding men, are much more important for women. Because of the natural differences in the genders, women are both far more prone to be occasions of sin, and, being "the weaker vessel" (1Pet. 3:7),to be treated with less dignity or respect. Proper dress does much to overcome this, and this is why St. Paul wrote in the New Testament that women should appear "in decent apparel; adorning themselves with modesty and sobriety." As far as I can tell, it is from a booklet by a "modesty crusade" group.
EmilyAnn Posted May 13, 2013 Posted May 13, 2013 (edited) I understand the point you are making. It is very similar to a conversation I had with my sis-in-law re JPII theology of the body. I was encouraging her to read some of it. She did some, but told me that it was not infallible teaching, implying she was not bound to adhere to. This is true, but I told her we would be doing ourselves a disservice if we dismissed things on the basis that we are not bound by Church law to believe. I think perhaps the message of Fatima may fit into this category. Just something to think about. I do not mean to say you do not believe the message of Fatima. That I do not know. I think you are misunderstanding why I was making that point, and I have already explained in my posts responding to MarysLittleFlower . To clarify, my objection was not to the use of Fatima in the discussion, my objection was that the other poster was demanding I use only doctrinal sources but not doing so themselves. Edited May 13, 2013 by EmilyAnn
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now