jim111 Posted April 26, 2013 Posted April 26, 2013 (edited) First, the original accounts we have of St. Perpetua's martyrdom are not considered to be divinely inspired. Second, it is common for early martyrs to have had the accounts of their deaths exaggerated or modified simply as a result of pious sentiment. If they dont have there accounts, then how could tehy know they were exagurated? Perhaps your right, but would you agree its only prudent to assume the pope is taching the truth unless we have good reason to doubt otherwise? Even if the story is false, the teaching has an obvious message. HIs teachings on modesty, are consistent with Catholic Tradtioion, what authority do you have to reject his regualtions on modesty. Edited April 26, 2013 by jim111
the171 Posted April 26, 2013 Posted April 26, 2013 GRAMMAR AND SPELLING GRAMMAR AND SPELLING I didn't want to say anything, but I had to.
jim111 Posted April 26, 2013 Posted April 26, 2013 ^I may be a trad but if JP2 has a teaching that contrdicts Pius XII, I see that as a valid arguemnt.^
dominicansoul Posted April 26, 2013 Posted April 26, 2013 Transmundane Lane NO DEBATING. Serious theological and spiritual discussion. why is this thread in Transmundane Lane? sounds more like Debate Table material to me....
arfink Posted April 26, 2013 Posted April 26, 2013 Transmundane Lane NO DEBATING. Serious theological and spiritual discussion. why is this thread in Transmundane Lane? sounds more like Debate Table material to me.... Agreed! Lets get the mods in here...
beatitude Posted April 26, 2013 Posted April 26, 2013 Blah, blah, blah. So much bickering. Why can't I just wear clothes and be fabulous? Because wearing clothes and being fabulous would make you into a brazen hussy and would spell the death knell to any purity you have (which probably isn't much). As we have established, the only acceptable attire is a pinafore/jumper dress made out of a pair of old curtains for maximum coverage. I can't believe this conversation has been revived when I have just spent the evening debating with some unknown guy on a friend's Facebook wall (bad move) about an upcoming fashion week, in which there will be models wearing - gasp - clothes that aren't floor-length and made of old curtains. He earnestly assured me that the next thing we know, the young women who have applied to model for the show will be out prostituting themselves in the street. And I am not exaggerating. I wish I were. It's enough to make me want to wear the super-modest cardboard box with cut-outs for my eyes that I mentioned earlier in the thread. At least that way I might get a little peace. None of these people would come blundering into my box to disturb me.
ploomf Posted April 26, 2013 Posted April 26, 2013 I don’t teachings that make women feel like their bodies are stumbling blocks for men, that they must “save†men from lust by covering up. It’s not healthy for them and it’s not healthy for men, instead of being taught to take responsibility for their thoughts and actions men can just blame women for not being modest. Besides modesty is about much more than how much clothes women wear. You could be covered up from head to toe and still not be a modest person if all you think about is how virtuous and modest you are. Women shouldn’t be ashamed to wear attractive clothing that makes them feel beautiful.
the171 Posted April 26, 2013 Posted April 26, 2013 Thought processes like those that ploomf described are what fuel the rape culture. We go from "well, she was dressed inappropriately so it's not like I couldn't lust" (double negative, i know) to "Well she was dressed inappropriately, so the rape was justified." Yes. Women shouldn't dress inappropriately, but a lot men don't care what women are wearing. They'll lust after them no matter what. I once saw someone catcall a woman wearing a hijab.
EmilyAnn Posted April 27, 2013 Posted April 27, 2013 I grew up in the Middle East. I can tell you absolutely that getting women to cover up does very little to stop men from lusting. The problem is the attitude of men towards women. Teach a man to respect women and that's what will help him the most.
the171 Posted April 27, 2013 Posted April 27, 2013 I known this was discussed earlier in the thread, but... WOMEN LUST TOO.
MIKolbe Posted April 27, 2013 Posted April 27, 2013 Hey, let's get back to some srs theological discussion, and not debate. :) Thanks
Papist Posted April 27, 2013 Posted April 27, 2013 There are some people who do care to dress in a manner that could lesson impure thoughts, I don't see a fault in that. I believe someone should be able to live out their modesty in such a manner without being mocked and told he/she is wrong. I don't think anyone is saying that the more you cover, the more modest you are, the more impure thoughts you will prevent. There is no for sure way to prevent one's thoughts. However, I believe I am my brother's keeper, insomuch that if there is something I can do or not do to aid him, I will. If I believe that by dressing in a certain manner would lessen a woman's impure thoughts towards me, then I will do my best to dress in that manner. Me believing this way is not an indictment on you if you do not .
dominicansoul Posted April 27, 2013 Posted April 27, 2013 Amen. The mocking is utterly ridiculous, and it prevents any mature discussion on the Church's guidance. The church does not say, "modesty is relative and do whatever you feel is right for you..." She also doesn't teach us to be ridiculously scrupulous about it either. There's a beautiful and holy balance that we all need to practice.
jim111 Posted April 27, 2013 Posted April 27, 2013 (edited) Yeah, it's a claim I'm making. :) You don't have to run around killing women and thinking they're the same as animals to be a misogynist. I'm not throwing him in the fire, either. It's just as bad to throw away a great saint because he had flaws as it is to ignore all the flaws he had. Like Beatitude said, the modesty rules at the Vatican are different, it's a different situation. I find it ESPECIALLY problematic (and ironic) that St.Pio would deny women the sacrament concerned with contrition and forgiveness of sin because he made a judgment about their personal conviction based solely on their clothing...And this is coming from a guy who supposedly could READ SOULS. WHY bother with judging a woman's contrition based solely on her skirt length (or wearing a skirt at all) when you HAVE THE ABILITY to see what their true state of contrition is? If he had made all the men come to confession wearing a button down shirt and tie, then I wouldn't have as big of a problem with it, because THEN it would be clear he's trying to foster a respect for the sacrament in all people. One day Padre Pio's spiritual director reproached him for his harsh conduct. He replied: "I could obey you, but each time it is Jesus who tells me how I am to deal with people." He also said "I beg you not to criticize me by invoking charity, because the greatest charity is to deliver souls held fast by Satan in order to win them over to Christ." Back in the day of Padre Pio there was no face to face confessions, the priest was in a confessional. If it was not divine inspriration that gave him this insight how did he know what the girls were wearing. I'm not arguing but it was always my understanding that this was divine inspiration. Edited April 27, 2013 by jim111
the171 Posted April 27, 2013 Posted April 27, 2013 The priest could usually see them before they walked in. Also, who was the source of that story of the SD to Pio conversation? Once again, pious legend most likely. How about we stay away from those and focus on the theological basis of modesty. Even saints can be wrong. (e.g.-Thomas Aquinas)
Lilllabettt Posted April 27, 2013 Posted April 27, 2013 I am looking forward to summer because I will once again be able to don my Imam-approved swimsuit and face riptide death once or twice. In that long sleeved, long pants suit I feel good. I feel relaxed. I don't worry about looking fat or my butt cheecks accidentally showing. I DON'T HAVE TO SHAVE MY LEGS. I always have that twinge of embarassment in the beginning of the summer that someone will judge me as wierd or a modesty fanatic. But then I remember I DON'T HAVE TO SHAVE MY LEGS, and then frankly my dears I don't give a damm.
jim111 Posted April 28, 2013 Posted April 28, 2013 (edited) The priest could usually see them before they walked in. Also, who was the source of that story of the SD to Pio conversation? Once again, pious legend most likely. How about we stay away from those and focus on the theological basis of modesty. Even saints can be wrong. (e.g.-Thomas Aquinas) If the church is consistently teaching somthing, you cant reject it, when you do not have any doctrin that says the contrary. 'We recall that a dress cannot be called decent which is cut deeper than two fingers breadth under the pit of the throat, which does not cover the arms at least to the elbows, and scarcely reaches a bit beyond the knee. Furthermore, dresses of transparent material are improper. Let parents keep their daughters away from public gymnastic games and contests; but, if their daughters are compelled to attend such exhibitions, let them see to it that they are fully and modestly dressed. Let them never permit their daughters to don immodest garb.' The Sacred Congregation of the Council (by the mandate of Pope Pius XI), January 12, 1930 A.D. Moral Theology The Church consistently teaches us that there are three degrees of decency regarding the parts of the human body. Some parts are considered honest for show in public, some less honest, and other dishonest. Some moralists used to employ a more rigorous language, qualifying these parts as not-shameful, semi-shameful and shameful. The honest or not-shameful parts are the face, hands and feet; the less honest or semi-shameful are the lower neck, back, legs and arms; the dishonest or shameless are the reproductive organs and their proximities. The criterion that establishes this classification is the degree of incentive toward the sensual passions that the mentioned parts arouse. Edited April 28, 2013 by jim111
jim111 Posted April 28, 2013 Posted April 28, 2013 The priest could usually see them before they walked in. Also, who was the source of that story of the SD to Pio conversation? Once again, pious legend most likely. How about we stay away from those and focus on the theological basis of modesty. Even saints can be wrong. (e.g.-Thomas Aquinas) The source is Rev. Fr. Jean, O.F.M., CAP. http://www.fatima.org/apostolate/newsletters/stjohn/2002/june/sjv_jun02pg1.asp Saints can be wrong, but not when there intentions are divinely inspired.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now