Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Church/saint Teaching And Modesty


Recommended Posts

Posted

Saying this saint or that saint was a mysoginistic jerk who hated women trivializes the fact that this man was deemed to be someone with heroic virtue by the Church. If by mysogyny you mean "someone who did not view women as equals" then say it. That's not what mysogyny means. It literally means "women haters".


No, it emphasises the grace of God and the strength of God's love by showing us that even people who held some terrible ideas can become saints and demonstrate great virtue.

 

I feel that you are hair-splitting here in order to make St Augustine's views more palatable. There are thousands of words in the English language that are used to mean things that aren't quite in alignment with their etymological root, and misogyny is one of them.

 

As for the use of 'misogyny' versus the use of 'sexism' - a lot of men who use prostitutes (an industry that is pretty much built on the bodies of trafficked and otherwise very vulnerable women) would deny hotly that they hate women. And maybe they have female friends and women colleagues whom they like and they love their mothers. But if you go to the prostituted woman who has been trafficked from Ukraine and is being kept as a sex slave, semantic issues over whether the punters can be said to hate her or not aren't going to be her first concern. Her first concern is that there are men out there who see her and her body as an object to be bought, a legitimate transaction. A society where this can flourish on the scale that it does is a misogynistic society, full stop. When I look at this, men who get upset over the root of the word (and it is overwhelmingly men) are not my primary issue of concern either.

Roamin Catholic
Posted

Let this be the thread for a discussion for Church/Saint teaching in regards to modesty. 

 

As this is TL; please remember the rule of no debating. 

Posted

Let this be the thread for a discussion for Church/Saint teaching in regards to modesty. 

 

As this is TL; please remember the rule of no debating. 

 

I see what you did there.

KnightofChrist
Posted

I see. So you accept going to dances as sinful because a couple of saints have said so.
 
I have referred a few times to St Augustine's derogatory comments on women. Here they are in full:
 
"What is the difference whether it is in a wife or a mother, it is still Eve the temptress that we must beware of in any woman...I fail to see what use woman can be to man, if one excludes the function of bearing children."
 
This is the opinion of a saint and a doctor of the Church, one of Christianity's foremost theologians and scholars. Would you recommend that husbands on Phatmass use this as a guide to how they should view their wives? That they are dangerous temptresses and their only worth is determined by the fact they have a womb? After all, it was written by a saint, so it must be right.

[ETA: Part of] This quote comes from St Augustine's 243rd letter. The second half of the quote "I fail to see what use woman can be to man, if one excludes the function of bearing children" is not part of the letter. Therefore, it appears that Sherif Abdel Azeem has invented a bad statement and falsely attributed it to a great Christian. Anyone who wants a copy of the entire letter is welcome to email me. Alternately, the entire letter can be found in

The Fathers of the Church - A New Translation, Volume 32, St Augustine Letters (204-270), trans. Sr Wilfrid Parsons, S. N. D. (New York: Fathers of the Church, Inc, 1956).

St Augustine wrote this letter to a friend named Laetus. Laetus had entered religious life and his mother was tempting him to abandon this way of life for worldly reasons. Religious life consists in Christian men and women committing themselves completely to the service of God and his Church in a life of poverty, celibacy and obedience. Laetus wanted St Augustine to write to him.

The context explains why St Augustine said, "What is the difference whether it is in a wife or a mother, it is still Eve the temptress that we must beware of in any woman." This was not an arbitrary statement, but was said to strengthen Laetus against his mother's attempts to remove him from religious life for worldly reasons. The rest of the letter is filled with other Biblical ideas and images. Augustine's statement is similar to Christians saying "Beware of Pharaoh the tyrant in rulers", "Beware of Adam the blame-shifter in men", "Beware of Judas the traitor in the people around you", or "Beware of Peter the denier in yourself" (Genesis 3:12; Exodus 1:8-16; Matthew 26:14-16, 69-75). Elsewhere in the same letter, St Augustine tells Laetus to treat his mother with respect because she is a sister to him in Christ.

Speaking more generally about St Augustine's view of women, it is fair to say that Sherif Abdel Azeem's picture of St Augustine is not accurate. Firstly, Augustine supported and praised virginity, widowhood and monasticism. Therefore, it is incorrect to say that he thought the only purpose of women was for childbearing. Secondly, in the classic autobiography of his spiritual journey and conversion to Christianity (the Confessions), Augustine says that male and female are one and that God does not discriminate between them (Book 13, Section 23). Thirdly, Augustine talks about Adam being the cause and transmitter of original sin and its consequences (City of God, Books 13 and 14).


The relevant works may be found online at the following addresses:

CATHOLIC ENCYCLOPAEDIA: The Rule of St Augustine
http://www.newadvent.org/cathen/02079b.htm

Of Holy Virginity by St Augustine
http://www.newadvent.org/fathers/1310.htm

On the Good of Widowhood by St Augustine
http://www.newadvent.org/fathers/1311.htm

The Confessions
http://www.newadvent.org/fathers/1101.htm

The City of God
http://www.newadvent.org/fathers/1201.htm


Source: http://answering-islam.org/Wales/eve.htm

 

  • 3 weeks later...
Posted (edited)

THERE ARE NO SET STANDARDS FOR MODESTY IN CATHOLIC TRADITION.

 

 

Standards of Modesty in Dress
Imprimatur dated Sept. 24, 1956
"A dress cannot be called decent which is cut deeper than two fingers breadth under the pit of the throat; which does not cover the arms at least to the elbows; and scarcely reaches a bit beyond the knees.  Furthermore, dresses of transparent materials are improper."
The Cardinal Vicar of  Pius XII
 

 

Edited by jim111
Posted

^^ That's a bunch of bull, as previously established in this thread. Please re-read.

Posted

 

Standards of Modesty in Dress
Imprimatur dated Sept. 24, 1956
"A dress cannot be called decent which is cut deeper than two fingers breadth under the pit of the throat; which does not cover the arms at least to the elbows; and scarcely reaches a bit beyond the knees.  Furthermore, dresses of transparent materials are improper."
The Cardinal Vicar of  Pius XII
 

 

Please see around pages 3-4 of this thread, it sheds a lot of light on the lack of authenticity of those "standards". 

Posted

THERE ARE NO SET STANDARDS FOR MODESTY IN CATHOLIC TRADITION.

 

 

 

 

Therefore, modesty is whatever you want/need it to be.

Posted



Standards of Modesty in Dress

Imprimatur dated Sept. 24, 1956

"A dress cannot be called decent which is cut deeper than two fingers breadth under the pit of the throat; which does not cover the arms at least to the elbows; and scarcely reaches a bit beyond the knees. Furthermore, dresses of transparent materials are improper."

The Cardinal Vicar of Pius XII


http://www.catholicmodesty.com/Popesonmodesty.html


Hi Jim! It's so nice to meet you, but...


NO.
ToJesusMyHeart
Posted

I like the standards, Jim. Let's be friends.

Posted (edited)

You know how hard it is to follow those gosh darn "standards" in the gosh darn south of Louisiana? No. It's not hard. IT IS IMPOSSIBLE. I run. I work out. I work. I am today's woman and I can't do everything in a skirt and mid-length sleeved shirts that reach up however high they say I must. We have already gone over this: the sources are questionable, priests are sometimes wrong, and modesty is more than a set of standards.

/endrant Edited by the171
Posted

I like the standards, Jim. Let's be friends.

I don't think people are objecting to anyone liking them (if you wanna dress to those standards, go for it) but to the suggestion that the Church has mandated that all women adhere to them, which is blatantly false. 

Posted

Jim, I feel like I've seen you on Fish Eaters. Were you the one who started that crapstorm about whether or not women can be theologians? Your avatar and "about me" makes me think that's you.

ToJesusMyHeart
Posted

Isn't Israel/where JMJ lived hotter than Texas/the south? 

 

Anyway, I love you always 171.

Posted

Actually, no. It is also humid down here. Imagine heat sticking to you and your sweat only makes it worse. Welcome to the Bayou!

Posted

Yup. It is you! Well, welcome to Phatmass. If you have come here to convert the "liberals" be prepared. We have many female theologians here.

ToJesusMyHeart
Posted

Actually, no. It is also humid down here. Imagine heat sticking to you and your sweat only makes it worse. Welcome to the Bayou!

My roommate and I made a list once about 10 things we'd rid the world of, and sweating/over-heating was on the list. It's a major pain. I go through a deoderant in like a month.

Posted

My roommate and I made a list once about 10 things we'd rid the world of, and sweating/over-heating was on the list. It's a major pain. I go through a deoderant in like a month.


I go through it in like a week. Hint: reapply.
Posted

I go through it in like a week. Hint: reapply.

 

^^ This. Also, get the gel stuff that has the super high concentration of whatever it is in deodorant that makes it work, it helps too.

Posted

^^ This. Also, get the gel stuff that has the super high concentration of whatever it is in deodorant that makes it work, it helps too.


That's what I use. Secret Gel Lavendar. Smells divine!

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...